MGT 640 Topic 7 benefits realization review example

Fundamentals of Project Management Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 640 Topic 7 sample paper reviews whether a claims intake project delivered its three promised benefits eighteen months after go-live at a composite insurer. It sits in GCU MGT 640, Fundamentals of Project Management, catalog code MGT-640, within the Grand Canyon University MBA with an Emphasis in Project Management. Auto claims cycle time was meant to fall from 21 days to 16 and stands at 19, because adjuster assignment was never redesigned. Intake staffing shrank by 6 positions instead of 18, saving about 0.37 million dollars a year rather than 1.1 million. Customer satisfaction cannot be judged at all after the survey vendor changed. No benefit ever had a named owner.

CourseMGT 640 Fundamentals of Project Management
TopicTopic 7
Paper typeBenefits realization review
LengthAbout 960 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 640 Topic 7

1

Three Promised Benefits, One Partly Delivered and None Owned: A Benefits Realization Review of a Claims Intake Project Eighteen Months After Go-Live

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

MGT-640: Fundamentals of Project Management

Topic 7 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title gives the review's verdict in one line, including the gap it traces most of the shortfall to, the absence of benefit owners. The insurer and every figure are an illustrative composite; the sources are real.
2

Three Promised Benefits, One Partly Delivered and None Owned: A Benefits Realization Review of a Claims Intake Project Eighteen Months After Go-Live

What Was Promised

Two years ago, Larkspur Mutual approved a project to rebuild its auto claims intake: a new online and phone first-notice-of-loss process, automated triage of incoming claims and integration with the claims platform. The project went live eighteen months ago, on time and slightly under budget, and was closed as a success. This review asks a different question: did it deliver the benefits in the approved business case? The case promised three. All figures are illustrative.

Closing a project as a success at go-live is common practice. The project manager's measures, scope, schedule and budget, are known at that point, while the benefits take months or years to appear. But a project approved for its benefits should be judged on them as well, which is why this review was requested by the portfolio board.

The Three Benefits

Table 1

Promised Benefits Against What Can Be Shown

Benefit in the business caseTargetTodayStatus
Auto claims cycle time, report to settlementFrom 21 days to 1619 daysPartly delivered
Intake staffing reduced through attrition18 fewer positions, saving $1.1M a year6 fewer positions, saving about $0.37MPartly delivered
Customer satisfaction with claims intakeUp 10 pointsCannot be assessedUnknown

Table 1 sets each promised benefit beside what can be shown today.

Cycle Time: Faster Intake, Unchanged Assignment

Cycle time fell from 21 days to 19, not 16. Breaking the cycle into stages shows why. Intake, from first report to a claim being opened in the system, fell from about four days to under one, which is what the project built. But the next stage, assigning the claim to an adjuster, did not change at about three days, and the rest of the cycle was unaffected. The business case had assumed that adjuster assignment would be redesigned to use the new automated triage, routing simple claims straight to a fast-track team. That redesign was listed as a dependency in the business case, but it was never assigned to anyone and never happened. The project delivered its part; the benefit depended on a change outside it that no one owned.

The fast-track team itself would cost little: the claims unit estimated that four experienced adjusters could handle the simple claims that make up about a third of auto volume. The dependency was not expensive; it was simply unowned.

What this page is doingBreaking the cycle into stages shows exactly where the benefit stopped, which turns a missed target into a specific, fixable gap.
3

Staffing: Calls That Kept Coming

The intake team was expected to shrink by 18 positions through attrition, as policyholders moved to online reporting. It shrank by 6, saving about $0.37 million a year rather than $1.1 million. Online reporting grew as expected, to about 40 percent of new claims. But policyholders who reported online kept phoning to check the status of their claims, because the online process did not show status. Twelve intake staff whose positions would have been eliminated were reassigned to answer those calls. The status-checking problem was not in the project's scope, and nobody was responsible for watching whether staff actually left as positions emptied.

The status calls were predictable. Policyholders who report a claim want to know what happens next, and the old phone process had given them a person to ask. The new online process did not replace that conversation with anything, so policyholders simply went back to the phone. A benefit owner reviewing the process before go-live might well have caught the gap.

Satisfaction: A Measure That Disappeared

The case promised a 10-point rise in customer satisfaction with claims intake, measured by the insurer's post-claim survey. Six months after go-live, the insurer changed survey vendors. The new vendor uses a different scale and different questions, and the old and new scores cannot be compared. No one checked whether the project's benefit measure would survive the change. As a result, the benefit cannot be assessed at all.

The loss of the measure also means the insurer cannot tell whether the new intake process improved or harmed the experience. Policyholders may value the online option, or they may be frustrated by the status gap; without a consistent measure, neither can be shown.

A single question to the project team before the switch would have kept the measure.

The Common Cause

Each shortfall has a different immediate cause, but they share one underlying cause: no benefit had a named owner. The project manager owned delivering the system, and did. The business case named benefits but did not assign anyone to realize them, to manage the dependencies outside the project or to protect the measures. When the project closed, there was no one left to watch.

Benefits management treats benefits as things that must be actively managed after delivery, with owners in the business, because a new system rarely produces benefits without changes in how people work (Ward & Daniel, 2012). Research has found that projects with benefits management practices are more likely to be judged successful in delivering their intended value (Badewi, 2016; Serra & Kunc, 2015).

