| Course | FIN 660 Advanced Financial Strategies |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Divestiture discussion post |
| Length | About 580 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Finance |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 660 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
Sell the Unit Buyers Value, Not the Unit That Matters Least: Ranking Three Divisions by What Each Sale Does to Debt
Initial Post
My rule is that a sale lowers the firm's debt burden only if the division sells for a higher multiple of its EBITDA than the firm's own net debt multiple. By that rule, the diversified manufacturer in our case should sell its coatings unit. Every figure here is illustrative and invented for the exercise.
Table 1
Three Divisions Run Through the Rule, Millions of Dollars
| Division | EBITDA | Multiple within 9 months | Proceeds | Debt to EBITDA after sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coatings | 30 | 8.5 | 255 | About 4.38 |
| Core packaging | 130 | 7.0 | 910 | Firm largely gone |
| Legacy printing | 40 | 3.5 | 140 | About 5.38, note not covered |
The firm carries 1,000 million of net debt against 200 million of EBITDA, 5.0 times, and must repay a 250 million note in nine months. Table 1 applies the rule to each division. Coatings, with EBITDA of 30, would fetch about 8.5 times, or 255, which covers the note and leaves 745 of debt against 170 of EBITDA, about 4.38 times. Core packaging, with EBITDA of 130, would fetch about 7.0 times, or 910; that would pay the note many times over but leave the firm with only 70 of EBITDA and most of its business gone. Legacy printing, with EBITDA of 40, would bring only about 140 at 3.5 times, short of the 250 needed, and would raise the debt multiple to about 5.38 times because the firm gives up earnings at a lower multiple than its own.
Why is the core division's price depressed? Shleifer and Vishny (1992) argued that assets sold under pressure fetch less when the buyers who value them most are firms in the same industry, because those buyers tend to be short of cash at the same time as the seller. The rivals who would pay most for core packaging are caught in the same downturn, so its price now sits about an eighth below its normal 8.0 times. Coatings attracts chemical companies the downturn has not touched, so it sells close to normal value.
The cost is real. Coatings is a sound, growing business, and the firm gives up 30 of EBITDA it would keep if the note could be refinanced on reasonable terms. Lang et al. (1995) found that firms selling assets tend to be poor performers or highly indebted, and that markets reward sales whose proceeds pay down debt. That fits this case: the point of the sale is repayment, and coatings is the division that makes repayment work.
Reply to Priya
Priya, you suggest selling the legacy printing unit because it matters least to the firm's strategy. I agree it matters least strategically, and in a calmer year it would be first on my list. The arithmetic points the other way here, though.
Printing earns 40 and would sell for about 140, a multiple of 3.5 against the firm's 5.0. Selling it removes more earnings, proportionally, than debt. Debt falls to 860 while EBITDA falls to 160, so the multiple rises to about 5.38 times, and the firm is still 110 short of the 250 it owes in nine months. It would then need a second sale under even more pressure. The division that matters least strategically is often the one buyers value least, which is why it cannot solve a debt problem. I would keep printing for now and revisit selling it once the note is repaid and the firm is not a forced seller (Shleifer & Vishny, 1992).
References
Lang, L., Poulsen, A., & Stulz, R. (1995). Asset sales, firm performance, and the agency costs of managerial discretion. Journal of Financial Economics, 37(1), 3-37. https://doi.org/10.1016/0304-405X(94)00791-X
Shleifer, A., & Vishny, R. W. (1992). Liquidation values and debt capacity: A market equilibrium approach. Journal of Finance, 47(4), 1343-1366. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1992.tb04661.x
FIN 660 Topic 5 instructions, in plain terms
FIN-660 Topic 5 asks students to decide which assets a firm under pressure should sell. A strong post states a rule before naming any division and applies it to each, showing proceeds and the debt multiple after every sale. Students should explain why some assets fetch less when sold under pressure, citing research on liquidation values and industry buyers, acknowledge what the firm gives up, and connect the choice to evidence on how markets treat asset sales. The reply should test a classmate's proposal with the same arithmetic rather than by opinion.
