MGT 640 Topic 5 stopping criterion dq post example

Fundamentals of Project Management Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 640 Topic 5 sample paper takes the position that a composite insurer should halt its telematics program this quarter, in an initial discussion post and one classmate reply. The course is GCU MGT 640, Fundamentals of Project Management, catalog code MGT-640, in the Grand Canyon University MBA with an Emphasis in Project Management. The approved case assumed 20 percent of eligible auto policyholders would enroll within a year; the pilot has reached 3 percent. Of a 12.5 million dollar budget, 9.0 million is gone, and the post sets that money aside as unrecoverable. It asks only what the remaining 3.5 million buys, answers the strongest case for continuing and cites Staw on escalation of commitment.

CourseMGT 640 Fundamentals of Project Management
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeDiscussion post and reply
LengthAbout 470 words, 3 pages
FormatDiscussion post, APA 7 citations
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 640 Topic 5

1

Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply

Stop the Telematics Program This Quarter: Setting Aside $9 Million Already Spent and Asking What the Remaining $3.5 Million Buys

Initial Post

Stop the telematics program this quarter.

Here are the facts in the composite insurer I am using, all illustrative. Fourteen months ago, the investment committee approved a program offering auto policyholders a discount for installing a driving-behavior app. The business case assumed 20 percent of eligible policyholders would enroll within a year of launch, allowing more accurate pricing and lower claims. The pilot, running for eleven months in two states, has reached 3 percent enrollment. Of a $12.5 million budget, $9.0 million has been spent.

The $9.0 million is gone whatever the insurer does next. It cannot be recovered by continuing or by stopping, so it should play no part in the decision. The only question is whether the remaining $3.5 million buys a benefit worth having. At 3 percent enrollment, it does not: the pricing data are too thin to improve rates, and the discounts are paid mostly to careful drivers who were already low risk.

The strongest counterargument is that enrollment will rise once the discounts become visible to policyholders at renewal. The pilot's own data answer it. Pilot policyholders saw their discounts at their first renewal six months ago, averaging about 7 percent, and enrollment rose from 2.4 to 3.0 percent afterward, not toward 20. There is no evidence that visibility will close a gap that large.

Staw (1976) showed that decision makers who had chosen a course themselves were more willing to commit additional resources to it after negative results, which helps explain why programs like this continue past the point the evidence supports. That is the risk here: the sponsor and committee approved the program and may be reluctant to admit it has not worked.

My question for the class: what stopping criterion should the committee have written when it approved the program? I would suggest something like enrollment of at least 10 percent after twelve months, or the program returns to the committee for a decision to continue.

What this page is doingThe post states its verdict in one line, sets aside sunk costs explicitly and answers the strongest counterargument with the program's own data.
2

Reply to Alex

Alex, you suggested continuing at reduced scope, keeping the app running in the two pilot states but stopping expansion, so the insurer does not waste the work already done. I see the appeal; it avoids writing off the whole program. But reduced scope still spends money for a benefit the data do not show is coming, and the work already done is sunk either way. Research on software projects that escalate has found that teams often continue failing projects in modified form rather than stopping them, partly to avoid admitting failure (Keil et al., 2000). Would you set a deadline and an enrollment target for the reduced program, so that it does not continue indefinitely on the same hope?

What this page is doingThe reply recognizes what the classmate's proposal tries to protect and asks for the one thing that would keep it from becoming another open-ended commitment.
3

References

Keil, M., Mann, J., & Rai, A. (2000). Why software projects escalate: An empirical analysis and test of four theoretical models. MIS Quarterly, 24(4), 631-647. https://doi.org/10.2307/3250950

Staw, B. M. (1976). Knee-deep in the big muddy: A study of escalating commitment to a chosen course of action. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 16(1), 27-44. https://doi.org/10.1016/0030-5073(76)90005-2

MGT 640 Topic 5 instructions, in plain terms

The Topic 5 discussion question in MGT-640 asks when a project should be stopped and how sunk costs and escalation of commitment shape that decision. Students post an initial response and then reply to classmates during the week. A post fits the brief when it takes a clear position on a specific project, separates money already spent from money still to be spent, and uses evidence to judge whether the remaining investment is justified. Graduate posts are expected to cite research on escalation, address the strongest argument for continuing and say what governance should have been in place from the start. Replies should extend a classmate's point with a new consideration, not repeat agreement, and both pieces should stay concise and readable on a discussion board.

