HCA 610 Topic 7 capital request business case example

Essential Health Care Business Analysis Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This HCA 610 Topic 7 sample paper is a capital request business case asking for $696,000 to bring a hospital's inpatient dialysis in house instead of paying $12.3 million to a vendor over five years. It was prepared for GCU HCA 610, Essential Health Care Business Analysis, the course listed as HCA-610 in the Grand Canyon University MS in Health Care Administration. The case opens with the request and recommendation, describes rising prices and late urgent starts from the hospital's own records, and prices the status quo. A table sets out incremental cash flows, excluding sunk costs, and the staffing and space consequences follow. The return is a $1.41 million net present value with payback under two years, and the case names the staffing result that would make approval wrong.

CourseHCA 610 Essential Health Care Business Analysis
TopicTopic 7
Paper typeCapital request business case
LengthAbout 1,070 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMS in Health Care Administration
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for HCA 610 Topic 7

1

$696,000 to Stop Paying $12.3 Million: A Capital Request Business Case for Bringing Inpatient Dialysis In House, With the Result That Would Make Approval Wrong

[Author Name]

College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University

HCA-610: Essential Health Care Business Analysis

Topic 7 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title sets the amount requested against the five-year cost of the status quo, which is the comparison the committee must make, and promises the condition under which the request should be refused. The hospital and figures are composites; the sources are real.
2

$696,000 to Stop Paying $12.3 Million: A Capital Request Business Case for Bringing Inpatient Dialysis In House, With the Result That Would Make Approval Wrong

Request, Amount and Recommendation

Nursing and finance request $486,000 in capital and $210,000 in one-time start-up operating funds, $696,000 in total, to establish an in-house inpatient hemodialysis program at Bristlecone Regional Medical Center beginning July 1, 2027. We recommend approval. The program would replace a vendor contract whose best and final renewal price is $734 a treatment, rising 4 percent a year, and it is expected to save about $329,000 in its first full year and to repay its start-up investment in under two years. At the hospital's 6 percent hurdle rate, the five-year net present value is about $1.41 million.

The Problem in Operational Terms

Bristlecone delivered 2,900 inpatient hemodialysis treatments in fiscal 2026, all by vendor nurses, at a cost of $2.05 million after correcting 41 erroneous invoice lines. Three features of the current arrangement can be verified from the hospital's own reports. First, cost: the contract price has risen from $640 to $708 over three years, and the renewal adds another 3.7 percent with a 4 percent escalator. Second, timeliness: the contract requires urgent treatments to start within four hours of the order, and the clinical record shows a median of 5.2 hours for urgent treatments in fiscal 2026, with 31 percent starting late. Third, volume: treatments rose from about 2,510 to 2,900 in four years, consistent with national growth in dialysis for acute kidney injury driven by sepsis and respiratory failure (Hsu et al., 2016). The hospital is buying more of a service whose price and timeliness it does not control.

The Status Quo, Priced

The alternative to approval is not free. Renewing the contract for five years at $734 a treatment, rising 4 percent a year, with volume growing 3 percent a year after fiscal 2028, would cost about $12.27 million over fiscal 2028 to 2032. The status quo also carries costs that are harder to price: late starts for urgent treatments, which extend intensive care stays, and continued invoice errors unless the hospital builds its own checking, which it should do under either option.

Incremental Cash Flows

The comparison counts money that moves differently under the two options and nothing else. The $38,000 spent in 2025 on a water system feasibility study is excluded, because it has been spent whatever the committee decides, and so is the fourth-floor dialysis room, renovated in 2019 and used under either option. Overhead assigned by formula is left out as well, since both options carry the same amount (Gapenski & Reiter, 2016). Table 1 shows the flows, with the source of each estimate.

