HCA 827 Topic 3 payer mix exposure study example

Sustainability of Health Care Organizations Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This HCA 827 Topic 3 sample paper is a payer mix exposure study that measures a rural system's revenue on what was remitted and groups it by the counterparty that sets each price. It was prepared for GCU HCA 827, Sustainability of Health Care Organizations, catalog code HCA-827, in the Grand Canyon University Doctor of Health Administration (DHA) program. A table shows federal Medicare, state Medicaid and one commercial insurer setting prices on 63 percent of revenue, while one employer's self-funded plan sets 9 percent at the best rates. Census data for Grant County, New Mexico, where 30.3 percent of residents are 65 or older, show the direction of travel, and the study names the system's own choices before ranking exposures and early signals.

CourseHCA 827 Sustainability of Health Care Organizations
TopicTopic 3
Paper typePayer mix exposure study
LengthAbout 980 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDoctor of Health Administration (DHA)
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for HCA 827 Topic 3

1

Who Sets Our Prices: A Payer Mix Exposure Study of Pinon Valley Health by Counterparty, Not by Category

[Author Name]

College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University

HCA-827: Sustainability of Health Care Organizations

Topic 3 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title turns the payer mix into a question about who fixes each price, which is what exposure means. Pinon Valley Health and its revenue figures are invented composites; its service area age structure is taken from real Census data for Grant County, New Mexico, and the other sources are real.
2

Who Sets Our Prices: A Payer Mix Exposure Study of Pinon Valley Health by Counterparty, Not by Category

Mix Measured on What Was Remitted

Pinon Valley Health's payer mix is usually reported from gross charges, the list prices the system bills before any discount. Measured that way, commercial insurers appear to supply 31% of revenue, because their contracts start from list price. Measured on net patient revenue actually remitted last year, $296 million, the picture changes, because commercial payers discount heavily and cost-based Medicare payment to the critical access hospital does not start from charges at all. This study uses remitted revenue throughout. It also groups revenue by counterparty, the party that actually fixes the price, rather than by payer category, because two systems with identical category shares can depend on very different numbers of decision makers.

Revenue by the Party That Sets Its Price

Table 1

Net Patient Revenue by Counterparty

CounterpartyShare of remitted revenueHow the price is setWhen it can change
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, traditional Medicare27%Annual federal rules; cost-based payment at the critical access hospitalEach year by rulemaking
Medicare Advantage plan A11%Negotiated contractRenewal in 14 months
Medicare Advantage plan B6%Negotiated contractRenewal in 26 months
State Medicaid program, through managed care organizations22%Rates set by the state agency within the legislature's budgetEach legislative session
Largest commercial insurer14%Negotiated contractRenewal December 31
Self-funded plan of the region's largest employer9%Direct agreement with the employerAny year; depends on the employer's survival
Other commercial insurers5%Several small contractsStaggered
Self-pay and other6%System's own charity and discount policySystem's decision

Three counterparties, the federal Medicare program, the state Medicaid program and one commercial insurer, set the prices on 63% of remitted revenue. A fourth, a single employer, sets 9%. That employer is the exposure the category view hides: in a category table it disappears into commercial revenue, but its plan pays better than any other commercial contract, and its future depends on one company's decisions about one operation.

What this page is doingConcentration is measured against the parties who set prices, which exposes the single employer a category table would bury inside commercial revenue.
3

The Direction the Mix Is Already Traveling

The service area is modeled on Grant County, New Mexico, and its age structure explains where the mix is heading. In the American Community Survey for 2020 to 2024, 30.3% of the county's residents were 65 or older and 13.0% were 75 or older, compared with 19.3% of New Mexico's population and 17.2% of the nation's (U.S. Census Bureau, 2025). A population that old will move revenue toward Medicare as residents age out of employer coverage, and within Medicare, toward Medicare Advantage: slightly more than half of eligible beneficiaries nationally were enrolled in Medicare Advantage plans in 2024 (Freed et al., 2024). Each shift moves revenue from counterparties that negotiate with Pinon Valley toward counterparties that set prices by rule or that hold considerable bargaining power of their own.

The consequence is structural. National profitability research links a heavier Medicare load to weaker hospital results (Bai & Anderson, 2016), and Pinon Valley's load is rising with the age of its neighbors, not with any decision it has made.

Where the System Has Choices

Treating the mix as entirely external would miss what Pinon Valley controls. It chooses which Medicare Advantage contracts to sign and on what terms; plan A's contract allows prior authorization denials that cost the system an estimated $1.1 million last year, and the renewal in 14 months is a real decision. It chooses its charity care and discount policy, which sets the self-pay line. It chooses which services it offers and where, and some services, such as orthopedic surgery and imaging, attract commercially insured patients who would otherwise travel to a metropolitan system. And its critical access hospital's cost-based Medicare payment, set at 101% of reasonable costs under federal rules (Payment for Services of a CAH, 2024), rewards accurate cost reporting in ways that are within the system's control.

Exposure Ranked

Ranked by how much revenue a single decision could move and how little warning the system would get, the exposures are, first, the largest employer's self-funded plan: 9% of revenue at the best commercial rates, dependent on one operation that could close or change its health plan with a year's notice or less. Second, the state Medicaid rates, 22% of revenue set in each legislative session, with rates exposed whenever the state budget tightens. Third, the largest commercial contract, 14% of revenue renegotiated on a fixed date. Traditional Medicare, although the largest share, ranks fourth, because its changes arrive through published rules with months of notice and because cost-based payment protects the critical access hospital. The employer's plan is carried forward as the scenario for the stress test later in this course.

