| Course | HIM 200 Principles and Practices of Health Information Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Legal record boundary memo |
| Length | About 810 words, 2 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Health Information Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HIM 200 Topic 2
Memorandum
To: Release of Information Staff and Privacy Officer, Ocotillo Regional Hospital
From: [Author Name], Health Information Management Supervisor
Date: [Date]
Re: What belongs to the legal health record, the designated record set, and neither
Why Three Groups, Not One
Our electronic system stores far more than the record we disclose in response to a subpoena or produce for a patient. Treating everything in the system as the record would lead us to release drafts, audit data and other providers' records in response to requests that never reached them. Treating the patient's access right as limited to the legal record would quietly narrow what patients are entitled to see. This memo sorts stored material into three groups and places ten common items, so that staff can apply the same reasoning to the next item they meet.
The Three Groups
The legal health record is the record Ocotillo has formally designated as its business record of care, the record it produces when legally required to disclose and attests to as complete. The designation is an internal decision, adopted by our health information committee in 2023 and documented in policy HIM-104. Professional guidance recommends that each organization define its legal health record in writing precisely because no federal rule defines it (AHIMA, 2011).
The designated record set is a HIPAA term. It includes a provider's medical records and billing records about individuals, and anything else the provider relied on, even partly, when deciding something about a person (Definitions, 2024). Its importance is that patients have a right to inspect and obtain copies of information in it, with limited exceptions such as psychotherapy notes (Access of Individuals to Protected Health Information, 2024). The two groups overlap heavily but are not identical: billing records are in the designated record set but not our legal health record.
The third group is everything else the system stores: working drafts, system data and administrative records. Some of it can still be reached in litigation through discovery, but it is neither disclosed as the record nor subject to the patient's access right.
Ten Items Placed
Table 1
Placement of Stored Material
| Item | Legal health record | Designated record set | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Signed physician progress note | Yes | Yes | Authenticated documentation of care |
| Itemized bill and claim history | No | Yes | Billing records are named in the HIPAA definition |
| Unsigned draft note | No | No | Not yet an entry; not used to make decisions until signed |
| Audit trail of who viewed the record | No | No | System security data, available through discovery if relevant |
| Incident report on a patient fall | No | No | Administrative and quality record, reported to our patient safety organization |
| Outside hospital records faxed and reviewed by the admitting physician | Yes, by Ocotillo's designation | Yes | Used to make care decisions |
| Outside records received but never reviewed | No | No | Not used in care; held in a separate queue |
| Patient portal message asking about a medication | Yes | Yes | Clinical communication our policy designates |
| Psychotherapy notes kept separately by a psychologist | No | Excluded from access right | Specifically excepted from patient access |
| Fetal monitoring strips | Yes | Yes | Documentation of care, retained on their own schedule |
The incident report deserves a note. At Ocotillo, incident reports are submitted to a patient safety organization, which gives them the privilege and confidentiality protections of patient safety work product under federal law (Patient Safety and Quality Improvement Act of 2005, 2005). Filing a copy of an incident report in the chart would put that protection at risk, which is why the policy forbids it.
The Two Errors to Avoid
The first error is over-disclosure. When an attorney's subpoena asks for "the complete medical record," staff produce the legal health record and certify it; they do not produce audit trails, drafts or incident reports, which require a separate, specific legal demand reviewed by the privacy officer. The second error is under-disclosure. When a patient requests a copy of their records, staff must include billing records and anything else relied on in deciding the patient's care or coverage, even though billing records are not part of the legal health record. A patient's access request is measured against the designated record set, not the legal record, and the timelines and fee limits of the access right apply.
When an Item Is Not on the List
Staff who meet an item not in Table 1 should ask three questions in order. Is it an authenticated entry documenting care that policy HIM-104 designates? If so, it belongs to the legal health record. Did anyone at Ocotillo rely on it, even partly, to decide something about the patient, or is it a billing record? If so, it belongs to the designated record set. If neither, it belongs to the third group, and any request for it goes to the privacy officer. Oachs and Watters (2020) note that as electronic systems expand, the boundary of the record must be managed deliberately rather than inferred from what the system happens to store, and these three questions are how that boundary is managed at the release window.
References
Access of Individuals to Protected Health Information, 45 C.F.R. § 164.524 (2024).
AHIMA. (2011). Fundamentals of the legal health record and designated record set. Journal of AHIMA, 82(2).
Definitions, 45 C.F.R. § 164.501 (2024).
Oachs, P. K., & Watters, A. L. (Eds.). (2020). Health information management: Concepts, principles, and practice (6th ed.). AHIMA Press.
Patient Safety and Quality Improvement Act of 2005, Pub. L. No. 109-41, 119 Stat. 424 (2005).
