| Course | HCA 675 Health Care Innovation |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Evidence threshold memo |
| Length | About 1,060 words, 3 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 675 Topic 3
Memorandum
To: Chief Nursing Officer, Cottonwood Valley Medical Center
From: [Author Name], Administrative Fellow, Patient Care Services
Date: [Date]
Re: Proof each approver would accept for a twelve-week virtual nursing trial on 4 West
The Proposal and the Approval Next in Line
The proposal is a twelve-week trial of virtual nursing on 4 West, our 32-bed medical-surgical unit: one experienced registered nurse working from the second-floor hub, four camera carts on loan from the vendor at no charge, and the virtual nurse taking admission histories, medication reconciliation and discharge teaching during the sixteen waking hours. Direct cost is about $31,000, almost all of it the virtual nurse's wages and a small training block. The next approval is not the executive team. It is the Clinical Practice Council, which meets on the second Thursday of next month and must approve draft policy NUR-212, the interim rule defining which admission activities a remote registered nurse may complete. Nothing else can move until that vote, so this memo starts with the council but covers all five parties whose agreement the trial needs.
The Five Parties and the Question Each Is Answering
Treating these approvers as one audience is the mistake I most want to avoid. Walshe and Rundall (2001) observed that managers use evidence differently from clinicians, drawing on a wider and weaker base of research and on their own experience, and the same holds within our building. Each party is answering a different question.
The Clinical Practice Council is asking whether a registered nurse on a screen can complete part of an admission without lowering the standard the policy protects. The 4 West nurse manager is asking whether the day actually gets lighter for the bedside nurses or merely rearranged. Finance is asking whether overtime cost per patient day falls enough to cover the virtual nurse's wages, since the trial will show as a nursing expense before any saving appears. Risk management is asking whether a new exposure appears when teaching delivered by camera is misunderstood and the patient returns. Informatics is asking whether the trial can run on existing documentation fields, because its build queue is committed through the spring.
Proof in the Form Each Accepts
The council accepts a written policy from a comparable hospital and the published description of how others divided the work. The nurse manager accepts the account of bedside nurses elsewhere and, most of all, a conversation with a manager who has run the model. Finance accepts figures from a comparable organization, preferably with overtime reported in dollars, and discounts supplier projections. Risk management accepts a written opinion from our counsel on the draft policy and nothing published will substitute for it. Informatics accepts a documentation walk-through showing that no new fields are needed. The council and finance, notably, would accept nothing in common: a policy document means nothing to finance, and an overtime figure answers no question the council is asking.
What Exists, What Only the Supplier Holds and What Does Not Exist
Table 1
Evidence Available Against Each Approver's Standard
| Party | Proof accepted | Available now | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clinical Practice Council | Comparable policy; published role division | Published role division; two peer policies on request | None once policies arrive |
| 4 West nurse manager | Bedside nurse accounts; a manager to call | Qualitative study; one reference site | None |
| Finance | Overtime and discharge figures from a peer | System-level figures only | Our own figures |
| Risk management | Counsel's written opinion | Nothing | Opinion not yet requested |
| Informatics | Walk-through on existing fields | Nothing | Walk-through not yet held |
The published material is stronger for the council and the nurse manager than for finance. A system that expanded virtual nursing from 2 units to 30 across three hospitals reported that virtual nurses supported 78% of discharges and more than half of admissions, cut discharge order-to-departure time by 30 minutes and reduced incidental overtime occurrences and costs by 10% (Ghidini et al., 2026). A qualitative evaluation on one medical-surgical unit found bedside nurses moved from resistance to acceptance once direct communication channels were in place and reported a perceived reduction in overtime (Gorbenko et al., 2026). A children's hospital described a model in which the virtual nurse also mentored newer staff and helped with communication for families who do not speak English (Johnson-Salerno et al., 2025).
