| Course | MGT 465 Employee Relations |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Grievance analysis |
| Length | About 960 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 465 Topic 2
Two Hundred Seventy-Six Dollars of Overtime and Three Steps Nobody Read the Contract: Analyzing One Seniority Grievance at a Union Warehouse
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MGT-465: Employee Relations
Topic 2 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Two Hundred Seventy-Six Dollars of Overtime and Three Steps Nobody Read the Contract: Analyzing One Seniority Grievance at a Union Warehouse
The Grievance
At Lakeview Distribution's Joliet warehouse, an order selector with nine years' seniority, Dana Kowalski, filed a grievance after being passed over for an eight-hour Saturday overtime shift. The shift went to a selector with two years' seniority. Article 14 of the collective bargaining agreement states that voluntary overtime within a job classification shall be offered in order of seniority, and that the employer shall keep a log of overtime offers. On its face, the article appears to have been violated. This analysis follows the grievance through four stages, identifies what each stage did and did not do, and prices the stakes. All details are illustrative.
Step One: The Supervisor
The grievance was filed with the shift supervisor, who answered in one line: "Denied. Operational need." The answer did not explain what operational need required the junior selector, did not refer to Article 14 and did not mention whether Kowalski had been called. A first-step answer is supposed to resolve disputes close to where they arise, with the people who know the facts. This one resolved nothing, because it did not engage with the grievance.
Step Two: The Operations Manager
At the second step, the operations manager met the steward and the grievant and issued a written denial citing Article 3, the management rights clause, which gives Lakeview the right to direct the workforce and schedule work. The answer did not address Article 14 at all.
That reasoning is weak. Management rights clauses generally reserve to management the decisions the agreement does not otherwise limit, and arbitrators commonly read a specific provision, such as an overtime-by-seniority article, as controlling over a general reservation of rights (Elkouri & Elkouri, 2016). Citing the general clause without explaining why the specific one did not apply would not hold up at arbitration.
Step Three: Labor Relations
Only at the third step did anyone pull the overtime call log required by Article 14. The labor relations representative found that the supervisor had called four selectors for the Saturday shift in order of seniority, skipping Kowalski, who was fifth on the list. There was no record of a call to Kowalski and no note explaining the skip. Asked later, the supervisor said he believed Kowalski did not like weekend work, based on a conversation months earlier, and had not checked.
With the log in hand, the grievance was plainly valid. The question at step three was no longer whether Article 14 had been violated but what remedy to offer.
The supervisor's assumption is a common source of overtime grievances. A conversation months earlier, in which an employee mentioned not liking weekend work, is not a waiver of a contractual right. Article 14 requires an offer; the employee decides whether to accept it.
What Arbitration Would Cost
The stakes are easy to price. Eight hours of overtime at time and a half on a $23 base rate is 8 times $34.50, or $276. That is the make-whole remedy an arbitrator would most likely award.
Taking the grievance to arbitration would cost far more. Lakeview's share of the arbitrator's fees and expenses, plus its outside counsel's preparation and hearing time, would come to roughly $6,000 for a one-day hearing. Given the call log, Lakeview would very probably lose. It would then pay the $276, its $6,000 in costs and lose some credibility with the union on future overtime disputes.
The numbers point to settling at step three: pay Kowalski $276, acknowledge the violation in writing and commit to following the call log. The step three representative did exactly that.
Settling also has a less visible benefit. A written acknowledgment that the call procedure was not followed, together with a commitment to follow it, signals to the union that management takes the agreement seriously, which can make the next dispute easier to resolve at an early step.
What the Process Shows
The grievance was resolved correctly, but two steps later than it should have been. Each earlier step had the information needed to resolve it. The supervisor knew he had skipped Kowalski. The operations manager could have read Article 14 and asked for the log. Instead, both treated the grievance as a challenge to management authority rather than a question about whether the agreement had been followed.
Research on grievance procedures has found that grievances settled at lower steps tend to be associated with better labor-management relations, and that the way grievances are handled shapes employees' views of fairness (Bemmels & Foley, 1996). A procedure in which the first two steps routinely deny without engaging wastes time, raises costs and teaches employees that only the third step listens.
There is also a broader point. Freeman and Medoff (1984) argued that one of a union's main functions is to give workers a collective voice, a channel to raise problems without quitting, and that a working grievance procedure is central to that voice. When the early steps do not function, the channel weakens, and the union's value to employees, and to management as a source of information about problems, falls with it.
Recommendations
Three changes would help. First, supervisors should check the overtime log before answering any overtime grievance, and the first-step form should require them to cite the article in question. Second, second-step answers should address the article the grievance cites, not only the management rights clause, and labor relations should review any second-step denial before it is issued. Third, supervisors should be reminded that Article 14 requires an actual call, not an assumption about who wants the work. A short refresher at the next supervisors' meeting, using this grievance as the example, would cost far less than one arbitration.
