FIN 660 Topic 1 leveraged recapitalization assessment example

Advanced Financial Strategies Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This FIN 660 Topic 1 sample paper tests an activist's claim that a composite industrial distributor has room to borrow 400 million for a buyback. It was written for GCU FIN 660, Advanced Financial Strategies, catalog code FIN-660, in the Grand Canyon University MS in Finance. Reported net debt of 900 against EBITDA of 500 gives 1.8 times, against peers near 2.6. Adding 450 of lease liabilities and a 120 after-tax pension deficit, with 60 of lease cost restored to EBITDA, gives about 2.6 times against an adjusted peer median of 2.5. The full recap would reach about 3.3, so the paper returns 150 from cash flow instead.

CourseFIN 660 Advanced Financial Strategies
TopicTopic 1
Paper typeRecapitalization assessment
LengthAbout 980 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMS in Finance
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for FIN 660 Topic 1

1

Is 1.8 Times Really Spare Capacity? Restating a Distributor's Debt for Leases and Its Pension Before Answering a 400 Million Dollar Recapitalization

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

FIN-660: Advanced Financial Strategies

Topic 1 Recapitalization Assessment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the activist's figure and the adjustment that tests it. The company, its peers and every figure are illustrative; the sources are real.
2

Is 1.8 Times Really Spare Capacity? Restating a Distributor's Debt for Leases and Its Pension Before Answering a 400 Million Dollar Recapitalization

The Proposal

An activist shareholder argues that a composite industrial distributor carries too little debt. The company reports net debt of 900 million dollars against EBITDA of 500 million, or 1.8 times. Five comparable distributors report about 2.6 times. The activist proposes borrowing 400 million, the difference of 0.8 turns on 500 of EBITDA, and using it to buy back shares. This assessment first restates the activist's case fairly and then tests it against the balance sheet as it actually stands. All figures are in millions of dollars and are illustrative.

What Theory Grants the Activist

The activist's argument has a real basis. The trade-off view of capital structure holds that a firm should borrow until the tax benefit of an extra dollar of debt is offset by the expected costs of financial distress. A distributor with stable cash flow and taxable income is the kind of firm that view expects to carry meaningful debt. Graham (2000) estimated that many large, profitable firms with low expected distress costs could borrow substantially more and capture larger tax benefits, which suggests that some firms are conservative by habit rather than by necessity. Myers (1984) offered a different account, the pecking order, in which firms prefer internal funds and borrow only when they need outside money, so low debt can simply reflect past profitability rather than a decision to leave value unused. The activist is right that low reported debt deserves a question. The answer depends on what the reported figure leaves out.

What the Reported Ratio Leaves Out

The reported ratio counts only borrowed money. Two other obligations rank ahead of shareholders and have to be paid whatever the company does with its shares.

The first is leases. The company leases most of its warehouses, and under current accounting standards it reports lease liabilities of 450 on its balance sheet (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2016). Adding them to debt without adjusting EBITDA would mismatch the ratio, because reported EBITDA is already reduced by about 60 a year of lease cost. To compare obligations and earnings measured the same way, the lease liabilities join debt and the 60 returns to EBITDA, which becomes 560.

The second is the pension. The company's defined benefit plan is underfunded by 160. The shortfall is a claim on future cash that the company must fund regardless of its capital structure, and because contributions are tax-deductible, its after-tax burden at a 25 percent rate is 120. That amount is added to debt.

Adjusted debt is 900 plus 450 plus 120, or 1,470, and adjusted EBITDA is 560. The adjusted multiple is about 2.6 times, not 1.8. The reported ratio leaves out 570 of obligations.

Table 1

Reported and Adjusted Debt, Millions of Dollars, Illustrative

ItemReportedAdjusted
Net debt900900
Lease liabilitiesNot counted450
Pension deficit, after taxNot counted120
Total debt9001,470
EBITDA500560 (lease cost of 60 added back)
Debt to EBITDA1.8 timesAbout 2.6 times

Peers on the Same Basis

A comparison is meaningful only if the peers are adjusted the same way. Repeating the lease and pension adjustment for the five comparable distributors gives a median of about 2.5 times. Most peers own more of their warehouses and have smaller or no defined benefit plans, so their adjusted figures sit close to their reported ones. On a like-for-like basis, the company already carries slightly more obligations relative to earnings than its peers, not less. The activist's 0.8 turns of spare capacity came from comparing the company's narrow measure with peers whose debt is closer to the whole of their obligations.

The Recapitalization Tested

Borrowing 400 would raise adjusted debt to 1,870 against adjusted EBITDA of 560, about 3.3 times, well above the peer median of 2.5. Coverage would weaken as well: at an assumed borrowing cost of 7 percent, interest on the new debt adds 28 a year, and fixed charges including lease cost would rise accordingly. The case's lenders and rating agencies already measure the company on an adjusted basis, so the recapitalization would likely bring a lower credit rating and higher cost on all of the company's debt, not only the new borrowing. The tax benefit Graham describes is real, but at this level it would be bought at the price of distress risk the reported ratio hides.

A buyback of 400 would also lift earnings per share, which the activist is likely to cite. That gain is mechanical: fewer shares divide the same profit, while each remaining share carries more risk. Higher earnings per share bought with borrowed money do not by themselves show that value was created.

A Smaller Return of Cash

Rejecting the full proposal is not the same as rejecting the activist's underlying point, that shareholders deserve cash the business does not need. The company generates free cash flow of about 75 a year after dividends. The assessment recommends returning 150 through buybacks over two years, funded from that cash flow rather than from new debt. Adjusted debt stays near 1,470 while EBITDA grows, so the adjusted multiple drifts down toward the peer median.

