| Course | MGT 460 Workforce Planning |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Build, buy or borrow comparison |
| Length | About 980 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 460 Topic 4
Eighteen Analysts, Three Deadlines, Three Routes: A Build, Buy or Borrow Comparison for an Insurer's Analytics Gap, Dated Before It Is Costed
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MGT-460: Workforce Planning
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Eighteen Analysts, Three Deadlines, Three Routes: A Build, Buy or Borrow Comparison for an Insurer's Analytics Gap, Dated Before It Is Costed
Dating the Gap
Prairie Mutual Insurance, a composite regional property and casualty insurer, plans to grow its data analytics team from 28 analysts today to 42 by December 2028. Four of the current analysts are projected to leave before then, based on the team's recent turnover, so internal supply is 24 and the gap is 18 analysts. All figures are illustrative.
The gap is not one number with one deadline. It breaks into three parts, each needed at a different time and for a different purpose, and the timing decides which options can fill each part.
1. Six analysts by June 2027, for the launch of a claims analytics program that flags suspicious claims for review.
2. Eight more by December 2028, for permanent pricing and reserving work as the insurer grows.
3. Four for a two-year regulatory reporting project, from early 2027 to early 2029, after which the work ends.
The Three Options
Build: train current employees, mainly experienced claims adjusters and underwriters with an interest in data, through a twelve-month analytics development program. The program costs about $22,000 per enrollee, and about four in five complete it. Built analysts know the insurer's products, claims processes and data, which external hires take time to learn.
Buy: hire experienced analysts from the market. External hiring fills a position in three to four months on average, with a recruiting cost of about $20,000 per hire and starting salaries about 10 percent above what a promoted internal analyst would earn.
Borrow: engage contract analysts through a staffing firm or a consultancy for a fixed term. Contractors start within weeks but cost about 60 percent more per hour than an employee and leave when the contract ends, taking their knowledge with them. Organizations increasingly use contract arrangements for work with a defined end, while keeping work that builds lasting capability in house (Cappelli & Keller, 2013).
Scoring Each Part of the Gap
Table 1
Options Scored Against Each Part of the Gap
| Part of the gap | Build | Buy | Borrow |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 by June 2027, claims analytics | Cannot meet date: 12-month program | Meets date; strong fit if hires have claims analytics experience | Meets date, but launch knowledge leaves with contractors |
| 8 by December 2028, permanent | Meets date; best fit; lowest cost | Meets date; higher salary cost | Poor fit for permanent work |
| 4 for two-year regulatory project | Wasteful: trained analysts would need new work in 2029 | Poor fit: permanent hires for temporary work | Best fit for defined, temporary work |
Table 1 scores each option for each part of the gap on lead time, cost and fit.
Why Each Part Goes Where It Does
The June 2027 claims analysts must be bought. Even if the development program started today, its first graduates would not finish until a year from now, and the launch requires analysts who can build models in the first months. Six external hires, recruited over the next six months, would cost about $120,000 in recruiting fees. To keep the knowledge in house, the insurer should pair each external hire with a claims professional who is enrolled in the development program, so that the launch builds internal capability too.
The eight permanent analysts for 2028 should be built. The work is ongoing, it benefits from knowing the insurer's products and data, and the deadline allows time for the program. Because about one in five enrollees do not complete it, the insurer should enroll ten to produce eight, at a program cost of about $220,000. Pricing and reserving analysis depends heavily on firm-specific knowledge, which is the kind of capability worth developing internally (Lepak & Snell, 1999).
The four regulatory analysts should be borrowed. The work ends in early 2029. Hiring permanent staff would leave the insurer with four analysts and no work for them; training internal staff would spend development money on skills needed only briefly. Contractors cost more per hour, but over two years that premium is smaller than the cost of carrying permanent staff beyond the project.
The pairing of external hires with internal enrollees also reduces a risk. Experienced analysts hired from outside often leave within two years for higher offers, and when they do, the insurer would lose the claims models they built. Pairing each with an internal colleague means someone who knows the work stays.
Costs Compared
Table 2
Costs of the Recommended Mix
| Part | Route | One-time cost | Ongoing premium |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 claims analysts | Buy | About $120,000 in recruiting | About 10 percent salary premium |
| 8 permanent analysts | Build, enrolling 10 | About $220,000 in program costs | None; internal pay scale |
| 4 regulatory analysts | Borrow | None | About 60 percent hourly premium for two years |
Table 2 summarizes the one-time and premium costs of the recommended mix.
The table leaves out one cost on purpose: the time of the experienced analysts who will mentor the ten development enrollees. That time is real, about two hours a week per enrollee, but it also builds the team's own capability and is better treated as part of the work than as an added cost.
Recommendation and Risks
The insurer should buy six analysts for the claims launch, build eight for permanent work by enrolling ten in the development program, and borrow four contractors for the regulatory project. This mix meets every date while keeping the most valuable, firm-specific work in house and avoiding permanent commitments for temporary work. Workforce plans that match each part of a gap to the route suited to its timing and duration are more resilient than plans that rely on a single source of talent (Cappelli, 2008).
Two risks should be watched. If the external market for claims analysts tightens, the June 2027 hires may take longer than four months; recruiting should begin immediately. And if completion in the development program falls below three in four, the insurer should enroll a second cohort early in 2027 to protect the 2028 target.
