| Course | HCA 470 Strategic Planning and Implementation in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Competitive position analysis |
| Length | About 1,020 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 470 Topic 3
Follow the Referral, Not the Brochure: A Competitive Position Analysis of How Patients With Diabetic Foot Wounds Reach Care in One County
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HCA-470: Strategic Planning and Implementation in Health Care
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Follow the Referral, Not the Brochure: A Competitive Position Analysis of How Patients With Diabetic Foot Wounds Reach Care in One County
How Volume Moves in This Market
Competitive position in health care is rarely decided by consumers choosing among providers. For patients with diabetic foot ulcers in Ocotillo County, it is decided mostly by referral paths, insurance networks and where a patient goes when a wound becomes an emergency. The analysis therefore begins by tracing how new diabetic foot wound episodes reach care, using Ocotillo Regional Health's own records, claims data shared by the county's largest Medicare Advantage plan and interviews with the podiatry group and three primary care practices. Last year, the county had an estimated 410 new episodes of diabetic foot ulcer treated by some provider. Physician referrals have become a larger share of how patients reach specialists nationally, nearly doubling as a share of ambulatory visits over a decade (Barnett et al., 2012), and this market follows that pattern.
The Five Paths
Table 1 shows the paths by which the estimated 410 episodes reached care and where each path ended.
Table 1
Estimated Paths of New Diabetic Foot Ulcer Episodes Into Care, Ocotillo County, Last Year
| Path into care | Episodes | Where most ended | Who controls the path |
|---|---|---|---|
| Podiatry office visit | 150 | Rival hospital's wound center (about 90); podiatry office only (about 60) | The podiatry group, whose senior partner is medical director of the rival center |
| Primary care referral | 95 | Split between podiatry and the rival center; few to Ocotillo | Primary care physicians, including Ocotillo's own clinics |
| Emergency department with infection | 85 | Ocotillo inpatient admission, then discharge to podiatry or home health | Patients and ambulance crews |
| Home health nurses | 45 | Ocotillo home health, wound care at home | Ocotillo's home health agency |
| Dialysis unit staff | 35 | Rival center or Ocotillo emergency department | Two dialysis units run by a national company |
Reading the Flow
The flow tells a clear story. Ocotillo sees these patients mainly when their wounds have become emergencies: 85 episodes began in its emergency department, often with infection, and most ended with an admission and sometimes an amputation. Ocotillo's own primary care clinics, which see many of the county's patients with diabetes, sent few foot ulcers anywhere inside the system, because the system has no wound clinic to receive them; clinicians referred to podiatry by habit. The podiatry group controls the largest path, and its senior partner directs the rival hospital's wound center, so podiatry patients who need more than office care move to the rival. The rival center's position rests on that relationship and on being in the Medicare Advantage plan's preferred network for wound care, not on outcomes, which it does not publish.
Early, outpatient care for foot ulcers is where amputations are prevented, and Ocotillo is largely absent from it. Its volume arrives late, which is both a mission problem and a financial one, since late-stage inpatient care for infected feet is expensive and outcomes are worse.
Strengths That Would Change the Flow
A strength counts only if it could change where patients go. Ocotillo has three. First, it can open blocked leg arteries locally, with a pair of vascular surgeons and its own catheter-based suite, while the rival hospital refers revascularization to the metropolitan academic center. Blood flow is central to healing diabetic foot wounds, and amputation prevention teams are built on combining vascular care with podiatric care (Rogers et al., 2010). A program that offers both in one place could attract referrals from primary care physicians frustrated by sending patients across two systems. Second, Ocotillo owns 11 primary care clinics, which could screen feet and refer early inside the system if there were somewhere to refer to. Third, Ocotillo owns the home health agency that already follows 45 wound patients a year at home.
Weaknesses That Would Keep It From Changing
Ocotillo also has weaknesses that would keep the flow where it is. It has no dedicated wound clinic, no certified wound nurse and no employed podiatrist. It is not in the Medicare Advantage plan's preferred wound care network, which the plan will revisit only at contract renewal in 18 months. And its relationship with the podiatry group is distant; the group sees Ocotillo mainly as the place its patients go when things go wrong.
The Rival's Likely Response
A competitive analysis should also ask how the rival would respond if Ocotillo moved. The rival's wound center is run by a national management company whose contract pays it partly on treatment volume, including hyperbaric sessions, so it has a strong interest in protecting its referral base. Its most likely responses are to deepen its tie to the podiatry group, for example by offering the younger podiatrists paid clinic sessions, and to argue to the Medicare Advantage plan that a second wound program in the county would duplicate services. It is unlikely to add vascular surgery, which requires surgeons and an endovascular suite the rival hospital does not have. Ocotillo should therefore expect competition for podiatrists and for the plan's attention, not for revascularization. That argues for approaching the podiatry group early and for bringing the plan outcome data, particularly amputation and readmission rates among its members, before the contract renewal rather than at it.
Position and Implications
Ocotillo's competitive position is strong at the end of the patient's path and weak at the beginning. It controls the emergency and inpatient path and could control the primary care and home health paths, but it has no presence in the podiatry path, which carries the most volume. A strategy that simply opened a wound clinic would compete for podiatry referrals it is unlikely to win. A strategy that captured its own primary care and home health patients first, with foot screening in every clinic and a referral pathway into a vascular-led limb preservation clinic, would build volume from paths the system already controls. The podiatry group becomes a potential partner rather than a competitor to beat: employing or contracting with one of its younger podiatrists would bring part of that path inside. Value in health care depends on organizing around the patient's full cycle of care (Porter, 2010), and in this market that means organizing the path before the emergency, not after it.
