HIM 615 Topic 3 total cost of ownership model example

Health Care Information Systems and Technology Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This HIM 615 Topic 3 sample paper is a ten-year total cost of ownership model for two EHR finalists, with every figure marked illustrative. It was prepared for GCU HIM 615, Health Care Information Systems and Technology, catalog code HIM-615, in the Grand Canyon University MS in Health Informatics program. Costs are built by category, from subscription and implementation to interfaces, hosting, internal analysts, training backfill, reduced clinic schedules, upgrades, archive and exit, each with its source. The finalist $12.0 million cheaper on license finishes $9.7 million more expensive overall. Present value at 4 and 7 percent, a sensitivity table and a separate clinician time line complete the model.

CourseHIM 615 Health Care Information Systems and Technology
TopicTopic 3
Paper typeTotal cost of ownership model
LengthAbout 980 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMS in Health Informatics
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for HIM 615 Topic 3

1

The Cheaper License Costs More: A Ten-Year Total Cost of Ownership Model for Paloma Basin's Two EHR Finalists

[Author Name]

College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University

HIM-615: Health Care Information Systems and Technology

Topic 3 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title gives the model's main finding, that ranking by license price reverses once every cost is counted. Paloma Basin, the finalists and every figure are illustrative composites; the sources are real.
2

The Cheaper License Costs More: A Ten-Year Total Cost of Ownership Model for Paloma Basin's Two EHR Finalists

Horizon and Sources

This model compares the full cost of Paloma Basin Health's two finalist electronic health records over ten years. Ten years was chosen rather than the seven-year contract term because enterprise records are rarely replaced at the end of a first term, and because some costs, such as upgrades and eventual exit, fall late. With only a handful of enterprise vendors left and switching this expensive, a hospital's choice is closer to a long commitment than a purchase (Koppel & Lehmann, 2015), and the horizon should reflect that. Every figure is illustrative and stated in millions of dollars.

Costs are assembled by category rather than taken from the proposals' totals, since each proposal defines its total differently. Each category has a stated source: the vendor's proposal, Paloma Basin's own payroll assumptions, or an estimate labeled as such. Finalist A is self-hosted through a third-party data center and prices interfaces separately beyond 20 included. Finalist B is vendor-hosted, with hosting and 60 interfaces included in its subscription. Paloma Basin's interface inventory counts 64 interfaces that must be built.

Costs by Category

Table 1

Ten-Year Costs by Category, Millions of Dollars (Illustrative)

CategoryTypeFinalist AFinalist BSource
License or subscriptionRecurring24.036.0Proposals
Implementation servicesOne-time18.016.0Proposals
Interface build beyond includedOne-time2.40.2Proposals and interface inventory
Interface maintenanceRecurring6.02.0Proposals
Hosting and disaster recoveryRecurring8.0IncludedData center quote for A
Internal analysts and trainers, implementationOne-time9.08.0Payroll assumptions
Internal analysts, ongoingRecurring31.027.0Payroll assumptions; reference calls
Backfill for staff in trainingOne-time4.24.8Training hours in proposals
Reduced clinic schedules at go-liveOne-time3.12.9Estimate, four weeks at 75%
Upgrades, years 3 to 10Recurring4.01.6Proposals; estimate for A
Legacy archiveBoth3.03.0Archive vendor quote
Exit and data extraction, year 10One-time2.03.5Proposals
Total, nominal114.7105.0

What the Table Shows

On license alone, Finalist A leads by $12.0 million over ten years. It finishes second once everything is counted, $9.7 million behind. Three categories account for the reversal. Hosting adds $8.0 million to A, since Paloma Basin must pay a data center for what B includes. Interfaces add $8.4 million to A against $2.2 million for B, because A's proposal includes only 20 of the 64 interfaces the inventory requires. Ongoing internal analysts cost $4.0 million more over the period for A, because a self-hosted system needs technical staff that the vendor provides for B, a figure the reference calls supported.