References
Cappelli, P. (2008). Talent on demand: Managing talent in an age of uncertainty. Harvard Business Press.
Cappelli, P., & Keller, J. R. (2013). Classifying work in the new economy. Academy of Management Review, 38(4), 575-596. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.2011.0302
Lepak, D. P., & Snell, S. A. (1999). The human resource architecture: Toward a theory of human capital allocation and development. Academy of Management Review, 24(1), 31-48. https://doi.org/10.2307/259035
What the MGT 460 Topic 4 instructions ask for
The Topic 4 instructions for MGT-460 ask students to compare options for closing a talent gap. Choosing one route for the whole gap, or comparing options before knowing when the people are needed, misses the analysis. The assignment rewards dating the gap first, splitting it by purpose and deadline, and then scoring building, buying and borrowing on lead time, cost and fit for each part. Students should explain why each part goes to its route, account for completion rates in development programs, compare costs on a consistent basis and name the risks to the recommended mix along with the action that would protect against each.
Inside the MGT 460 Topic 4 example
The paper opens by dating the gap and splitting it into three parts with different deadlines. The three options are described with their lead times, costs and strengths. Table 1 scores each option against each part of the gap. A section explains each assignment: buying for the June launch because development cannot finish in time, building for permanent work with ten enrollees to produce eight, and borrowing for the temporary regulatory project. Table 2 summarizes costs. The recommendation states the mix and names two risks, with actions to protect against each. Each option's lead time, cost and completion rate is labeled as illustrative.
Where the marks sit in the MGT 460 Topic 4 rubric
Instructors grading the comparison reward a gap dated before any option is discussed. Strong papers split the gap by purpose and deadline and rule out options that cannot meet a date regardless of cost. Credit goes to accounting for completion rates, to keeping firm-specific work in house and to using temporary arrangements for temporary work, with sources that support each choice. The rubric values a clear cost comparison and named risks with responses. The highest band pairs routes so that knowledge stays inside the organization even when talent is bought. Comparisons that choose one route for everything usually land in the lower bands. Labeled figures throughout let the reader follow every cost.
MGT 460 Topic 4 help: mistakes that cost marks
The comparison is judged mostly on whether time enters the decision. A table rating build, buy and borrow on cost alone, with no lead time, treats a twelve-month program and a three-month hire as interchangeable and usually recommends development for a deadline it cannot meet. Gaps presented as one total, with no dates, make that error invisible, since nothing shows the June launch. Papers that recommend contractors for permanent roles pay the premium indefinitely and lose the knowledge when the contract ends. Development plans assuming everyone enrolled will finish produce a shortfall nobody budgeted for. Cost per analyst compared for the first year only makes contracting look better than it is over the horizon. The weakest versions pick one option for all eighteen seats, which ignores that the gap has parts with different deadlines.
Get an MGT-460 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-460 Topic 4 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and whatever gap or case data the assignment provides. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the gap dated, permanent and temporary needs separated, each option scored on lead time and cost and a mixed recommendation, delivered in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More MGT 460 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- MGT 460 Topic 1: Planning Horizon Memo
- MGT 460 Topic 2: Headcount Demand Forecast
- MGT 460 Topic 3: Internal Supply Projection
- MGT 460 Topic 5: Critical Role Dq Post
- MGT 460 Topic 6: Succession Bench Review
- MGT 460 Topic 7: Multi-year Workforce Cost Model
- MGT 460 Topic 8: Freeze-tested Workforce Plan
- MGT 455 Topic 4: Cost of Poor Quality Breakdown
- MGT 440 Topic 4: Critical Path Calculation
- MGT 434 Topic 4: Internal Equity Pay Review
- BUS 317 Topic 4: Break-even Sensitivity Analysis
MGT 460 Topic 4 questions, answered
What does build, buy or borrow mean in workforce planning?
Three ways to close a talent gap. Build means developing existing employees into the roles through training, rotation or apprenticeship. Buy means hiring people who already have the skills from outside. Borrow means using contractors, consultants or temporary staff. Many courses add redeploy, moving people from roles being reduced, and some add redesigning the work so fewer people are needed.
Why is lead time so important in comparing options?
Because an option that cannot deliver people before the need arrives is not really an option for that part of the gap. Development is often cheaper per person and builds loyalty, but it takes months or years. Hiring is faster; contracting is fastest. Dating the gap shows which options are feasible for each deadline before cost is even considered.
When is borrowing talent the right choice?
When the need is temporary, urgent or highly specialized, and the organization does not need to keep the capability afterward. A two-year project is a typical case. For permanent roles, the premium paid to contractors continues for as long as the need does, and the knowledge they build leaves when they do, which usually makes hiring or development the better long-term choice.
Where can I find a free MGT 460 Topic 4 sample paper?
The insurer comparison is complete above, with the dated gap, the three options, the scoring table, the reasons for each choice, the cost table and the risks. Tell us about the gap you need to close and we can draft a free comparison for it.
Why can development not fill the June 2027 need in MGT 460 Topic 4?
The development program takes twelve months, so analysts who start it now would not finish until after the claims launch needs them. External hiring fills a seat in three to four months.