FIN 655 Topic 2 liability-relative allocation study example

Investments Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This FIN 655 Topic 2 sample paper measures a composite utility pension's 60/40 mix against its promises rather than an index. It forms part of GCU FIN 655, Investments, listed as FIN-655 in the Grand Canyon University MS in Finance. Assets of 800 million face 900 million of liabilities with a duration of 12, while core bonds at duration 6 hedge only about 17.8 percent of rate risk. A one-point fall in rates widens the deficit from 100 to about 189 million. Long bonds at duration 14 lift the hedge ratio to 41.5 percent, hold the widening to about 63 million, and on the case's curve add expected return instead of costing it.

CourseFIN 655 Investments
TopicTopic 2
Paper typeLiability-relative allocation study
LengthAbout 1,180 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMS in Finance
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for FIN 655 Topic 2

1

Measuring a 60/40 Pension Against Its Promises: Hedge Ratio, Rate and Equity Shocks, and a Funded-Status Glide Path

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

FIN-655: Investments

Topic 2 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title names the study's measure, funded status, and its three tests. The plan, the sponsor and every figure are illustrative; the sources are real.
2

Measuring a 60/40 Pension Against Its Promises: Hedge Ratio, Rate and Equity Shocks, and a Funded-Status Glide Path

The Plan Read From the Liability Side

A composite utility sponsors a defined benefit plan that holds 800 million dollars of assets against 900 million dollars of promised benefits, measured at the discount rate the case supplies. The plan is 88.9 percent funded, with a deficit of 100 million. The liabilities have a duration of 12 years. The assets sit 60 percent in return-seeking holdings, mostly equities, and 40 percent in a core bond portfolio with a duration of 6. Every figure in this study is illustrative.

In asset-only terms the mix looks moderate, a conventional 60/40 split. Sharpe and Tint (1990) argued that a pension's investment problem should be framed as the surplus, assets minus liabilities, because the sponsor's real exposure is to that difference. A portfolio that is cautious when judged by asset volatility can still carry most of its risk against the promises. This study therefore measures every candidate policy by funded status and deficit, not by the asset return alone.

The Hedge Ratio

The first measure is how much of the liabilities' interest rate sensitivity the bonds offset. Dollar duration is value multiplied by duration. For the liabilities it is 900 times 12, or 10,800; for the core bonds it is 320 times 6, or 1,920. The bonds therefore hedge about 17.8 percent of the liabilities' rate exposure. The other 82 percent is open.

This is the omission the study is designed to expose. Bonds are often treated as the safe part of a pension portfolio, but safety depends on what the bonds are meant to match. A short core bond portfolio is low in volatility measured in dollars, yet relative to a 12-year liability stream it leaves the plan exposed whenever rates fall, because the liabilities' value rises far faster than the bonds'. Fisher and Weil (1971) showed that matching the duration of assets to the horizon of the obligation protects against parallel rate moves, and the same logic applies to a pension's promises.

Three Candidate Policies Under Shock

The study compares three policies with the same 800 million. Policy A is the current mix: 60 percent return-seeking and 40 percent core bonds at duration 6. Policy B keeps the 60/40 split but replaces core bonds with long bonds at duration 14, raising the hedge ratio to about 41.5 percent. Policy C cuts return-seeking assets to 45 percent and holds 55 percent in core bonds at duration 6, a common first response to a deficit, with a hedge ratio of about 24.4 percent.

Each policy faces three shocks: a one-point parallel fall in rates, a 25 percent fall in return-seeking assets, and both together. Table 1 reports the deficit after each.

Table 1

Deficit After Each Shock, Millions of Dollars, Illustrative

PolicyHedge ratioRates down 1 pointReturn-seeking down 25%Both
A: 60/40, duration 617.8%188.8220.0308.8
B: 60/40, duration 1441.5%163.2220.0283.2
C: 45/55, duration 624.4%181.6190.0271.6

A one-point fall in rates raises the liabilities by about 108 million, to 1,008 million. Under Policy A the bonds rise by only about 19 million, so the deficit widens from 100 to about 189 million without any stock moving. Under Policy B the long bonds rise by about 45 million and the deficit widens to about 163 million. Under Policy C the larger core bond holding rises by about 26 million, and the deficit reaches about 182 million, little better than doing nothing.