References
Bemmels, B., & Foley, J. R. (1996). Grievance procedure research: A review and theoretical recommendations. Journal of Management, 22(3), 359-384. https://doi.org/10.1177/014920639602200301
Elkouri, F., & Elkouri, E. A. (2016). How arbitration works (8th ed.). Bloomberg BNA.
Freeman, R. B., & Medoff, J. L. (1984). What do unions do? Basic Books.
Reading the GCU MGT 465 Topic 2 instructions
The Topic 2 instructions in MGT-465 ask students to analyze how a grievance moved through the procedure. A summary of who said what at each step will not show where the process failed. The assignment rewards an analysis that compares each step's answer with the agreement, explains why weak reasoning would fail before an arbitrator, identifies the step at which the facts were finally checked and prices the stakes of settling versus arbitrating. Students should draw on research about grievance procedures and employee voice, and close with practical changes that would let the early steps resolve similar grievances.
Inside the MGT 465 Topic 2 example
The paper opens with the grievance and the overtime article it cites. The supervisor's one-line denial is examined first. The second step's reliance on the management rights clause is tested against how arbitrators read specific and general provisions. The third step pulls the call log and finds that the senior selector was skipped on an assumption. A costing section compares the $276 remedy with about $6,000 in arbitration costs. A section on what the process shows draws on research about grievance resolution and on the role of a working procedure as employee voice, and three recommendations close the analysis. Every figure, from the hourly rate to the arbitration estimate, is labeled as illustrative.
Reading the MGT 465 Topic 2 rubric
Instructors grading the grievance analysis reward a close comparison of each step's answer with the contract. Strong papers explain why citing a general management rights clause would not defeat a specific overtime article. Credit goes to identifying the evidence that resolved the dispute and asking why earlier steps did not find it. The rubric values pricing the remedy against arbitration costs and drawing on research about grievance procedures and voice. The highest band recommends specific changes to how supervisors and managers answer grievances. Analyses that only narrate the steps, or that defend management's position without testing it, usually lose points. A short explanation of why the early steps failed, not just that they did, also counts.
MGT 465 Topic 2 help: mistakes that cost marks
Grievance papers score poorly when they describe the procedure as a ladder and never climb it with a case. A paper listing the steps and their time limits has summarized the agreement; the question set here is what each step is for and whether it did its work. Step answers accepted at face value, without asking what record supported them, miss the reason most grievances escalate. Writers who treat the management rights clause as a trump card overlook that arbitrators usually let a specific article govern over a general one. Recommending that the employer fight on principle, with no cost set against a small remedy, ignores what arbitration costs both sides. Papers that settle without stating a non-precedent basis create the very past practice the employer was trying to avoid.
Get an MGT-465 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-465 Topic 2 instructions and the rubric for it, with the grievance, agreement excerpt or case the assignment provides. A custom example comes back in 24 to 48 hours, with the grievance article and time limits set out, each step answer read against the record behind it, the escalation explained and a settlement priced against arbitration. The first one is free.
More MGT 465 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- MGT 465 Topic 1: Employment Relationship Analysis
- MGT 465 Topic 3: Progressive Discipline File Review
- MGT 465 Topic 4: Concerted Activity Analysis
- MGT 465 Topic 5: Informal Resolution Dq Post
- MGT 465 Topic 6: Workplace Investigation Report
- MGT 465 Topic 7: Bargaining Preparation Brief
- MGT 465 Topic 8: Relations Climate Evidence Review
- MGT 460 Topic 2: Headcount Demand Forecast
- MGT 455 Topic 2: Timed Process Flowchart
- BUS 317 Topic 2: Statement Reading Memo
- MGT 440 Topic 2: Project Charter
MGT 465 Topic 2 questions, answered
Why does a grievance procedure start with the supervisor?
Because the supervisor is closest to the facts and can usually offer the cheapest remedy while memories and records are fresh. Each later step adds authority and distance, which helps with disputes about interpretation but costs time. Many agreements are built so that most grievances end at the first or second step, and a procedure where nearly everything escalates usually signals weak early answers rather than difficult cases.
What does a non-precedent settlement do?
It resolves the individual grievance while both parties agree the resolution will not be cited as an interpretation of the agreement or as evidence of past practice. Employers use it when a particular case looks weak but the underlying contract reading still matters to them. The example recommends one because paying the 276 dollars without that wording could later be read as conceding how the overtime article works.
Is this legal advice about a real grievance?
It is not. This is coursework built on a composite case, and its time limits, rates and costs are illustrative. Real grievances turn on the wording of a specific collective agreement, the history between the parties and the applicable law, which is why labor relations staff and counsel handle them. The paper shows the reasoning a finished assignment is expected to demonstrate, nothing more.
Where can I find a free MGT 465 Topic 2 sample paper?
The overtime grievance analysis appears here with each step, the cost comparison, what the process shows and the recommendations. Share the grievance you are analyzing and the contract language, and a free analysis can be prepared.
Why does the management rights clause not win in MGT 465 Topic 2?
Arbitrators generally read a specific provision, such as an overtime-by-seniority article, as controlling over a general reservation of management rights, so citing the general clause alone would not answer the grievance.