| Course | HCA 240 Health Care Accounting and Billing |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Reimbursement comparison |
| Length | About 990 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 240 Topic 4
One Visit, Six Contracts: Comparing What Six Payers Allow for a 99214 at a Family Medicine Office, and Which Rates the Practice Can Change
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HCA-240: Health Care Accounting and Billing
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
One Visit, Six Contracts: Comparing What Six Payers Allow for a 99214 at a Family Medicine Office, and Which Rates the Practice Can Change
The Service Held Constant
This comparison holds one service fixed so that the contract is the only thing that varies. The service is CPT 99214, an established patient office visit with moderate medical decision making, delivered in a physician office, which Medicare and most contracts treat as a non-facility setting. The same visit delivered in a hospital outpatient department would be paid under different rules, with a separate facility payment, so the setting is part of the definition. The practice is Canyon Ridge Family Medicine, which bills 99214 about 935 times a month across six payers. Its chargemaster price for the visit is $210.00. All rates below are the composite figures used in this exercise.
Six Payers and Six Routes to an Allowed Amount
Each payer reaches its allowed amount by a different route. Traditional Medicare pays from the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule, which multiplies relative value units for the service by a conversion factor and adjusts for the practice's geographic area; in this exercise that produces $120.00. The Medicare Advantage plan pays 100 percent of the Medicare fee schedule, so its allowed amount is also $120.00. The state Medicaid program pays from its own fee schedule, set by the state, at $78.00; Medicaid physician fees have remained well below Medicare fees for years (Zuckerman et al., 2021). Commercial PPO A pays from a negotiated fee schedule that lists a dollar amount per code, $132.00, with a lesser-of provision. Commercial PPO B pays 125 percent of the Medicare fee schedule, which produces $150.00. Plan C, a small regional plan, pays 60 percent of billed charges, which produces 60 percent of $210.00, or $126.00.
Table 1
Allowed Amount for One 99214 Office Visit by Payer, With Basis, Terms and Volume
| Payer | Basis | Allowed for 99214 | Terms that adjust it | Monthly volume |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional Medicare | Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (administered) | $120.00 | Filing within 12 months; national correct coding edits | 260 |
| Medicare Advantage plan | 100% of Medicare fee schedule | $120.00 | Filing within 90 days; prior authorization for some services | 180 |
| State Medicaid | State fee schedule (administered) | $78.00 | Filing within 180 days | 90 |
| Commercial PPO A | Negotiated fee schedule, lesser-of charge | $132.00 | Filing within 90 days | 310 |
| Commercial PPO B | 125% of Medicare fee schedule | $150.00 | Filing within 60 days; bundles same-day lab into the visit | 70 |
| Plan C | 60% of billed charges | $126.00 | Filing within 90 days; tied to the chargemaster | 25 |
Terms That Move the Number Afterward
The allowed amount on the fee schedule is only the starting figure; contract terms change what the practice actually receives. PPO B, the highest payer, bundles point-of-care laboratory tests performed on the same day into the visit, so the hemoglobin A1c that Canyon Ridge bills separately to other payers is paid at zero when PPO B patients have it with a 99214. About a third of PPO B's diabetes visits include that test, which lowers PPO B's effective rate for those visits. PPO B also allows only 60 days to file a claim, and any claim delayed by a registration error past that window is lost entirely. Plan C's rate is tied to the chargemaster, so if Canyon Ridge raised its charge, Plan C's payment would rise with it, which is the only case among the six where the practice's own price list matters to what it is paid. PPO A's lesser-of provision means the practice would be paid its charge if the charge ever fell below $132.00, which it will not at current prices.
The Spread, Weighted by Volume
The spread between the best and worst rates is $72.00 per visit, from PPO B's $150.00 to Medicaid's $78.00. That gap looks large, but the payers do not carry equal volume. Multiplying each payer's rate by its monthly volume shows where the 99214 revenue, about $114,390 a month in total, actually comes from. PPO A contributes $40,920, the most of any payer, because it has the largest volume. Traditional Medicare contributes $31,200 and Medicare Advantage $21,600. PPO B contributes $10,500, Medicaid $7,020 and Plan C $3,150.
Weighted this way, a 5 percent improvement in the PPO A fee schedule, about $6.60 per visit, would add roughly $2,046 a month. The same 5 percent improvement with PPO B, the most generous payer, would add only about $525, and with Plan C about $158. The highest rate is not the most valuable contract; the largest contract at a middling rate is.
Which Rates Canyon Ridge Can Change
Only some of these rates are open to negotiation. Traditional Medicare and Medicaid rates are administered: they are set by federal and state rules, and no one at Canyon Ridge negotiates them. The Medicare Advantage rate is contractual, but it is pegged to the Medicare schedule, and plans rarely agree to pay more than 100 percent of it to a primary care practice of this size. PPO B's rate is also pegged to Medicare, so it will move whenever Medicare moves, and research has found that private physician prices follow Medicare's lead, with a one-dollar change in Medicare fees associated with a $1.16 change in corresponding private prices (Clemens & Gottlieb, 2017).
PPO A and Plan C are the contracts Canyon Ridge can actually influence, and PPO A is the one that matters. The practice's administrator should prepare for PPO A's renewal next year by showing the plan the practice's volume, quality measures and denial rate, and should ask for a fee schedule increase on its five highest-volume codes, starting with 99214. The practice should also ask PPO B to stop bundling the point-of-care A1c test, since removing that term would be worth more than a small increase in the rate. The administered rates cannot be changed at the table, but the cost of serving those patients can be managed, and billing complexity differs sharply by payer type (Gottlieb et al., 2018), so reducing rework on Medicaid claims is the practical response to a low rate.
