| Course | HRM 635 Acquiring, Developing, and Leveraging Human Capital |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Build versus buy case |
| Length | About 950 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for HRM 635 Topic 3
Build or Buy Five Security Analysts: A Three-Year Cost Case for One Seat at a Regional Bank, Both Columns Held to the Same Items
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
HRM-635: Acquiring, Developing, and Leveraging Human Capital
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Build or Buy Five Security Analysts: A Three-Year Cost Case for One Seat at a Regional Bank, Both Columns Held to the Same Items
The Need
Prairie Federal Bank, a composite regional bank with about 2,100 employees, is bringing its security operations function in house after years of relying on a managed service provider. The new function needs five security analysts who monitor alerts, investigate incidents and escalate threats around the clock. The go-live date is fifteen months away. Human resources has been asked whether to buy the analysts, by hiring experienced people from the market, or build them, by training current employees from the bank's IT help desk and operations teams. All figures below are illustrative.
The Unit of Comparison
Build and buy comparisons go wrong most often when the two columns hold different things, such as a hire's salary set against a trainee's course fee. This case compares one filled analyst seat over three years, so recruiting fees, pay, training, lost productivity and the cost of replacing people who leave all land in the same total. Three years is long enough to include turnover, which repeats some costs, and short enough that estimates remain grounded in current pay data.
The Buy Route
Experienced security analysts are scarce. The bank's recruiting partner charges an illustrative fee of 20 percent of first-year salary, about $27,000 per hire. Loaded pay, meaning salary plus benefits and payroll taxes, runs about $135,000 a year for an analyst with three or more years of experience. Turnover among experienced analysts is high, so the bank would need to refill some seats within three years; spreading the expected refills across seats gives a reserve of about $36,000 per seat for repeat fees and vacancy coverage.
Table 1
Illustrative Three-Year Cost of a Hired Analyst
| Buy route, one seat, three years | Cost |
|---|---|
| Recruiting fee | $27,000 |
| Loaded pay, $135,000 x 3 years | $405,000 |
| Refill reserve for turnover | $36,000 |
| Total | $468,000 |
The Build Route
The build route uses a twelve-month program combining a vendor bootcamp, an industry certification and supervised work alongside the managed service provider's analysts. It costs about $36,000 per enrollee. Not everyone finishes: the vendor's illustrative completion rate is three in four. Dividing by completers rather than enrollees gives the true cost per trained analyst, $48,000. During the first year, trainees are paid at their current rate, about $90,000 loaded, and spend roughly half their time in training, so about $45,000 of first-year pay buys training rather than output. Years two and three cost about $110,000 a year in loaded pay, $220,000 in total. A pay step of $12,000 at certification and a refill reserve of $20,000 complete the column.
Table 2
Illustrative Three-Year Cost of a Trained Analyst
| Build route, one seat, three years | Cost |
|---|---|
| Program cost per completer, $36,000 / 0.75 | $48,000 |
| First-year pay spent in training | $45,000 |
| Loaded pay, years two and three | $220,000 |
| Pay step at certification | $12,000 |
| Refill reserve for turnover | $20,000 |
| Total | $345,000 |
Building costs about $123,000 less per seat over three years, or about $615,000 across the five seats.
Portability
The build route has a weakness that the cost table does not show. A security certification is valuable to every bank and every security firm, not only to Prairie Federal. Economic theory has long predicted that employers will be reluctant to pay for training in general skills, because trained workers can take those skills to a competitor who pays more (Becker, 1993). The $12,000 pay step at certification is meant to close part of the gap between a newly certified analyst's pay and the market rate. The bank could also use a prorated training repayment agreement where state law allows it. Even with both, some trained analysts will leave, which is why the build column carries a refill reserve and why its pay in years two and three is set close to the market.
Testing the Completion Rate
The input that moves the result most is the completion rate. At one in two completing, the program cost per completer rises to $72,000 and the build total to $369,000, still about $99,000 below buying. The two routes cost the same only if completion falls to about one in five, at which point the program cost per completer reaches about $171,000. The bank's candidates come from its own IT staff, screened for aptitude, so a completion rate that low is unlikely.
What the Cheaper Column Cannot Do
Building has one disadvantage that money does not fix: time. Trainees spend their first year learning, so no one from the build route can work a console unassisted before month thirteen. The go-live date is month fifteen, leaving two months of margin. If the program slips or the first cohort's completion is low, the bank would go live short-staffed. Buying puts experienced analysts on the console within a few months of hire.
Recommendation
The bank should build four of the five seats and buy one. The hired analyst, an experienced lead, would join in the first quarter, help design the function's procedures and supervise trainees in their second half-year, reducing the risk that the go-live date arrives before the trained analysts are ready. The four built seats save about $492,000 over three years compared with buying them. This follows the general pattern that firms buy where speed and experience are scarce and build where a capability will be used for years and can be shaped to the firm's own systems (Lepak & Snell, 1999).
The buy route's strongest point is conceded: it is faster and less exposed to program risk. That is exactly why one seat is bought. Relying on the market for all five would cost about $615,000 more over three years, and the market for experienced analysts is tight enough that the bank might not fill all five in time anyway (Cappelli, 2008).
