| Course | FIN 655 Investments |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Constrained frontier memo |
| Length | About 880 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Finance |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 655 Topic 3
Memorandum
To: Board of Trustees, Covenant Community Foundation
From: Investment Office
Date: [Date]
Re: Pricing the foundation's three investment rules against the 7.5 percent target
The Target and the Rules
The foundation needs an expected return of 7.5 percent a year to fund its grants and keep their real value. Its governing documents impose three rules: it may not borrow, it may not hold companies in one excluded industry, and illiquid holdings may not exceed 15 percent of assets. This memo first states what portfolio theory would recommend without those rules and then prices each rule in turn, so the board can see which one is expensive. All capital market inputs are the case's illustrative assumptions.
The Unconstrained Answer
With cash yielding 3.0 percent, the mix on the case's efficient frontier with the highest ratio of excess return to risk expects 6.5 percent at 10 percent volatility, a Sharpe ratio of 0.35. Tobin (1958) showed that once a risk-free asset exists, every investor should hold that same risky mix and adjust risk only by adding cash or borrowing. Reaching 7.5 percent this way means holding (7.5 minus 3.0) divided by (6.5 minus 3.0), or about 129 percent of the mix, funded by borrowing the other 29 percent. Volatility would be 1.29 times 10, about 12.9 percent. That is the reference point every constrained portfolio is measured against.
Rule One: No Borrowing
The foundation cannot borrow, so it cannot scale the best mix up. Instead it must move up the frontier itself to a mix heavier in equities, which on the case's inputs expects 7.5 percent at 13.5 percent volatility. The borrowing ban therefore costs about 0.6 points of volatility for the same expected return.
Black (1972) showed that when borrowing is restricted, investors who want higher returns tilt toward high-beta assets instead, which is exactly the move the foundation is forced to make. The practical consequence is that the foundation's portfolio carries more equity risk, concentrated in more volatile holdings, than a borrowing investor would need for the same target.
Rule Two: The Exclusion
The excluded industry makes up about 4 percent of the benchmark. Removing it does not have a cost that can be forecast in return, because the evidence does not settle whether excluded industries outperform or underperform over long periods. The cost that can be stated is tracking error: on the case's inputs, the exclusion adds about 0.5 percent a year of deviation from the benchmark. The board should judge the rule by that figure, and by whether it is willing to explain a year in which the industry rallies, rather than by a guess at forgone return.
Rule Three: The Illiquidity Cap
The optimizer's private equity inputs come from appraisal-based returns, which report 12 percent volatility. Appraisals change slowly and smooth reported values, so measured volatility understates true risk. Getmansky et al. (2004) showed that this smoothing creates serial correlation in reported returns and can be partly reversed. Unsmoothed, the case's private equity volatility is about 22 percent.
On the smoothed figure the optimizer treats private equity as a low-risk diversifier and wants more of it than the 15 percent cap allows, so the cap appears to bind and to cost return. On the corrected figure the optimizer's preferred weight falls below 15 percent and the cap no longer binds. The rule costs little once the inputs are honest; the apparent cost was a product of smoothing.
Ranking the Costs
Table 1
Each Rule Priced in Its Own Unit, Illustrative
| Rule | What it forbids | Cost, stated unit |
|---|---|---|
| No borrowing | Scaling the best mix to 129% | About 0.6 points of volatility |
| Industry exclusion | About 4% of the benchmark | About 0.5% tracking error |
| Illiquidity cap at 15% | Private assets above 15% | Near zero on unsmoothed inputs |
Ranked by cost, the borrowing ban comes first, at about 0.6 points of added volatility at the target. The exclusion comes second, at about 0.5 percent of tracking error with no forecast return loss. The illiquidity cap comes last, costing close to nothing once private equity returns are unsmoothed.
The Alternative: A Lower Target
The board could instead hold the unlevered best mix and accept its 6.5 percent expected return at 10 percent volatility. That avoids the extra risk but lowers expected return by a full point. On the foundation's assets, a point of return is a point of grants, so the board should see this choice as smaller awards rather than as a safer portfolio.
What the Board Should Watch
Three figures belong in the board's quarterly report once the mix is in place. The first is realized volatility against the 13.5 percent the policy expects, so a drift toward more equity risk is caught early. The second is tracking error from the exclusion, reported separately, so the cost of the rule stays visible rather than blending into manager results. The third is private equity's weight measured at current appraisals, because a fall in public markets raises that weight even when nothing is bought.
Recommendation
The memo recommends the equity-heavier frontier mix expecting 7.5 percent at about 13.5 percent volatility, with the exclusion applied and private equity held at the weight the unsmoothed inputs support, below the cap. The board should record that the borrowing ban is its most expensive rule and revisit it only through the governing documents, not by a workaround in the portfolio.
References
Black, F. (1972). Capital market equilibrium with restricted borrowing. Journal of Business, 45(3), 444-455. https://doi.org/10.1086/295472
Getmansky, M., Lo, A. W., & Makarov, I. (2004). An econometric model of serial correlation and illiquidity in hedge fund returns. Journal of Financial Economics, 74(3), 529-609. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfineco.2004.04.001
Tobin, J. (1958). Liquidity preference as behavior towards risk. Review of Economic Studies, 25(2), 65-86. https://doi.org/10.2307/2296205
FIN 655 Topic 3 instructions, in plain terms
Topic 3 of FIN-655 asks students to show how real-world constraints change an optimal portfolio. Strong memos state the unconstrained answer first, using the line from cash through the highest-Sharpe mix, and then take each constraint in turn: what it forbids, what the portfolio does once it binds, and what it costs in a stated unit. Students should explain why restricted borrowing pushes investors toward riskier holdings, price an exclusion through tracking error rather than a forecast, and correct smoothed private asset returns before optimizing. The memo should rank the costs, weigh a lower target as the alternative, and recommend a mix.
