| Course | HCA 827 Sustainability of Health Care Organizations |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Turnover cost analysis |
| Length | About 970 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | Doctor of Health Administration (DHA) |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 827 Topic 4
Finance Counts $660,000; the Full Cost Is Nearer $4.6 Million: A Nurse Turnover Cost Analysis From Pinon Valley Regional Medical Center's Own Records
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
HCA-827: Sustainability of Health Care Organizations
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Finance Counts $660,000; the Full Cost Is Nearer $4.6 Million: A Nurse Turnover Cost Analysis From Pinon Valley Regional Medical Center's Own Records
Why Not the National Figure
Trade reports publish an average cost of replacing a bedside registered nurse, and the figure circulates in board presentations as though it described every hospital. It describes none in particular. It hides where the money goes, and it cannot tell Pinon Valley Regional Medical Center which part of the cost it could reduce. This analysis builds the cost instead from the hospital's own records for the last fiscal year, following the logic of the Nursing Turnover Cost Calculation Methodology, which divides turnover costs into those incurred before a replacement is hired, such as advertising, recruiting and vacancy coverage, and those incurred after, such as orientation, training and lost productivity (Jones, 2005). The facts: the hospital employs 418 registered nurses, 79 left last year, a turnover rate of 18.9%, and 64 of the positions were filled during the year.
Costs the Budget Already Shows
Table 1
Recorded Costs of Replacing One Registered Nurse
| Cost per replacement hire | Amount | Source in the hospital's records |
|---|---|---|
| Advertising, recruiter time and background checks | $3,900 | Human resources cost center |
| Sign-on incentives: $10,000 paid to 41 of 64 hires | $6,406 average | Payroll |
| Orientation hours paid but not yet productive: 12 weeks for 26 new graduates, 6 weeks for 38 experienced nurses | $15,543 average | Education department schedules, wage and benefit rates |
| Preceptor time lost to supervision, at a quarter of preceptor hours during orientation | $4,471 average | Education department estimate |
| Subtotal | $30,320 |
The finance department's turnover figure includes only the first two rows, $10,306 a hire, or about $660,000 for the year. Orientation and preceptor costs appear in the budget but are charged to education and to nursing units, so nobody adds them to turnover. They are the larger part of the recorded cost.
Costs No Ledger Records
Two further costs belong to each vacancy and appear in no account labeled turnover. The first is agency coverage. Vacancies stayed open an average of 94 days last year, and about 70% of the vacant shifts were covered by agency nurses, at an average billed rate of $104 an hour against a fully loaded employed nurse cost of $49.28. Over 94 days of a 36-hour position, that premium comes to about $18,500 per vacancy. The second is overtime absorbed by the nurses who stayed, covering most of the remaining vacant shifts at time and a half, about $2,900 per vacancy in premium pay alone. Together the unrecorded costs add about $21,400 to each separation, and they are paid whether or not the position is ever filled. Adding the recorded and unrecorded costs gives about $51,700 per separation, or about $4.09 million for 79 separations.
The Second Resignation
Resignations are not independent. The hospital's 22 nursing units show a pattern over the last three years: in a quarter after a unit loses a nurse, the chance it loses another within 90 days is 41%, against 24% for units that lost nobody. The mechanism is visible in the overtime records, since the nurses who absorb a vacancy's shifts are the ones who leave next. Applied to last year's separations, the pattern implies about nine resignations that would probably not have happened without an earlier one, adding roughly $465,000. The full cost of last year's turnover is therefore about $4.6 million, seven times the figure finance reports.
Bae (2022), reviewing studies of nurse turnover in acute hospitals, found that nearly every study measuring cost found turnover very costly, and that the evidence on its noneconomic effects, on workload, nurse outcomes and patient outcomes, was supportive though less consistent. The compounding pattern at Pinon Valley is one of those noneconomic effects turning back into an economic one.
How Firm the Figures Are
Not every figure in the analysis is equally firm, and the board should know which carry the result. Recruiting costs, sign-on payments, wage rates and agency invoices come straight from ledgers. Orientation length comes from the education department's schedules, which record what was planned rather than what happened, and some new graduates took longer. The preceptor share of one quarter is an estimate from the education department and could reasonably be anywhere from a fifth to a third. The compounding estimate rests on three years of unit data, enough to show a pattern but not to prove that each second resignation was caused by the first. Removing the compounding estimate entirely leaves a cost of about $4.1 million, and halving the preceptor share lowers it by about $140,000 more. Under any reasonable set of assumptions, the full cost is at least six times the figure finance currently reports, which is the conclusion the board needs.
What the Figure Changes
A turnover cost of $4.6 million changes the arithmetic of retention. Reducing turnover from 18.9% to 14%, about 20 fewer separations a year, would save roughly $1.03 million in direct and vacancy costs, plus some share of the compounding. That sum could fund, for example, a night-shift differential increase and a guaranteed-schedule program together costing about $800,000 a year, and still leave a return. Under the workforce standard adopted in the first topic of this course, the analysis also changes what counts as a financial priority: retention spending is not a benefit competing with the margin target in the previous topic, but one of its sources, since replacing agency nurses with employed ones was already counted there as a $3 million contribution.
Jones (2008) showed how a hospital can carry a baseline turnover cost forward with a price index when it cannot repeat the full calculation every year. Pinon Valley should do the full calculation once, as here, and update it annually with the index between full recalculations, so that the board sees a derived figure instead of a national one.
