| Course | HIM 490 Health Information Management Capstone |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Implementability options matrix |
| Length | About 1,020 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Health Information Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HIM 490 Topic 4
Four Ways to Clear a Scanning Backlog, Judged on Whether Saltbush Can Actually Do Them: An Implementability Options Matrix
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HIM-490: Health Information Management Capstone
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Four Ways to Clear a Scanning Backlog, Judged on Whether Saltbush Can Actually Do Them: An Implementability Options Matrix
The Problem the Options Address
Saltbush Regional Medical Center receives about 2,600 paper and faxed documents a week that must become part of patients' electronic records: outside hospital records, results from reference laboratories, signed consent forms and records from physicians' offices. The HIM department scans and indexes them, but the backlog has grown to about nine days. Documents that sit unscanned are invisible to clinicians. Kripalani et al. (2007) found that information from one setting often failed to reach physicians in the next, and at Saltbush the backlog means that an outside echocardiogram faxed on Monday may not appear in the record until the following week. Federal participation rules require records to be retained in original or legally reproduced form and to be accessible (Condition of Participation: Medical Record Services, 2024), and a nine-day delay in filing strains that obligation.
Four options survived the capstone's constraint analysis. This matrix judges each on implementability: not whether it would work in principle, but whether Saltbush can put it in place with the authority, money and systems it has.
The Matrix
Table 1
Options Judged on Implementability
| Criterion | A. Two more HIM scanning staff | B. Point-of-care scanning by clinical units | C. Contracted scanning vendor | D. Electronic intake queue for faxes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Whose authority is needed | HIM director and finance: within HIM's authority to request | Chief nursing officer and unit managers: outside HIM's authority | HIM director, purchasing and privacy officer | HIM director and information technology change control |
| Which cost center pays | HIM, about $108,000 a year | Nursing units, in staff time they do not have | HIM, about $0.11 a page, about $15,000 a year for overflow | Information technology, about $30,000 one time; license already owned |
| Systems change required | None | Scanners on every unit; training | Secure transfer and indexing interface | Configure the existing fax server to route to an indexing queue |
| Time to implement | Three to four months to hire | Six months or more | Two to three months to contract | Four to six weeks in the change control queue |
| Risk to record integrity | Low: trained indexers | High: indexing by staff for whom it is a side task | Moderate: documents leave the building | Low: documents never become paper |
| Effect on backlog | Clears it within about three months, then keeps pace | Uncertain | Clears it quickly; ongoing use optional | Removes about 60% of volume from scanning |
Reading the Cells
Option D stands out because about 60% of the documents arrive by fax. Today the fax server prints them, and HIM staff scan the paper back into electronic form, a round trip that adds a day and an opportunity for pages to be lost. Routing faxes directly into an indexing queue removes both. It needs only a configuration change using a license the hospital already owns, and its main obstacle is time in the information technology change control queue, which the capstone's timeline must account for.
Option B fails on authority and on integrity. The HIM department cannot direct nursing units to scan documents, and indexing is a skill: a document filed to the wrong patient is a privacy breach and a safety risk, and misfiling rates rise when indexing is a side task done between patient care duties. Ash et al. (2004) described how information systems can produce errors in the entry and retrieval of information, and a misindexed document is exactly such an error.
Option C is useful for clearing the backlog quickly but carries privacy review requirements, a business associate agreement and a secure transfer process, and it does not address the round trip that creates much of the volume. Option A is within HIM's authority but slow to hire and permanently expensive.
The Recommendation
The capstone recommends D as the core change, with C used once to clear the existing backlog while D is being configured, and A reduced to one position to handle the remaining paper documents at the current pace. Together they would bring filing time under two days within about ten weeks. The combination costs about $30,000 once for D, about $12,000 for C's one-time backlog work and about $54,000 a year for one position, far less than two permanent positions and without depending on nursing units. Option B is set aside.
The matrix changed the capstone's direction. The student's first proposal was Option A alone, because hiring is the most familiar answer to a backlog. Judging each option on who must approve it, who pays and what must change showed that the fastest, cheapest and safest option required only a configuration request, which the HIM director could submit the same week.
Why Implementability Rather Than Effectiveness
An effectiveness matrix would have ranked Option A and Option C near the top, because both add scanning capacity and both would clear the backlog. That ranking hides the questions a sponsor asks first: who signs, whose budget absorbs the cost and which system must change. Ogrinc et al. (2016) ask improvement reports to describe the context and the practical features of an intervention, because a change that works in one hospital fails in another when those features differ. At Saltbush the deciding context is that the HIM director controls one budget line and can submit configuration requests, but cannot direct nursing staff or add permanent positions without a finance review that runs on an annual cycle. Scoring options against that context, rather than against an ideal hospital, is what makes the recommendation one the director can act on this quarter.
Risks in the Recommended Path
The recommendation depends on the change control queue, which currently runs about five weeks for configuration requests. If the request waits longer, the backlog cleared by the vendor will begin to rebuild, and the capstone's timeline therefore places the request first and the vendor work second, so the vendor's cleanup finishes as the queue goes live. It also depends on indexers adapting to a screen-based queue. Two HIM staff will pilot the queue for two weeks before it takes all fax traffic, and their indexing accuracy will be audited daily during the pilot.