The assessment also states what would change its answer. If the pension deficit closes, for example through rising discount rates or contributions, or if the company buys out warehouse leases on favorable terms, the adjusted multiple falls. Once adjusted debt sits below about 2.2 times EBITDA, a debt-funded return of cash becomes reasonable and the board should revisit it.

Conclusion

Measured on the balance sheet as it stands, the company does not have 400 million of unused borrowing capacity. Its adjusted debt is already slightly above its peers'. The board should respond to the activist with the adjusted figures, a cash-funded buyback of 150, and a stated threshold at which more debt would make sense.

References

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2016). Leases (Topic 842) (Accounting Standards Update No. 2016-02). https://www.fasb.org/

Graham, J. R. (2000). How big are the tax benefits of debt? Journal of Finance, 55(5), 1901-1941. https://doi.org/10.1111/0022-1082.00277

Myers, S. C. (1984). The capital structure puzzle. Journal of Finance, 39(3), 574-592. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1984.tb03646.x

Reading the GCU FIN 660 Topic 1 instructions

Topic 1 in FIN-660 asks students to assess a proposed change in capital structure for a real or case company. Strong submissions restate the proposal fairly, set out what capital structure theory says about firms like this one, and then measure debt on the balance sheet as it actually stands, adding leases and pension obligations and adjusting earnings to match. Students should restate peers on the same basis, test the proposal on adjusted debt and coverage, and recommend a course the board can defend, including an alternative to the proposal and the conditions under which the answer would change.

Inside the FIN 660 Topic 1 example

Illustrative figures in millions carry the finished assessment. Reported net debt of 900 against EBITDA of 500 gives the 1.8 times the activist quotes; peers report about 2.6, so the activist sees 0.8 turns, or 400, of unused capacity. The assessment then adds what the reported ratio leaves out. Lease liabilities of 450 join debt, and EBITDA is restated before the 60 of annual lease cost, giving 560. An unfunded pension obligation of 160, or 120 after tax at 25 percent, is added as well. Adjusted debt of 1,470 over 560 gives about 2.6 times, above the peers' 2.5 on the same basis. After the proposed recap the adjusted figure would reach about 3.3. The assessment recommends a 150 buyback funded from two years of free cash flow instead.

FIN 660 Topic 1 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward an assessment that changes the activist's terms with evidence. An Excellent paper grants the trade-off argument, citing Graham on tax benefits and Myers on the pecking order, before testing it. Credit goes to adding leases and the after-tax pension deficit to debt while restoring lease cost to EBITDA, so the ratio is consistent. The rubric values peers restated on the same basis and the recap tested at about 3.3 times. Strong papers explain why higher earnings per share from a buyback proves little. Top marks go to a cash-funded alternative and a stated threshold for revisiting debt.

Common FIN 660 Topic 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Answers that argue with the activist on the reported ratio draw the largest deduction, because that ratio leaves out 570 of obligations and the topic asks for capital structure on the balance sheet as it actually stands. Adding lease liabilities to debt while EBITDA stays net of lease cost mismatches the ratio and overstates the debt burden. Papers that compare the firm's adjusted figure with peers' reported ones set two different measures side by side. Treating a pension deficit as an accounting footnote misses a claim the firm must fund whatever it does with its shares. Citing trade-off theory as the answer, detached from what this firm owes, recommends a number rather than analyzing one. A rejection of the recap with no alternative offered leaves the board defending inaction against a holder who has proposed something.

Get a FIN-660 Topic 1 example written to your instructions

Send the FIN-660 Topic 1 instructions and the rubric in your classroom, with the firm's statements your section assigns. We write a custom example to them, with the proposal restated, leases and pension obligations adjusted on both sides of the ratio, peers restated on the same basis and a defended alternative to the recap, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More FIN 660 papers and MS in Finance samples

FIN 660 Topic 1 questions, answered

Why add leases to debt?

Because a long lease commits the firm to fixed payments much as a loan does, and a firm that leases its warehouses carries obligations a firm that borrowed to buy them would show as debt. Adjusting both firms the same way makes them comparable. The adjustment must run through EBITDA as well, adding back the lease cost, or the ratio compares an enlarged debt figure with earnings already reduced by the same payments.

Why count the pension deficit after tax?

Because contributions that close the deficit are generally deductible, so each dollar paid costs the firm less than a dollar after tax. The case's convention applies its 25 percent rate, turning a 160 shortfall into 120 of debt-like obligation. Some analysts add the full pre-tax amount instead; the assessment names its convention and shows that either choice leaves the firm above its peers measured the same way.

Where can I find a free FIN 660 Topic 1 sample paper?

This page carries the full assessment: the proposal, what theory grants the activist, what the reported ratio leaves out, peers on the same basis, the recap tested, a smaller return of cash and the conclusion. Send your company's statements and the proposal and a free assessment can be built.

Why does adjusted debt reach 2.6 times in FIN 660 Topic 1?

Net debt of 900, lease liabilities of 450 and a pension deficit of 120 after tax total 1,470. Divided by EBITDA of 560, which adds back 60 of lease cost, the ratio is about 2.6 times rather than the reported 1.8.

Could the FIN 660 Topic 1 assessment answer a real activist?

No. The distributor, its leases, the pension figures and the peer ratios are invented so the gap between reported and adjusted debt shows plainly. A real response depends on audited statements, actual lease and pension disclosures, rating agency methods and advice from the board's bankers and counsel.