| Course | HCA 610 Essential Health Care Business Analysis |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Data source inventory |
| Length | About 1,080 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 610 Topic 2
Invoices Say 2,941, the Record Says 2,877: A Data Source Inventory for the Inpatient Dialysis Make-or-Buy Analysis
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HCA-610: Essential Health Care Business Analysis
Topic 2 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Invoices Say 2,941, the Record Says 2,877: A Data Source Inventory for the Inpatient Dialysis Make-or-Buy Analysis
The Questions the Inventory Serves
Bristlecone Regional Medical Center is deciding whether to renew its contract for inpatient hemodialysis or to run the service itself. The scoping memo fixed four questions the analysis must answer. How many treatments are delivered, of what kind and where? How much nursing time does each one take? What does the service cost now? And what would the inputs of an in-house program cost: nurses, supplies, equipment and maintenance? This inventory is organized around those questions. A catalog of every system that mentions dialysis would be long and would not tell the analyst which number to use, so each source below is described by what it can answer, what it cannot and who owns it.
The Sources, One by One
Vendor invoices. Accounts payable holds a monthly invoice from the dialysis vendor listing each treatment billed, with date, patient account number and a flat rate of $708. The invoices are the only record of what the hospital actually pays and are refreshed monthly. They cannot show how long a treatment took, whether it was completed or what the vendor's own costs were.
Clinical record. The vendor's nurses document each treatment in the hospital's electronic record, on a dialysis flowsheet that records the order, start and stop times, location, machine and any complications. Clinical informatics owns the data, which is available in real time at the level of the individual treatment. The record can answer questions about volume, duration, location and time of day. It cannot show the setup, travel and cleanup time around each treatment, which the vendor nurse spends but does not document.
Billing file. Revenue cycle posts a charge for each treatment under the inpatient hemodialysis revenue code. This shows what was charged, not what it cost or what was paid, and because payers pay a single amount for the whole admission, no payment is attached to dialysis at all. The billing file is useful only as a third count of treatments.
General ledger. The ledger records the contract under one purchased services account in monthly totals. It confirms total spending but cannot be broken down by treatment.
Payroll and time keeping. Human resources and payroll hold wage rates, overtime and agency use for the hospital's own nurses. Because the vendor supplies the dialysis nurses, this system says nothing about dialysis today, but it is the best source for what an in-house nurse would cost and how often similar units have needed agency help. It holds data by shift, which is the level a staffing model needs.
Cost accounting system. Finance's cost accounting system spreads the contract across the units where treatments occurred and adds allocated overhead. Its figures are shaped by allocation rules rather than by resource use, which makes them unsuitable for a make-or-buy decision. Kaplan and Witkowski (2014) argued that such systems, built on departmental allocations, give managers little insight into what care actually costs.
Vendor monthly report. The contract requires the vendor to report monthly treatment counts, response times and adverse events. The report is useful for quality comparisons, but the hospital cannot verify it independently.
Biomedical engineering asset system. Biomedical engineering tracks maintenance hours and service contracts for the hospital's own equipment, including the continuous therapy machines in the ICU. It is the best available guide to what maintaining dialysis machines and water treatment units would cost.
What Each Source Can and Cannot Support
Table 1 summarizes the inventory against the four questions.
Table 1
Dialysis Data Sources and the Questions Each Can Answer
| Source | Volume | Time per treatment | Current cost | In-house input costs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vendor invoices | Billed count only | No | Yes, by treatment | No |
| Clinical record | Yes, by type and location | Treatment time only | No | No |
| Billing file | Charged count | No | No | No |
| General ledger | No | No | Monthly total | No |
| Payroll and time keeping | No | No | No | Nurse wages, agency use |
| Cost accounting | No | No | Allocated, unsuitable | No |
| Vendor report | Unverified count | No | No | No |
| Biomedical engineering | No | No | No | Maintenance hours and contracts |
Reconciling the Invoices With the Record
The invoices and the clinical record both count treatments for fiscal 2026, and they disagree. The invoices list 2,941 treatments. The clinical record shows 2,877 treatments started: 2,785 completed and 92 stopped early, usually because the circuit clotted or the patient's blood pressure fell. The gap of 64 was traced line by line. Twenty-three treatments took place during two downtimes of the electronic record in March and were documented on paper; they were real and correctly billed. Eighteen invoice lines were duplicates of treatments already billed. And 23 lines were for treatments that were ordered and then canceled before the patient was connected, typically because the patient improved or was transferred; the contract allows billing once a treatment has started, not when it is ordered.
The reconciliation has two consequences. First, the true volume for fiscal 2026 is 2,900 treatments: 2,877 in the electronic record plus the 23 on paper. Treatments stopped early count, because they consume setup time, a nurse and a full set of supplies. Second, 41 invoice lines, the duplicates and the canceled orders, were billed in error, at a cost of $29,028. That amount should be recovered from the vendor whatever the hospital decides, and the monthly invoice should be matched against the record from now on.
The Source of Record for This Analysis
For volume, the source of record is the clinical record supplemented by the paper downtime logs, giving 2,900 treatments. It is the only source that documents treatments at the level of the individual patient and that the hospital controls. For the current cost of the service, the source of record is the invoices, corrected for the 41 erroneous lines, because they show what was actually paid. For in-house input costs, the sources are payroll for wages, biomedical engineering for maintenance, and supply quotes that purchasing will obtain. Treatment time will come from the clinical record, with setup and cleanup time estimated from the vendor's staffing pattern, since neither party records it.