References
Ash, J. S., Berg, M., & Coiera, E. (2004). Some unintended consequences of information technology in health care: The nature of patient care information system-related errors. Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 11(2), 104-112. https://doi.org/10.1197/jamia.M1471
Condition of Participation: Medical Record Services, 42 C.F.R. ยง 482.24 (2024).
Kripalani, S., LeFevre, F., Phillips, C. O., Williams, M. V., Basaviah, P., & Baker, D. W. (2007). Deficits in communication and information transfer between hospital-based and primary care physicians: Implications for patient safety and continuity of care. JAMA, 297(8), 831-841. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.297.8.831
Ogrinc, G., Davies, L., Goodman, D., Batalden, P., Davidoff, F., & Stevens, D. (2016). SQUIRE 2.0 (Standards for QUality Improvement Reporting Excellence): Revised publication guidelines from a detailed consensus process. BMJ Quality & Safety, 25(12), 986-992. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjqs-2015-004411
HIM 490 Topic 4 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 4 instructions in HIM-490 ask students to compare possible solutions to the capstone problem. Weak papers rank options by how well they would work in an ideal organization. The assignment rewards matrices that judge each option on implementability: whose approval it needs, whose budget pays, what systems must change, how long it takes and what risks it carries for record integrity. Students should explain the reasoning in the cells rather than totaling scores, recommend an option or combination the department can actually pursue, state the risks in the recommended path and describe how the comparison changed their original plan.
Inside the HIM 490 Topic 4 example
The finished matrix places options in columns and implementability criteria in rows, with every cell carrying a short reason rather than a rating alone. Four options survive the constraint analysis: additional scanning staff in HIM, point-of-care scanning by clinical units, a contracted scanning vendor and an electronic intake queue that captures faxed documents for indexing. The criteria ask whose authority each needs, which cost center pays, whether it waits on an information technology build, how much staff time it consumes outside HIM and how long before the backlog would begin to fall. Ideal outcome appears as a row too, placed last and weighted least. The matrix shows that the most effective option depends on a build queue the department does not control, and the recommendation follows from that finding rather than from preference.
Reading the HIM 490 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty grading the options matrix reward realism about authority and cost. Excellent matrices name the approver and the paying cost center for every option and show why an option outside the department's authority fails regardless of merit. Credit goes to recognizing integrity risks, such as misindexing when scanning becomes a side task for clinical staff. The rubric values a recommendation grounded in the matrix, with costs and timing stated. The highest level shows how implementability changed the student's first instinct and plans around the dependencies of the chosen path. Matrices that score options on effectiveness alone usually lose marks.
Common HIM 490 Topic 4 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Matrices score poorly when options are compared on what they would achieve if everything went right. Ranking point-of-care scanning first because it would clear the backlog fastest ignores that clinical units never agreed to take on the work. Cells holding numbers with no reasons invite the question every panel asks, which is where that rating came from. Criteria left undefined allow the writer to rate each option however the preferred answer requires. Many drafts list a dependency and then treat it as settled, recommending an option whose first step belongs to a department nobody consulted. Some examples bring back options the constraint analysis had already removed, which contradicts the previous section outright. A recommendation without a runner-up leaves the project with nothing to fall back on when the first choice stalls.
Get an HIM-490 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the HIM-490 Topic 4 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the options and constraints your project has reached so far. We write a custom example to those criteria, with options written operationally, criteria defined in advance, a reason in every cell, dependencies checked and a runner-up named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.
More HIM 490 papers and BS in Health Information Management samples
- HIM 490 Topic 1: Actionable Problem Statement
- HIM 490 Topic 2: Baseline Measurement Report
- HIM 490 Topic 3: Regulatory Constraint Analysis
- HIM 490 Topic 5: Forgotten Constraint Dq Post
- HIM 490 Topic 6: Owned Implementation Timeline
- HIM 490 Topic 7: Internal Consistency Audit
- HIM 490 Topic 8: Capstone Panel Defense
- HIM 200 Topic 4: Release of Information Case Review
- HIM 452 Topic 4: Comorbidity Capture Review
- HIM 310 Topic 4: Terminology Versus Classification Paper
- HIM 430 Topic 4: Data Quality Policy
HIM 490 Topic 4 questions, answered
Should the matrix use numerical scores?
Scores are fine where the rubric wants them, provided every score has a reason beside it. Numbers make a matrix look rigorous and can hide judgment that was never examined. A short written reason in each cell lets a reader check the rating. Where weights are used, state them and explain why implementability outweighs ideal outcome for a department with limited authority.
What if the best option depends on another department?
Then the dependency is recorded along with whether that department has agreed. An option waiting on a commitment nobody has made cannot be recommended as though it were ready. The matrix can still keep it as a runner-up, stating the agreement that would move it forward, which gives the capstone a realistic path if that commitment arrives later.
Can the matrix include doing nothing?
It often should. Doing nothing has a cost, the backlog growing and outside documents reaching clinicians late, and stating that cost makes the case for action concrete. Including it also shows a panel that the recommendation was compared against the status quo rather than assumed necessary. Your instructions may specify the options, and the matrix follows them.
Where can I find a free HIM 490 Topic 4 sample paper?
Everything is here: the backlog problem, the matrix of four options, the reading of its cells, the recommendation, why implementability beats effectiveness and the risks of the chosen path. Tell us your options for a free worked matrix.
Which option wins in HIM 490 Topic 4?
An electronic intake queue for faxes, with a one-time vendor cleanup and one added position. The queue removes about 60 percent of scanning volume and needs only a configuration change.