FIN 504 Topic 7 capital structure analysis example

Finance Principles Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This FIN 504 Topic 7 sample paper shows debt magnifying a composite heating and cooling contractor's returns in both directions and explains why a profitable year left it short of cash. It forms part of GCU FIN 504, Finance Principles, catalog code FIN-504, in Grand Canyon University's MBA. Borrowing half its 5.0 million of assets at 7 percent lifts return on equity from 9.0 to 12.75 percent in a normal year and cuts it from 3.0 to 0.75 in a weak one; the two structures meet at 350,000 dollars of operating profit. A 70-day cash conversion cycle means 20 percent growth needs about 440,000 dollars, which faster collection would release.

CourseFIN 504 Finance Principles
TopicTopic 7
Paper typeCapital structure analysis
LengthAbout 990 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for FIN 504 Topic 7

1

Debt That Cuts Both Ways and a Profitable Year Without Cash: Capital Structure and Working Capital at a Heating and Cooling Contractor

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

FIN-504: Finance Principles

Topic 7 Capital Structure Analysis

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title pairs the two downside risks the analysis treats. The contractor and every figure are a composite; the sources are real.
2

Debt That Cuts Both Ways and a Profitable Year Without Cash: Capital Structure and Working Capital at a Heating and Cooling Contractor

Two Ways to Fail

A composite heating and cooling contractor's owners, running a business with 5.0 million dollars of assets and 12.0 million of annual revenue, are deciding whether to finance half the business with debt, and they are puzzled that a profitable year left them short of cash. The two questions belong together, because both concern surviving a bad year. This analysis shows how debt magnifies the owners' returns in both directions, finds the point at which borrowing stops helping, and then examines the working capital that determines whether a profitable firm can pay its bills.

Two Structures

In the first structure the contractor is financed entirely by the owners' 5.0 million dollars of equity. In the second it borrows 2.5 million at 7 percent, paying 175,000 dollars a year in interest, and the owners provide 2.5 million. Operating profit before interest and taxes, which depends on the construction market, is 200,000 dollars in a weak year, 600,000 in a normal year and 1,000,000 in a strong year. Taxes are 25 percent of profit after interest. The return on equity is net income divided by the owners' investment.

Table 1

Return on Equity Under Two Capital Structures

Operating profitAll equity: return on equityHalf debt: return on equityInterest coverage, half debt
100,0001.50%-2.25%0.57 times
200,0003.00%0.75%1.14 times
350,0005.25%5.25%2.00 times
600,0009.00%12.75%3.43 times
1,000,00015.00%24.75%5.71 times

Magnification in Both Directions

In a normal year, borrowing raises the owners' return from 9.0 to 12.75 percent; in a strong year, from 15.0 to 24.75 percent. In a weak year it lowers the return from 3.0 to 0.75 percent, and if operating profit fell to 100,000 dollars the owners would lose money with debt while still earning 1.5 percent without it. The swing between weak and strong years is 12 points of return on equity without debt and 24 points with it. Debt does not make the business riskier; it concentrates the same business risk on a smaller equity base. That is why Modigliani and Miller (1958) argued that, without taxes and costs of financial distress, the higher expected return from borrowing exactly compensates the owners for the higher risk, leaving the firm's total value unchanged.

Where Borrowing Stops Helping

The two structures give the same return on equity when operating profit equals 350,000 dollars, a return on assets of 7 percent, the same as the interest rate. Whenever the business earns more on its assets than the debt costs, borrowing raises the owners' return; whenever it earns less, borrowing lowers it. The contractor's normal year clears that threshold comfortably, but its weak year does not. Interest coverage, operating profit divided by interest, shows the safety margin: 3.4 times in a normal year but only about 1.1 times in a weak one, which is close to the point where the contractor could not pay its lender from operations.

What the Owners Should Decide

Two real-world considerations move the answer away from the irrelevance result. Interest is deductible, which makes debt somewhat cheaper than equity, and financial distress is costly, since a contractor that misses payments loses suppliers' credit and customers' confidence (Brealey et al., 2020). For a business as cyclical as construction, the analysis recommends borrowing less than half: about 1.5 million, which keeps interest near 105,000 dollars and coverage close to 2 times even in a weak year. The smaller loan gives up some of the tax saving, about 26,250 dollars a year at a 25 percent rate instead of 43,750 on the larger loan, but the difference of 17,500 dollars is a modest price for staying well clear of default in the years the contractor is most likely to need its suppliers' patience.

Profitable but Short of Cash

The owners' second puzzle is explained by working capital. Each dollar of revenue is tied up for a period before it returns as cash. The contractor carries 2.0 million dollars of receivables on 12.0 million of revenue, so customers take about 61 days to pay. It holds 0.9 million of equipment and parts inventory against 8.4 million of annual cost of goods sold, about 39 days of supply. It owes suppliers 0.7 million, so it takes about 30 days to pay them. The cash conversion cycle, days of inventory plus days of receivables minus days of payables, is about 70 days: the contractor pays for parts roughly 70 days before it collects from the customer.