Separating one-time from recurring costs shows the same pattern from a different angle. A's one-time costs are $40.2 million and its recurring costs $74.5 million; B's are $36.9 million and $68.1 million. B is cheaper both to implement and to keep, so the ranking does not depend on how the years are weighted.

What this page is doingThe paper names the three categories that reverse the ranking and quantifies each, so a reader can check the reversal directly.
3

Present Value

Costs spread over ten years are not equivalent to costs paid now, so the model discounts them. It uses a 4% annual rate, close to Paloma Basin's recent cost of borrowing, with one-time costs placed in the first year. At that rate the present value of A's costs is $98.4 million and of B's $89.7 million. At a 7% rate, the figure the system's finance committee uses for capital projects, the values are $88.8 million and $80.7 million. The ranking holds at either rate.

Sensitivity

Three assumptions are most open to dispute. Table 2 varies each and reports whether the ranking changes.

Table 2

Sensitivity of the Ranking, Millions of Dollars, Nominal

Assumption changedFinalist AFinalist BRanking
Base case114.7105.0B first
A includes all 64 interfaces, maintenance falls to 0.2 a year108.3105.0B first
A's ongoing analysts equal B's, 2.7 a year110.7105.0B first
Both changes to A together104.3105.0A first by 0.7
B's subscription rises 3% a year114.7110.3B first
Reduced schedules last eight weeks for both117.8107.9B first

Reading the Sensitivity Table

No single change reverses the ranking. Only when A concedes all interfaces and its staffing assumption proves as low as B's does A move ahead, and then by less than 1% of the total. Both are possible: A's sales team has signaled flexibility on interfaces, and A argues that its build tools need fewer analysts. The model therefore gives the negotiating team two specific questions to put to A. It also flags a risk in B's proposal: the subscription has no escalation cap after year five, and a 3% annual increase would narrow the gap to $4.4 million. A cap belongs in the contract.

Clinician Time, Stated as Its Own Line

The largest cost of any record rarely appears in a budget. Sinsky et al. (2016) found that physicians in ambulatory practice spent nearly half of their office day on the record and desk work and about a quarter on direct clinical face time with patients. Fleming et al. (2011) similarly counted the time staff and physicians spent learning and adapting to a new record as a real cost of implementation in primary care practices. At Paloma Basin, with about 1,450 clinicians who document, a difference of five minutes a day in documentation time between the two products would amount to about 27,800 hours a year. Valued at an illustrative blended rate of $120 an hour, that is $3.3 million a year, or about $33 million over ten years, more than three times the gap between the finalists.

The model does not know which product is faster, and it does not pretend to. The unscripted sessions measured task times for a small number of clinicians, and the results were mixed. The recommendation is that the contract require a joint measurement of documentation time six and twelve months after go-live, reported by role, so that this line is measured rather than assumed.

References

Fleming, N. S., Culler, S. D., McCorkle, R., Becker, E. R., & Ballard, D. J. (2011). The financial and nonfinancial costs of implementing electronic health records in primary care practices. Health Affairs, 30(3), 481-489. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2010.0768

Koppel, R., & Lehmann, C. U. (2015). Implications of an emerging EHR monoculture for hospitals and healthcare systems. Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 22(2), 465-471. https://doi.org/10.1136/amiajnl-2014-003023

Sinsky, C., Colligan, L., Li, L., Prgomet, M., Reynolds, S., Goeders, L., Westbrook, J., Tutty, M., & Blike, G. (2016). Allocation of physician time in ambulatory practice: A time and motion study in 4 specialties. Annals of Internal Medicine, 165(11), 753-760. https://doi.org/10.7326/M16-0961

The HIM-615 Topic 3 assignment instructions

HIM-615 Topic 3 asks students to estimate the full cost of acquiring and running a health information system. Many papers compare license or subscription prices. The assignment rewards models that assemble costs by category over a stated horizon, separate one-time from recurring costs, cite a source or label an estimate for each figure and include internal staff, training and lost productivity. Students should discount costs to present value with a justified rate, test the assumptions most open to dispute in a sensitivity analysis and state the ranking along with the conditions that would reverse it.