For finance, those figures are system-level and describe organizations far larger than ours, and the qualitative study says itself that the true return on investment has not been calculated. The vendor's return calculator projects a 22% reduction in overtime on our volumes, but the vendor sells the cameras; I have kept the projection in the file and labeled it as supplier material. The vendor's reference list includes a 210-bed hospital about 90 miles away, and its nurse manager has agreed to take a call.
The Gaps and the Smallest Run That Closes Each
Lavis et al. (2005) argued that research summaries written for managers must report how context shapes whether a finding applies and what an option costs, not only whether it worked, and that is exactly what finance lacks. No published figure tells us what virtual nursing does to overtime on a 32-bed unit with our afternoon discharge peak. The smallest run that would answer finance is the twelve-week trial itself, provided we extract overtime minutes and discharge order-to-departure time for 4 West for the twelve weeks before it starts. That baseline costs four hours of analyst time and belongs to finance's question alone.
The other two gaps are cheaper still. Risk management's gap closes with a request to counsel for a written opinion on NUR-212 before the council votes, which costs nothing but a two-week lead time. Informatics' gap closes with a one-hour walk-through in which the virtual nurse documents a mock admission in the existing fields while an analyst watches.
Why Not Proceed on the Published Figures Alone
Proceeding on the published figures and the vendor's projection would save three months. It would also mean wiring 128 rooms, at about $4,500 each, on the strength of results from systems several times our size, with finance holding no figure of our own. If the savings failed to appear, the nursing budget would carry about $576,000 in cameras and seven virtual nurse positions with nothing to show the executive team. The twelve-week run costs $31,000 and answers the one question nobody else has answered for a hospital like ours. I recommend we choose the smaller risk, request counsel's opinion this week and hold the walk-through before the council meets.
References
Ghidini, J., Williams, E., Quito, A., Christoffersen, M., Giza, J., Gattinella, L., & Vose, C. (2026). The use of technology to support the nurse and nurse leader: The impact of virtual nursing on organizational goals and outcomes. Nursing Administration Quarterly, 50(3), 140-146. https://doi.org/10.1097/NAQ.0000000000000763
Gorbenko, K., Bailon, M., Randall, J., Viskochil, J., Cualing, C., Healy, P., Mazumdar, M., & Freeman, R. (2026). Virtual nursing pilot in the inpatient setting: Qualitative evaluation. JMIR Nursing, 9, Article e76994. https://doi.org/10.2196/76994
Johnson-Salerno, E., Rodriguez, S., Fausnaugh, J., Pillow, J. B., Haut, C., Carpenter, A., Johnson, N., & Mericle, J. (2025). Implementing a virtual nurse model pilot in a pediatric hospital. Journal of Nursing Administration, 55(6), 335-342. https://doi.org/10.1097/NNA.0000000000001585
Lavis, J., Davies, H., Oxman, A., Denis, J.-L., Golden-Biddle, K., & Ferlie, E. (2005). Towards systematic reviews that inform health care management and policy-making. Journal of Health Services Research & Policy, 10(Suppl. 1), 35-48. https://doi.org/10.1258/1355819054308549
Walshe, K., & Rundall, T. G. (2001). Evidence-based management: From theory to practice in health care. Milbank Quarterly, 79(3), 429-457. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-0009.00214
What the HCA 675 Topic 3 instructions ask for
The Topic 3 instructions in HCA-675 ask students to determine what evidence decision makers would need before adopting an innovation. Students often assemble one literature file and grade it by study design. The assignment rewards memos organized by approver instead: each party whose agreement the change needs, the question that party is answering and the proof it would accept, whether a peer figure, a local run, a written opinion or a reference site. Students should separate available evidence from supplier material and from proof nobody has produced, propose the smallest local step that closes each gap and compare that step with proceeding on published claims alone.
