| Course | HIM 350 Classification of Diagnostic Data |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Audit response letter |
| Length | About 690 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Letter with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Health Information Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HIM 350 Topic 8
Canyon Rim Hospital
Health Information Management Department
[Address]
[Date]
Clinical Coding Review Unit
[Reviewer organization]
[Address]
Dear Reviewer:
This letter responds to your review of the inpatient claim for patient account 40718, a 76-year-old admitted with a hip fracture after a fall. Your review disputed three secondary diagnoses. We respond to each finding in order. We contest the first two, on grounds of both coding validation and clinical validation, and we accept the third.
Finding 1: Severe Protein-Calorie Malnutrition
Your review states that severe protein-calorie malnutrition is not supported. We respectfully disagree, on two separate grounds.
Coding validation. The attending physician documented "severe protein-calorie malnutrition" in progress notes on hospital days two, three and five and in the discharge summary. The official guidelines state that code assignment is based on the provider's diagnostic statement that the condition exists, and that it is not based on clinical criteria used by the provider to establish the diagnosis (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services & National Center for Health Statistics, 2025). The condition also meets the criteria for an additional diagnosis: it was evaluated by the registered dietitian on day two and again on day four, and treated with an oral nutritional supplement three times daily and a calorie count.
Clinical validation. We recognize that your review may also question whether the diagnosis is clinically supported, which is a separate question from coding. The dietitian's assessment documents an unintended weight loss of 9% over the previous three months, an estimated energy intake below 75% of requirements for more than a month before admission, and severe loss of muscle mass at the temples and shoulders on examination. Under the consensus characteristics for adult malnutrition in the context of chronic illness, a weight loss of more than 7.5% in three months, intake at or below 75% of requirements for a month or more, and severe muscle loss each support a finding of severe malnutrition, with at least two characteristics recommended for the diagnosis (White et al., 2012). The record shows three. We ask that the finding be reversed.
Finding 2: Acute Kidney Injury
Your review states that acute kidney injury is not clinically supported because the patient's creatinine never exceeded 1.6 mg/dL. The provider documented acute kidney injury on day three and in the discharge summary. The patient's baseline creatinine, from an outpatient visit six weeks before admission, was 1.0 mg/dL, and it rose to 1.6 mg/dL within 48 hours of surgery. The international clinical practice guideline defines acute kidney injury by an increase in serum creatinine of at least 0.3 mg/dL within 48 hours, or to at least 1.5 times baseline within seven days (Kidney Disease: Improving Global Outcomes Acute Kidney Injury Work Group, 2012). The rise of 0.6 mg/dL, to 1.6 times baseline, meets both criteria. The absolute value is not the test; the change from baseline is. The condition was treated: the patient's nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medication was stopped, intravenous fluids were adjusted and creatinine was measured daily until it returned to 1.1 mg/dL. We ask that the finding be reversed.
Finding 3: Long-Term Use of Insulin
Your review states that the code for long-term current use of insulin is not supported. We agree. The patient's diabetes was treated with oral medication at home; insulin was given only on a sliding scale during the stay, which does not represent long-term use. The code was assigned in error, and we have corrected the claim and will submit it as a corrected claim within the timeframe your letter specifies. The coder involved has reviewed the guideline on status codes for medication use, and our next monthly internal audit will sample records with this code.
Summary
In summary, we request reversal of Findings 1 and 2, each supported by the provider's diagnostic statements, by treatment meeting the criteria for an additional diagnosis and by clinical indicators that meet recognized criteria. We accept Finding 3 and have corrected the claim. Copies of the progress notes, dietitian assessments, laboratory results and medication administration records cited above are enclosed and indexed by finding. If you would like to discuss any finding, please contact me at the address above.
Sincerely,
[Author Name], RHIA
Coding Compliance Manager, Canyon Rim Hospital
References
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services & National Center for Health Statistics. (2025). ICD-10-CM official guidelines for coding and reporting FY 2025.
Kidney Disease: Improving Global Outcomes Acute Kidney Injury Work Group. (2012). KDIGO clinical practice guideline for acute kidney injury. Kidney International Supplements, 2(1), 1-138.
White, J. V., Guenter, P., Jensen, G., Malone, A., Schofield, M., Academy Malnutrition Work Group, A.S.P.E.N. Malnutrition Task Force, & A.S.P.E.N. Board of Directors. (2012). Consensus statement: Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics and American Society for Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition: Characteristics recommended for the identification and documentation of adult malnutrition (undernutrition). Journal of Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition, 36(3), 275-283. https://doi.org/10.1177/0148607112440285
What the HIM 350 Topic 8 instructions ask for
The final topic of HIM-350 asks students to respond to an external review that disputes diagnosis codes. Many responses contest every finding or argue in general terms. The assignment rewards letters organized finding by finding, written for a reviewer who knows the guidelines, that quote the provider's diagnostic statements, show the treatment that makes each condition reportable and separate coding validation from clinical validation. Students should support clinical validation with recognized criteria, concede findings the record does not support, describe the correction and follow-up, and list the documentation enclosed for each finding.