How this FIN 660 Topic 5 example is built
The post opens with its rule: a sale lowers the debt burden only if the division sells for a higher multiple of EBITDA than the firm's own net debt multiple. Its illustrative firm carries 1,000 million of net debt on 200 of EBITDA, 5.0 times, and owes a 250 note in nine months. Core packaging, 130 of EBITDA, would fetch about 7.0 times now, an eighth below normal, because its natural buyers are rivals caught in the same downturn. Coatings, earning 30, draws chemical buyers the downturn has not touched and would fetch about 8.5 times, or 255. Selling it leaves 745 on 170, about 4.38 times. Printing, 40 of EBITDA, would bring about 140 at 3.5 times, missing the target and lifting the ratio to about 5.38.
FIN 660 Topic 5 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty reward a post that states a rule and applies it to every option. An Excellent post compares each sale multiple with the firm's 5.0 times and tables proceeds and the ratio after each sale. Credit goes to Shleifer and Vishny's argument that industry buyers short of cash depress prices. The rubric values conceding that coatings is a good business and naming what the firm loses. Strong posts link the choice to Lang, Poulsen and Stulz on asset sales that repay debt. Top marks go to a reply that shows the printing sale moving the ratio the wrong way.
Common FIN 660 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Posts that name the least important division and stop draw the heaviest penalty here, since a unit nobody wants raises little cash and, sold below the firm's own multiple, leaves the balance sheet worse. Answers that rank divisions by strategic fit alone never check whether the sale meets the nine-month need. Assuming every division sells at its normal multiple ignores who the buyers would be and what the downturn has done to them. Papers that recommend selling the core division because it raises the most cash solve the maturity by dismantling the firm. Naming the fire-sale literature without asking which buyers each unit would attract leaves the citation idle. A reply that endorses the classmate's pick unexamined leaves the thread holding a proposal that fails its own test.
Get a FIN-660 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-660 Topic 5 discussion prompt and your classroom rubric, plus any readings your section assigns. We write a custom example to that prompt, with a divestiture rule stated, each division's sale priced against the firm's debt multiple, buyers and discounts reasoned through and a reply that runs a classmate's proposal through the numbers, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 660 papers and MS in Finance samples
- FIN 660 Topic 1: Leveraged Recapitalization Assessment
- FIN 660 Topic 2: Buyout Debt Sizing Memo
- FIN 660 Topic 3: Dividend Cut Board Paper
- FIN 660 Topic 4: Distress Stage Assessment
- FIN 660 Topic 6: Recovery Waterfall Analysis
- FIN 660 Topic 7: Synergy Evidence and Payment Memo
- FIN 660 Topic 8: Cross-border Financing Board Paper
- FIN 210 Topic 5: Debt or Invest Dq Post
- FIN 655 Topic 5: Factor Exposure Dq Post
- FIN 350 Topic 5: Required Return Dq Post
- FIN 490 Topic 5: Unfollowed Recommendation Dq Post
FIN 660 Topic 5 questions, answered
What did Shleifer and Vishny argue about asset sales?
That the buyers who value an asset most are usually firms in the same industry, and when an industry is in trouble those firms are often short of cash or credit themselves. Assets sold under pressure then go to less natural owners at lower prices. The argument explains why a distressed seller should look for units whose likely buyers sit outside the downturn, where prices hold up better.
Where can I find a free FIN 660 Topic 5 sample paper?
Both parts of the discussion appear below: the rule, the three divisions in a table, why the core division is discounted, the cost of selling coatings and the reply on selling printing. Share your section's prompt and figures and we will write a free post for it.
Why sell coatings rather than printing in FIN 660 Topic 5?
Coatings sells at 8.5 times EBITDA, above the firm's 5.0, so the sale cuts debt faster than earnings and covers the note. Printing sells at 3.5 times, below 5.0, so selling it raises the ratio and still leaves the firm 110 short.
Why can selling a unit raise the debt multiple in FIN 660 Topic 5?
Because the sale removes the unit's EBITDA as well as some debt. If the price, as a multiple of that EBITDA, sits below the firm's own net debt multiple, debt falls proportionally less than earnings. Printing at 3.5 times against the firm's 5.0 leaves 860 of debt on 160 of EBITDA.
Does the FIN 660 Topic 5 post tell a real company which business to sell?
No. The manufacturer, its divisions, the multiples and the nine-month deadline are illustrative, set up so the sale rule and the buyer question can be tested in a few lines. A real divestiture depends on audited segment results, actual buyer interest, tax consequences and advice from bankers and counsel.