Table 1

Incremental Cash Flows of the In-House Program

Cash flowAmountBasis
Eight dialysis machines$256,000, fiscal 2027Two vendor quotes
Eight portable water units$144,000, fiscal 2027Two vendor quotes
Water and drain connections in six ICU rooms$50,000, fiscal 2027Facilities estimate
Testing equipment and record interface$36,000, fiscal 2027Biomedical engineering and IT estimate
Recruitment, eight weeks of training, overlap$210,000, fiscal 2027Nursing education estimate
In-house operating cost, fiscal 2028$1.80 million, rising with wagesCost structure analysis
Contract payments avoided, fiscal 2028$2.13 million, rising 4 percent plus volumeVendor final offer; reconciled volume

Operational Consequences

The program changes staffing and space as well as dollars. It adds about 10.4 full-time positions: 9.4 dialysis nurses covering four 12-hour shifts a day, a nurse coordinator and a biomedical technician, with an on-call rotation for nights and busy days. Recruitment would begin in January 2027, and new nurses without dialysis experience would complete eight weeks of training before July. The existing four-station dialysis room continues in use; six intensive care rooms receive water and drain connections for portable units; and a 200-square-foot office on the fourth floor becomes a supply and machine storage room. The four nephrologists who write the dialysis orders support the change on the condition that urgent treatments start within two hours, which four scheduled nurses and an on-call nurse can provide.

Return

The hospital evaluates capital requests by net present value at a 6 percent hurdle rate and by payback period. Over five years, the program saves about $329,000 in fiscal 2028, rising to about $710,000 in fiscal 2032 as the contract escalator outpaces wage growth. Against the $696,000 investment, the net present value is about $1.41 million and the payback period is about 1.9 years. On an accounting basis, with equipment depreciated over seven years, the first-year saving is about $272,000, above the $250,000 threshold the chief financial officer set before the analysis began.

What this page is doingEach figure in the return section can be traced to an assumption stated earlier, so an approver can test any one of them.
3

Risks

The largest risk is labor. If the hospital must fill 30 percent of dialysis shifts with agency nurses in the first two years, as its intensive care unit did from 2022 to 2024, and volume does not grow, the first-year saving falls to about $101,000, present value net of the investment drops to roughly $250,000 and payback stretches to about 3.6 years. The program would still pay for itself, but only just. The second risk is volume: a fall below about 2,470 treatments a year would make the program more expensive than the contract. That has not happened in four years and would most likely result from a change in physician referral patterns rather than a decline in illness. The third is clinical: water quality and machine maintenance become the hospital's responsibility, which is why the budget includes a biomedical technician, a testing program and a medical director. Because most health care costs are the costs of staff time, the program's success depends more on its people than its equipment (Kaplan & Witkowski, 2014).

The Result That Would Make Approval Wrong

The committee would be wrong to approve if the hospital cannot staff at least about 60 percent of dialysis shifts with employed nurses over the life of the program. At a sustained agency share above roughly 40 percent, the net present value falls to zero or below. Approval would also be wrong if the nephrology group intends to move a significant share of its patients elsewhere. We therefore ask the committee to approve the request on two conditions: that nursing has accepted offers from at least six dialysis nurses by April 1, 2027, and that the notice letter secures the vendor's agreement to continue service month to month, for up to six months at the renewal price, if recruitment falls short.

References

Gapenski, L. C., & Reiter, K. L. (2016). Healthcare finance: An introduction to accounting and financial management (6th ed.). Health Administration Press.

Hsu, R. K., McCulloch, C. E., Heung, M., Saran, R., Shahinian, V. B., Pavkov, M. E., Burrows, N. R., Powe, N. R., & Hsu, C. Y. (2016). Exploring potential reasons for the temporal trend in dialysis-requiring AKI in the United States. Clinical Journal of the American Society of Nephrology, 11(1), 14-20. https://doi.org/10.2215/CJN.04520415

Kaplan, R. S., & Witkowski, M. L. (2014). Better accounting transforms health care delivery. Accounting Horizons, 28(2), 365-383. https://doi.org/10.2308/acch-50658

The HCA-610 Topic 7 assignment instructions

The Topic 7 instructions in HCA-610 ask students to prepare a business case for a capital investment at a provider organization. Most cases explain the need, present alternatives, estimate costs and benefits, calculate financial returns and address risks. The assignment rewards cases arranged for the person who must approve them: the request, amount and recommendation first, the problem shown with evidence the committee can verify, and the status quo priced rather than treated as free. Students should include only incremental cash flows, exclude sunk costs, describe operational consequences in staffing and space, and state the result that would make approval a mistake.