How this HIM 350 Topic 8 example is built
The finished defense is a response letter organized by finding, written to a reviewer who knows the guidelines. The first finding disputes a secondary diagnosis of severe protein-calorie malnutrition. The defense quotes the provider's diagnostic statements from the progress notes and discharge summary, sets out the dietitian's documented intake and weight history, and shows the treatment that satisfies the criteria for a secondary diagnosis. It separates coding validation from clinical validation, citing the guideline that code assignment rests on the provider's statement, and then answers the clinical question with indicators from the chart rather than with that guideline alone. The second finding, that a symptom was placed first although the discharge summary names its cause, is conceded, and the corrected sequence is shown. The letter ends with a request for reconsideration limited to the point it can support.
Where the marks sit in the HIM 350 Topic 8 rubric
GCU's rubric for the audit defense rewards evidence organized by finding. Excellent letters cite the guideline that code assignment follows the provider's diagnostic statement, then address clinical validation separately with published criteria. Credit goes to precise clinical indicators, such as weight loss percentages and creatinine change from baseline. The rubric values conceding an unsupported finding and describing the corrective action, since a defense that contests everything reads as reflex. The highest level gives the reviewer an indexed set of documents and a clear request for each finding.
HIM 350 Topic 8 help: mistakes that cost marks
Defenses lose marks by arguing every finding with equal force. A reviewer reading a letter that contests a finding the record plainly supports stops trusting the rest of it, so the honest concession is part of the grade. Answering a clinical validation challenge only with the guideline on provider statements misses the question asked, since the reviewer has already seen the statement and doubts it. Letters that quote the guidelines at length and the chart hardly at all argue in the abstract about a specific claim. Supporting phrases given without author and date force the reviewer to search, and an unverifiable quotation carries little weight. Some drafts cite a query response as proof of a diagnosis without showing that the query was worded neutrally, which invites a second finding about the query itself.
Get an HIM-350 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the HIM-350 Topic 8 instructions, your classroom rubric and the audit findings, record or scenario you were given. We write a custom example to those criteria, with each finding quoted, the documentation attributed, coding and clinical validation argued separately and any unsupported point conceded, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HIM 350 papers and BS in Health Information Management samples
- HIM 350 Topic 1: Coding Conventions Analysis
- HIM 350 Topic 2: Index to Tabular Verification
- HIM 350 Topic 3: Combination Code Analysis
- HIM 350 Topic 4: Principal Diagnosis Selection Paper
- HIM 350 Topic 5: Physician Query Discussion
- HIM 350 Topic 6: Uncertain Diagnosis Coding Comparison
- HIM 350 Topic 7: Diagnosis Sequencing Rationale
- HIM 355 Topic 8: Procedure Code Audit Rebuttal
- HIM 310 Topic 8: Classification Choice Defense
- HIM 370 Topic 8: Installed System Evaluation
- HIM 200 Topic 8: Plain Language Records Policy
HIM 350 Topic 8 questions, answered
What separates coding validation from clinical validation?
Coding validation asks whether the codes match what the provider documented and whether the guidelines were followed in assigning and sequencing them. Clinical validation asks whether the documented diagnosis is supported by the clinical picture at all. The official guidelines say code assignment rests on the provider's statement, but a reviewer questioning validity is asking something else, so the example answers each question on its own terms.
Should a defense ever concede a finding?
Yes, when the record supports the reviewer. A defense that contests everything reads as reflex, and the reviewer judges its strong arguments by the company they keep. Conceding the weak point and correcting it shows an organization that reads its own records carefully, which strengthens the appeal where the chart holds. Even where an assignment demands a full rebuttal, the example still flags any finding the documentation cannot answer.
Is this example professional advice for a real audit?
No. The letter is a classroom exercise built on published coding guidance, a composite claim and a composite review. Real audit responses follow the payer's process, its deadlines and the organization's own policy, and they are prepared by the facility's coding staff. What the example demonstrates is the reasoning a reviewer expects to see: findings quoted, documentation attributed, guidelines named and conclusions limited to what the record supports.
Where can I find a free HIM 350 Topic 8 sample paper?
This page holds the complete defense letter, with the malnutrition finding contested on coding and clinical grounds, the kidney injury finding contested, the insulin finding conceded and the summary. Tell us your audit findings for a free worked response.
Why does the letter concede one finding in HIM 350 Topic 8?
The patient took oral diabetes medication at home and received only sliding-scale insulin in the hospital, which is not long-term use, so the code was wrong and the claim is corrected.