MGT 434 Topic 4 internal equity pay review example

Human Resources Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 434 Topic 4 sample paper reviews a $52,000 starting offer for an inventory coordinator against the pay of the coordinators already in the job. It belongs to GCU MGT 434, Human Resources, the course listed as MGT-434 in the Grand Canyon University BS in Business Management. The band runs from $42,000 to $58,000 with a $50,000 midpoint, and the offer's compa-ratio of 1.04 places a newcomer above two seven-year coordinators. Because most private-sector staff may lawfully discuss pay, the incumbents will learn the figure. The review also finds a $3,500 gap between a woman and a man in the same job with no documented reason, an Equal Pay Act concern.

CourseMGT 434 Human Resources
TopicTopic 4
Paper typePay equity review
LengthAbout 970 words, 4 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Business Management
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 434 Topic 4

1

One Starting Offer, Two Problems Found: An Internal Equity Review of a $52,000 Offer for a Warehouse Coordinator, Compression Above Long-Serving Staff and an Unexplained Gap Between Two of Them

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

MGT-434: Human Resources

Topic 4 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title starts from the decision the supervisor owns, a single offer, and names the two problems the review turns up. The warehouse, its staff and all pay figures are an illustrative composite; the statutes and research are real.
2

One Starting Offer, Two Problems Found: An Internal Equity Review of a $52,000 Offer for a Warehouse Coordinator, Compression Above Long-Serving Staff and an Unexplained Gap Between Two of Them

The Decision

The shipping supervisor at the composite auto parts distribution center wants to hire an inventory coordinator from a competitor and has asked HR to approve a starting offer of $52,000. The candidate has five years of experience and has said they will not move for less. The supervisor's argument is simple: good coordinators are hard to find, and this one is worth it. This review does not redesign the center's pay system. It checks what the offer does to pay among the people already in the job, which is the decision the supervisor actually owns.

Starting offers are where most pay problems begin. A supervisor under pressure to fill a role agrees to the candidate's number, and the effect on people already doing the job is noticed only months later, when someone discovers the difference. Reviewing the offer against current pay before approving it is the cheapest point at which to catch the problem.

The Band and the Incumbents

The inventory coordinator job sits in a pay band with an illustrative minimum of $42,000, a midpoint of $50,000 and a maximum of $58,000. The midpoint is set to match the local market rate for a fully competent coordinator. A compa-ratio, salary divided by midpoint, shows where each person sits: 1.00 means paid at the market rate.

Table 1

Inventory Coordinator Pay Against the Band

PersonTenureSalaryCompa-ratio
Coordinator A (woman)7 years$47,5000.95
Coordinator B (man)7 years$51,0001.02
Coordinator C2 years$45,0000.90
Proposed hire0 years at the center, 5 elsewhere$52,0001.04

Problem One: Compression

The proposed offer would place a new hire above both seven-year coordinators on their first day. This is pay compression: the gap between new and experienced employees shrinks or reverses, usually because starting pay follows the market while existing pay moves more slowly. Compression is common, but it carries a cost here.

The incumbents will almost certainly learn the figure. Most non-supervisory employees in the private sector have a legally protected right to discuss their pay with one another, and employers may not prohibit it (National Labor Relations Act, 2018). The center cannot keep the offer quiet and should not try. When the coordinators learn that a newcomer earns more than they do after seven years, they will compare what they contribute and receive with what the newcomer does. People who see their ratio of outcomes to inputs as unfair relative to others tend to reduce effort, press for change or leave (Adams, 1965). Coordinator A, the lowest-paid of the experienced pair, would have the strongest reason to feel this.

Compression also tends to spread. Once a new coordinator starts at $52,000, the next request from a current coordinator for a raise will cite that figure, and the center will face the same question for every role where the market has moved faster than internal pay.

What this page is doingThe review explains how the incumbents will learn the figure and how they are likely to respond, which turns compression from an abstract term into a practical risk.
3

Problem Two: An Unexplained Gap

The same table shows something the offer did not cause but brings to light. Coordinators A and B have the same title, the same tenure and, according to their supervisor, the same duties and similar performance ratings over the past three years. Coordinator A, a woman, earns $47,500. Coordinator B, a man, earns $51,000. HR found no documented reason for the $3,500 difference in either personnel file.

The Equal Pay Act forbids a pay gap between men and women doing substantially the same job under similar conditions, unless the employer can point to seniority, merit, output-based pay or some other factor that has nothing to do with sex (Equal Pay Act, 2018). The center may have had a legitimate reason seven years ago, perhaps a difference in starting offers driven by prior experience. But if it cannot document one, the gap is a legal exposure as well as an equity problem, and the new offer would draw attention to it.

HR should also check whether the difference grew over time. If both coordinators started at similar pay and the gap opened through raises, the explanation lies in how raises were decided, which is a different problem from a difference in starting offers.

Options

Three options were considered.

1. Approve $52,000 and do nothing else. The center gets the candidate quickly but creates compression and leaves the gap between A and B in place, now more visible.

2. Offer $50,000, the midpoint, and risk losing the candidate. This limits compression to a small amount above A and C and at parity with B, but the candidate has said they will not accept less than $52,000.