References
Barnett, M. L., Song, Z., & Landon, B. E. (2012). Trends in physician referrals in the United States, 1999-2009. Archives of Internal Medicine, 172(2), 163-170. https://doi.org/10.1001/archinternmed.2011.722
Porter, M. E. (2010). What is value in health care? New England Journal of Medicine, 363(26), 2477-2481. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMp1011024
Rogers, L. C., Andros, G., Caporusso, J., Harkless, L. B., Mills, J. L., & Armstrong, D. G. (2010). Toe and flow: Essential components and structure of the amputation prevention team. Journal of Vascular Surgery, 52(3 Suppl.), 23S-27S. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvs.2010.06.004
HCA 470 Topic 3 instructions, in plain terms
HCA-470 Topic 3 asks students to assess an organization's competitive position in its market. The instructions typically ask students to identify competitors, compare strengths and weaknesses, and explain the organization's advantages or disadvantages using tools such as SWOT, Porter's five forces or market share analysis. In health care, competition often runs through referral relationships, insurance networks and transfer patterns rather than consumer choice, so the strongest analyses explain how patients reach each organization before judging advantage. Students should support their claims with data, acknowledge what they cannot observe about competitors, and draw strategic implications, with sources on health care markets and strategy.
How the HCA-470 Topic 3 example is put together
The finished analysis explains the flow of patients before it claims any advantage. It describes how volume reaches each organization in this market, which typically runs through referring physicians, employer contracts, transfer agreements and emergency arrival rather than through anything a consumer decides. Strengths are then tested against that flow, so a reputation no referring practice acts on is recorded as an asset with no route to volume. Each claimed advantage is supported by something a rival would have difficulty copying inside the planning horizon, since anything matched easily is not a position. Competitors are described as they would describe themselves. A closing passage names the rival most likely to take share and how.
Where the marks sit in the HCA 470 Topic 3 rubric
GCU faculty grading the competitive position analysis look for an explanation of patient flow. Excellent papers show how volume reaches each organization, through referrals, networks, emergency arrival or contracts, before claiming strengths. The rubric rewards counting a strength only when it could change that flow, and treating weaknesses the same way. Credit goes to anticipating how a competitor would respond and to recognizing when a competitor could become a partner. The highest level draws a clear strategic implication from the analysis, uses data honestly with its limits stated, and supports the reasoning with relevant research on referrals or value. Market share tables with no account of how patients arrive tend to earn only partial credit.
HCA 470 Topic 3 help: mistakes that cost marks
Marks reward mechanism, and the standard weak version is a list of strengths with no route to volume. Quality and caring staff appear in every organization's self description, cost nothing to claim and change no referring physician's behavior. Competitors dismissed rather than described suggest an analysis written to reassure. Advantages asserted without asking how quickly they could be matched treat a temporary lead as a structural one. Analyses that skip the referral mechanism explain patient volume as consumer choice, which fits retail and misfits most of health care. Vulnerabilities omitted make the piece a brochure. Positions supported by nothing from the scan read as preference, which is the failure this course is built to prevent.
Get an HCA-470 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-470 Topic 3 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and the organization and market you are working with. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the referral mechanism mapped, competitors described fairly, each claimed strength tested against the flow and the likeliest share loss named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HCA 470 papers and BS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 470 Topic 1: Mission Constraint Analysis
- HCA 470 Topic 2: Environmental Scan
- HCA 470 Topic 4: Strategic Trade-off Memo
- HCA 470 Topic 5: Service Line Viability Post
- HCA 470 Topic 6: Implementation Roadmap
- HCA 470 Topic 7: Feasibility Stress Test
- HCA 470 Topic 8: Strategy Measurement Plan
- HCA 240 Topic 3: Coding Exercise
- HCA 465 Topic 3: Departmental Budget Memo
- HCA 360 Topic 3: Interoperability Report
- HCA 460 Topic 3: Staffing Model Comparison
HCA 470 Topic 3 questions, answered
Why does the referral mechanism matter so much?
Because it is how volume actually moves. Outside a few consumer facing services, patients arrive because a physician sent them, an employer contracted for them, a transfer agreement routed them or an ambulance took them somewhere. A strength that never reaches one of those channels does not become a case, however real it is inside the building.
What counts as a durable advantage?
Something a rival cannot assemble quickly. A subspecialty team with recruiting difficulty behind it, an exclusive contract, a location with a genuine drive time advantage or an installed referral relationship all take time to reproduce. Equipment, a service line anybody can staff and a marketing position are usually matched within a planning cycle, which is why they rarely support a strategy.
Should I write about competitors I only partly know?
Yes, using what is public and marking the gaps. Filings, published service listings, recruitment postings and local coverage tell you a great deal about where a rival is investing. Guessing beyond that is fine if the guess is labeled, and a reader trusts an analysis that says what it does not know far more than one appearing to know everything.
Where can I find a free HCA 470 Topic 3 sample paper?
This page carries the full competitive position analysis, with the five paths into care, the flow explained, strengths and weaknesses, the rival's likely response and the implications. A free model for your own market can be requested.
What is the rival's advantage in HCA 470 Topic 3?
A referral relationship. The senior partner of the county's podiatry group directs the rival wound center, and the rival sits in a large insurer's preferred network, not because patients chose it for published outcomes.