How this MGT 640 Topic 5 example is built

The post opens with its verdict: stop the telematics program this quarter. The facts follow, all labeled illustrative. The case approved fourteen months ago assumed 20 percent of eligible auto policyholders would enroll within a year of launch; the pilot has reached 3 percent. Of a 12.5 million dollar budget, 9.0 million is spent. The post sets the spent money aside, since it cannot be recovered whatever happens next, and asks only whether the remaining 3.5 million buys a benefit worth having. At 3 percent enrollment it does not. The post then concedes the strongest counterargument, that enrollment may rise once pricing discounts become visible, and answers it with the pilot's own discount data. It cites Staw on escalation of commitment for one claim only and ends by asking what stopping criterion should have been written at approval.

Reading the MGT 640 Topic 5 rubric

Instructors grading the post look first for a decision stated plainly and backed by the case's own figures. An Excellent post applies the sunk cost principle to a named project, here by setting aside 9.0 million and judging only the remaining 3.5 million against what 3 percent enrollment can return. Credit goes to engaging the best counterargument with evidence instead of dismissing it, and to citing escalation research for a specific claim rather than as decoration. The rubric also values the forward-looking point that a stopping criterion belongs in the approval itself. Replies earn marks when they add something the classmate missed. Posts meet the length and citation expectations of the discussion forum and remain courteous and professional throughout.

MGT 640 Topic 5 help before you submit

Stopping posts lose credit most often by discussing sunk cost in general and never applying it. A reply explaining that past spending should not drive future decisions has restated a principle every classmate already knows, and it names no project where the principle is hard to follow. Posts that count the 9.0 million already spent as a reason to finish have made exactly the error under discussion. Recommending continuation with closer monitoring defers the decision and sets no point at which it must be taken. Replies that ignore the strongest case for continuing look one-sided, and a classmate will supply it. A post that never mentions the missing stopping criterion leaves out the graduate point, which is that the hardest part of stopping is deciding at approval what would justify it.

Get an MGT-640 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-640 Topic 5 discussion question and the participation rubric for your section, with any project the prompt describes. A custom example is written to those criteria, with the verdict first, assumption set against evidence, spent money separated, the best counterargument answered, one source used narrowly and a question for classmates, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MGT 640 papers and MBA samples

MGT 640 Topic 5 questions, answered

What is escalation of commitment?

The tendency to keep investing in a failing course of action, often more heavily after negative feedback, particularly when the decision maker is personally responsible for the original choice. Barry Staw's experiments are the usual starting point for the literature. Project sponsors are exposed to it because their reputation is tied to the project, which is one reason the example argues for stopping criteria set in advance.

Is stopping a project the same as failing?

Not in the sense that matters for governance. A project stopped because its case no longer holds has released the remaining budget and people for better uses, which is the portfolio working as intended. The failure, where there is one, usually lies earlier, in approving a case without a condition that would end it. The post makes that distinction explicitly.

What does a good stopping criterion look like?

A measurable condition, a date for checking it and the person who decides, all agreed at approval. For the telematics program that might read: if enrollment is below 10 percent of eligible policyholders twelve months after launch, the sponsor brings a stop recommendation to the portfolio board. The post itself leaves the drafting to classmates, so the thread can compare versions.

Where can I find a free MGT 640 Topic 5 sample paper?

Both the telematics post and the reply to Alex appear here in full, with the enrollment figures, the spent and remaining budget and the answer to the case for continuing. Paste your discussion question and we can write a free post and reply for it.

Why stop the telematics program in MGT 640 Topic 5?

The case assumed 20 percent enrollment within a year and the pilot reached 3 percent. Setting aside the 9.0 million already spent, the remaining 3.5 million cannot buy a benefit worth having at that enrollment level.