| Course | MGT 640 Fundamentals of Project Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Governance audit paper |
| Length | About 950 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 640 Topic 3
Forty-One Agenda Items, Six Decisions: Auditing a Year of Steering Committee Minutes for a Claims System Project, and the Scope Cut Nobody Approved
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MGT-640: Fundamentals of Project Management
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Forty-One Agenda Items, Six Decisions: Auditing a Year of Steering Committee Minutes for a Claims System Project, and the Scope Cut Nobody Approved
Purpose and Method
Larkspur Mutual's claims platform replacement has had a steering committee for twelve months. The committee includes the chief operating officer as sponsor, the claims vice president, the chief information officer, the finance director and the vendor's account executive. Its charter says it exists to make decisions the project manager cannot make alone. This audit asks whether it did.
The audit reviewed the minutes of all twelve monthly meetings and classified every agenda item by what the minutes show happened. An item was a decision if the minutes record an option chosen and an owner for carrying it out. It was a status report if the committee received information and noted it. It was deferred if the minutes record that it would be taken up later. All figures are illustrative.
What the Minutes Show
Table 1
Steering Committee Agenda Items Over Twelve Months
| Classification | Items | Share | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Decision: option chosen, owner named | 6 | 15% | Approve test environment purchase; approve change to go-live sequence |
| Status report: received and noted | 29 | 71% | Monthly progress update; budget status; vendor staffing |
| Deferred | 6 | 15% | Data retention policy (deferred twice); training approach (deferred twice) |
| Total | 41 | 100% |
Table 1 summarizes the 41 agenda items.
In twelve months, the committee made six decisions, an average of one every two meetings. Nearly three-quarters of its agenda consisted of reports it received. Four of the six deferred items were deferred twice, meaning they returned to the agenda and were again put off. Most decisions the minutes record were relatively minor purchases or sequencing changes.
The deferred items are worth a closer look. The data retention policy was deferred twice because the chief information officer and the claims vice president disagreed about how long to keep claim images, and the committee never asked either of them to bring options. Deferring a disagreement does not resolve it; it moves the cost of the delay onto the project team, which cannot finish the archive design without an answer.
The Item That Changed the Project Most
One item stands out. In month seven, the vendor reported that the project was running five months behind schedule. To hold the budget, the vendor proposed dropping the subrogation module, the part of the system that would manage the recovery of claim payments from other parties, such as at-fault drivers' insurers. The minutes for that meeting record: "Vendor update on revised schedule and scope noted. Project to continue on revised plan."
No one approved the reduced scope. No option was chosen, no owner was named and no one asked what dropping the module would do to the business case. The audit traced that question. In the approved business case, improved subrogation recoveries supplied about a fifth of the project's projected benefits. Dropping the module removed that benefit, yet the business case was never revisited, and the project continues to report against the original benefit figures.
In effect, the most important scope decision of the year was made by the vendor and recorded as a status update. The committee was told, and it noted what it was told.
Diagnosis
The committee has functioned as an audience rather than a decision-making body. Three features of how it works explain why. First, its agenda is built around updates from the project manager and the vendor, so most meeting time goes to hearing them. Second, the minutes do not distinguish decisions from information, so a scope change can be recorded in the same words as a progress report. Third, no one on the committee speaks for the project's benefits; the claims vice president attends, but no member is accountable for whether subrogation recoveries, or any other benefit, materialize.
Project governance is meant to give a project direction and to hold it to the purpose for which it was approved, and a governing body that only receives information cannot do either (Too & Weaver, 2014). Research on project sponsorship has also found that sponsors and steering groups contribute most when they actively decide and remove obstacles, not when they monitor passively (Crawford et al., 2008).
The vendor's place on the committee adds to the problem. The vendor's account executive attends every meeting and presents most updates, which gives the vendor a strong influence over what the committee hears and how it is framed. A vendor should report to the committee, not sit as one of its members when decisions about the vendor's own scope are being made.
Recommendations
Three changes would make the committee a decision-making body.
1. Decision rights. The committee's charter should list the decisions reserved to it, including any change to scope, any change to the go-live date of more than one month and any change in budget above the project manager's limit. A vendor proposal that touches any of these goes to the committee as a decision item with options, not as an update.
2. A decision log. Every meeting ends by recording each decision, the option chosen, the owner and the date. Status reports are circulated in writing before the meeting and discussed only if a member raises a question.
3. A seat for the benefits. The claims vice president should be named benefit owner, accountable for the subrogation and other benefits in the business case, and should report at each meeting whether they remain achievable.
The immediate action is to bring the subrogation decision back to the committee as a formal item: either restore the module in a later phase or revise the business case to remove its benefit. Leaving the business case unchanged while the scope has changed misstates the project's value to the board (Project Management Institute, 2021).
References
Crawford, L., Cooke-Davies, T., Hobbs, B., Labuschagne, L., Remington, K., & Chen, P. (2008). Governance and support in the sponsoring of projects and programs. Project Management Journal, 39(Suppl.), S43-S55. https://doi.org/10.1002/pmj.20059
Project Management Institute. (2021). A guide to the project management body of knowledge (PMBOK guide) (7th ed.). Project Management Institute.
