| Course | FIN 655 Investments |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Factor exposure discussion post |
| Length | About 580 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Finance |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 655 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
From 2.5 Points to 0.3: What a Manager's Alpha Looks Like Once Size and Value Enter the Regression
Initial Post
My answer is that the pension plan's equity manager has delivered mostly exposure, not skill. The reported alpha of 2.5 points a year falls to 0.3 once size and value factors enter the regression. The fund and figures are composite and illustrative.
Table 1
Two Regressions, Five Years, Illustrative Figures in Points
| Model | Market loading | Size loading | Value loading | Predicted excess | Alpha |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CAPM | 1.10 | None | None | 6.6 | 2.5 |
| Three-factor | 1.00 | 0.50 | 0.60 | 8.8 | 0.3 |
Over five years the fund returned 12.1 percent a year against 3.0 percent for cash, an excess return of 9.1 points. With a market beta of 1.10 and a market premium of 6.0 points, the capital asset pricing model predicts 6.6 points of that excess, leaving the 2.5 the manager reports. Adding the size and value factors of Fama and French (1993), which returned 2.0 and 3.0 points a year over the period, changes the loadings: 1.00 on the market, 0.50 on size and 0.60 on value. Together they predict 6.0 plus 1.0 plus 1.8, or 8.8 points, so alpha shrinks to 0.3. The two tilts account for 2.8 points of the fund's excess return.
Significance matters before anyone claims skill. Residual volatility of 3.0 percent a year over five years gives alpha a standard error near 1.3 points (3.0 over the root of 5). Even the original 2.5 has a t-statistic near 1.9, short of the usual threshold of 2, and the adjusted 0.3 has a t-statistic near 0.2, which cannot be told apart from zero.
Whether the size and value premiums are rewards for risk, as Fama and French (1993) argued, or the result of investors extrapolating past growth and mispricing out-of-favor stocks, as Lakonishok et al. (1994) argued, the conclusion for the committee is the same. A tilt held steadily for five years can be bought cheaply through factor or style index funds, so it belongs to the plan's allocation decision rather than to the manager's fee. One caveat applies to my own answer too: any alpha is measured against a model, so a test of skill is also a test of whether the model is right, the joint hypothesis problem Fama (1991) described. The three-factor model may be missing exposures of its own, but it explains this fund far better than the market alone.
Reply to Marcus
Marcus, you argue that choosing the small and value tilt was itself skill, because the manager decided to hold those stocks before they paid off. I agree it was a decision, and a reasonable one. The question is what kind of skill it shows and what it is worth to the plan.
If the manager held the same tilt throughout, the decision was a policy choice that the committee could have made itself with an index fund at a few basis points. Paying an active fee for it rewards an exposure, not insight. Timing skill would look different: the loadings on size and value would rise before those factors did well and fall before they did poorly. That is testable by running the regression over rolling periods and checking whether changes in the loadings led the factor returns. If they did, I would grant the manager real skill and credit it. If the loadings stayed flat, as the five-year figures suggest, the committee is better served by holding the tilt directly and keeping the active budget for a manager whose alpha survives the three factors (Fama & French, 1993).
References
Fama, E. F. (1991). Efficient capital markets: II. Journal of Finance, 46(5), 1575-1617. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1991.tb04636.x
Fama, E. F., & French, K. R. (1993). Common risk factors in the returns on stocks and bonds. Journal of Financial Economics, 33(1), 3-56. https://doi.org/10.1016/0304-405X(93)90023-5
Lakonishok, J., Shleifer, A., & Vishny, R. W. (1994). Contrarian investment, extrapolation, and risk. Journal of Finance, 49(5), 1541-1578. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1994.tb04772.x
The FIN-655 Topic 5 assignment instructions
FIN-655 Topic 5 asks students to judge whether a manager's alpha reflects skill once factor exposures are counted. A strong post commits to a position in its opening line, tables the single-factor and multifactor regressions with loadings and predicted returns, and checks the significance of alpha using residual volatility and the length of the record. Students should present the risk and mispricing explanations of the size and value premiums fairly, note the joint hypothesis problem, and draw a conclusion for the plan. The reply should engage a classmate's argument directly and propose a test that could settle it.
