| Course | FIN 504 Finance Principles |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Project ranking analysis |
| Length | About 1,020 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 504 Topic 6
A 27 Percent Return or 1.27 Million of Value? Ranking Two Ways to Automate Coil Brazing When IRR and NPV Disagree
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-504: Finance Principles
Topic 6 Project Ranking Analysis
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
A 27 Percent Return or 1.27 Million of Value? Ranking Two Ways to Automate Coil Brazing When IRR and NPV Disagree
Two Projects, One Choice
The composite equipment manufacturer must automate the brazing of copper coils, a step that now limits output on its heat pump line. Engineering has proposed two ways to do it, and only one can be built, so the projects are mutually exclusive. A semi-automatic fixture system costs 2.0 million dollars. A robotic brazing cell costs 8.0 million dollars and handles far more volume. Both run four years before the line is redesigned. The company's cost of capital is 7.71 percent. This analysis computes each project's value added and its percentage return, shows that the two criteria rank the projects in opposite order, explains why, and recommends which to follow.
The Cash Flows and Both Criteria
The fixtures return 1.0 million dollars in each of the first two years, 0.8 million in year 3 and 0.5 million in year 4. The robotic cell returns 2.4, 2.8, 3.0 and 3.0 million. Discounted at 7.71 percent, the fixtures have a net present value of about 0.80 million dollars and the robotic cell about 1.27 million. Discounting at a rate that brings each project's value added to exactly zero gives its internal rate of return: about 26.7 percent for the fixtures and about 14.4 percent for the cell.
Table 1
Cash Flows in Millions of Dollars, NPV and IRR
| Project | Now | After 1 year | After 2 years | After 3 years | After 4 years | NPV at 7.71% | IRR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semi-automatic fixtures | -2.0 | 1.0 | 1.0 | 0.8 | 0.5 | 0.80 | 26.7% |
| Robotic cell | -8.0 | 2.4 | 2.8 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 1.27 | 14.4% |
| Cell minus fixtures | -6.0 | 1.4 | 1.8 | 2.2 | 2.5 | 0.47 | 10.8% |
The Conflict
Ranked by internal rate of return, the fixtures win easily, 26.7 percent against 14.4. Ranked by net present value, the robotic cell wins, 1.27 million against 0.80. Both projects are acceptable on their own, since each adds value and each returns more than 7.71 percent, but the company can build only one. A manager who chose by the higher percentage would pick the fixtures and leave about 0.47 million dollars of value unclaimed.
Why It Happens: Scale
The main cause is scale. The internal rate of return is a percentage, so it says nothing about how many dollars a project earns. A 26.7 percent return on 2.0 million creates less value than a 14.4 percent return on 8.0 million when capital costs 7.71 percent. Net present value measures value in dollars, which is what the owners keep. The incremental project, building the cell instead of the fixtures, makes the point directly: spending an extra 6.0 million produces extra cash flows of 1.4, 1.8, 2.2 and 2.5 million, with a net present value of about 0.47 million and an internal rate of return of about 10.8 percent. That increment earns more than the cost of capital, so it is worth undertaking.
Why It Happens: Timing and Reinvestment
The fixtures also return cash sooner. Their cash flows are front-loaded, while the cell's grow over time. The internal rate of return implicitly treats each project's interim cash as if it earned that project's own rate when reinvested, 26.7 percent for the fixtures, while net present value assumes reinvestment at the cost of capital. The cost of capital is the more realistic assumption, because it is the return the company's other average-risk opportunities actually offer (Hirshleifer, 1958).
The Crossover Rate
The rankings depend on the discount rate. The incremental internal rate of return, about 10.8 percent, is the crossover rate at which the two projects have the same net present value. Below it, the robotic cell has the higher net present value; above it, the fixtures do. At 5 percent the cell is worth about 1.89 million against 0.96 for the fixtures, while at 12 percent the fixtures lead, 0.58 against 0.42. Because the company's cost of capital, 7.71 percent, lies below the crossover, the cell is preferred. The finding also tells management how robust the choice is: the cost of capital would have to rise by more than three points for the ranking to reverse.
Which Criterion to Follow
For mutually exclusive projects, follow net present value (Brealey et al., 2020). It measures what each project adds to the owners' wealth, it uses a realistic reinvestment rate and it adds across projects. The internal rate of return remains useful; managers find a percentage easy to communicate and compare with a borrowing rate, and survey evidence shows it is used about as often as net present value (Graham & Harvey, 2001). It answers whether a single project clears the hurdle, but not which of two exclusive projects to choose.
The Exception: Limited Capital
If the company could spend only 2.0 million dollars this year, the comparison would change, because the cell would not be available at all. When capital is rationed, projects are compared by net present value per dollar invested, the profitability index: about 1.40 for the fixtures and 1.16 for the cell. The fixtures would then be the right choice. The manufacturer faces no such limit, since its cash and credit lines cover the 8.0 million outlay.
Checking the Forecasts
The recommendation rests on the cell's later cash flows, which are less certain than the fixtures' early ones, so they deserve a test. If the cell's cash flows in years 3 and 4 came in 15 percent below forecast, at 2.55 million each, its net present value would fall to about 0.58 million, below the fixtures' 0.80. The engineering team should therefore confirm the volume assumptions behind those years before the purchase order is signed. If the forecasts hold, the cell is the better project; if the team cannot support them, the margin of advantage is thin enough that the fixtures become the safer choice.
