| Course | HCA 515 Analysis of Contemporary Health Care Delivery Models |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Risk transfer analysis |
| Length | About 1,020 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 515 Topic 4
Three Kinds of Risk, Four Contracts: A Risk Transfer Analysis of Who Bears What When a Medicaid Plan Pays for COPD Care
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HCA-515: Analysis of Contemporary Health Care Delivery Models
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Three Kinds of Risk, Four Contracts: A Risk Transfer Analysis of Who Bears What When a Medicaid Plan Pays for COPD Care
Why the Word Needs Taking Apart
Health care leaders often say that a payment arrangement puts providers "at risk" without saying at risk of what. The phrase covers at least three different exposures, and they are not equally manageable. The first is insurance risk: the chance that the people covered turn out to be sicker, and more expensive, than expected when the price was set. The second is technical or performance risk: the chance that caring for a given patient with a given condition costs more than budgeted because of how the care is delivered. The third is quality risk: the chance of losing money because measured results fall short of a target written into a contract. This analysis traces how four contracts in one state's Medicaid program move each kind of risk for members with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and asks whether each risk sits with the party best placed to manage it.
Contract 1: The State and the Managed Care Organization
The state pays the managed care organization a fixed amount per member per month. That transfers both insurance risk and technical risk from the state to the plan: if COPD members cost more than expected, the plan absorbs the loss. The state limits the transfer in three ways. It adjusts payments for the health status of each plan's members, so a plan that enrolls sicker members receives more; risk adjustment exists because without it, plans have strong reasons to avoid people likely to be costly (Geruso & Layton, 2017). It shares gains and losses beyond a set band through a risk corridor. And it requires a minimum share of premium to be spent on care, which caps how much the plan can keep. The plan is well placed to bear insurance risk, because it covers hundreds of thousands of members and the costs of individual members average out across them.
Contract 2: The Plan and the Regional Medical Center
For each admission, the regional medical center receives a set sum determined by the stay's diagnosis-related group. This moves technical risk within each stay to the hospital: if Doris, a 61-year-old member with COPD, stays six days instead of four, the hospital absorbs the extra cost. The plan keeps the risk that admissions happen at all. The hospital is well placed to manage the cost of a stay, which depends on its own processes, but it has no financial reason to prevent the next admission, and under per-case payment an extra admission brings more revenue.
Contract 3: The Plan and the Community Health Center
The plan pays the community health center per visit, and the state tops up payment to the center's federally defined per-visit rate. The center bears almost no financial risk: it is paid for each visit whether Doris is admitted or not. The plan has proposed a new arrangement: a monthly care management payment of $25 for each member with COPD, plus a share of any savings in hospital costs for those members, with 10 percent of the care management payment withheld unless the center meets targets for inhaler technique checks and follow-up within seven days of discharge. That would move a modest amount of technical risk and some quality risk to the center, while the plan keeps insurance risk.
Contract 4: A Proposed Arrangement With the Health System
Sagebrush Health, which owns the regional medical center and the critical access hospital Doris uses, has proposed taking a sub-capitation payment for the plan's members with COPD in two counties: a fixed monthly amount per member covering all hospital, specialist and pulmonary rehabilitation costs. This would transfer insurance risk, not only technical risk, to Sagebrush. The plan would like the arrangement because it moves cost uncertainty to the provider. Sagebrush wants it because it would profit from preventing admissions. Its confidence rests partly on its experience running an accountable care organization for Medicare patients, where shared savings arrangements produced modest savings in their early years nationally (McWilliams et al., 2016); sub-capitation is a larger step, because shared savings programs typically limit downside losses while full sub-capitation does not.
Table 1
How Four Contracts Move Three Kinds of Risk for Members With COPD
| Contract | Insurance risk | Technical risk | Quality risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| State to managed care organization | Plan, limited by risk adjustment and corridors | Plan | Plan, through state quality incentives |
| Plan to regional medical center | Plan | Hospital, within each stay | Small, through reporting |
| Plan to community health center (proposed) | Plan | Shared, through savings | Center, through a 10% withhold |
| Plan to health system (proposed sub-capitation) | Health system | Health system | Health system |
Is Each Risk Where It Belongs?
Technical risk belongs with whoever controls the process that produces the cost, and the proposed center and hospital contracts move it roughly in that direction. Quality risk belongs with whoever can change the measured result, which argues for the center's withhold. Insurance risk belongs with a party large enough to spread it. A sub-capitation covering perhaps 900 COPD members would expose Sagebrush to large swings from a handful of very expensive patients, the kind of variation that pooling across a whole plan absorbs. The 1990s showed how difficult it was for providers to take on meaningful insurance risk through capitation, and later models such as accountable care organizations have sought a middle point on the spectrum of risk between payers and providers (Frakt & Mayes, 2012). If the sub-capitation goes ahead, it should include stop-loss protection above a set cost per member, so that Sagebrush bears the technical risk it can manage and the plan keeps the insurance risk that Sagebrush's small pool cannot.
What This Means for Doris
None of these contracts is visible to Doris, but each shapes what happens to her. The proposed center contract would pay someone to check her inhaler technique and call her after discharge. The proposed Sagebrush contract would give the system a reason to bring pulmonary rehabilitation closer to her home. Whether either improves her care depends less on how much risk moves than on whether the party receiving it can do something about it.
