| Course | HCA 610 Essential Health Care Business Analysis |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Scenario projection |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 610 Topic 6
More Patients, Smaller Savings: A Three-Scenario Projection for In-House Dialysis in Which Nurse Labor, Not Volume, Moves the Result
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HCA-610: Essential Health Care Business Analysis
Topic 6 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
More Patients, Smaller Savings: A Three-Scenario Projection for In-House Dialysis in Which Nurse Labor, Not Volume, Moves the Result
The Base Case and Its Assumptions
Table 1
Base Case Assumptions
| Assumption | Base value | Source and date |
|---|---|---|
| Treatments, fiscal 2028 | 2,900, then 3 percent a year | Reconciled clinical record, fiscal 2026; four-year trend |
| Contract price | $740, rising 4.5 percent a year | Vendor renewal quote, August 2026 |
| Nurse wage | $52 an hour plus 28 percent benefits, rising 3.5 percent | Payroll and 2026 market survey |
| Share of shifts filled by agency | 0 percent | Assumption, tested below |
| Supplies and per-treatment costs | $67, rising 3.5 percent | Purchasing quotes, 2026 |
| Other fixed cash costs | $439,000, rising 3.5 percent | Cost structure analysis |
| Equipment and start-up | $486,000 and $210,000, fiscal 2027 | Biomedical engineering and nursing education estimates |
This projection estimates the five-year saving from running inpatient hemodialysis in house at Bristlecone Regional Medical Center rather than renewing the vendor contract, for fiscal 2028 through 2032. It uses one model and changes its inputs, so that each scenario can be described as a change to specific lines. The model counts cash: equipment is charged when it is bought, in fiscal 2027, rather than depreciated, which is why the first-year saving here is higher than the accounting figure in the break-even exercise. Table 1 lists every base case assumption with its source.
The Drivers the Result Turns On
Four inputs move the result materially. Volume matters because the contract is paid per treatment while most in-house costs are fixed, and because the nurse schedule steps up once average volume passes about 3,300 treatments a year. The contract escalator matters because it compounds over five years. Nurse labor matters because it is about two-thirds of in-house cost, and an agency nurse at $110 an hour costs about $521 more per 12-hour shift than an employed one. Supply prices matter little: a 10 percent change moves annual cost by less than $20,000. Scenario planning works best when it varies the few drivers that matter rather than every input at once (Schoemaker, 1995), so the scenarios below move volume and labor, and the escalator is tested separately.
The Base Case Result
In the base case, the in-house program saves about $347,000 in fiscal 2028, rising each year as the contract escalator outpaces wage growth, to about $787,000 in fiscal 2032. Over five years it saves about $2.78 million in operating cost. After the $696,000 in equipment and start-up spending, the net five-year saving is about $2.09 million.
A Downside Built From Experience
The downside moves two drivers to values Bristlecone has already seen. For labor, it assumes that 30 percent of dialysis shifts are filled by agency nurses in the first two years and 10 percent after that. That is close to what happened in the hospital's own intensive care unit from 2022 to 2024, when it could not fill vacancies with employed nurses. For volume, it assumes no growth at all, as happened in 2020 and 2021. Under those assumptions, the program saves about $118,000 in the first year and $144,000 in the second, well below the $250,000 threshold, before recovering to about $334,000 to $407,000 a year once agency use falls. The five-year operating saving is about $1.37 million, and the net saving after equipment and start-up is about $677,000. The program still pays for itself, but slowly, and its first two years would disappoint anyone who approved it on the base case.
An Upside That Is Not One
The upside moves volume to the pace Bristlecone has actually recorded, 4.9 percent a year from 2022 to 2026, driven by the larger intensive care unit and rising sepsis admissions. Nationally, dialysis for acute kidney injury has risen alongside sepsis, respiratory failure and shock (Hsu et al., 2016), so this pace is plausible. The result is counterintuitive. Faster growth pushes average volume past 3,300 treatments in fiscal 2031, while the base case stays below that level through 2032, and the fifth nurse shift adds about $323,000 in that year's wages. The saving dips from about $956,000 in fiscal 2030 to $828,000 in 2031 before recovering. Over five years the upside saves about $2.58 million in operating cost, less than the base case. More patients bring the step forward, and until volume fills the fifth shift, the extra nurse costs more than the extra treatments avoid.
The Three Scenarios Side by Side
Table 2
Results of the Three Scenarios
| Scenario | Fiscal 2028 saving | Five-year operating saving | Five-year net of equipment and start-up |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base | $347,000 | $2.78 million | $2.09 million |
| Downside: agency nurses, flat volume | $118,000 | $1.37 million | $0.68 million |
| Upside volume: 4.9 percent growth | $347,000 | $2.58 million | $1.89 million |
What the Hospital Would Do in Each Case
In the base case, the hospital proceeds and reviews staffing each quarter. In the downside, it proceeds only if it has a plan to bring agency use below 10 percent within 24 months of launch, and it sets a stop point: if more than 40 percent of shifts are still filled by agency nurses six months after launch, it asks the vendor for a short-term coverage agreement while recruitment continues. In the upside, it plans the fifth shift a year ahead and considers whether a ninth machine would allow two nurses to share a larger dialysis room, which could delay the step.
The Driver That Matters Most
The result is most sensitive to nurse labor. Every 10 percentage points of agency share costs about $76,000 a year, and a sustained 30 percent share removes about $228,000, most of the first-year saving. Volume, by contrast, changes the five-year result by a few hundred thousand dollars either way, and the escalator matters only over time: capping it at 3.5 percent would reduce the five-year saving to about $2.53 million, not enough to change the decision. Reporting the range of outcomes and the drivers behind them, rather than a single point estimate, is what makes a projection useful to decision makers (Briggs et al., 2012). For Bristlecone, the practical conclusion is that the recruitment plan deserves as much scrutiny as the financial model.