What the Board Should Watch

Each ranked exposure has an early signal the board can follow without waiting for a budget variance. For the employer's plan, the signal is the employer's own public filings and announcements about the operation, together with the plan's monthly covered lives, which the third-party administrator reports; a fall of more than 10% in covered lives in a quarter should trigger the stress test's response plan. For Medicaid, the signal is the state budget calendar: the governor's proposed budget each January shows whether provider rates are at risk months before they change. For the largest commercial contract, the signal is the insurer's opening position, which typically arrives about six months before renewal.

The board should also track the mix itself on remitted revenue each quarter, by counterparty, beside the category table it now receives. The category table will keep describing a system that looks diversified, with revenue spread across Medicare, Medicaid and commercial payers. The counterparty table describes a system in which four decisions, made by four organizations Pinon Valley does not control, set the terms on nearly three-quarters of its income, and that is the version the board needs to govern.

References

Bai, G., & Anderson, G. F. (2016). A more detailed understanding of factors associated with hospital profitability. Health Affairs, 35(5), 889-897. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2015.1193

Freed, M., Biniek, J. F., Damico, A., & Neuman, T. (2024, August 8). Medicare Advantage in 2024: Enrollment update and key trends. KFF. https://www.kff.org/medicare/issue-brief/medicare-advantage-in-2024-enrollment-update-and-key-trends/

Payment for Services of a CAH, 42 C.F.R. ยง 413.70 (2024).

U.S. Census Bureau. (2025). American Community Survey 5-year estimates, 2020-2024 [Data set]. https://data.census.gov/

The HCA-827 Topic 3 assignment instructions

HCA-827 Topic 3 asks doctoral learners to analyze how their organization's payer mix affects its sustainability. Papers often rank payers by margin or report mix from gross charges. The assignment rewards studies that measure mix on remitted revenue and attach each share to the party that fixes its price, such as a federal program, a state legislature, a contracted insurer or a single employer. Learners should measure concentration by counterparty, use sourced demographic data to show where the mix is heading, identify the organization's own choices and rank exposures with signals the board can watch. Figures for the service area's age structure should carry the survey name and years.

How the HCA-827 Topic 3 example is put together

In the finished study the mix is a statement about who sets the terms, not a table of margins by payer. Each share of revenue is attached to the party that fixes its price: a federal rate somebody else revises, a state legislature working inside its own budget, a commercial agreement with a renewal date, a single large employer whose plant could close. Concentration is measured against those counterparties instead of against payer categories, which is why two organizations with identical category shares can carry very different risk. The age structure and employment base of the service area supply the direction the mix is already traveling. Services the organization cannot decline usually sit in the worst part of the map, and the study says so plainly.

HCA 827 Topic 3 rubric: what Excellent looks like

GCU's rubric for the exposure study rewards counterparties over categories. Excellent studies explain why remitted revenue gives a truer mix than charges and show concentration by who sets prices. Credit goes to identifying a single employer or contract hidden inside a category and to demographic projections tied to a named, dated source. The rubric values acknowledging choices the organization controls, such as contracts signed and services offered. The highest level ranks exposures by how much revenue one decision could move and how much warning the organization would have. Studies built on gross charges, or that treat the mix as entirely beyond the organization's control, lose marks.

HCA 827 Topic 3 help before you submit

A reader working this rubric wants exposure and will not accept a profitability ranking in its place. Studies that sort payers by margin and stop have described this year's earnings and said nothing about what happens when one of those payers changes its mind. A mix built from gross charges rather than from what was remitted overstates every category that discounts heavily. Category level concentration with no counterparty behind it conceals the single employer or single agreement the organization actually depends on. Projections offered with no source or date behind the population figures cannot be argued with. Treating mix as entirely outside management control excuses the writer from the assignment, and treating it as a dial leadership can turn forgets which party holds the pen.

Get an HCA-827 Topic 3 example written to your instructions

Send us the HCA-827 Topic 3 instructions, the rubric in your classroom and whatever the assignment tells you about the organization and its service area. We write a custom example against those criteria, with each share tied to the party that sets its terms, concentration measured by counterparty and the moveable portion separated out, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More HCA 827 papers and DHA samples

HCA 827 Topic 3 questions, answered

Is a favorable payer mix a sustainable one?

Not on its own, and the distinction carries this topic. A mix weighted toward well paying commercial agreements can rest on one employer, which makes it profitable and fragile at the same moment. Durability asks what happens when a counterparty leaves, so a slightly poorer mix spread across many payers can outlast a richer one that depends on few.

What if I have no access to remittance data?

Work from what the assignment supplies and say where a real figure would come from. Filed cost reports, audited statements and published state releases carry category shares for many organizations. Where you have to estimate, name the source you would use and hold that estimate steady wherever it appears, since a share drifting between sections cannot be checked by anybody.

How far out can a mix projection be defended?

As far as the demographic evidence reaches and no further. Age structure moves slowly and can be projected with some confidence, while employment concentrated in one industry can change inside a single year. A study projecting both at the same confidence has overstated one of them, and naming the weaker leg is what a doctoral reader is looking for.

Where can I find a free HCA 827 Topic 3 sample paper?

This page contains the full study, with mix on remitted revenue, a counterparty table, the direction of travel, the system's choices, ranked exposures and what the board should watch. Describe your payers for a free worked study.

Which exposure ranks first in HCA 827 Topic 3?

The largest employer's self-funded plan. It supplies 9 percent of revenue at the best commercial rates and depends on one operation that could close or change its plan with little notice, so it carries forward into the stress test.