References
Clemens, J., & Gottlieb, J. D. (2017). In the shadow of a giant: Medicare's influence on private physician payments. Journal of Political Economy, 125(1), 1-39. https://doi.org/10.1086/689772
Gottlieb, J. D., Shapiro, A. H., & Dunn, A. (2018). The complexity of billing and paying for physician care. Health Affairs, 37(4), 619-626. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2017.1325
Zuckerman, S., Skopec, L., & Aarons, J. (2021). Medicaid physician fees remained substantially below fees paid by Medicare in 2019. Health Affairs, 40(2), 343-348. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2020.00611
HCA 240 Topic 4 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 4 instructions in HCA-240 ask students to compare reimbursement methods across payers. Students typically examine how Medicare, Medicaid and commercial insurers pay for services, explain methods such as fee schedules, percentage of charges, capitation, case rates and per diems, and compare the resulting payments for a service or set of services. The analysis should consider contract terms beyond the base rate and explain what the differences mean for the organization's revenue and strategy. Supporting sources on reimbursement policy and a clear table or worked example are expected in APA format. Where the prompt supplies no contract terms, state the assumptions used so the comparison can still be followed.
How this HCA 240 Topic 4 example is built
The finished comparison keeps one service fixed and lets the contract be the only variable in the table. The service is identified by code and by setting, and each payer then gets a row carrying the allowed amount, the mechanism that set it, and the terms riding alongside: a bundling rule, a reduction for a second procedure, a timely filing window, a carve out. Government payers are marked as administered rates rather than negotiated ones, since nobody from the organization sat across a table from them. The closing passage weights the differences by volume, because a generous rate on a service rarely ordered is worth less than a thin rate on the daily work.
Where the marks sit in the HCA 240 Topic 4 rubric
GCU's rubric for the reimbursement comparison rewards comparisons that can be reproduced. Excellent papers keep the service and setting constant, name the basis behind every rate and show how each allowed amount is calculated. Credit goes to identifying terms that adjust payment afterward, such as bundling, lesser-of provisions and filing limits. The rubric looks for the spread weighted by volume, not only ranked by rate, and for an accurate distinction between administered government rates and negotiated commercial ones. A recommendation aimed at the contracts the organization can actually change completes the highest level. Rankings by rate alone usually fall short.
HCA 240 Topic 4 help before you submit
The comparison is checkable, so an allowed amount that does not follow from the stated basis is caught immediately. Applying a percentage to the wrong figure, usually the charge when the contract reads from a schedule, produces a number that is simply wrong rather than debatable. Tables of payer names with rates attached, and no mechanism shown, cannot be reproduced by anybody. Ranking payers by allowed amount alone ignores the terms underneath, and a high rate with a short filing window and aggressive bundling can pay less in practice. Versions that never weight the spread by volume recommend chasing a contract that carries almost no work. Treating an administered government rate as a negotiation target proposes a conversation that does not exist.
Get an HCA-240 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the HCA-240 Topic 4 instructions, the rubric your classroom posted and the service, payers or contract terms you were assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with one service held fixed, each allowed amount derived from its stated basis and the spread weighted by volume, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.
More HCA 240 papers and BS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 240 Topic 1: Charge to Payment Breakdown
- HCA 240 Topic 2: Revenue Cycle Analysis
- HCA 240 Topic 3: Coding Exercise
- HCA 240 Topic 5: Claim Denial Discussion
- HCA 240 Topic 6: Patient Responsibility Analysis
- HCA 240 Topic 7: Remittance Reconciliation
- HCA 240 Topic 8: Revenue Leakage Audit
- HCA 360 Topic 4: Data Stewardship Plan
- HCA 470 Topic 4: Strategic Trade-off Memo
- HCA 450 Topic 4: Accreditation Readiness Report
- HCA 465 Topic 4: Interprofessional Conflict Case
HCA 240 Topic 4 questions, answered
Why does the same procedure pay different amounts?
Because each contract computes it a different way. One payer reads a schedule that lists the service outright, another applies a percentage to what was billed, a third folds it into a case rate covering the whole stay. None of those is a discount off a real price, since the charge they start from was set by the organization itself.
Is the highest allowed amount the best contract?
Not by itself. Read the terms sitting underneath it: how long you have to file, what gets bundled into what, whether a second procedure is reduced, how quickly the payer adjudicates and how often it asks for records first. A slightly lower rate that pays promptly and denies rarely often produces more collected money.
What if I was given no contract terms?
Pick a plausible basis for each payer, say in the paper that you are supplying it, and hold to it through every calculation. What sinks this topic is not a missing contract but arithmetic that changes its own rules midway. Name the one conclusion that would move if a payer turned out to pay a case rate instead.
Where can I find a free HCA 240 Topic 4 sample paper?
The complete comparison of six payers' rates for one 99214 visit is on this page, with the basis for each, the terms that adjust it, volume weighting and the contracts worth renegotiating. A model using your own section's payers is free on request.
Which contract matters most in HCA 240 Topic 4?
The largest one at a middling rate. In the example, a 5 percent rise with the busiest PPO adds about $2,046 a month, while the same rise with the highest-paying plan adds only about $525, because it carries far fewer visits.