MGT 455 Topic 4 cost of poor quality breakdown example

Production/Operations Management Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 455 Topic 4 sample paper sorts a year of quality-related spending at a composite cabinet door maker into the four categories of the cost of quality model. It belongs to GCU MGT 455, Production/Operations Management, the course listed as MGT-455 in the Grand Canyon University BS in Business Management. Prevention costs $20,000, appraisal $45,000, internal failure $90,000 and external failure $125,000, a total of $280,000 or 8 percent of $3.5 million in sales. A Pareto analysis of 400 rejected doors shows finish defects at 250, traced to sanding practice and wood moisture. The paper proposes $30,000 more in prevention that should save about twice that.

CourseMGT 455 Production/Operations Management
TopicTopic 4
Paper typeCost of quality breakdown
LengthAbout 1,010 words, 4 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Business Management
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 455 Topic 4

1

Eight Percent of Sales Spent on Getting It Wrong: A Cost of Poor Quality Breakdown for a Cabinet Door Maker, a Pareto of Rejects and Where to Spend Instead

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

MGT-455: Production/Operations Management

Topic 4 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title leads with the size of the problem and names the two analyses that locate it before proposing where money should go instead. The manufacturer and every figure are an illustrative composite; the sources are real.
2

Eight Percent of Sales Spent on Getting It Wrong: A Cost of Poor Quality Breakdown for a Cabinet Door Maker, a Pareto of Rejects and Where to Spend Instead

Why Count Quality Costs

Timberline Door Works, a composite maker of wooden cabinet doors for kitchen remodelers and builders, had $3.5 million in sales last year. Its owner knows the plant has quality problems, but the costs are scattered across the accounts: scrap in materials, rework in labor, warranty replacements in customer service and inspection wages in overhead. No one had added them up. This breakdown sorts a year of quality-related spending into the four categories of the standard cost of quality model, shows where the defects come from and proposes where to spend differently. All figures are illustrative.

The model sorts this spending four ways: money spent so that bad doors are never made, money spent looking for them, money lost to the bad doors caught inside the plant and money lost to the ones a remodeler finds (Feigenbaum, 1956). Its value is that it puts all four in the same currency, so the owner can see how money spent on prevention compares with money lost to failure.

What this page is doingThe paper explains why the costs had never been seen together and introduces the four categories only as the tool that solves that problem.
3

The Breakdown

Table 1

Cost of Quality, Last Year

CategoryWhat it includesAnnual costShare of quality cost
PreventionOperator training, preventive maintenance on sanders and spray booths, supplier qualification$20,0007%
AppraisalFinal inspection staff, incoming lumber checks, finish gloss testing$45,00016%
Internal failureScrapped doors, rework labor for sanding and refinishing, downtime from defects$90,00032%
External failureWarranty replacements, return freight, credits to remodelers, customer service time$125,00045%
Total$280,000100%

Table 1 sorts last year's quality-related spending.

Quality costs totaled $280,000, or 8 percent of sales. Failure, internal and external together, accounted for $215,000, about three-quarters of the total. Prevention received $20,000, about 7 percent. External failure, at $125,000, was the largest single category, which is the worst place for costs to concentrate: a defect found by a remodeler costs the door itself, freight both ways, a credit and, often, the customer's next order.

That distribution is typical of a firm that has not invested in prevention. Studies of cost of quality programs consistently report that shifting spending toward prevention reduces failure costs by more than the added prevention costs, lowering total quality cost (Schiffauerova & Thomson, 2006).

The categories also show where the plant's attention has been. Most of its quality spending goes to inspection and to handling defects after they occur, which is the pattern of a plant that has relied on catching problems rather than preventing them.

Where the Defects Come From

Table 2

Pareto Analysis of 400 Rejected Doors

Defect typeDoors rejectedShareCumulative share
Finish defects: blotching, runs, orange peel25062.5%62.5%
Joint gaps at rails and stiles7017.5%80%
Dimensional errors4511.25%91.25%
Wood defects: knots, splits256.25%97.5%
Other102.5%100%

A cost breakdown shows where money goes but not why. To find out, the quality lead classified the 400 doors rejected last year, whether at final inspection or after return, by defect type. Table 2 shows the result as a Pareto analysis, ordered from most to least frequent.

Finish defects account for 250 of the 400 rejects, more than three in five. Together with joint gaps, they account for 80 percent. Concentrating on a few causes that account for most of the problem is the core of Pareto analysis as applied to quality (Juran & De Feo, 2010).

The quality lead traced most finish defects to two causes. First, sanding practice: operators sand to different grits and pressures, and doors sanded unevenly absorb stain unevenly, producing blotches. Second, wood moisture: lumber arriving above 9 percent moisture content shrinks after finishing and causes the finish to crack and the joints to open, which also explains some of the joint gaps. Neither cause is checked systematically today.

Both causes are upstream of the spray booth, so checking doors after the spray booth can find the damage but never stop it. A blotched door is already ruined by the time an inspector sees it; the only choice left is to refinish it or scrap it.

What this page is doingThe Pareto analysis does not stop at counting defects; it traces the largest category to two specific causes that the cost breakdown alone could not reveal.
4

Where to Spend Instead

The breakdown and the Pareto analysis point in the same direction. The plant spends little on prevention, and its largest failure costs come from two preventable causes. The proposal spends $30,000 more a year on prevention, raising prevention spending from $20,000 to $50,000.

1. Operator training and a written sanding standard, with grit sequences and pressure for each door style: $12,000 a year.

2. Moisture meters at receiving and a rule to reject or condition lumber above 9 percent: $6,000 for meters plus $4,000 a year in conditioning time.