Reading the GCU HIM 200 Topic 2 instructions
The Topic 2 instructions in HIM-200 ask students to distinguish the legal health record from other information an organization holds. Papers often treat everything in the electronic system as the legal record or equate the legal record with the designated record set. The assignment rewards memos that start from the organization's formal designation, explain the designated record set as a HIPAA concept tied to the patient's access right, and place a realistic range of items, including drafts, audit trails, incident reports and outside records, with a reason for each. Students should show the practical consequences of placing items wrongly and give staff a way to handle items the memo does not list.
Inside the HIM 200 Topic 2 example
This memo classifies stored material for a reader who must apply the result. It begins with the designation the organization has formally adopted for its legal health record, because that designation is an internal decision the organization makes and documents. It then takes a realistic spread of items, such as signed notes, billing records, draft entries, audit trails, incident reports, faxed outside records and patient portal messages, and places each one. The designated record set is explained as a HIPAA term tied to the individual's rights of access and amendment, which is why it usually runs wider than the legal record. Items outside both are named rather than ignored. The memo ends on the practical consequence: which set answers a subpoena, and which answers a patient asking for a copy.
Reading the HIM 200 Topic 2 rubric
Faculty grading the boundary memo reward placements a clerk could apply. Excellent memos separate the organization's legal record designation from the regulatory designated record set and explain why billing records belong to one and not the other. Credit goes to giving a reason with each placement, including protections for patient safety work product and the exclusion of psychotherapy notes from access. The rubric values explaining how over-disclosure and under-disclosure happen in practice. The highest level supplies a short decision sequence for new items, so the reasoning outlasts the table. Memos that equate everything in the system with the record usually lose marks.
HIM 200 Topic 2 help: mistakes that cost marks
Where this memo usually falls down is in treating the three groups as one. Writers who describe everything in the electronic system as the legal record set the organization up to over-disclose, releasing drafts, audit data or another provider's records in response to a request that never reached them. The reverse error, defining the designated record set as identical to the legal record, quietly narrows what a patient is entitled to see. Placements given without a reason cannot be applied to the next item that arrives. A memo that never mentions the organization's formal designation has invented a boundary the organization did not draw. Leaving the hard cases undecided hands the decision to whoever is working the release desk that afternoon.
Get an HIM-200 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the HIM-200 Topic 2 instructions, your classroom rubric and the organization, record items or request scenario you were assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the designation quoted, every stored item placed with a reason, the hard cases decided and each set matched to a request, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HIM 200 papers and BS in Health Information Management samples
- HIM 200 Topic 1: Record Content Requirements Analysis
- HIM 200 Topic 3: Retention Schedule Analysis
- HIM 200 Topic 4: Release of Information Case Review
- HIM 200 Topic 5: Defensible Entry Discussion
- HIM 200 Topic 6: Records Profession Role Survey
- HIM 200 Topic 7: Record Completeness Audit
- HIM 200 Topic 8: Plain Language Records Policy
- HIM 310 Topic 2: Diagnosis Hierarchy Analysis
- HIM 490 Topic 2: Baseline Measurement Report
- HIM 350 Topic 2: Index to Tabular Verification
- HIM 452 Topic 2: Abstraction Judgment Log
HIM 200 Topic 2 questions, answered
Why is the designated record set usually larger?
Because HIPAA defines it by what a record is used for rather than by where it lives. Medical and billing records, and any other records used to make decisions about the individual, fall inside it. The legal health record is the organization's own business record of care, chosen for evidentiary purposes, and many organizations keep billing material out of it. The two overlap heavily without being the same thing.
Are audit trails part of the legal record?
Organizations answer that differently, which is why the memo quotes its own organization's designation instead of assuming. Audit trails are usually kept outside the legal health record and produced only when a court or an investigation specifically asks for them, but a policy can say otherwise. The defensible position is the one written down and applied consistently, not the one that seems obvious to the writer.
What about records sent from another provider?
They are a genuine hard case. Some organizations fold outside records into their own record once clinicians rely on them for treatment; others keep them separate and refer a requester back to the provider that created them. The memo states the rule its organization follows and the reason, since a release clerk facing a stack of faxed pages needs an answer rather than a range of views.
Where can I find a free HIM 200 Topic 2 sample paper?
The complete boundary memo is on this page, with why three groups, the definitions, ten items placed in a table, the two errors to avoid and what to do with an item not on the list. Request a free model memo for your facility.
Why are billing records in only one group in HIM 200 Topic 2?
HIPAA names billing records in the designated record set, so patients can see them, but the hospital's legal health record designation covers documentation of care, so billing records are not produced as the legal record.