The equity shock tells the opposite story. A 25 percent fall in return-seeking assets costs Policies A and B 120 million each and Policy C 90 million. In the combined shock, the year sponsors fear most, Policy A's deficit reaches about 309 million, Policy B's about 283 million and Policy C's about 272 million.

What this page is doingPolicy C looks safest in the combined shock, but it buys that with expected return, as the next section shows.
3

Expected Return and the Curve

The shock table alone would favor Policy C, so expected return has to sit beside it. Using the case's assumptions, return-seeking assets are expected to earn 7.0 percent, core bonds yield 4.6 percent and long bonds 4.9 percent on the case's upward-sloping curve. Policy A's expected return is about 6.04 percent, Policy B's about 6.16 percent and Policy C's about 5.68 percent. On 800 million, Policy C gives up roughly 2.9 million a year of expected return against Policy A, and nearly 3.8 million against Policy B.

Extending duration therefore costs nothing in expected return on this curve; it slightly adds. If the curve were inverted, long bonds would yield less than core bonds and lengthening would carry a cost, which the committee would weigh against the hedge it buys. These yields are the case's assumptions and not a forecast of where rates will go.

Ibbotson and Kaplan (2000) distinguished three questions that are often blurred: how much of a fund's return variation over time policy explains, how much of the difference between funds it explains, and how much of the level of return it explains. The question here is the first, because the plan's year-to-year funded status is driven mainly by its policy exposures to rates and equities, which is why the bond duration decision deserves as much attention as the stock and bond split.

Duration as a First Estimate

Duration is a first-order estimate of rate sensitivity. For a one-point move, convexity adds a small correction to both the liabilities and the long bonds, and because both are long-dated the corrections partly offset. The conclusions above do not depend on it. For larger moves, or for a curve that twists rather than shifts in parallel, the study would need key rate durations matched across the curve.

A Glide Path Tied to Funding

The study recommends Policy B now. It raises the hedge ratio from about 18 to about 41 percent and keeps the return-seeking share the deficit still needs to close. Cutting equities first, as Policy C does, gives up expected return while leaving most of the rate exposure in place.

From there, de-risking should follow progress rather than a committee's mood in a given year. At 95 percent funded, return-seeking assets step down to 55 percent and the hedge ratio rises to 55 percent. At 100 percent funded they step to 50 percent with a 70 percent hedge ratio, and at 105 percent to 45 percent with a hedge ratio near 85 percent. Each step is reviewed quarterly against funded status measured on the plan's own discount basis, and steps are not reversed when markets fall, so gains, once locked in, stay locked in. A written rule of this kind spares future committees the hardest decision, which is when to sell risk assets after a good year.

Conclusion

Measured against its promises, the plan's most important exposure is not its equity weight but the short duration of its bonds. Lengthening that duration before cutting equities hedges more of the deficit's main driver at no cost in expected return on the case's curve, and the funding-based glide path then reduces equity risk as the plan earns its way toward full funding.

References

Fisher, L., & Weil, R. L. (1971). Coping with the risk of interest-rate fluctuations: Returns to bondholders from naive and optimal strategies. Journal of Business, 44(4), 408-431. https://doi.org/10.1086/295402

Ibbotson, R. G., & Kaplan, P. D. (2000). Does asset allocation policy explain 40, 90, or 100 percent of performance? Financial Analysts Journal, 56(1), 26-33. https://doi.org/10.2469/faj.v56.n1.2327

Sharpe, W. F., & Tint, L. G. (1990). Liabilities: A new approach. Journal of Portfolio Management, 16(2), 5-10. https://doi.org/10.3905/jpm.1990.409248

The FIN-655 Topic 2 assignment instructions

In Topic 2, FIN-655 asks students to evaluate a pension plan's asset allocation relative to its liabilities. Strong submissions measure funded status, compute the hedge ratio from dollar durations, and test candidate policies against a fall in rates, a fall in return-seeking assets and both together. Students should compare expected returns alongside the shock results, explain how the yield curve affects the cost of lengthening duration, note the limits of duration as an estimate, and cite allocation research for the question it actually answers. The study should close with a recommended policy and a glide path that reduces risk as funding improves.