3. Offer $51,000, matching Coordinator B, raise Coordinator A to $51,000 immediately, and plan to move Coordinator C toward the midpoint at the next review. The candidate may or may not accept; if they insist on $52,000, the supervisor can decide whether the extra $1,000 is worth the remaining compression.

Each option was judged on three things: whether the center is likely to get the candidate, what the incumbents will see when they learn the figure and whether the unexplained gap is closed.

Recommendation

HR recommends option 3. Raising Coordinator A to $51,000 costs $3,500 a year and closes an unexplained gap that should be closed regardless of the new hire. Offering $51,000 places the new coordinator at the same rate as the most experienced incumbents rather than above them, which the incumbents can see is consistent. If the candidate declines, the center has still fixed a problem it would otherwise have carried. The review also recommends that HR check the other bands at the center for similar unexplained gaps, since a gap found by accident in one job is unlikely to be the only one.

What this page is doingThe recommendation fixes the problem the offer exposed even if the offer itself fails, and it extends the check beyond the one job where the gap was found.
4

References

Adams, J. S. (1965). Inequity in social exchange. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 2, 267-299. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0065-2601(08)60108-2

Equal Pay Act, 29 U.S.C. § 206(d) (2018).

National Labor Relations Act, 29 U.S.C. § 157 (2018).

MGT 434 Topic 4 instructions, in plain terms

The Topic 4 instructions in MGT-434 ask students to evaluate a pay decision for internal equity. Designing a whole compensation system is not the task. The assignment rewards a review that starts from one decision a manager owns, sets out the pay band and incumbents with compa-ratios and identifies compression and any unexplained gaps. Students should explain how employees are likely to learn and react to pay figures, address legal requirements such as equal pay for equal work and employees' right to discuss pay, compare options on their consequences and recommend an approach that solves the problems found even if the original offer fails.

How this MGT 434 Topic 4 example is built

The review opens with the supervisor's request and narrows the scope to its effect on current coordinators. Table 1 shows the band and four people with salary and compa-ratio. The compression section explains how incumbents will learn the figure and why equity theory predicts a reaction. The second problem, the unexplained gap between two seven-year coordinators of different sexes, is examined under the Equal Pay Act. Three options are compared on getting the candidate, what incumbents see and whether the gap closes. The recommendation offers $51,000, raises the underpaid coordinator to match and calls for checking other bands. All pay figures are labeled as illustrative.

MGT 434 Topic 4 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Instructors grading the equity review reward a clear table and correct compa-ratio arithmetic. Strong papers identify compression and explain its practical consequences, including how employees will learn about pay. Credit goes to noticing a problem the offer exposes but did not cause, and to applying the law accurately without overstating it. The rubric values options compared on the same criteria and a recommendation that fixes an unexplained gap regardless of whether the candidate accepts. The highest band extends the check beyond the one job. Reviews that approve or reject the offer without examining current staff pay usually lose marks. Showing the arithmetic for each compa-ratio lets a reader check every figure.

Common MGT 434 Topic 4 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Pay reviews at this level lose marks when they design instead of decide. Papers proposing a new compensation philosophy for the whole organization have left the line manager's seat, and the topic asks what one supervisor does with one offer. A review comparing salaries in raw dollars without a midpoint cannot tell a generous payment from a generous band. Compression noted as a morale concern and never priced leaves the recommendation unconnected to its cost. The equal pay question decides most of the marks, because a gap between two people doing substantially equal work needs a documented factor, and a review that notices the gap and moves on has found exposure and filed it. Recommendations assuming staff never compare salaries overlook a right most private-sector employees hold under federal labor law.

Get an MGT-434 Topic 4 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-434 Topic 4 instructions, the rubric for it and any pay band, salary list or scenario the assignment provides. We write a custom example to those criteria, with compa-ratios computed, compression priced, the equal work comparison tested and an offer recommended, every figure labeled illustrative, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MGT 434 papers and BS in Business Management samples

MGT 434 Topic 4 questions, answered

What is a compa-ratio?

An employee's salary divided by the midpoint of the pay band for the role. A ratio of 1.00 means pay sits at the midpoint, a lower figure means below it and a higher one above it. It lets a supervisor compare people in different pay situations on one scale, and it is the figure many compensation offices use when reviewing an individual offer or raise.

When does a pay gap raise an Equal Pay Act question?

When a man and a woman in the same establishment do jobs requiring substantially equal skill, effort and responsibility under similar working conditions and are paid differently. The employer then needs a reason such as seniority, merit, a production-based system or another factor other than sex. Job titles do not settle it, since the comparison looks at the work itself.

Can a manager tell staff to keep salaries confidential?

For most non-supervisory employees in the private sector, a rule forbidding pay discussion generally conflicts with the National Labor Relations Act, and several states add pay transparency laws of their own. The example treats pay as something staff can and will compare. This is coursework support rather than legal advice, and a real policy question belongs with HR or counsel.

Where can I find a free MGT 434 Topic 4 sample paper?

The coordinator pay review appears in full above, from the decision and the band table through compression, the unexplained gap, the options and the recommendation. Tell us the offer and the pay band involved, and we will prepare a free equity check for your case.

What is compression in MGT 434 Topic 4?

A shrinking or reversed gap between new and experienced employees' pay. The $52,000 offer would pay a newcomer more than two coordinators with seven years each, who will likely learn the figure.