Why Growth Consumes Cash

Net working capital, receivables plus inventory minus payables, is 2.2 million dollars, about 18 percent of revenue. If revenue grows 20 percent next year, to 14.4 million, working capital must grow with it by about 440,000 dollars, more than the 318,750 dollars of net income the half-debt structure earns in a normal year. The contractor can be profitable and still run out of cash because the growth itself absorbs the cash its profits produce.

Shortening the Cycle

The most effective lever is receivables. Invoicing at job completion instead of month end, requiring deposits on replacement installations and following up on balances over 30 days could bring collection from 61 to about 45 days, which would release about 493,000 dollars, enough to fund the growth. Firms that shorten collection and inventory periods have been found to be more profitable (Deloof, 2003). Stretching supplier payments is a weaker option, since it risks losing early-payment discounts and supplier goodwill.

Conclusion

Debt magnifies the owners' returns in both directions and helps only when the business earns more on its assets than the debt costs, which this contractor does in normal years but not in weak ones; a smaller loan keeps it safe. A profitable year left it short of cash because a 70-day cycle ties up working capital as it grows. Faster collection would release about 493,000 dollars and fund next year's growth.

References

Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.

Deloof, M. (2003). Does working capital management affect profitability of Belgian firms? Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 30(3-4), 573-588. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-5957.00008

Modigliani, F., & Miller, M. H. (1958). The cost of capital, corporation finance and the theory of investment. American Economic Review, 48(3), 261-297.

What the FIN 504 Topic 7 instructions ask for

The Topic 7 assignment in FIN-504 asks MBA students to analyze capital structure and working capital. Strong analyses show one firm under two debt levels in good and bad years, find where borrowing stops helping and explain why distress costs limit debt. Students should compute the cash conversion cycle, read it as days the firm must fund itself, and weigh the cost of each working capital policy on both sides. The threshold where borrowing stops helping, the return on assets equal to the interest rate, should be found and explained. Working capital should be treated as a set of decisions about inventory, credit and payment terms, each with a cost on both sides.

How the FIN-504 Topic 7 example is put together

The finished example shows debt amplifying results rather than describing it. The same firm is shown at two debt levels in good and bad years, so returns rise further in strong years and fall further in weak ones from identical operations. Distress costs explain why an optimal structure exists, since without them more debt would always look better. Working capital is handled as decisions with a cost on both sides, and the cash conversion cycle is read as the days the firm must fund itself. The tax saving given up by borrowing less is computed and weighed against default risk, and faster collection is costed as the cash it would release.

Reading the FIN 504 Topic 7 rubric

Faculty reward debt shown cutting both ways on the same firm. An Excellent paper tables return on equity for two structures across five profit levels with interest coverage. Credit goes to the 350,000 dollar crossover where return on assets equals the 7 percent rate, with Modigliani and Miller on irrelevance. The rubric values a smaller loan justified by distress costs. Strong papers compute a 70-day cycle and the cash growth consumes. Top marks go to faster collection, with Deloof on working capital. Credit also goes to explaining why a profitable, growing firm can run short of cash, using net working capital as a share of revenue. Faculty value a recommendation sized to the industry's cyclical risk rather than to a normal year alone.

FIN 504 Topic 7 help: mistakes that cost marks

Showing borrowing in a good year only is the standard shortfall, since amplification is convincing only when the same firm appears in a bad year too. Presenting debt as simply cheaper ignores distress costs and implies borrowing without limit. Papers lose marks for treating working capital as ratios rather than decisions, since each policy costs something on both sides. A cash conversion cycle computed and never interpreted wastes the calculation, and aggressive policies proposed without their lost sales tell half the story. Papers that recommend debt without testing a weak year, or tighter credit terms without counting the sales they cost, miss the downside the topic is about.

Get a FIN-504 Topic 7 example written to your instructions

Send the FIN-504 Topic 7 problems and the rubric your classroom posts, with the firm data your section supplied. We write a custom example to those criteria, with one firm modeled at two structures across a good and a bad year, distress costs argued and the cash conversion cycle read as days, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More FIN 504 papers and MBA samples

FIN 504 Topic 7 questions, answered

What does the cash conversion cycle actually tell me?

How many days pass between paying for inventory and collecting from the customer who bought it, which is the period the firm must fund out of its own resources. A long cycle means capital is tied up in the operating process; a negative one means suppliers are effectively financing the business. Reading it as a funding requirement rather than as a ratio is what makes it useful.

Where can I find a free FIN 504 Topic 7 sample paper?

The capital structure analysis is shown here complete: two ways to fail, two structures, magnification both ways, where borrowing stops helping, the owners' decision, cash shortfalls, why growth consumes cash, shortening the cycle and the conclusion. Send your firm's figures and we will write it free.

Why does debt magnify losses in FIN 504 Topic 7?

Interest of 175,000 dollars is owed whatever the year brings. In a weak year it absorbs most of the operating profit, so the owners' smaller equity base takes the whole shortfall.

Why not finance the contractor mostly with debt in FIN 504 Topic 7?

Distress costs rise with debt. A contractor that misses payments loses supplier credit and customer confidence, which outweighs the tax saving on interest.

How can a profitable contractor run short of cash in FIN 504 Topic 7?

Growth ties up cash in receivables and inventory. At 18 percent of revenue, 20 percent growth needs about 440,000 dollars, more than a normal year's net income.