| Course | FIN 504 Finance Principles |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Capital budgeting analysis |
| Length | About 990 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 504 Topic 5
A Production Line That Fails the Four-Year Payback Rule and Adds 1.76 Million in Value: Net Present Value Against Payback
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-504: Finance Principles
Topic 5 Capital Budgeting Analysis
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
A Production Line That Fails the Four-Year Payback Rule and Adds 1.76 Million in Value: Net Present Value Against Payback
The Project and the Question
The composite equipment manufacturer is considering a new production line for high-efficiency heat pumps. Its capital budgeting policy requires projects to pay back their investment within four years, and the finance team also computes net present value at the company's weighted average cost of capital of 7.71 percent. This analysis builds the project's incremental cash flows, evaluates it on both criteria, explains why they disagree and states which one answers the question that matters: whether the project makes the company's owners better off.
Incremental Cash Flows
Cash flows enter the analysis only when the project itself causes them (Brealey et al., 2020). The line costs 12.0 million dollars installed, and it requires 1.0 million of additional inventory and receivables, working capital that is recovered when the line closes after six years. A 0.3 million dollar engineering study completed last year is excluded: it has been paid whatever the decision, so it is sunk. After-tax operating cash flows, which include the tax saved by depreciation, are 2.2 million in year 1, rising to 3.4 million in years 3 and 4 as the line reaches capacity, then falling as newer designs compete. In year 6 the line's equipment is sold for 0.8 million after tax and the working capital is recovered.
Table 1
Heat Pump Line: Cash Flows, Present Values and Payback
| Year | Cash flow, millions | Discount factor at 7.71% | Present value | Cumulative cash flow |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | -13.0 | 1.0000 | -13.000 | -13.0 |
| 1 | 2.2 | 0.9284 | 2.043 | -10.8 |
| 2 | 3.0 | 0.8620 | 2.586 | -7.8 |
| 3 | 3.4 | 0.8003 | 2.721 | -4.4 |
| 4 | 3.4 | 0.7430 | 2.526 | -1.0 |
| 5 | 3.0 | 0.6898 | 2.069 | 2.0 |
| 6 | 4.4 | 0.6404 | 2.818 | 6.4 |
| Net present value | | | 1.763 | |
Net Present Value
Each cash flow is discounted at 7.71 percent for the years until it arrives, and the present values are summed. The project's net present value is about 1.76 million dollars. That figure has a direct meaning: after paying every provider of capital the return it requires, the project adds about 1.76 million dollars of value to the company today. A positive net present value means accept.
Payback
Payback counts the years until cumulative cash flows recover the investment. After four years the project has recovered 12.0 of its 13.0 million, leaving 1.0 million; year 5 brings 3.0 million, so payback is about 4 plus 1.0 / 3.0, or 4.33 years. Under the four-year rule, the project is rejected. A discounted payback, using present values, is about 5.4 years, which would also fail.
Why the Criteria Disagree
Payback has two features that explain the conflict. It ignores everything after the cutoff: the 7.4 million dollars the line generates in years 5 and 6, including the recovered working capital, play no part in the decision. And simple payback ignores the time value of money, treating a dollar in year 4 as equal to a dollar today. Net present value uses every cash flow and discounts each at the rate investors require. The disagreement is therefore not a close call between two reasonable measures; payback is answering a different question, how quickly money comes back, and is silent on whether the project creates value.
A Quick-Payback Alternative
The problem is sharper when payback chooses between projects. The production team has proposed instead a line for retrofit kits, with the same 13.0 million outlay but cash flows front-loaded: 4.5, 4.0, 3.5, 1.5, 0.8 and 1.5 million, the last including recovered working capital. Its payback is about 3.7 years, so it passes the rule, and its net present value is only about 0.05 million dollars. Payback would choose the retrofit line and reject the heat pump line; net present value prefers the heat pump line by about 1.7 million dollars.
Why Payback Persists
Payback remains widely used alongside net present value (Graham & Harvey, 2001). It is simple, it favors projects that return cash quickly when a firm is short of funds, and it offers a rough guard against forecasts that grow less reliable with distance. Lefley (1996) argues that its value lies in measuring liquidity and exposure to risk, not profitability. The analysis therefore reports payback as information about how long the company's money is at risk, but ranks the criteria plainly: net present value decides; payback informs.
What the Discount Rate Assumes
Using 7.71 percent assumes the heat pump line carries the same risk as the manufacturer's existing business. That is reasonable here: heat pumps are sold through the same distributors to the same contractors and depend on the same construction cycle. Had the project been a move into an unfamiliar market, the rate would need adjusting upward before net present value could be trusted. The analysis also checks the result against the rate's plausible range. At a cost of capital of 8.1 percent, the top of the range estimated for the manufacturer, the project's net present value is still about 1.57 million dollars, so the decision does not depend on a precise rate. Its internal rate of return, about 11.7 percent, gives the same reading from the other direction: the line earns roughly four points more than its capital costs.
Recommendation
The manufacturer should approve the heat pump line, which adds about 1.76 million dollars of value, and should not adopt the retrofit line merely because it passes the payback rule. Management concerned about the line's later-year cash flows should test them directly, for example by asking whether the project still adds value if years 5 and 6 fall by a third, rather than discarding them with a cutoff. At that reduced level, the project's net present value would still be positive, at roughly 0.5 million dollars.