How the FIN-655 Topic 5 example is put together
The post states its answer first: the result is mostly exposure. Its illustrative five-year figures give the fund 12.1 percent a year against 3.0 for cash, an excess of 9.1. With a market beta of 1.10 and a market premium of 6.0, the capital asset pricing model predicts 6.6 of that excess, leaving the reported alpha of 2.5. The post then adds the Fama and French size and value factors, which returned 2.0 and 3.0 over the period. Loadings of 1.00 on the market, 0.50 on size and 0.60 on value predict 8.8, and alpha shrinks to 0.3, with a t-statistic near 0.2. The post names the joint hypothesis problem Eugene Fama described: any alpha is measured against a model, so a claim of skill is also a claim about which model is right.
FIN 655 Topic 5 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty reward a post that shows where the return went. An Excellent post states that alpha falls from 2.5 to 0.3 and tables both regressions so classmates can recompute them. Credit goes to a significance check that finds even the original 2.5 below the usual threshold. The rubric values presenting Fama and French's risk view and Lakonishok, Shleifer and Vishny's mispricing view without picking a side as a premise. Strong posts name the joint hypothesis problem with Fama's 1991 review. Top marks go to a reply proposing a rolling-regression test of timing skill.
FIN 655 Topic 5 help before you submit
The characteristic failure here takes the most: a post that accepts the 2.5 points as skill because the manager beat the market after adjusting for beta, when the size and value exposures account for nearly all of it. Posts that add factors but never report the loadings leave classmates unable to see where the return went. Treating a factor-adjusted alpha as final, without the joint hypothesis caveat, overstates what any single model can settle. Declaring markets efficient, or inefficient, as a premise rather than an argument skips the evidence the prompt asks for. Omitting significance lets a five-year average speak with more confidence than its standard error allows. Replies that praise the tilt as clever leave the thread where it was, because the question is whether the committee could have bought it for a fraction of the fee.
Get a FIN-655 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-655 Topic 5 prompt and your classroom rubric, plus any return data or readings your section assigns. We write a custom example to that prompt, with the single-factor and multifactor regressions tabled, significance tested, the efficiency debate presented fairly and a reply that tests a classmate's claim of skill, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 655 papers and MS in Finance samples
- FIN 655 Topic 1: Mandate Design Memo
- FIN 655 Topic 2: Liability-relative Allocation Study
- FIN 655 Topic 3: Constrained Frontier Memo
- FIN 655 Topic 4: Benchmark Suitability Review
- FIN 655 Topic 6: Total Fund Attribution Review
- FIN 655 Topic 7: Endowment Policy Statement
- FIN 655 Topic 8: Trustee Performance Letter
- FIN 490 Topic 5: Unfollowed Recommendation Dq Post
- FIN 210 Topic 5: Debt or Invest Dq Post
- FIN 451 Topic 5: Drawdown Response Dq Post
- FIN 350 Topic 5: Required Return Dq Post
FIN 655 Topic 5 questions, answered
What are the Fama and French factors?
Return series built from portfolios that go long one group of stocks and short another: small companies minus large for size, and high book-to-market minus low for value. Eugene Fama and Kenneth French found that these factors, added to the market, explain much more of the variation in returns across stock portfolios than the market alone. Later versions add profitability and investment factors, and momentum is often included as well.
What is the joint hypothesis problem?
Market efficiency, Eugene Fama pointed out, can never be tested by itself. To say a return was abnormal, one must first say what normal return a model predicts, so every test of efficiency is also a test of the model. An alpha that disappears when factors are added shows the return came from the tilts, but whether those tilts earn a reward for risk or exploit a mispricing depends on which model is believed.
Does the post evaluate a real fund's manager?
No. The fund, its returns, the loadings and the factor returns are illustrative, picked because the two regressions then tell different stories that a classmate can check by hand. Real factor regressions depend on the data source, the period, the factor definitions and the standard errors, all of which change the answer. The post shows the kind of argument FIN-655 discussions reward, and it offers no view on any actual manager or product.
Where can I find a free FIN 655 Topic 5 sample paper?
The full post and reply are on this page: the answer in one number, both regressions in a table, the significance check, the efficiency debate, the joint hypothesis caveat and the reply to a classmate. Send your section's prompt and return data and a free post can be written to it.
Why does alpha fall to 0.3 in FIN 655 Topic 5?
Adding size and value lowers the market loading to 1.00 and credits 1.0 point to size and 1.8 to value. The three factors predict 8.8 of the 9.1-point excess return, leaving 0.3.