References
Frakt, A. B., & Mayes, R. (2012). Beyond capitation: How new payment experiments seek to find the "sweet spot" in amount of risk providers and payers bear. Health Affairs, 31(9), 1951-1958. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2012.0344
Geruso, M., & Layton, T. J. (2017). Selection in health insurance markets and its policy remedies. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 31(4), 23-50. https://doi.org/10.1257/jep.31.4.23
McWilliams, J. M., Hatfield, L. A., Chernew, M. E., Landon, B. E., & Schwartz, A. L. (2016). Early performance of accountable care organizations in Medicare. New England Journal of Medicine, 374(24), 2357-2366. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMsa1600142
HCA 515 Topic 4 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 4 instructions in HCA-515 ask students to analyze how financial risk is shared among payers and providers in contemporary payment arrangements. Students typically explain arrangements such as capitation, bundled payments, shared savings and pay for performance, identify which party bears which risks, and assess the consequences for cost, quality and access. The assignment rewards precision about the different kinds of risk and about the mechanisms that limit them, such as risk adjustment, corridors and stop-loss. Students should apply the analysis to specific contracts or a realistic scenario, supported by research on managed care and value-based payment. The history of capitation in the 1990s is a useful reference point for many sections.
Inside the HCA 515 Topic 4 example
The finished analysis is precise about a word that usually stays vague. Risk is separated into its kinds: the chance that patients turn out sicker than expected, the chance that a given case costs more to treat than budgeted, and the chance that the organization cannot deliver the measured result. An arrangement may move one of these and leave the others where they were. The example names the arrangement, states which risk crossed, and identifies who now absorbs a bad quarter. It then asks whether the receiving organization has the reserves, the data and the influence over referrals to survive one, since accepting risk without those three is a wager rather than a strategy.
HCA 515 Topic 4 rubric: what Excellent looks like
The rubric for the risk transfer analysis rewards precision. Excellent papers distinguish insurance risk, technical or performance risk and quality risk, and trace how each contract moves them between parties. The rubric gives credit for identifying mechanisms that limit risk, such as risk adjustment, risk corridors, withholds and stop-loss protection. Credit also goes to judging whether each risk sits with the party best able to manage it and explaining why. The highest level applies the analysis to concrete proposals, recommends terms that would place risk appropriately, and supports the reasoning with evidence on capitation and value-based payment. Using the phrase at risk without saying at risk of what is the most common reason papers lose marks here.
Common HCA 515 Topic 4 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Marks depend on precision about what moved, and general enthusiasm for value based care earns very little. A paper praising the shift from volume to value, without naming a population, a period or an adjusted payment, has described a direction rather than an arrangement. Treating all risk as one substance misses the difference between a sicker panel and a slower discharge process, which are answered by completely different capabilities. Analyses ignoring stop loss and risk adjustment overstate the transfer, sometimes dramatically. Versions that never ask whether the organization could survive a bad year have recommended a contract on the strength of its good year. Papers assuming a small practice can accept the same exposure as a large system have skipped the reserves question entirely.
Get an HCA-515 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-515 Topic 4 instructions, your rubric and the value based arrangement or scenario the assignment gives you. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the contract described operationally, insurance risk kept apart from performance risk, the real transfer measured and one bad year worked through, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HCA 515 papers and MS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 515 Topic 1: Delivery Model Analysis
- HCA 515 Topic 2: Payment Pathway Trace
- HCA 515 Topic 3: Integration Case Study
- HCA 515 Topic 5: Incentive Effects Post
- HCA 515 Topic 6: Access Barrier Report
- HCA 515 Topic 7: Model Comparison Paper
- HCA 515 Topic 8: Operating Feasibility Brief
- HCA 530 Topic 4: Cost and Access Trade-off
- HCA 680 Topic 4: Divided Duty Analysis
- HCA 540 Topic 4: Measurement Appraisal
- HCA 675 Topic 4: Burden and Benefit Ledger
HCA 515 Topic 4 questions, answered
What kind of risk does a value based contract move?
Usually performance risk, sometimes insurance risk, and the two are answered by different capabilities. Performance risk asks whether the organization can produce a result at a cost, which is a management problem. Insurance risk asks who enrolls or who is attributed, which is an actuarial problem a clinical organization is rarely built to hold. Saying which one moved is the analysis.
Does shared savings count as risk?
Only partly, and saying so precisely is worth marks. An arrangement paying a share of savings with no downside exposes the organization to its own investment and nothing more, which is why many groups start there. Once losses are repaid, the exposure changes character, and the reserves and measurement questions that were optional become the ones that decide the outcome.
Should the paper recommend accepting the contract?
Where the assignment asks for a recommendation, take one and attach conditions. Supporters argue these arrangements reward keeping people well rather than treating them often; skeptics argue they push selection toward healthier panels. Both claims have evidence behind them, so attribute each, then decide on what this particular organization can measure and absorb.
Where can I find a free HCA 515 Topic 4 sample paper?
The complete risk transfer analysis is on this page, with three kinds of risk, four contracts, the risk table, where each risk belongs and what it means for the patient. Send the contracts in your own scenario for a free model analysis.
Why add stop-loss protection in HCA 515 Topic 4?
Because a health system covering about 900 members cannot spread the cost of a few very expensive patients the way a large plan can. Stop-loss lets it bear the technical risk it can manage while the plan keeps insurance risk.