| Course | FIN 655 Investments |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Trustee performance letter |
| Length | About 880 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Letter with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Finance |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 655 Topic 8
[Chief Investment Officer Name]
Investment Office, Valley Community Foundation
[Address]
[Date]
Raymond Delgado, Trustee
[Address]
Dear Mr. Delgado,
Your Question
Thank you for your letter. You are right that the fund earned 6.44 percent last year while the broad domestic stock index rose 14.0 percent. On the fund's 300 million dollars, that difference of 7.56 points is about 22.7 million, and you deserve a full account of it. The short answer is that 6.8 points of the gap came from the policy the board adopted, and 0.76 points came from decisions made under that policy, which the investment office owns. The figures in this letter are illustrative.
The Three Returns Side by Side
Table 1
Last Year's Returns, Illustrative
| Measure | Return | Gap to stock index |
|---|---|---|
| Broad domestic stock index | 14.0% | None |
| Policy benchmark | 7.2% | 6.8 points, about $20.4 million |
| Fund | 6.44% | 7.56 points, about $22.7 million |
Three returns explain the year. The fund returned 6.44 percent. The stock index returned 14.0 percent. The policy benchmark, the mix the board adopted in its investment policy statement and measured with index returns, returned 7.2 percent.
The Board's Policy: 6.8 Points
The policy benchmark holds 40 percent domestic stocks, 20 percent international stocks, 30 percent bonds and 10 percent real assets. Last year those earned 14.0, 6.0, 1.0 and 1.0 percent, so the policy as a whole earned 7.2 percent. In a year when domestic stocks led everything else by a wide margin, any diversified policy trails them, and the 6.8 points is the cost of the diversification the board chose.
The board chose it for a reason that still holds. The foundation makes grants every year, and a portfolio entirely in domestic stocks would have fallen by more than a third in its worst years, cutting grants when the community needed them most. Swensen (2009) argued that a long-term institution's policy mix, not its yearly decisions, is the main driver of its results, and research on pension funds found the same: policy explains most of the variation in a fund's returns over time (Brinson et al., 1986). The board's policy was designed to give up some return in years like this one in exchange for steadier grants in bad years. Last year it did exactly what it was designed to do.
The Fund's Decisions: 0.76 Points
The policy accounts for the bulk of the difference, and the rest is ours to explain. The fund also trailed its own policy benchmark by 0.76 points, about 2.3 million dollars, and that shortfall belongs to us.
About 0.39 points, roughly 1.2 million dollars, came from the asset mix. Staff held domestic stocks three points below their 40 percent target and put the difference in bonds, judging that stock prices had risen too far. Domestic stocks then beat the policy as a whole by 6.8 points and bonds trailed it by 6.2, so the underweight cost on both sides. That was a staff decision, within the bands the policy allows, and it was wrong last year.
About 0.40 points, roughly 1.2 million dollars, came from the domestic stock manager, who returned 13.0 percent against its index's 14.0. Because the fund held less in that manager than the policy, a small interaction effect returned about 0.03 points. The attribution method follows Brinson and Fachler (1985), which credits an asset class weight against the policy's total return, and the three effects add to the 0.76-point shortfall.
Table 2
The Fund's 0.76-Point Shortfall to Policy
| Source | Points | Dollars, approximately | Decision made by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Domestic stocks held 3 points under target | minus 0.39 | $1.2 million | Investment staff |
| Domestic manager behind its index | minus 0.40 | $1.2 million | Manager |
| Interaction | plus 0.03 | $0.1 million | Shared |
| Total shortfall to policy | minus 0.76 | $2.3 million |
What Follows Under the Policy
The policy statement sets the rules for both decisions, and we will apply them. The underweight is within the allowed band, but staff will report each tactical deviation to the investment committee in advance, with the reasoning, so the committee can judge these calls as they are made. The domestic manager's one-point shortfall places it on watch under the policy's review rules. The committee will review the manager's three-year record against its index, its style and its team within two quarters and record a decision.
Two Proposals I Recommend Against
Your letter asks whether the fund should move into the stock index. I recommend against it. Switching after a year in which stocks led would abandon the policy just after paying its cost, and would expose grants to the full fall of the next bad year. If the board believes the policy holds too little in stocks, that is a question for the policy's annual review, decided on the foundation's needs and not on last year's winner.
I also recommend against ending the manager's mandate now. A single year says very little about a manager's skill, and the policy's review rules exist so that decisions like this rest on a longer record. If the review finds the shortfall reflects a lasting problem, the committee will act on it.
Next Steps
I would welcome the chance to go through these figures with you before the next committee meeting, and I will send the full attribution report with this letter. You raised a fair question, and the foundation is better for trustees who ask it.
Sincerely,
[Chief Investment Officer Name]
References
Brinson, G. P., & Fachler, N. (1985). Measuring non-U.S. equity portfolio performance. Journal of Portfolio Management, 11(3), 73-76. https://doi.org/10.3905/jpm.1985.409005
Brinson, G. P., Hood, L. R., & Beebower, G. L. (1986). Determinants of portfolio performance. Financial Analysts Journal, 42(4), 39-44. https://doi.org/10.2469/faj.v42.n4.39
Swensen, D. F. (2009). Pioneering portfolio management: An unconventional approach to institutional investment (Rev. ed.). Free Press.