How the HCA-610 Topic 7 example is put together

The finished case opens with the ask and the number attached to it, because a committee reading three pages before learning the amount reads them impatiently. The comparison is stated as a choice between two futures, one where the money is spent and one where it is not, and the second is priced rather than assumed to be free. Only cash flows that change appear in the calculation, which excludes money already spent and includes the maintenance the current equipment will need if nothing is bought. The operational consequence is described in staffing and space, not only in dollars. Every figure carries the assumption behind it. The case ends with the result that would make the committee wrong to approve.

HCA 610 Topic 7 rubric: what Excellent looks like

GCU's rubric for the capital request rewards cases an approver can test. Excellent business cases open with the amount and recommendation, show the problem with the organization's own data and price the option of doing nothing. Credit goes to counting only cash flows that change, excluding sunk costs explicitly and tracing every figure to a stated assumption. The rubric values operational detail about staffing and space alongside the financial return measured the way the organization measures it. The highest level states honestly the result that would make approval wrong and builds a condition into the request that protects the organization if that result occurs.

Common HCA 610 Topic 7 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Marks follow whether the committee could act on it, and several defects are checkable rather than debatable. A case comparing the project against nothing has omitted the cost of doing nothing, which is the omission most likely to be raised in the meeting itself. Sunk cost included in the calculation inflates the return on a decision that cannot recover it. Totals in the narrative that disagree with the totals in the table end the discussion of everything else. Figures presented without their assumptions cannot be interrogated, and an approver who cannot interrogate a number discounts it. Cases with no rejected alternative offer a committee one option and call it a recommendation. Requests silent about staffing produce equipment nobody is available to operate.

Get an HCA-610 Topic 7 example written to your instructions

Send us the HCA-610 Topic 7 instructions, the rubric your section works from and the project or scenario you were assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the ask stated first, the status quo priced, incremental cash flows separated from sunk cost and the rejected alternative on record, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More HCA 610 papers and MS in Health Care Administration samples

HCA 610 Topic 7 questions, answered

Why price the option of doing nothing?

Because it is the option the committee will otherwise take. Leaving equipment in place carries repair costs, downtime and eventually a failure at a worse moment, and a case ignoring those compares its project against a future that does not exist. Putting a figure on the status quo is often what makes the request persuasive.

What counts as a sunk cost here?

Anything already spent that the decision cannot recover: the consultant who wrote the feasibility work, the deposit paid last year, the renovation completed for a previous plan. It feels wasteful to leave those out, which is exactly why so many cases include them. The committee is choosing what happens next, and only future amounts respond to that choice.

Do I need real financial figures for this?

You need figures that hold together and assumptions a reader can see, which an assigned scenario usually supplies. Where you have to invent an amount, say where a real one would come from and keep it consistent everywhere it appears. A case whose table and narrative disagree loses a marker's confidence faster than one built on modest numbers.

Where can I find a free HCA 610 Topic 7 sample paper?

The complete business case is on this page, with the request and recommendation, the problem, the status quo priced, the cash flow table, operational consequences, the return, risks and the result that would make approval wrong. A free model case for your own request can be drafted.

What counts as a sunk cost in HCA 610 Topic 7?

The $38,000 water system feasibility study and the dialysis room renovated in 2019. Both have already been paid for whatever the committee decides, so neither belongs in the comparison.