MGT 475 Topic 6 employee monitoring assessment example

Technology in Human Resource Management Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 475 Topic 6 sample paper assesses three monitoring proposals at a composite grocery chain against two tests: whether each is lawful and whether it is sensible. It belongs to GCU MGT 475, Technology in Human Resource Management, listed as MGT-475 in the Grand Canyon University BS in Business Management. Fingerprint time clocks in the Illinois stores fall under the state's biometric privacy law, which requires notice, a signed release and a retention schedule. Round-the-clock tracking of managers' phones is generally lawful with notice but captures private lives. Keystroke logging is lawful but measures activity, not outcomes. Each proposal gets a recommendation and a data owner.

CourseMGT 475 Technology in Human Resource Management
TopicTopic 6
Paper typeMonitoring assessment
LengthAbout 980 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Business Management
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 475 Topic 6

1

Lawful and Sensible Are Two Different Tests: Assessing Fingerprint Time Clocks, Location Tracking and Keystroke Logging at a Grocery Chain

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

MGT-475: Technology in Human Resource Management

Topic 6 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the assessment's method, two tests for every proposal, and lists the three proposals. The chain and every detail are an illustrative composite; the statute and sources are real.
2

Lawful and Sensible Are Two Different Tests: Assessing Fingerprint Time Clocks, Location Tracking and Keystroke Logging at a Grocery Chain

Three Proposals

Prairie Market's operations team has proposed three forms of employee monitoring. First, replace badge time clocks in all 38 stores with fingerprint time clocks, to stop employees clocking in for each other. Second, track the location of the company phones issued to store managers, around the clock, to verify store visits. Third, install keystroke logging on the computers in the chain's customer service call center, to measure productivity.

Each proposal is assessed against two tests. The first is whether it is lawful where it would be used. The second is whether it is sensible: whether it achieves a business purpose that could not be met less intrusively, and whether its costs, including to employee trust, are worth that purpose. Monitoring can affect employees' stress, satisfaction and perceptions of fairness, and its effects depend heavily on how and why it is used (Ravid et al., 2020). All details are illustrative, and the legal points are general, not advice for a specific case.

Each proposal came from a real problem. Store managers reported that some employees clocked in for colleagues who arrived late. District directors could not easily confirm that managers visited all their assigned stores. And the call center's handle times had risen. The assessment takes each problem seriously; the question is whether the proposed monitoring is the right answer to it.

What this page is doingThe paper sets two separate tests before assessing anything, which is what lets it say that some lawful practices are still unwise.
3

Fingerprint Time Clocks

This proposal carries the sharpest legal risk, so it comes first. Prairie Market's Illinois stores fall under the state's biometric privacy law, which requires a private entity to inform people in writing before collecting a biometric identifier such as a fingerprint, to obtain a written release, and to publish a retention schedule and guidelines for destroying the data (Biometric Information Privacy Act, 2008). The law gives individuals a right to sue for violations, with damages per violation, and employers that installed fingerprint clocks without following its steps have faced large class actions.

If Prairie Market proceeds in Illinois, it must give written notice, obtain signed releases from every employee before enrolling them, publish its retention and destruction policy and make sure its time clock vendor follows the same rules. Employees who decline to sign need an alternative way to clock in.

The Indiana stores face no equivalent state statute. That does not make the practice sensible there. The business problem, employees clocking in for absent colleagues, can be addressed less intrusively with badge clocks that photograph the person clocking in, or with managers reviewing clock-in records against schedules. Collecting fingerprints creates data the chain must then protect; if it were breached, employees could not change their fingerprints as they could a password.

Recommendation: do not install fingerprint clocks. Use photo-capture badge clocks in all stores, which address buddy punching without collecting biometric data.

Location Tracking of Managers' Phones

Tracking the location of company-issued phones is generally lawful in most states when employees are told about it, though some states have notice requirements. The legal test is likely met if Prairie Market gives managers written notice.

The sensible test is not met as proposed. The business purpose is to verify that managers visit the stores they are responsible for during working hours. Tracking around the clock, including at night and on days off, captures where managers live, worship, seek medical care and spend their private time, for no business purpose. Workplace surveillance that extends beyond the work it is meant to oversee tends to damage trust and to be resented as intrusion (Ball, 2010).

Recommendation: if store visits need verifying, use the store's own systems, such as login records on the store's computer or a check-in at the store, rather than tracking phones. If location tracking is used at all, limit it to scheduled working hours and tell managers exactly when it is on.

Keystroke Logging in the Call Center

Keystroke logging on company computers is generally lawful when employees are told about it. The legal test is likely met.

The sensible test fails for a different reason: the data would not tell the chain what it wants to know. Keystroke counts measure typing activity, not whether customers' problems are solved. The call center already scores call quality, records handle time and tracks customer satisfaction after each call, all of which measure the work more directly. An agent who types less because they solved the problem on the first call would look less productive. Measures that count activity rather than outcomes tend to encourage activity for its own sake.

Recommendation: do not install keystroke logging. Use the existing quality and satisfaction measures, and review them with agents.

The rise in handle times that prompted the proposal also has a likely explanation in the call center's own data: a new product line launched in the spring generated more complex calls. Keystroke logging would not reveal that; the call center's existing reason codes for calls already do.

