| Course | HRM 640 Designing HR for Competitive Advantage |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Implementation gap review |
| Length | About 960 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for HRM 640 Topic 6
Intended, Implemented, Perceived: The Gap Between a $150 Recovery Allowance on Paper and in Practice Across Fourteen Hotels, and How Administration Should Change
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
HRM-640: Designing HR for Competitive Advantage
Topic 6 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Intended, Implemented, Perceived: The Gap Between a $150 Recovery Allowance on Paper and in Practice Across Fourteen Hotels, and How Administration Should Change
Three Versions of Every Practice
Earlier topics designed Mesa Lantern's HR system on paper. This review asks how much of that design reaches employees. Wright and Nishii (2013) distinguished three versions of any HR practice: the intended practice, as designed by the organization; the implemented practice, as line managers actually carry it out; and the perceived practice, as employees understand and experience it. A practice affects behavior only through the version employees perceive, so a strong design can fail if implementation or perception drifts. The review compares the three versions for the two practices most central to the group's position: the service recovery allowance and preference capture.
The Recovery Allowance
Table 1
Three Versions of the Recovery Allowance
| Version | What it looks like | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Intended | Up to $150 per incident, no approval | Policy manual |
| Implemented | Use from 0.2 to 2.4 per 100 occupied rooms; four properties require sign-off | Spending records, manager interviews |
| Perceived | 38% of agents do not know they can act alone | Pulse survey of front desk agents |
Intended. Any front desk agent may spend up to $150 to put a guest's problem right, such as a meal credit, a room move or a late checkout, without asking a manager. The allowance is meant to be used, and managers are told not to second-guess reasonable use.
Implemented. On illustrative figures from the past year, use varies widely, from 0.2 recoveries per hundred occupied rooms at the lowest-using property to 2.4 at the highest. The difference is too large to reflect differences in guest problems. Interviews with general managers explain much of it: four of the fourteen require agents to get sign-off before spending, which turns the allowance into a manager's approval process.
Perceived. A short pulse survey of front desk agents found that 38 percent did not know they could act without approval. At the four properties requiring sign-off, the figure was over 70 percent. Even at properties where managers follow the design, some agents believe they need permission.
The gap matters for the strategy. Topic 2 identified the allowance as a practice that resists imitation because of the trust behind it. At the properties requiring sign-off, that trust does not exist, and the advantage disappears for the guests who stay there.
Preference Capture
Intended. Housekeepers record what a guest changed in the room, and the note reaches the guest preference software, so the front desk and the next stay can use it.
Implemented. Eight properties have housekeepers enter notes on shared tablets at the end of each floor. Six still log notes on paper forms collected at the end of the shift and typed in later by a supervisor when time allows. At those six, notes reach the software for fewer than one room in ten, and often days after the guest has left.
Perceived. Housekeepers at the paper-based properties described the forms as paperwork for supervisors rather than as information for the front desk. Employees respond to HR practices according to why they believe the practices exist (Nishii et al., 2008); a form seen as monitoring produces compliance at best, while one seen as serving guests is more likely to be completed with care.
The gap has a direct cost to the position. A preference recorded on paper on Tuesday and typed in on Friday is useless for a guest who returns on Thursday, and business travelers often return within the same week. At the six paper-based properties, front desk agents reported relying on memory and on their own handwritten notes kept at the desk, which works only for the agents who were on shift when the guest last stayed.
Why the Gaps Arise
The gaps have a common source. Both practices depend on line managers and on administrative routines that the original design did not address. The allowance policy said what agents could do but not how spending would be recorded or reviewed, so cautious managers built their own controls. The capture routine said what housekeepers should record but not how the note would travel, so properties without tablets fell back on paper. An HR system is strong when its messages are visible, consistent and agreed upon by those who administer it (Bowen & Ostroff, 2004). Here the administration was left to each property, and the message weakened accordingly.
How Administration Should Change
The review recommends three changes that reshape the design through its administration.
1. Log recovery spending at the point of use. Each use is entered in the property system by the agent, with a short reason, at the moment it happens. This gives managers the visibility that made some of them insist on sign-off, without slowing the guest's recovery.
2. Review use rates, not individual spends. A regional operations manager reviews each property's recovery rate monthly against a target band of 1.0 to 2.0 per hundred occupied rooms. Properties far below the band are asked why agents are not using the allowance; those far above are asked what recurring problems are driving it. Individual spends are reviewed only if a pattern suggests misuse. The four sign-off requirements are withdrawn.
3. Give housekeepers handheld capture. Handheld devices for housekeepers at the six paper-based properties, with a simple screen for common preferences, would cost about $42,000 across the group, including devices, software licenses and training. Notes would reach the front desk before the guest's next arrival rather than days later.
A short message from the group's chief operating officer to every agent, repeated in shift briefings, should restate that the allowance is theirs to use. Perception will lag behind any change in implementation, and a repeat pulse survey in six months will show whether the 38 percent has fallen.
