| Course | HCA 610 Essential Health Care Business Analysis |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Cost structure analysis |
| Length | About 980 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 610 Topic 3
Mostly Fixed, Stepping at Nine a Day: A Cost Structure Analysis of an In-House Inpatient Dialysis Program
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HCA-610: Essential Health Care Business Analysis
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Mostly Fixed, Stepping at Nine a Day: A Cost Structure Analysis of an In-House Inpatient Dialysis Program
The Program and the Period
This analysis classifies the costs of the in-house inpatient hemodialysis program that Bristlecone Regional Medical Center is considering as an alternative to its vendor contract. The period is fiscal 2028, the first full year the program would run, and the expected volume is 2,900 treatments, the reconciled count for the year just ended. The program would employ dialysis nurses to deliver treatments in the fourth-floor dialysis room and in ICU patient rooms, using portable machines with their own water purification units. A cost behaves differently over a month than over a year, so each classification below is stated for a one-year horizon, with notes where the behavior is different over a shorter period.
Each Cost Line and Its Behavior
Table 1 lists the program's costs and assigns each to a behavior. The evidence for each assignment follows the table.
Table 1
Cost Lines of the Proposed In-House Dialysis Program, Fiscal 2028
| Cost line | Annual amount at 2,900 treatments | Behavior |
|---|---|---|
| Dialysis nurses, four 12-hour shifts a day | $1,166,000 | Step |
| Call pay and overtime for peaks | $120,000 | Semi-variable |
| Program coordinator (RN) | $125,000 | Fixed |
| Biomedical technician | $78,000 | Fixed |
| Medical director stipend | $60,000 | Fixed |
| Equipment depreciation, 8 machines and 8 water units | $57,000 | Fixed |
| Service contracts | $24,000 | Fixed |
| Training and competency | $20,000 | Fixed |
| Water testing | $12,000 | Fixed |
| Supplies, $58 a treatment | $168,200 | Variable |
| Utilities and per-treatment testing, $9 a treatment | $26,100 | Variable |
| Allocated overhead | About $140,000 | Allocated, excluded |
The Evidence for Each Assignment
Supplies are variable, and almost proportionally so. Each treatment uses one dialyzer, one set of blood lines, concentrate, saline and heparin, which purchasing priced at $58, and a treatment that is not delivered uses none of them. Utilities and the per-treatment water checks behave the same way at $9 a treatment.
The coordinator, the biomedical technician, the medical director's stipend, the service contracts, the training budget and the water testing program are fixed. None of them changes whether the program delivers 2,400 treatments or 3,200. Depreciation is fixed as well: the machines lose value over their seven-year life whether they run twice a day or four times.
Call pay and overtime are semi-variable. The on-call nurse is paid a standby rate whether or not she is called in, which is fixed, and is paid overtime for each treatment she delivers, which varies with the number of days on which demand exceeds what the scheduled nurses can handle.
Nurse labor is the interesting case. Inpatient hemodialysis requires a nurse with the patient throughout a treatment of three to four hours, plus setup, travel to the bedside and cleanup, so one nurse can deliver about two treatments in a 12-hour shift. At 2,900 treatments a year, about eight a day on average, the program needs four scheduled shifts a day, or about 9.4 full-time nurses. Within a pay period, the schedule is posted six weeks ahead and nurses are paid for their shifts whatever the census, so labor is fixed. Across a quarter, the schedule can be changed, so labor responds to volume. But it responds in steps, one 12-hour shift at a time, rather than smoothly. Kaplan and Witkowski (2014) noted that in health care most costs are the costs of people and space, which behave as committed capacity in the short term, and that treating them as variable produces misleading unit costs.
Direct and Allocated Costs
The hospital's cost accounting system would assign the program about $140,000 a year in overhead: a share of human resources, information technology, finance and building costs, allocated by square footage and head count. These costs are real, but they do not change whether the hospital runs dialysis itself or pays a vendor. Human resources, the information systems and the building would cost the same under either option, so nothing the program decides can remove them. For a make-or-buy comparison, only costs that differ between the options are relevant, and allocated overhead is set aside (Gapenski & Reiter, 2016). The direct fixed costs, by contrast, would disappear if the program were never started.
The Step Points
The step in nurse labor is where most of the program's financial risk sits. With four scheduled shifts, the program can deliver about eight treatments on an average day, or roughly 2,920 a year, and the on-call nurse covers days with more. Daily demand varies: in fiscal 2026 it ranged from two treatments to fourteen. As average volume rises, the number of days above eight grows, and so does overtime. At roughly nine treatments a day on average, about 3,300 a year, a fifth scheduled shift becomes cheaper than the overtime it replaces. That fifth shift adds about $292,000 a year at once. The reverse step matters too: if volume fell below about six treatments a day, the program could drop to three scheduled shifts, but not quickly, and not without letting nurses go whom it had just recruited.
Contribution per Treatment and the Valid Range
The program earns no separate revenue, because the admission is paid as one bundle and dialysis carries no price of its own. What each in-house treatment does is avoid a payment to the vendor. At the renewal price of $740, each treatment delivered in house avoids $740 and adds $67 in variable cost, a contribution of $673 toward the program's direct fixed costs of about $1,662,000. At 2,900 treatments the program would cost about $1,856,000, or $640 a treatment, against $2,146,000 under the contract. This classification holds between about 2,200 and 3,300 treatments a year. Below that range the nurse schedule could shrink, and above it a fifth shift is needed, so any projection outside it must redraw the fixed cost line. Kaplan and Porter (2011) argued that providers rarely know what their services cost because they do not track resources this way, and the break-even analysis that follows depends on it.