Inside the FIN 655 Topic 3 example
The finished memo begins with the foundation's 7.5 percent target and its three rules. With cash at 3.0 percent, the highest-Sharpe mix expects 6.5 percent at 10 percent volatility, a ratio of 0.35. Reaching the target from there takes about 129 percent of that mix, financed by borrowing, at volatility near 12.9. The foundation may not borrow, so it moves up the frontier to an equity-heavier mix expecting 7.5 at 13.5 volatility, and the borrowing ban costs about 0.6 points of risk. Excluding an industry worth about 4 percent of the benchmark adds roughly 0.5 percent of tracking error. Appraisal-based private equity shows 12 percent volatility, about 22 once unsmoothed, and on the honest figure the 15 percent cap no longer binds.
FIN 655 Topic 3 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty reward a memo that measures the distance between theory and the foundation's rules. An Excellent memo states the unconstrained answer and prices each rule in its own unit, volatility for the borrowing ban and tracking error for the exclusion. Credit goes to citing Black on restricted borrowing and Getmansky, Lo and Makarov on smoothed returns. The rubric values correcting private equity inputs before the optimizer sees them. Strong memos rank the three costs in a table and add what the board should monitor. Top marks go to weighing a lower target as smaller grants and recommending a mix the documents permit.
Common FIN 655 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them
An optimizer's output presented as the recommendation, with the foundation's rules applied afterward or not at all, loses the most here, because the topic is about the distance between the two. Memos that list the rules without pricing any of them leave the board unable to tell which one is expensive. Treating the exclusion as a certain loss of return asserts a forecast the evidence does not settle; tracking error is the cost that can be stated. Feeding appraisal-based returns into the optimizer unadjusted lets smoothing pass for diversification and fills the portfolio with illiquid assets. Recommending borrowing the governing documents forbid proposes a portfolio the committee has no authority to hold. A memo that never weighs a lower target against more volatility has skipped the one trade the board actually faces.
Get a FIN-655 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-655 Topic 3 instructions and the rubric shared in your classroom, with the inputs and constraints your section's case supplies. We write a custom example to them, with the unconstrained answer stated, each constraint priced in its own unit, smoothed returns corrected and the recommended mix defended against a lower target, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 655 papers and MS in Finance samples
- FIN 655 Topic 1: Mandate Design Memo
- FIN 655 Topic 2: Liability-relative Allocation Study
- FIN 655 Topic 4: Benchmark Suitability Review
- FIN 655 Topic 5: Factor Exposure Dq Post
- FIN 655 Topic 6: Total Fund Attribution Review
- FIN 655 Topic 7: Endowment Policy Statement
- FIN 655 Topic 8: Trustee Performance Letter
- FIN 490 Topic 3: Integrated Household Analysis
- FIN 210 Topic 3: Debt Repayment Order Comparison
- FIN 451 Topic 3: Net-of-cost Selection Review
- FIN 350 Topic 3: Annuity Problem Set
FIN 655 Topic 3 questions, answered
Why does the textbook solution require borrowing?
Because the best risk-adjusted mix on the frontier expects less than the target. Portfolio theory says any investor should hold that mix combined with cash, lending to take less risk and borrowing to take more. An investor needing 7.5 percent from a mix expecting 6.5 must borrow to scale it up. When borrowing is forbidden, the next best choice is a riskier mix higher on the frontier, which carries a lower Sharpe ratio.
What does unsmoothing do to private asset returns?
Appraisal-based valuations change slowly, so reported returns look steadier and less correlated with public markets than the underlying assets are. Unsmoothing methods estimate the underlying volatility by removing that lag from the return series. In the example, private equity's reported 12 percent volatility becomes about 22 once corrected, which shrinks the weight an optimizer would give it and changes whether the illiquidity cap matters at all.
Is the memo's mix suitable for a real foundation?
The memo cannot say. Its return and volatility inputs, the target, the exclusion's size and the private equity figures are all illustrative, chosen so that each constraint's cost appears separately. A real foundation's portfolio depends on its own governing documents, spending policy, grant commitments and the capital market assumptions its consultant documents. The memo demonstrates constrained portfolio reasoning for FIN-655 and makes no recommendation about any real fund.
Where can I find a free FIN 655 Topic 3 sample paper?
The constrained frontier memo is printed here in full: the target and rules, the unconstrained answer, each rule priced, the cost ranking, what to watch, the lower-target alternative and the recommendation. Share your case's inputs and constraints and a free memo can be worked from them.
Which rule costs the most in FIN 655 Topic 3?
The ban on borrowing. Without it the target is reached at about 12.9 percent volatility; with it the foundation needs a 13.5 percent mix, about 0.6 points more risk. The exclusion costs about 0.5 of tracking error, and the cap costs little once returns are unsmoothed.