References
Briggs, A. H., Weinstein, M. C., Fenwick, E. A. L., Karnon, J., Sculpher, M. J., & Paltiel, A. D. (2012). Model parameter estimation and uncertainty analysis: A report of the ISPOR-SMDM Modeling Good Research Practices Task Force Working Group-6. Medical Decision Making, 32(5), 722-732. https://doi.org/10.1177/0272989X12458348
Hsu, R. K., McCulloch, C. E., Heung, M., Saran, R., Shahinian, V. B., Pavkov, M. E., Burrows, N. R., Powe, N. R., & Hsu, C. Y. (2016). Exploring potential reasons for the temporal trend in dialysis-requiring AKI in the United States. Clinical Journal of the American Society of Nephrology, 11(1), 14-20. https://doi.org/10.2215/CJN.04520415
Schoemaker, P. J. H. (1995). Scenario planning: A tool for strategic thinking. Sloan Management Review, 36(2), 25-40.
Reading the GCU HCA 610 Topic 6 instructions
HCA-610 Topic 6 asks students to project the financial results of a health care initiative under different scenarios. Students generally build a base case, develop alternative scenarios, compare outcomes and explain the implications for decision making. The strongest projections keep one model and change specific inputs, list every base assumption with a source, and identify the few drivers the result actually turns on. Students should build downside and upside cases from values that have already occurred somewhere comparable rather than from round percentages, report all scenarios on the same measure, state what the organization would do in each and name the driver the result is most sensitive to.
How the HCA-610 Topic 6 example is put together
The finished projection keeps one model and moves the inputs. The base case is built first, with every assumption listed and sourced, so the two variants can be described as changes to specific lines instead of as different moods. Each scenario names the driver that moves, the value it takes and the reason that value is plausible, whether that is a payer contract under negotiation, a competitor opening nearby or a wage settlement already announced elsewhere in the market. The output for each is carried through to the same measure, which keeps the three comparable. What the organization would do in each case is stated, including the point at which it would stop. The projection ends by naming the driver the result is most sensitive to.
HCA 610 Topic 6 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Marks on the scenario projection reward disciplined modeling. Excellent papers present a sourced base case, identify the drivers that move the result and build each scenario by changing named inputs to values with a stated basis. The rubric gives credit for reporting every scenario on one comparable measure and for noticing results that run against intuition, such as growth that reduces savings. Credit also goes to stating what the organization would do in each case, including a stop point. The highest level names the driver the result is most sensitive to and draws a practical conclusion about where management attention belongs.
Common HCA 610 Topic 6 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Marks here go to scenarios that could change somebody's mind. Three cases produced by applying a favorable, a neutral and an unfavorable percentage to one total have moved a result without touching a driver, and the arithmetic is the same guess three times. Downside cases built from a round reduction, with no reference to anything that has occurred in a comparable market, are unargued. Projections reporting outcomes with no response attached leave a reader with a range and no decision. A recommendation identical across all three scenarios means the scenarios did no work, and the paper should say so rather than present the coincidence as robustness. Base cases with unsourced assumptions cannot be tested at all, which makes every variant built on them equally unverifiable.
Get an HCA-610 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-610 Topic 6 instructions, the rubric your classroom lists and the base figures or scenario you were given. We write a custom example to those criteria, with one model run three times, each driver moved to a defensible value, an action attached to every outcome and the sensitive input named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.
More HCA 610 papers and MS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 610 Topic 1: Analysis Scoping Memo
- HCA 610 Topic 2: Data Source Inventory
- HCA 610 Topic 3: Cost Structure Analysis
- HCA 610 Topic 4: Break Even Exercise
- HCA 610 Topic 5: Decision Framing Post
- HCA 610 Topic 7: Capital Request Business Case
- HCA 610 Topic 8: Analysis Defense Paper
- HCA 545 Topic 6: Effectiveness Evaluation
- HCA 540 Topic 6: Study Critique
- HCA 530 Topic 6: Compliance Response Memo
HCA 610 Topic 6 questions, answered
How many scenarios does a projection need?
Three is the usual answer because it gives a middle and two edges, but the count matters less than whether each one moves a named driver. Five cases produced by scaling a total teach less than two built on contract terms and staffing rates that could genuinely change. Add a fourth only when a driver behaves differently on its own.
Where does a defensible downside value come from?
From something that has already happened, preferably nearby. A payer term another system has accepted, a wage rate a competitor is advertising, a volume drop a comparable department recorded when a rival opened: each of these can be cited and argued. Reductions chosen because they look prudent cannot, and a reader has no way to weigh them.
Should the recommendation change between scenarios?
Not necessarily, but the paper has to notice either way. A recommendation holding across every case is a genuine finding when the scenarios were built to break it, and it is empty when they were built gently. Saying which of the two you have done, and what result would have changed your advice, is the graduate level move here.
Where can I find a free HCA 610 Topic 6 sample paper?
This page contains the full scenario projection, with the assumption table, the drivers, the base case, the downside, the upside, the side-by-side results, what the hospital would do and the most sensitive driver. Ask for a free worked projection of your own initiative.
Why does faster growth save less in HCA 610 Topic 6?
Growth pushes average volume past about 3,300 treatments sooner, triggering a fifth nurse shift costing about $323,000 a year before the extra treatments are enough to fill it.