Conclusion
Net present value and payback disagree on the heat pump line because payback ignores the cash flows after year 4 and the time value of money. Only net present value measures whether the project creates value, and it does, by about 1.76 million dollars.
References
Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
Graham, J. R., & Harvey, C. R. (2001). The theory and practice of corporate finance: Evidence from the field. Journal of Financial Economics, 60(2-3), 187-243. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0304-405X(01)00044-7
Lefley, F. (1996). The payback method of investment appraisal: A review and synthesis. International Journal of Production Economics, 44(3), 207-224. https://doi.org/10.1016/0925-5273(96)00022-9
The FIN-504 Topic 5 assignment instructions
Topic 5 in FIN-504 asks MBA students to evaluate a project with capital budgeting criteria. Strong analyses build incremental cash flows, excluding sunk costs and including working capital, compute net present value at the right rate and report payback alongside it. Students should explain why the criteria disagree, rank them plainly and test the cash flow assumptions instead of cutting them off. Students should also test whether the decision depends on a precise discount rate and report the internal rate of return as a cross-check. Assumptions about later cash flows should be tested directly rather than cut off.
Inside the FIN 504 Topic 5 example
The finished example builds the cash flows before it discounts anything, since the arithmetic is straightforward and the inputs are where projects are misvalued. Only incremental flows appear: sunk costs are excluded explicitly, opportunity costs are included even though nobody writes a check for them, and the effect on other parts of the business is counted. Depreciation is handled as a tax shield rather than as a cash outflow, which is the mechanical point students most often get wrong. Net present value is computed at the rate built in the previous topic. Payback is reported and then criticized directly, since it ignores everything after the break point and the timing of money inside it.
Where the marks sit in the FIN 504 Topic 5 rubric
Faculty reward a project judged on value with payback reported as information. An Excellent paper tables six years of cash flows with discount factors and cumulative totals. Credit goes to excluding a 0.3 million study as sunk, with Brealey and colleagues. The rubric values a quick-payback alternative that adds almost nothing, and evidence from Graham and Harvey and from Lefley on why payback persists. Strong papers test the discount rate. Top marks go to testing later cash flows directly. Papers that show a quick-payback alternative adding almost no value, while the slower project adds about 1.76 million, make payback's weakness concrete. Credit also goes to stating what the discount rate assumes about risk.
Common FIN 504 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Including sunk costs is the classic error and it is marked heavily, since money already spent cannot be affected by the decision and its inclusion changes the answer. A second failure is treating depreciation as a cash outflow, which double counts and understates the project, when its only cash relevance is the tax it saves. Papers lose marks for omitting working capital movements, which tie up cash at the start and release it at the end and are easy to forget entirely. Using payback as the deciding criterion inverts the ranking the topic teaches. Recommendations with no sensitivity comment present a single figure as though the forecast underneath it were certain, which no capital analysis should imply.
Get a FIN-504 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-504 Topic 5 problems and the rubric posted in your classroom, with the project data your section supplied. We write a custom example to those criteria, with only incremental flows included, depreciation handled as a tax shield, both criteria computed and the most sensitive input named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More FIN 504 papers and MBA samples
- FIN 504 Topic 1: Time Value of Money Problem Set
- FIN 504 Topic 2: Bond and Stock Valuation
- FIN 504 Topic 3: Risk and Required Return Analysis
- FIN 504 Topic 4: Cost of Capital Build
- FIN 504 Topic 6: Project Ranking Analysis
- FIN 504 Topic 7: Capital Structure Analysis
- FIN 504 Topic 8: Valuation Recommendation
- ECN 601 Topic 5: Macroeconomic Indicator Analysis
- HRM 635 Topic 5: Selection Utility Dq Post
- BUS 660 Topic 5: Linear Programming Formulation
- HRM 640 Topic 5: Site Consistency Dq Post
FIN 504 Topic 5 questions, answered
Why are sunk costs excluded?
Because they are unaffected by the decision. A feasibility study already paid for costs the same whether the project proceeds or not, so including it can make a value creating project look unattractive. The test for every flow is whether it changes as a result of this decision. Applying that test consistently also catches opportunity costs, which are easy to miss for the opposite reason.
How does depreciation enter the analysis?
Only through tax. Depreciation reduces taxable income, so it reduces the tax paid, and that reduction is a genuine cash saving. The depreciation charge itself moves no money and must not be subtracted as an outflow. The usual construction adds it back after tax has been calculated, which is why the layout of the cash flow schedule matters as much as the individual figures.
Is payback ever useful?
As a screen rather than a decision rule. It answers how long capital is at risk, which a manager may reasonably care about, particularly where liquidity is tight or the environment is uncertain. What it cannot do is say whether a project creates value, since it ignores everything after the cutoff and the timing of money before it. Report it, use it as context, and decide on net present value.
Where can I find a free FIN 504 Topic 5 sample paper?
The capital budgeting analysis is shown here complete: the question, incremental cash flows, net present value, payback, why they disagree, a quick-payback alternative, why payback persists, the discount rate and the recommendation. Send your project and we will evaluate it free.
Why approve a project that fails payback in FIN 504 Topic 5?
Payback ignores the 7.4 million the line returns after year 4. Net present value counts every cash flow and shows the line adds about 1.76 million dollars.