Recording these choices matters because a later reader, perhaps the capital committee, will want to know why the analysis used 2,900 rather than 2,941 treatments. The answer is in this inventory. Kaplan and Porter (2011) argued that a provider can only understand its costs by tracing the time and materials each patient consumes, and in health care those measures are scattered across systems that were built for other purposes (Gapenski & Reiter, 2016).
References
Gapenski, L. C., & Reiter, K. L. (2016). Healthcare finance: An introduction to accounting and financial management (6th ed.). Health Administration Press.
Kaplan, R. S., & Porter, M. E. (2011). How to solve the cost crisis in health care. Harvard Business Review, 89(9), 46-52.
Kaplan, R. S., & Witkowski, M. L. (2014). Better accounting transforms health care delivery. Accounting Horizons, 28(2), 365-383. https://doi.org/10.2308/acch-50658
The HCA-610 Topic 2 assignment instructions
The Topic 2 instructions in HCA-610 ask students to identify and evaluate the data sources needed for a health care business analysis. Students generally list the internal and external sources available, describe what each contains, assess quality and reliability and explain how the data will be used. The assignment rewards inventories built around the analytical questions, since a catalog assembled without them supports nothing. Students should state what each source cannot do as well as what it can, compare sources that record the same activity and explain any difference, and choose a source of record with reasons, drawing on literature about health care cost measurement.
Inside the HCA 610 Topic 2 example
The finished inventory is organized by question rather than by department. Each entry names a system, the office that owns it, what it records, how often it refreshes and the questions it can support without help from anything else. It also records what the system cannot do, which is usually the more valuable half: a billing system knows what was charged and not what was consumed, and a scheduling system knows appointments rather than arrivals. Two entries are then set against each other on the same activity, and the difference is explained instead of averaged. The inventory ends by choosing the source of record for this analysis and giving the reason, so a later reader can tell which number was used and why.
Reading the HCA 610 Topic 2 rubric
Marks on the data source inventory go to usefulness and candor. Excellent inventories start from the analysis questions and describe each source by owner, refresh interval and level of detail. The rubric rewards stating plainly what each source cannot support, which is often the more valuable half. Credit goes to reconciling two sources that count the same activity and explaining the difference line by line instead of averaging it away. The highest level chooses a source of record for each figure with a stated reason, so that a later reader can see which number was used and why.
HCA 610 Topic 2 help before you submit
Marks depend on whether the inventory could be used, and the common version cannot. A list of systems with a sentence of description each is a tour, not an inventory, because no question has been attached to anything. Treating the clinical record as a financial source produces figures that will not tie to the ledger, and a reader who has closed a month knows it immediately. Entries with no owner leave the analyst with no route to the data. Silence about what a system cannot do is the omission that costs most, since it is where every later error starts. Reconciliations that average two counts have hidden a difference rather than explained it, and inventories with no named source of record leave every downstream figure unattributable.
Get an HCA-610 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-610 Topic 2 instructions, your section's rubric and whatever the assignment tells you about the organization and its systems. We write a custom example to those criteria, with each source matched to the questions it answers, its limits stated, one reconciliation worked and a source of record chosen, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.
More HCA 610 papers and MS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 610 Topic 1: Analysis Scoping Memo
- HCA 610 Topic 3: Cost Structure Analysis
- HCA 610 Topic 4: Break Even Exercise
- HCA 610 Topic 5: Decision Framing Post
- HCA 610 Topic 6: Scenario Projection
- HCA 610 Topic 7: Capital Request Business Case
- HCA 610 Topic 8: Analysis Defense Paper
- HCA 545 Topic 2: Dual Authority Case
- HCA 540 Topic 2: Design Fit Memo
- HCA 530 Topic 2: Market Failure Analysis
HCA 610 Topic 2 questions, answered
Which system should a financial figure come from?
The general ledger, when the question is what the organization spent or received, because that is the record the finance office will defend. Operational systems are better for volume, timing and staffing detail the ledger never carries. Problems start when the two are mixed inside one calculation without saying which supplied which part.
What if two systems give different numbers?
Say so and account for the difference, since the gap is usually informative. Scheduling counts what was booked, billing counts what was billable and the clinical record counts what was documented, and those three describe the same day differently for reasons anybody in the department can explain. Choosing one and stating why is the finding.
Can I use data from an organization I invented?
Yes, provided the systems behave the way real ones do and you hold them consistent through the paper. An invented organization with a payroll system that suddenly reports case mix has stopped being useful. Keep each source doing what its real equivalent does, and any table you borrow from a published report still needs a citation before it goes through LopesWrite.
Where can I find a free HCA 610 Topic 2 sample paper?
The complete data source inventory is on this page, with the questions, eight sources described one by one, the capability table, the invoice reconciliation and the source of record. Tell us your analysis questions for a free model inventory.
Why did the invoices and record disagree in HCA 610 Topic 2?
Twenty-three treatments were documented on paper during system downtimes, 18 invoice lines were duplicates and 23 were for treatments canceled before they started, which the contract does not allow to be billed.