Too, E. G., & Weaver, P. (2014). The management of project management: A conceptual framework for project governance. International Journal of Project Management, 32(8), 1382-1394. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2013.07.006
The MGT-640 Topic 3 assignment instructions
Topic 3 of MGT-640 turns to governance, the structures that authorize, oversee and correct a project above the project manager. The prompt asks students to examine how a governing body such as a steering committee works in practice and whether it exercises the authority its charter gives it. Papers meet the brief when they gather evidence of what the body did, classify that evidence and compare it against the decisions it was supposed to make. A graduate response draws on governance research, identifies the most consequential gap between authority and action, explains its effect on the business case and recommends changes to decision rights, records or membership. Description of who sits on the committee is expected only as context for the analysis.
Inside the MGT 640 Topic 3 example
The finished audit is a table of 41 agenda items from twelve monthly meetings, all figures labeled illustrative, each classified by what the minutes show happened. Six items were decisions, with an option chosen and an owner. Twenty-nine were status reports received and noted. Six were deferred, four of them twice. The audit then isolates the item that changed the project most: in month seven the vendor reported a five-month delay and proposed dropping the subrogation module to hold the budget, and the minutes record only that the update was noted. No one approved the reduced scope, and no one revisited the business case, although subrogation recoveries supplied a fifth of its projected benefit. The audit concludes that the committee functioned as an audience and recommends decision rights, a decision log and a seat for the benefits owner.
Where the marks sit in the MGT 640 Topic 3 rubric
The rubric rewards evidence over description in this audit. An Excellent paper sets out its method for classifying agenda items and applies it consistently, so the gap between meetings held and decisions taken is measured instead of asserted. Graders look for the single most consequential item and a clear account of what it cost the business case, here a scope cut that removed a fifth of the projected benefit. Credit goes to a diagnosis that reads the charter against the minutes and answers the likely defense from the project manager. Recommendations earn marks when each one closes a specific gap, such as decision rights, a decision log and a seat for the benefits owner. Governance and project oversight literature supports the argument throughout.
MGT 640 Topic 3 help before you submit
A governance paper that describes the committee's membership and meeting schedule has documented a structure without examining what it did. Audits that never classify agenda items cannot see the gap between receiving and deciding, which is usually the central finding. Treating a minuted note as approval misreads the record, since the word noted commits nobody to anything. Papers that find the month-seven item and discuss only the delay miss the larger consequence, which is that a fifth of the benefit left the case with no one accepting its loss. Recommendations for better communication or more frequent meetings add activity to a body that already meets and decides little. A graduate paper also weighs the likeliest defense, that the project manager framed the change as an update, and shows why the charter still placed the decision with the committee.
Get an MGT-640 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-640 Topic 3 instructions, your section's rubric and any minutes, charter or governance case the assignment supplies. A custom example is written to those requirements, with every item classified by one test, the consequential item reconstructed, patterns identified and decision rights proposed, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More MGT 640 papers and MBA samples
- MGT 640 Topic 1: Strategic Initiative Triage Memo
- MGT 640 Topic 2: Competing Business Case Appraisal
- MGT 640 Topic 4: Methodology Fit Assessment
- MGT 640 Topic 5: Stopping Criterion Dq Post
- MGT 640 Topic 6: Portfolio Resource Contention Analysis
- MGT 640 Topic 7: Benefits Realization Review
- MGT 640 Topic 8: Governance Failure Diagnosis
- MGT 641 Topic 3: Backlog Ordering Rationale
- MGT 605 Topic 3: Transformational and Servant Models
- MGT 655 Topic 3: Process and Capacity Analysis
- LDR 670 Topic 3: Cross Border Negotiation Analysis
MGT 640 Topic 3 questions, answered
What should a project steering committee actually decide?
Typically the things no one below it has authority to settle: approval to proceed at each gate, changes to scope, cost or schedule beyond the project manager's limits, changes that alter the business case, and whether to continue at all. Status reporting supports those decisions but is not one of them. The example writes these into the charter as decisions the committee must record.
Why does it matter that the minutes say noted?
Because noted records that information was received, not that anyone accepted its consequences. When a change that removes part of the benefit is only noted, the organization has changed its investment without deciding to. Later, nobody can say who accepted the reduced case. The audit treats the wording as evidence of how the committee understood its own role.
Can this audit use real minutes from a workplace?
Many sections allow it, and real minutes make the classification concrete. Remove names, figures and anything commercially sensitive, and check whether your employer's policies permit sharing internal records in coursework. A composite committee, like the insurer's in the example, lets the audit show the same patterns without those concerns, and it usually suffices when the assignment does not require a real organization.
Where can I find a free MGT 640 Topic 3 sample paper?
The steering committee audit is printed here from start to finish: the method, the classified agenda items, the month-seven scope cut, the diagnosis and three recommendations. Describe the committee or minutes you are reviewing and a free audit can be written around them.
What did the MGT 640 Topic 3 audit find?
Of 41 agenda items, only six were decisions with an owner. The rest were noted or deferred, including the vendor's month-seven proposal to drop the subrogation module, which removed a fifth of the projected benefit without approval.