How the HCA-675 Topic 3 example is put together
The finished memo gives a line to every party whose agreement the change needs and, beside each, the question that party is answering. A department manager is deciding whether the work grows; a finance office is deciding whether cost per case moves; a compliance office is deciding whether a new exposure has appeared; a clinician is deciding whether it holds for the people in front of them. The proof each would accept is written in the form they accept it: a figure from a comparable organization, a short local run, a written opinion, a reference site they can telephone. The memo then marks which of that material exists, which only the supplier holds, and which would have to be produced here before anybody signs anything.
Where the marks sit in the HCA 675 Topic 3 rubric
GCU's rubric for the evidence threshold memo rewards matching proof to person. Excellent memos identify the next approval in the queue and each party's question in its own terms, recognizing that a compliance office and a unit manager are persuaded by different evidence. Credit goes to declaring supplier interest and treating reference sites as evidence where approvers would. The rubric values naming each gap and attaching a specific, inexpensive step to close it. The highest level weighs the local run against buying on published figures in dollars and states which risk the organization is choosing, rather than calling the evidence strong without saying for whom.
Common HCA 675 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Marks depend on whether the memo has separated its audiences, and the weak version has not. A single evidence file offered to everybody assumes a compliance officer and a department manager are persuaded by the same page, which anybody who has carried a proposal through an organization knows to be false. Memos grading sources by design hierarchy alone have imported a clinical habit into a purchasing decision, where an organization somebody can telephone often counts for more than a study of a different setting. Supplier material presented without its interest declared discredits everything sitting beside it. Naming a gap and proposing nothing that would close it leaves the reader where the memo found them. The outright failure asserts that the evidence is compelling and never says compelling to whom.
Get an HCA-675 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-675 Topic 3 instructions, your rubric and whatever the assignment tells you about the innovation and the organization considering it. We write a custom example to those criteria, with a line for each party, the proof each of them would accept, the gaps marked and a local run defended against the alternative, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HCA 675 papers and MS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 675 Topic 1: Adoption Lag Analysis
- HCA 675 Topic 2: Diffusion Attribute Audit
- HCA 675 Topic 4: Burden and Benefit Ledger
- HCA 675 Topic 5: Single Veto Discussion
- HCA 675 Topic 6: Pilot to Scale Analysis
- HCA 675 Topic 7: Local Fit Assessment
- HCA 675 Topic 8: Blocker-first Adoption Plan
- HCA 650 Topic 3: Administrative Evidence Review
- HCA 515 Topic 3: Integration Case Study
- HCA 620 Topic 3: Staffed Operations Section
- HCA 530 Topic 3: Legislative Brief
HCA 675 Topic 3 questions, answered
Does a supplier case study count as evidence?
It counts, and it often carries operating detail that appears nowhere else, so discarding it is not the same thing as being rigorous. The requirement is that the seller be named and the interest stated. A committee weighs a supplier claim very differently once two reference organizations have been telephoned and asked what the first year actually cost them.
How much evidence is enough to adopt?
Enough for the party who could stop it alone, which is a smaller and more awkward question than enough in general. Ask who stands at the front of the queue this quarter and what they have accepted before on comparable requests. Organizations leave that record behind them in prior approvals, and it guides a writer better than any general statement about levels of proof.
What if the proof I need does not exist?
Then say which party it was needed for and propose the smallest thing that would produce it here. A short run on one team, with the measure settled beforehand, often answers a manager who would never be moved by work from another state. Where the missing proof concerns patients, a local run carries approval obligations that belong to the organization and to you rather than to a paper.
Where can I find a free HCA 675 Topic 3 sample paper?
This page holds the complete memo, with the proposal, five approvers and their questions, the proof each accepts, an evidence table, the gaps and the case against buying on published figures. Describe your approvers for a free model memo.
Why keep the vendor projection in HCA 675 Topic 3?
Finance will ask about it, so the memo keeps it in the file but labels it as supplier material, since the vendor sells the cameras, and gives it no weight beside published figures or the hospital's own trial.