References
Bowen, D. E., & Ostroff, C. (2004). Understanding HRM-firm performance linkages: The role of the "strength" of the HRM system. Academy of Management Review, 29(2), 203-221. https://doi.org/10.2307/20159029
Nishii, L. H., Lepak, D. P., & Schneider, B. (2008). Employee attributions of the "why" of HR practices: Their effects on employee attitudes and behaviors, and customer satisfaction. Personnel Psychology, 61(3), 503-545. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-6570.2008.00121.x
Wright, P. M., & Nishii, L. H. (2013). Strategic HRM and organizational behaviour: Integrating multiple levels of analysis. In D. E. Guest, J. Paauwe, & P. M. Wright (Eds.), HRM and performance: Achievements and challenges (pp. 97-110). Wiley.
The HRM-640 Topic 6 assignment instructions
The Topic 6 instructions for HRM-640 ask students to examine how well an HR design is carried out in practice. A review that only confirms a policy exists falls short. What earns credit is a comparison of the intended practice, the version line managers implement and the version employees perceive, each supported by its own evidence. Students should explain why the gaps arise, connect them to the strategy the practice is meant to support and propose changes to administration that close the gaps without abandoning the design. A plan to check whether perception improves over time completes the review, and it should name the survey or record that will show the change and when it will be read.
Inside the HRM 640 Topic 6 example
The review introduces Wright and Nishii's three versions of a practice. The recovery allowance is examined first: the policy, the spending records and manager interviews showing sign-off requirements, and a pulse survey on what agents believe. Table 1 summarizes the three versions with their evidence. Preference capture follows, with tablet and paper properties compared and housekeepers' views read through research on why employees think practices exist. A section explains the common cause, administration left to each property, using Bowen and Ostroff. Three changes are proposed: point-of-use logging, review of use rates and handheld capture at about $42,000.
HRM 640 Topic 6 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Instructors grading the gap review reward three versions of each practice, each supported by different evidence. Strong papers quantify the gaps where possible, such as use rates and survey results, and explain their causes rather than blaming individuals. Credit goes to connecting the gaps to the strategy, since a practice that protects the advantage loses that value when it is not carried out. The rubric values administrative changes that preserve the design's intent, such as reviewing rates rather than each spend. The highest band plans a follow-up measure of perception. Reviews that assume a written policy equals practice tend to lose marks.
Common HRM 640 Topic 6 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Implementation reviews lose ground when they audit the policy manual instead of the property. A paper confirming that the allowance exists and is well designed has reviewed the intended practice only, and the gap the topic asks about sits in the other two versions. Averages across sites hide the variation that shows administration failing, so a mean use rate conceals the four properties where the practice has stopped. Treating the problem as manager resistance, without asking what the managers are able to run, blames people for a design flaw. Redesigns that add reporting burden to an already stretched general manager usually produce the same gap a year later. Papers citing Wright and Nishii as a list of terms, without applying all three versions to the case, use the framework as decoration rather than as method.
Get an HRM-640 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the HRM-640 Topic 6 instructions, the rubric for it and the practices or organization the review covers. We write a custom example to those criteria, with intended, implemented and perceived versions compared, variation shown across sites, administrative causes identified and a redesign priced that managers can realistically run, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HRM 640 papers and MBA samples
- HRM 640 Topic 1: Strategy and Role Behavior Paper
- HRM 640 Topic 2: Practice Imitability Audit
- HRM 640 Topic 3: Practice Bundle Fit Analysis
- HRM 640 Topic 4: Workforce Architecture Redesign
- HRM 640 Topic 5: Site Consistency Dq Post
- HRM 640 Topic 7: Redesign Outcome Measure Plan
- HRM 640 Topic 8: Competing Proposal Executive Case
- LDR 670 Topic 6: Cross Jurisdiction Ethics Analysis
- HRM 635 Topic 6: Training Return Evaluation Plan
- MGT 605 Topic 6: Culture Formation Study
- FIN 650 Topic 6: Relevant Cash Flow Estimation
HRM 640 Topic 6 questions, answered
What separates intended from implemented practices?
Patrick Wright and Lisa Nishii distinguished the practices an organization intends, the ones line managers actually implement, and the ones employees perceive, arguing that employee responses follow the perceived version. A well designed policy can fail at either later stage. Reviews using the framework check all three, because a gap anywhere in the chain means the practice is not producing the behavior it was designed for.
Why does administration change the design rather than just the rollout?
Because some designs cannot be run consistently by the people who must run them, and better communication does not fix that. If an allowance requires judgment calls that general managers have no time to review, the design itself needs a simpler control. Bringing administration into the design stage usually produces a practice that is easier to run and closer to its purpose.
Where would the survey and usage data come from?
In a real organization, from the property management system, expense records and a short staff survey. Cases set for this topic sometimes include usage figures, and any others can be labeled illustrative, provided they stay consistent. The example states the source of each figure and shows ranges across sites rather than a single average, since the variation is the finding.
Where can I find a free HRM 640 Topic 6 sample paper?
The hotel group review is above in full: the three versions, the recovery allowance and its table, preference capture, why the gaps arise and the three administrative changes. Share the practice you need to review, and a free paper can be drafted for it.
What gap does HRM 640 Topic 6 find in the allowance?
Four general managers require sign-off before agents spend, use varies from 0.2 to 2.4 per hundred occupied rooms and 38 percent of agents do not know they may act without approval.