References
Gapenski, L. C., & Reiter, K. L. (2016). Healthcare finance: An introduction to accounting and financial management (6th ed.). Health Administration Press.
Kaplan, R. S., & Porter, M. E. (2011). How to solve the cost crisis in health care. Harvard Business Review, 89(9), 46-52.
Kaplan, R. S., & Witkowski, M. L. (2014). Better accounting transforms health care delivery. Accounting Horizons, 28(2), 365-383. https://doi.org/10.2308/acch-50658
What the HCA 610 Topic 3 instructions ask for
HCA-610 Topic 3 asks students to analyze the cost structure of a health care service or department. Students generally identify the costs involved, classify them by behavior, distinguish direct from indirect costs and explain how cost structure affects decisions. The strongest analyses give evidence for each classification rather than asserting it, pay particular attention to labor, which is usually fixed in the short term and variable over longer periods, and identify step points where one more unit of volume requires another position. Students should explain why allocated overhead is treated separately, derive a contribution margin for one unit of service and state the volume range over which the classification holds.
Inside the HCA 610 Topic 3 example
The example builds its classification around one program, bedside and dialysis-room hemodialysis delivered by hospital nurses. It first fixes the period and expected volume, then presents a table of twelve cost lines with their annual amounts and behavior. The evidence section explains why supplies move with each treatment, why the coordinator, stipend, contracts and depreciation do not, and why call pay is part fixed and part variable. Nurse labor gets the longest treatment, since one nurse stays with each patient through a treatment and staffing changes one shift at a time. Allocated overhead is set aside, the step points are marked, and the paper closes with contribution per treatment and the valid volume range.
Where the marks sit in the HCA 610 Topic 3 rubric
GCU faculty grading the cost structure analysis look for argued classification. Excellent papers assign every cost line to a behavior with a sentence of evidence about what makes it move, and treat labor carefully rather than labeling it simply fixed or variable. The rubric rewards separating direct costs from allocated ones and explaining why the second group cannot be changed by the department's decisions. Credit goes to identifying step points and the volume that triggers each, since that is where much of the financial risk sits. The highest level derives contribution margin per unit and states the volume range over which the classification is valid.
HCA 610 Topic 3 help before you submit
This topic is marked as much for correctness as for reasoning, and several errors here are simply wrong. Salaries listed as variable because they can eventually be cut misdescribe what happens when tomorrow's census falls. A cost report copied into categories with no evidence for the sorting has classified nothing. Analyses that ignore step points describe a smooth line the department has never experienced, and the first added position exposes it. Treating allocated overhead as avoidable produces savings the organization will not see. A contribution margin built on full cost rather than variable cost is the error that propagates furthest, since every later break even figure inherits it. Classifications offered with no relevant range claim to hold at any volume at all.
Get an HCA-610 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-610 Topic 3 instructions, the rubric your section posted and the cost report or scenario you were assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with every line classified on evidence, the step points marked, contribution margin derived from variable cost and the relevant range stated, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HCA 610 papers and MS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 610 Topic 1: Analysis Scoping Memo
- HCA 610 Topic 2: Data Source Inventory
- HCA 610 Topic 4: Break Even Exercise
- HCA 610 Topic 5: Decision Framing Post
- HCA 610 Topic 6: Scenario Projection
- HCA 610 Topic 7: Capital Request Business Case
- HCA 610 Topic 8: Analysis Defense Paper
- HCA 545 Topic 3: Culture Assessment
- HCA 540 Topic 3: Sampling Plan
- HCA 530 Topic 3: Legislative Brief
HCA 610 Topic 3 questions, answered
Are salaries fixed or variable?
Both, depending on the period you are asking about. Inside a pay period the schedule is set and the cost arrives whatever the census does. Across a quarter positions can be held open, hours reduced and agency coverage stopped, which makes the same line variable. State the period first and the classification stops being ambiguous.
Why does allocated overhead sit outside the calculation?
Because the department cannot make it go away. A share of administration, plant and information systems is pushed down by a formula, and closing a service moves that share onto whatever remains rather than removing it from the organization. Decisions taken at department level are made on the costs that actually change, which is what incremental means here.
What is a step cost in a clinical department?
A cost that stays flat across a band of volume and then jumps. Ratios do this: staffing rules, licensure requirements and equipment capacity all hold until one more patient crosses a line, at which point a whole position or a whole room is required. Marking those thresholds matters more than the exact figure attached to them.
Where can I find a free HCA 610 Topic 3 sample paper?
This page carries the full cost structure analysis, with the program and period, the cost table, the evidence for each classification, direct and allocated costs, step points, and contribution per treatment. A free worked analysis of your own department can be requested.
Why is nurse labor a step cost in HCA 610 Topic 3?
One nurse stays with each patient through a treatment and can deliver about two in a 12-hour shift, so staffing rises one full shift at a time, adding about $292,000 a year when volume nears nine treatments a day.