References
Bae, S.-H. (2022). Noneconomic and economic impacts of nurse turnover in hospitals: A systematic review. International Nursing Review, 69(3), 392-404. https://doi.org/10.1111/inr.12769
Jones, C. B. (2005). The costs of nurse turnover, part 2: Application of the Nursing Turnover Cost Calculation Methodology. Journal of Nursing Administration, 35(1), 41-49. https://doi.org/10.1097/00005110-200501000-00014
Jones, C. B. (2008). Revisiting nurse turnover costs: Adjusting for inflation. Journal of Nursing Administration, 38(1), 11-18. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.NNA.0000295636.03216.6f
The HCA-827 Topic 4 assignment instructions
The Topic 4 instructions in HCA-827 ask doctoral learners to estimate the cost of workforce turnover for their organization. Many analyses quote a national average replacement cost or count only recruiting expenses. The assignment rewards analyses built from the organization's own records, separating costs before and after hiring and including those no ledger labels as turnover, such as agency coverage during vacancies and overtime absorbed by remaining staff. Learners should examine whether resignations compound, state how firm each figure is and show what the result changes about retention decisions. A sensitivity check on the least certain estimates, such as preceptor time, shows the reader which figures carry the result.
Inside the HCA 827 Topic 4 example
What the completed analysis does first is refuse the single replacement figure that circulates in trade coverage, because it conceals where the money actually goes. The cost is built from the organization's own records instead: posting and recruiting spend, sign-on incentives, the orientation weeks a new hire is paid for but not yet productive, and the preceptor hours taken off the schedule to supervise them. Then it prices what no ledger records. Agency coverage bought at a premium while a post sits open, overtime absorbed by the nurses who stayed, and the second resignation that follows the first are all costs of the same vacancy, and the analysis says so with its reasoning shown. It closes on what a retention spend would have to achieve to be worth making.
Reading the HCA 827 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty grading the turnover analysis reward local derivation. Excellent analyses use a recognized costing method and the organization's own figures, explaining why a national average cannot guide a local decision. Credit goes to pricing vacancy costs such as agency premium and absorbed overtime, which usually outweigh recruiting costs. The rubric values evidence of compounding resignations and a sensitivity check on the least certain estimates. The highest level converts the total into a retention decision the committee can make, rather than describing turnover as a morale problem. Analyses that stop at costs already in the budget, or quote a national figure as local, generally score lower.
Common HCA 827 Topic 4 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Nearly every mark surrendered here goes to one of two habits. The first is quoting a national replacement cost per nurse and treating it as this organization's number, which hands a finance committee a figure with no derivation and no local reference behind it. The second is stopping at the costs that already appear in a budget, which understates the total by omitting the agency premium and the absorbed overtime that make up the larger share of it. Treating a resignation that follows another resignation as unrelated misses the compounding the topic exists to show. Submissions describing turnover as a morale problem without pricing it have written about a different subject, and those that price it without naming a retention alternative leave the committee nothing to approve.
Get an HCA-827 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-827 Topic 4 instructions, your section rubric and any staffing or financial material the assignment supplies. We write a custom example against those criteria, with the boundary fixed, budgeted and unbudgeted costs separated, and the retention spend judged against the annual total, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HCA 827 papers and DHA samples
- HCA 827 Topic 1: Sustainability Definition Comparison
- HCA 827 Topic 2: Reinvestment Margin Memo
- HCA 827 Topic 3: Payer Mix Exposure Study
- HCA 827 Topic 5: Reduction Sequence Response
- HCA 827 Topic 6: Community Standing Analysis
- HCA 827 Topic 7: Adverse Scenario Stress Test
- HCA 827 Topic 8: Ten-year Position Defense
- HCA 812 Topic 4: Breach Notification Analysis
- HCA 822 Topic 4: Hiring and Purchasing Footprint Analysis
- HCA 817 Topic 4: Informal Authority Trace
HCA 827 Topic 4 questions, answered
Why not use a published replacement cost figure?
Because a committee will ask where it came from and the paper has no answer. A published figure averages organizations with different wage scales, different vacancy durations and different agency contracts. Building the cost from local recruiting spend, orientation length and agency rates produces a smaller looking number that survives questioning, which is the one worth having.
Which turnover costs are hardest to defend?
The consequential ones, and they are also the largest. Agency premium is documented and easy to evidence. Absorbed overtime takes a little work. The resignation that follows the first is real but arguable, so a strong example states the mechanism, shows the timing in the unit's own separation record, and marks the figure as an estimate rather than as something measured.
Does the analysis have to recommend a retention program?
It has to give the reader something to decide. An annual cost with no alternative beside it leaves a committee informed and idle. The recommendation need not be a formal program: a change to scheduling, orientation length or preceptor load counts, provided the paper says what it would cost and what share of the turnover it would have to prevent.
Where can I find a free HCA 827 Topic 4 sample paper?
The whole analysis appears here, with why not the national figure, recorded costs per hire, unrecorded vacancy costs, the second resignation, how firm the figures are and what the result changes. Send your turnover data for a free worked analysis.
What does finance miss in HCA 827 Topic 4?
Finance counts recruiting and sign-on payments, about $10,300 a hire. It misses orientation and preceptor time charged elsewhere, agency premium and overtime during 94-day vacancies, and resignations that follow earlier ones.