3. A sample door from each batch finished and checked before the full batch goes to the spray booth: $8,000 a year in labor.

If these measures cut finish defects by half and joint gaps by a third, rejects would fall by about 150 doors a year. Using the plant's average failure cost per rejected door, about $540, that would save roughly $80,000 a year in internal and external failure, more than twice the added prevention cost. Even if the effect were half as large, the program would still pay for itself.

The proposal does not cut appraisal yet. Final inspection should continue at its current level until the Pareto chart shows finish defects falling, so that the plant does not reduce its safety net before prevention has proved itself.

How to Know if It Works

The plant should repeat this breakdown every quarter, using the same categories, and track the Pareto chart monthly. Success looks like prevention rising as a share of quality cost, failure falling and total quality cost declining from 8 percent of sales toward 5 percent within two years. Finish defects should fall first, since they are the largest category and the most directly addressed. If they do not, the sanding standard or moisture rule is not being followed, and the next step is to check practice on the floor rather than to add more inspection.

References

Feigenbaum, A. V. (1956). Total quality control. Harvard Business Review, 34(6), 93-101.

Juran, J. M., & De Feo, J. A. (2010). Juran's quality handbook: The complete guide to performance excellence (6th ed.). McGraw-Hill.

Schiffauerova, A., & Thomson, V. (2006). A review of research on cost of quality models and best practices. International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management, 23(6), 647-669. https://doi.org/10.1108/02656710610672470

The MGT-455 Topic 4 assignment instructions

The Topic 4 instructions in MGT-455 ask students to analyze an organization's quality costs. Listing quality problems, or proposing more inspection, misses the analysis. The assignment rewards sorting actual spending into prevention, appraisal, internal failure and external failure, expressing the total as a share of sales and comparing how much goes to preventing defects with how much is lost to them. Students should use a tool such as a Pareto analysis to find which defects matter most, trace them to causes, propose spending that addresses those causes and estimate the return, with a plan to measure whether the change works.

How this MGT 455 Topic 4 example is built

The breakdown opens by explaining why quality costs had never been added up and introduces the four categories. Table 1 sorts last year's $280,000 into categories with shares. A paragraph notes that failure accounts for about three-quarters and prevention about 7 percent, with research on shifting spending toward prevention. Table 2 presents a Pareto analysis of 400 rejected doors. The largest category, finish defects, is traced to uneven sanding and wet lumber. Three prevention measures costing $30,000 are proposed with an estimated saving of about $80,000, and a closing section sets out how progress will be measured. Inspection is kept in place until prevention shows results.

Reading the MGT 455 Topic 4 rubric

Instructors grading the cost of quality breakdown reward categories applied correctly and totals that add up. Strong papers express quality cost as a share of sales and compare prevention with failure, with sources on why that comparison matters. Credit goes to a Pareto analysis that identifies the few defect types causing most rejects and traces them to causes. The rubric values proposals aimed at those causes, with the return estimated from the organization's own failure costs. The highest band sets up regular measurement to show whether the shift toward prevention works. Papers that recommend more inspection without examining causes usually lose marks. Category totals that reconcile to the stated share of sales let a reader check the breakdown.

MGT 455 Topic 4 help before you submit

Quality papers at the midpoint lose marks when defects are counted and never costed. A breakdown listing scrap rates and return percentages without converting them into dollars gives the company nothing to set beside its other spending. Misclassified lines are the next source of deductions: final inspection is appraisal rather than prevention, and a warranty claim is external failure even when the defect was created on the shop floor. Totals reported without a denominator, whether sales or total quality cost, give the reader no sense of scale. Proposals that cut appraisal to save money, with nothing added upstream, usually move defects from the internal category to the external one, where each costs more. A projected saving presented as certain, with no basis given for the estimated reduction, invites the question the marker will ask anyway.

Get an MGT-455 Topic 4 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-455 Topic 4 instructions and the grading rubric from your classroom, plus any cost data or company case the assignment provides. We write a custom example to those criteria, with every cost line categorized, totals stated against sales, a Pareto chart, causes traced and a prevention proposal priced, within 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MGT 455 papers and BS in Business Management samples

MGT 455 Topic 4 questions, answered

What are the four cost of quality categories?

Prevention covers spending that stops defects from occurring, such as training, process design and supplier qualification. Appraisal covers finding defects through inspection and testing. Internal failure covers defects caught before the customer receives the product, scrap and rework among them. External failure covers defects the customer finds, including warranty work, returns and lost goodwill, which is the hardest to measure and often the largest.

Why does moving money to prevention usually pay off?

Because a defect grows more expensive the further it travels. Stopping it at the source costs a little training or a better specification; catching it at inspection costs the materials and labor already spent; letting it reach the customer adds shipping, replacement and reputation. The example still prices the proposal rather than assuming the saving, since the pattern holds in general and has to be shown in particular.

Where does a Pareto chart fit in a cost of quality paper?

It tells the paper where to spend the prevention money. Ranking defects by frequency or cost usually shows a small number of types producing most of the failures, so effort aimed there returns the most. In the example, finish defects dominate, which is why the proposal targets sanding and wood moisture rather than spreading effort across every category.

Where can I find a free MGT 455 Topic 4 sample paper?

The door maker breakdown appears here in full, with both tables, the traced causes, the prevention proposal and the measurement plan. Tell us your organization's quality costs and a free breakdown can be prepared from them.

What does the Pareto chart show in MGT 455 Topic 4?

Finish defects account for 250 of 400 rejected doors, and with joint gaps they make up 80 percent. Both trace mainly to uneven sanding and lumber that arrives too wet.