Recommendations

First, assign the adjuster assignment redesign to the claims vice president as owner of the cycle time benefit, with a target of 16 days within a year. Second, add claim status to the online process, owned by the digital channels director, so that online reporters stop calling; the intake manager should then track headcount against the 18-position target. Third, re-baseline customer satisfaction on the new survey and set a new target, since the original benefit can no longer be measured. Finally, both the cycle time and staffing measures should be reported to the portfolio board each quarter until the targets are met or formally revised. For future projects, the business case should not be approved until each benefit has an owner who will remain accountable after the project closes.

References

Badewi, A. (2016). The impact of project management (PM) and benefits management (BM) practices on project success: Towards developing a project benefits governance framework. International Journal of Project Management, 34(4), 761-778. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2015.05.005

Serra, C. E. M., & Kunc, M. (2015). Benefits realisation management and its influence on project success and on the execution of business strategies. International Journal of Project Management, 33(1), 53-66. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2014.03.011

Ward, J., & Daniel, E. (2012). Benefits management: How to increase the business value of your IT projects (2nd ed.). Wiley.

Reading the GCU MGT 640 Topic 7 instructions

Topic 7 in MGT-640 looks past project closure to the question executives actually care about: did the investment deliver the benefits that justified it? The brief asks students to evaluate a completed project against its approved business case and to explain any gap between promised and realized value. A review satisfies the prompt when it lists each benefit as approved, sets current evidence beside it, judges what was delivered and traces each shortfall to its cause. Graduate work should draw on benefits management research, be honest when a measure no longer allows comparison, and separate technology problems from business changes that were never made. Recommendations should assign ownership and reporting so that remaining benefits can still be pursued after the project team has disbanded.

How this MGT 640 Topic 7 example is built

The finished review lists the three benefits in the approved case beside what can be shown today, all figures labeled illustrative. Auto claims cycle time was to fall from 21 days to 16 and now sits at 19, because intake got faster while adjuster assignment, which the case assumed would be redesigned, never changed. Intake staffing was to shrink by 18 positions through attrition, saving 1.1 million dollars a year; it shrank by 6, saving about 0.37 million, since policyholders kept phoning and staff were moved to answer them. Customer satisfaction cannot be assessed at all, because the survey vendor changed and the measure changed with it. No benefit had a named owner. The review recommends assigning the adjuster redesign to the claims vice president and reporting both measures to the portfolio board each quarter.

Reading the MGT 640 Topic 7 rubric

Graders award an Excellent review for evidence set against each promise, one benefit at a time. The rubric rewards a paper that uses the business case's own measures, reports what can be shown today and refuses to estimate where the measure has changed, as with the satisfaction survey here. Credit goes to diagnosis that finds the specific unmade business change behind a shortfall, such as the adjuster assignment redesign, rather than blaming the system. Strong papers name the common cause across benefits, which in this case is the absence of owners. Recommendations score highest when they assign named owners and regular reporting to the portfolio board. Benefits management literature, including Ward and Daniel, supports the analysis, and every figure is clearly labeled illustrative.

Common MGT 640 Topic 7 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Benefit reviews forfeit credit fastest by stopping at the closure report and treating on-time delivery as proof the investment worked. A paper that restates the promised benefits and assumes they arrived has reviewed nothing, and the case's own measures are the obvious place to check. Verdicts without evidence, or with a changed measure passed off as comparable, cannot be trusted, and the satisfaction benefit here is honestly unmeasurable. Reviews that blame the system for the cycle time shortfall miss that the missing piece was a business change nobody owned. Recommendations to communicate benefits better leave the ownership gap in place. Graduate reviews also address the most tempting alternative explanation, that the case was simply optimistic, and show that the shortfall traces to specific unmade changes rather than to arithmetic.

Get an MGT-640 Topic 7 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-640 Topic 7 instructions and the rubric for it, with the project, business case or closure data the assignment supplies. A custom example comes back in 24 to 48 hours, with the approved case quoted, benefits mapped to the changes they needed, each verdict evidenced, owners traced and a portfolio rule proposed. The first one is free.

More MGT 640 papers and MBA samples

MGT 640 Topic 7 questions, answered

What is a benefits dependency network?

A technique associated with John Ward and Elizabeth Daniel's work on benefits management, which links an investment's objectives to the benefits expected, the business changes those benefits require and the technology that enables them. Its value lies in showing that most benefits depend on changes people must make, not on the system alone. The example uses a simplified version to explain the cycle time shortfall.

How is benefits realization different from project closure?

Closure confirms that the project delivered what it was chartered to produce and releases its resources. Benefits realization asks, usually months later, whether those outputs changed the organization's results as the case promised. The two are judged against different documents, the charter and the business case, and a project can pass the first while failing the second, as this one did.

What should happen when a benefit cannot be measured?

The review should say so plainly rather than estimate a result. Here the satisfaction measure changed when the survey vendor did, so no before and after comparison is valid. The recommendation is to agree a stable measure now and a baseline from current data, and to record in the portfolio's lessons that measures must be protected from vendor changes for the life of a benefit.

Where can I find a free MGT 640 Topic 7 sample paper?

The whole claims intake benefits review is here, covering cycle time, staffing, the lost satisfaction measure, the common cause and the recommendations. Tell us the project and the benefits its case promised, and a free review can be written to match.

Why did cycle time miss its target in MGT 640 Topic 7?

Intake became faster, but adjuster assignment, which the case assumed would be redesigned, never changed. Cycle time fell from 21 days to 19 instead of 16, a business change that no one owned.