Recommendation
The manufacturer should build the robotic brazing cell. It adds about 1.27 million dollars of value, about 0.47 million more than the fixtures, and the extra 6.0 million it requires earns about 10.8 percent, above the 7.71 percent cost of capital. The fixtures' higher internal rate of return reflects their smaller size and earlier cash flows, not greater value.
References
Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
Graham, J. R., & Harvey, C. R. (2001). The theory and practice of corporate finance: Evidence from the field. Journal of Financial Economics, 60(2-3), 187-243. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0304-405X(01)00044-7
Hirshleifer, J. (1958). On the theory of optimal investment decision. Journal of Political Economy, 66(4), 329-352. https://doi.org/10.1086/258057
The FIN-504 Topic 6 assignment instructions
In Topic 6, FIN-504 asks MBA students to rank competing projects. Strong analyses compute net present value and internal rate of return for each, show where they conflict and explain the conflict through scale, timing and the reinvestment assumption. Students should find the crossover rate, state which criterion governs mutually exclusive choices and handle the capital rationing exception. Students should also test the preferred project's later forecasts, since its advantage depends on them. The incremental project, built from the difference in cash flows, should be valued on its own.
Inside the FIN 504 Topic 6 example
The finished example arranges projects that rank differently under the two criteria, which is the situation the topic exists for. Both measures are computed for each. Where they disagree, the example explains the cause rather than noting the fact: differences in scale, in the timing of cash flows, or in project life all produce it, and each works through a different mechanism. Net present value is followed, and the reason is given in terms of what the firm is trying to maximize rather than as a rule. The reinvestment assumption inside the internal rate of return is named, since it is the technical heart of the disagreement. Capital rationing appears where the budget cannot fund everything worthwhile.
Where the marks sit in the FIN 504 Topic 6 rubric
Faculty reward a conflict worked through, not avoided. An Excellent paper tables both projects and their difference with net present values and returns. Credit goes to the incremental return of 10.8 percent as the crossover, with Hirshleifer on reinvestment. The rubric values following net present value for exclusive projects, with Brealey and colleagues, and a profitability index for rationed capital. Strong papers cite Graham and Harvey on use of both criteria. Top marks go to testing the cell's later forecasts. Papers that show the crossover rate and how far the cost of capital would have to rise to reverse the ranking tell management how robust the choice is. Credit also goes to explaining why surveys find IRR used as often as NPV.
Common FIN 504 Topic 6 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Computing both criteria and reporting agreement is the missed opportunity, since the topic is built around the case where they conflict and a paper avoiding it has not engaged the material. A second failure is choosing the higher internal rate of return without argument, which is intuitive and wrong when the projects differ in scale. Papers lose marks for noting a conflict without explaining what produced it, because the mechanism is the assessed content. Ignoring the reinvestment assumption leaves the technical reason unstated. Handling a capital rationing case with absolute net present value, where the constraint calls for value per unit of capital, produces a defensible looking ranking that spends the budget badly.
Get a FIN-504 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-504 Topic 6 problems and the rubric from your classroom, with the competing projects your section supplied. We write a custom example to those criteria, with both criteria computed for each, the cause of any conflict identified, the reinvestment assumption named and rationing handled properly, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More FIN 504 papers and MBA samples
- FIN 504 Topic 1: Time Value of Money Problem Set
- FIN 504 Topic 2: Bond and Stock Valuation
- FIN 504 Topic 3: Risk and Required Return Analysis
- FIN 504 Topic 4: Cost of Capital Build
- FIN 504 Topic 5: Capital Budgeting Analysis
- FIN 504 Topic 7: Capital Structure Analysis
- FIN 504 Topic 8: Valuation Recommendation
- ECN 601 Topic 6: Business Cycle Position Analysis
- HRM 635 Topic 6: Training Return Evaluation Plan
- BUS 660 Topic 6: Network Optimization Problem
- HRM 640 Topic 6: Implementation Gap Review
FIN 504 Topic 6 questions, answered
Why do the two criteria ever disagree?
Because they measure different things. Net present value reports how much value a project adds in currency; internal rate of return reports the percentage it earns. A small project can earn a spectacular rate on very little money while a large one adds far more value at a lower rate. Differences in the timing of cash flows and in project life produce the same conflict through a different route.
Which criterion should I follow?
Net present value, in almost every case, because a firm is trying to maximize the value it adds rather than the rate it earns. A shareholder is better off with more money than with a higher percentage on less. Internal rate of return remains useful as a communication device, since a percentage is intuitive to non financial audiences, but it should not decide between mutually exclusive projects.
What changes under capital rationing?
The ranking basis. When the budget cannot fund every worthwhile project, the goal becomes getting the most value from the capital available, so projects are ranked by value created per unit invested rather than by absolute value. That can promote several smaller projects above one large one, which is the correct answer under the constraint even though it looks like the opposite of the usual rule.
Where can I find a free FIN 504 Topic 6 sample paper?
The ranking analysis is printed here in full: two projects, both criteria, the conflict, scale, timing and reinvestment, the crossover rate, which to follow, limited capital, checking the forecasts and the recommendation. Send your projects and we will rank them at no cost.
Why choose the lower return in FIN 504 Topic 6?
The cell's 14.4 percent applies to 8.0 million and adds 1.27 million of value, against 0.80 million for the fixtures. Value in dollars is what the owners keep.