How this FIN 655 Topic 2 example is built

Illustrative figures run through the finished study. Liabilities of 900 million carry a duration of 12 years; assets of 800 million sit 60 percent in return-seeking holdings and 40 percent in core bonds with a duration of 6. The bonds' dollar duration, 320 times 6, covers only about 18 percent of the liabilities' 900 times 12, so a one-point fall in rates raises liabilities by about 108 million and the bonds by about 19. The deficit widens from 100 million to nearly 189 without any stock moving. Keeping the 60/40 split but holding long bonds with a duration of 14 lifts the hedge ratio to about 41 percent and holds the widening to 63 million. On the case's upward-sloping curve, the longer bonds even yield slightly more.

Reading the FIN 655 Topic 2 rubric

Graders award an Excellent study for judging the plan by its surplus. The rubric rewards computing the hedge ratio and showing how little rate risk short bonds offset. Credit goes to a shock table that reports three policies under rate, equity and combined shocks, with expected returns beside it. Faculty look for the curve's role in pricing longer duration and an honest note on convexity. Strong papers cite Ibbotson and Kaplan for the question their finding answers. Top marks go to lengthening duration before cutting equities and a glide path with stated funding thresholds.

Common FIN 655 Topic 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Most of the marks on this topic go to one omission: an allocation judged by asset volatility alone, with the liabilities never measured, tracks a risk other than the one the plan actually runs. Papers that treat bonds as the safe asset without checking their duration miss that short bonds leave a pension exposed to falling rates. Recommending a cut in equities as the first response to a deficit gives up expected return the plan needs while leaving most rate risk in place. Stating current yields or a rate forecast as fact turns the case's assumptions into a prediction the study cannot defend. Shock tests that move rates or stocks but never both together understate the year sponsors fear. A policy with no rule for when to de-risk leaves each future committee to decide in the moment.

Get a FIN-655 Topic 2 example written to your instructions

Send the FIN-655 Topic 2 instructions and your classroom rubric, with the plan data your section supplies. We write a custom example to them, with funded status as the measure, the hedge ratio computed, rate and equity shocks run singly and together, and a glide path defended against an immediate cut in equities, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More FIN 655 papers and MS in Finance samples

FIN 655 Topic 2 questions, answered

What is a hedge ratio for a pension plan?

The share of the liabilities' interest rate sensitivity that the assets offset, usually measured by comparing dollar durations. A plan whose bonds have a dollar duration equal to a fifth of its liabilities' has hedged about 20 percent of its rate risk, so when rates fall, the deficit widens by most of the liabilities' increase. Raising the ratio can be done by holding more bonds, longer bonds or derivatives that add duration.

Why does duration matter more than the stock and bond split here?

Because the plan's deficit moves with rates as well as with markets, and rate risk sits almost entirely in the gap between the liabilities' duration and the bonds'. Moving from core to long bonds changes the hedge ratio from about 18 to about 41 percent without touching the split. Cutting equities would reduce market risk, but at a duration of 6 even more bonds would leave most rate risk unhedged.

Does the study say how a real pension plan should invest?

No. The plan, its liabilities, the durations and the expected returns are invented so that rate risk and market risk can be seen apart. A real plan's allocation depends on actuarial valuations, the sponsor's finances, the discount rate rules that apply to it and advice from its actuary and consultants. The study is FIN-655 coursework on measuring allocation against liabilities, and it recommends nothing to any actual plan.

Where can I find a free FIN 655 Topic 2 sample paper?

Here, in full: the plan read from the liability side, the hedge ratio, three policies under shock, expected return and the curve, duration as an estimate, the glide path and the conclusion. Give us your plan's assets, liabilities and durations and a free study can be run on them.

What does a one-point rate fall do in FIN 655 Topic 2?

Liabilities rise about 108 million while core bonds gain about 19, so the deficit widens from 100 to about 189 million with no stock moving. With long bonds the gain is about 45 million and the deficit reaches about 163.