The FIN-655 Topic 8 assignment instructions
FIN-655 ends with Topic 8, where students explain an investment result to someone displeased with it. A strong letter concedes the comparison in its opening lines and gives a short answer, then sets the fund, the policy benchmark and the stock index side by side. Students should separate the cost of the board's policy from the effect of decisions made under it, attribute those decisions in percentage points and dollars to whoever made them, and apply the policy's own review rules. The letter should respond to the trustee's proposals with reasons and invite further discussion.
Inside the FIN 655 Topic 8 example
The finished letter opens by conceding the comparison that stings and then accounts for every point of it. Every figure is illustrative. The fund returned 6.44 percent on 300 million; a broad domestic stock index returned 14.0; the policy benchmark the board adopted returned 7.2, because it holds 40 percent domestic stocks alongside international stocks, bonds and real assets that earned 6.0, 1.0 and 1.0. Of the 7.56-point gap, 6.8 points, about 20.4 million, is the policy itself. The remaining 0.76 points, about 2.3 million, came from decisions made under it, and the letter names both. Staff held domestic stocks three points below target and put the difference in bonds, which cost 0.39. The domestic manager trailed its index by a point, costing 0.40, with a small offsetting interaction of 0.03.
Where the marks sit in the FIN 655 Topic 8 rubric
Instructors reward a letter that accounts for every point. An Excellent letter concedes the 7.56-point gap and splits it into 6.8 of policy and 0.76 of decisions. Credit goes to explaining why the board diversified, with evidence that policy drives most of a fund's results. The rubric values attributing the underweight to staff and the shortfall to the manager in dollars, under a named method. Strong letters apply the watch rules rather than ending the mandate. Top marks go to declining a switch to the stock index and a firing after one year, each with a reason.
Common FIN 655 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Letters that describe the investment process at length and never give the numbers are marked down hardest, because an unhappy trustee wants to know where the return went, not how carefully it was pursued. Accepting the stock index as the benchmark concedes a comparison the board rejected when it diversified, while dismissing it without figures sounds evasive. Papers that attribute the whole gap to the policy hide the 0.76 points the fund's own decisions cost. The opposite fault, blaming the manager for everything, ignores that the underweight was a staff decision and cost about as much. Figures given only in percentages leave a trustee to guess what 0.39 means for grants. Promising to fire the manager or rewrite the policy in response to one year answers the complaint by abandoning the rules written for exactly this letter.
Get a FIN-655 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-655 Topic 8 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the fund results and the complaint your case supplies. We write a custom example to them, with the gap conceded, the policy's share separated from the fund's decisions, each decision owned in dollars and the review rules applied to the manager, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 655 papers and MS in Finance samples
- FIN 655 Topic 1: Mandate Design Memo
- FIN 655 Topic 2: Liability-relative Allocation Study
- FIN 655 Topic 3: Constrained Frontier Memo
- FIN 655 Topic 4: Benchmark Suitability Review
- FIN 655 Topic 5: Factor Exposure Dq Post
- FIN 655 Topic 6: Total Fund Attribution Review
- FIN 655 Topic 7: Endowment Policy Statement
- FIN 490 Topic 8: Household Plan Presentation
- FIN 210 Topic 8: Personal Financial Plan
- FIN 451 Topic 8: Portfolio Change Request Response
- FIN 350 Topic 8: Capital Investment Recommendation
FIN 655 Topic 8 questions, answered
Why is the stock index the wrong benchmark for the fund?
Because the board never asked the fund to track it. The policy statement holds 40 percent in domestic stocks and spreads the rest across international stocks, bonds and real assets, so the fair comparison is the benchmark built from those same weights. The stock index is still worth showing, since it measures what diversification cost this year, but that cost belongs to the board's policy rather than to anyone implementing it.
Why keep a manager that trailed its index by a point?
Because one year of tracking error says very little about skill, and the policy's review rules were written before the result so that a single year would not decide. The manager moves to a watch list, and the rules list the grounds for ending the mandate: a longer shortfall net of fees, a change in the people running the portfolio or a drift away from the style it was hired to deliver.
Is the letter a template for answering a real trustee?
It can show the reasoning, not the facts. The foundation, its returns, the underweight and the manager's shortfall are illustrative, set so that the policy's cost and the fund's own decisions can be separated by hand. A real letter depends on audited results, the institution's actual policy and the judgment of its staff and advisers. The example is FIN-655 coursework and makes no claim about any real fund or manager.
Where can I find a free FIN 655 Topic 8 sample paper?
The whole trustee letter is printed on this page: the question, the three returns side by side, the board's policy, the fund's decisions, what follows under the policy, two proposals declined and next steps. Send the results and complaint from your case and we will draft the reply free.
How much of the gap did the fund's own decisions cost in FIN 655 Topic 8?
About 0.76 points, or 2.3 million dollars: 0.39 from holding domestic stocks three points under target, 0.40 from the manager's one-point shortfall, offset by 0.03 of interaction.