How the HIM-615 Topic 3 example is put together

The finished model compares two finalist systems for a composite hospital across a ten-year life, with every figure marked illustrative. Costs are assembled in categories rather than taken from the proposals: subscription or license, implementation services, interfaces built and maintained, hosting and disaster recovery, internal analysts and trainers, backfill for staff in training, reduced clinic schedules during go-live, upgrades, a legacy archive and eventual exit. Each category carries its source and an assumption the reader can change. The lower-priced proposal leads on license alone and finishes second once interfaces and internal staff are counted. Costs are discounted to present value, and a sensitivity table shows which two assumptions could reverse the ranking. The model ends with clinician time stated as its own line, because that burden seldom appears in any budget.

HIM 615 Topic 3 rubric: what Excellent looks like

GCU's rubric for the cost model rewards completeness and transparency. Excellent models count interfaces, hosting and internal analysts that proposals leave out, and they explain which categories reverse a ranking based on price. Credit goes to separating one-time and recurring costs and to a present value calculation at a stated rate. The rubric values sensitivity tables that identify which combination of assumptions changes the result. The highest level states clinician time as its own line and proposes measuring it. Models built on license price alone, or on figures without sources, usually lose marks.

Common HIM 615 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Comparisons built on license or subscription price alone lose the most, because that figure is often a minority of what the hospital will spend. A model that takes the vendor's implementation estimate at face value, with no internal staff costs added, describes what the vendor will charge rather than what the project will cost. Papers mixing one-time and recurring costs in a single total hide which proposal keeps costing money after go-live. Figures presented without sources or labels read as invented, and in a graduate paper that undermines every row. Drafts with no sensitivity analysis state a ranking with more confidence than the assumptions allow. Leaving out clinician time omits the cost that most shapes how the system is received on the wards, and graders frequently look for it.

Get an HIM-615 Topic 3 example written to your instructions

Send the HIM-615 Topic 3 instructions and your classroom rubric, together with any proposals, figures or cost categories the assignment provides. We write a custom example to those criteria, with costs assembled by category over the system's life, sources and labels on every figure, present value applied and a sensitivity test, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More HIM 615 papers and MS in Health Informatics samples

HIM 615 Topic 3 questions, answered

What belongs in total cost of ownership?

Everything the organization will spend because it chose this system, over the system's life. That includes license or subscription, implementation services, interfaces, hardware or hosting, internal staff, training and backfill, reduced clinical schedules at go-live, upgrades, optimization, archiving the old system and eventually leaving. The model groups these into categories and separates one-time costs from recurring ones.

Are the figures in the example real?

No. Every figure is illustrative and labeled that way, because the composite hospital is not a real organization and invented numbers presented as fact would mislead. The structure, categories and assumptions are the point. If your assignment supplies figures, the model uses them, and where it asks for estimates, each one should carry its source and be marked as an assumption.

Why discount future costs?

Because money spent later costs less in today's terms than money spent now, and two proposals with the same ten-year total can differ sharply in when the spending falls. Discounting to present value puts them on the same footing. The model states its discount rate and why it was chosen, often the organization's cost of capital, so a reader can substitute a different one.

Where can I find a free HIM 615 Topic 3 sample paper?

The whole model sits above, with the horizon and sources, the cost table, what it shows, present value, sensitivity and clinician time as its own line. Send your finalists' categories for a free worked model.

Why does the cheaper license lose in HIM 615 Topic 3?

Hosting, interfaces beyond the 20 included and extra internal analysts add more than the license saves, so the finalist cheaper on license costs $9.7 million more over ten years.