Summary and Data Ownership

Table 1

Monitoring Proposals Against Two Tests

ProposalLawful?Sensible?RecommendationData owner
Fingerprint time clocksOnly with notice, release and published policy in IllinoisNo: less intrusive alternatives existPhoto-capture badge clocks insteadPayroll manager
Location tracking of manager phonesGenerally yes, with noticeNo, as proposed: tracks private lifeStore check-ins; if tracking, working hours onlyStore operations director
Keystroke loggingGenerally yes, with noticeNo: measures activity, not outcomesUse existing quality measuresCall center manager

Table 1 summarizes the assessment.

Each recommendation names an owner for any data collected, who is accountable for its use, its security and its deletion. Monitoring data without an owner tends to be kept indefinitely and used for purposes nobody approved. The broader lesson for the operations team is that the absence of a law is not a reason to monitor; the reason must be a business purpose that the monitoring actually serves, by the least intrusive means available.

References

Ball, K. (2010). Workplace surveillance: An overview. Labor History, 51(1), 87-106. https://doi.org/10.1080/00236561003654776

Biometric Information Privacy Act, 740 Ill. Comp. Stat. 14/1 et seq. (2008).

Ravid, D. M., Tomczak, D. L., White, J. C., & Behrend, T. S. (2020). EPM 20/20: A review, framework, and research agenda for electronic performance monitoring. Journal of Management, 46(1), 100-126. https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206319869435

MGT 475 Topic 6 instructions, in plain terms

The Topic 6 instructions for MGT-475 ask students to evaluate proposals to monitor employees. Treating legality as the only question, or opposing all monitoring, misses the analysis. The assignment rewards applying two separate tests to each proposal: whether it complies with the laws where it would be used, and whether it serves a real business purpose by the least intrusive means. Students should explain relevant legal requirements accurately at a general level, take the business problem behind each proposal seriously, suggest less intrusive alternatives where they exist and assign an owner for any data collected, who is accountable for its use, security and deletion.

How the MGT-475 Topic 6 example is put together

The assessment opens with the three proposals and the problems behind them, then sets out the two tests with research on monitoring's effects. Fingerprint clocks are assessed first because of the Illinois biometric law, with a photo-capture alternative proposed. Location tracking is assessed as lawful with notice but intrusive beyond its purpose, with store check-ins proposed instead. Keystroke logging is assessed as lawful but uninformative, with existing quality measures and call reason codes pointing to the real cause of longer calls. Table 1 summarizes verdicts and data owners, and a closing paragraph states the general lesson.

MGT 475 Topic 6 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Instructors grading the monitoring assessment reward two distinct tests applied to every proposal. Strong papers describe legal requirements accurately without overstating them and recognize that the absence of a law does not settle the question. Credit goes to taking each business problem seriously and proposing a less intrusive way to address it. The rubric values research on monitoring's effects on trust and fairness, and naming an owner for any data collected. The highest band shows that a proposal can fail the sensible test for different reasons, intrusion in one case and uninformative data in another. Assessments that stop at legality usually lose marks.

Common MGT 475 Topic 6 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Monitoring papers slip most when the legal and the wise are folded into one judgment. A paper concluding that keystroke logging is acceptable because it is legal has stopped after the first of two questions and ignored what the practice communicates. The reverse error, condemning every measure as an invasion of privacy, skips the operational problems the chain actually has and offers no alternative. Summarizing the Illinois statute as a general privacy rule loses the specific steps that create liability when they are missed. Papers that invoke HIPAA for employee information held by an employer usually misstate its reach, since the rule governs health plans and providers rather than personnel files, though other laws still protect employee medical records. Recommendations that never say how long data is kept or who may see it leave the collection with no limit.

Get an MGT-475 Topic 6 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-475 Topic 6 instructions and the rubric for it, along with any monitoring practice, state or organization the case names. A custom example comes back in 24 to 48 hours, written to them, with the business reason stated, the legal position set out by state, the wisdom question asked separately, alternatives compared and retention and ownership fixed. The first one is free.

More MGT 475 papers and BS in Business Management samples

MGT 475 Topic 6 questions, answered

Is employee monitoring legal in the United States?

Much of it is, on employer-owned systems and with notice, though the rules differ from state to state and by method. Some states require written notice of electronic monitoring, Illinois regulates biometric collection closely, and federal law limits interception of certain communications. Monitoring that touches protected activity raises separate issues. The example sets out the position for its two states for study purposes only, never as advice.

Why does the assessment reject keystroke logging if it is lawful?

Because it answers the wrong question. The center's concern is whether customers are being helped, and keystroke counts measure typing, not help. The center already reviews recorded calls for quality, which speaks to the actual concern directly. Adding logging would signal distrust to sixty employees while producing data nobody could use to improve service, so the assessment judges it unwise on usefulness alone.

Does HIPAA cover the health information an employer holds?

Generally not in the employer's role as employer. HIPAA's privacy rule applies to health plans, health care providers and clearinghouses, so a sick note in a personnel file is usually outside it. Other rules still apply: the ADA requires medical information about employees to be kept confidential and stored apart from the general personnel file. None of this is offered as legal guidance.

Where can I find a free MGT 475 Topic 6 sample paper?

The monitoring assessment is complete above, with the three proposals, the two tests, each assessment, the summary table and data owners. Describe the monitoring your organization is considering, and a free assessment can be prepared.

Why reject fingerprint clocks in MGT 475 Topic 6?

In Illinois they require written notice, signed releases and a published retention policy, and everywhere they create sensitive data that cannot be changed if breached, while photo-capture badge clocks address buddy punching without it.