References
Becker, G. S. (1993). Human capital: A theoretical and empirical analysis, with special reference to education (3rd ed.). University of Chicago Press. https://doi.org/10.7208/chicago/9780226041223.001.0001
Cappelli, P. (2008). Talent on demand: Managing talent in an age of uncertainty. Harvard Business Press.
Lepak, D. P., & Snell, S. A. (1999). The human resource architecture: Toward a theory of human capital allocation and development. Academy of Management Review, 24(1), 31-48. https://doi.org/10.2307/259035
The HRM-635 Topic 3 assignment instructions
HRM-635 Topic 3 asks students to compare developing talent internally with hiring it from the market. The common failure is a comparison of unlike items, such as a hire's salary against a course fee. The assignment rewards a case that fixes a unit of comparison first, costs both routes line by line on that basis and includes turnover, completion rates and lost productivity during training. Students should address the risk that trained employees leave with general skills, test the input that moves the result most and recommend a route while conceding the strongest point of the one rejected. Labeled figures and clear arithmetic are expected throughout.
Inside the HRM 635 Topic 3 example
The case opens with the bank's need for five analysts and a go-live date fifteen months away. A section fixes the unit as one seat over three years. Table 1 costs the buy route: fee, loaded pay and a refill reserve. Table 2 costs the build route: program cost divided by completers, first-year pay spent in training, later pay, a certification step and a refill reserve. A portability section explains why employers hesitate to fund general skills and how the pay step responds. A sensitivity test finds the completion rate at which the routes cost the same, and the recommendation buys one lead and builds four.
Reading the HRM 635 Topic 3 rubric
Faculty grading the build-versus-buy case reward two columns that hold the same things over the same period. Strong papers divide training costs by those who finish and include the cost of refilling seats on both sides. Credit goes to recognizing that a widely valued certification makes trained staff attractive to competitors and to pricing a response. The rubric values a sensitivity test on the input that matters most, with the break-even value stated. The highest band recommends a route, explains how it handles timing risk and openly concedes the strength of the rejected route. Comparisons that set a salary against a course fee usually lose points.
HRM 635 Topic 3 help before you submit
Build and buy papers are marked on whether the two columns hold the same things. A comparison setting a hire's salary against a trainee's course fee has compared a whole cost with a fragment, and it usually crowns building without noticing. Recruiting fees counted while turnover is ignored flatter the buy route, since replacing a hired analyst repeats the fee. Program costs divided by enrollees rather than by completers understate what each trained analyst really costs. Papers treating training as a guarantee of loyalty overlook that a certification is valued by every competitor, which is why employers hesitate to pay for general skills at all. A recommendation that hides the rejected route's advantage loses ground as well, because whoever approves it will raise that point first.
Get an HRM-635 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the HRM-635 Topic 3 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and whatever capability, salaries or case figures the assignment supplies. A custom example comes back in 24 to 48 hours, with one unit of comparison, both routes costed line by line, completion and turnover included, the swing input tested and a recommendation that concedes the other side. The first one is free.
More HRM 635 papers and MBA samples
- HRM 635 Topic 1: Capability Need Analysis
- HRM 635 Topic 2: Costed Talent Gap Statement
- HRM 635 Topic 4: Selection Validity Review
- HRM 635 Topic 5: Selection Utility Dq Post
- HRM 635 Topic 6: Training Return Evaluation Plan
- HRM 635 Topic 7: Critical Talent Retention Analysis
- HRM 635 Topic 8: Talent Investment Business Case
- HRM 640 Topic 3: Practice Bundle Fit Analysis
- FIN 650 Topic 3: Beta and Required Return
- LDR 670 Topic 3: Cross Border Negotiation Analysis
- FIN 504 Topic 3: Risk and Required Return Analysis
HRM 635 Topic 3 questions, answered
What did Becker argue about training?
Gary Becker's human capital theory separates general training, which raises a worker's value to many employers, from firm-specific training, which raises it mainly to the current one. His argument was that employers have little reason to fund general training, because the worker can carry the higher value elsewhere. Security certifications sit close to the general end, which is why the example prices retention into the build route.
Why compare over three years instead of one?
A single year flatters whichever route has the lower start-up cost and hides recurring costs such as refilling a seat after turnover. Three years is long enough for most development programs to pay back or fail to, and short enough for the assumptions to stay credible. Some assignments set their own period, and the finished paper uses whatever the instructions specify.
Can the recommendation mix both routes?
Yes, and many strong papers do, for instance when one senior hire would shorten the program for everyone else or when part of the need cannot wait. The example keeps to one route because its go-live date allows it, and it says so. What matters is that any mix is argued from the costs on the page, not adopted as a compromise that avoids choosing.
Where can I find a free HRM 635 Topic 3 sample paper?
The bank's build-versus-buy case is complete on this page, from the need and the unit of comparison to both cost tables, portability, the completion test and the recommendation. Tell us the role you are costing and a free case can be built on the same method.
Why divide by completers in HRM 635 Topic 3?
Because not every enrollee finishes. With three in four completing, a $36,000 program costs $48,000 per trained analyst, and dividing by enrollees would understate the build route's true cost.