MGT 655 Topic 5 supply chain risk analysis example

Operations Management Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 655 Topic 5 sample paper maps a composite prep table line's critical suppliers to tier two and sizes each risk in lost days and dollars. It was written for GCU MGT 655, Operations Management, catalog code MGT-655, a core course in Grand Canyon University's MBA. Behind one distributor, every drain assembly comes from a single foundry and every caster from one region. At 21,000 dollars of contribution a day, the drain foundry carries the largest expected loss, about 79,000 dollars a year. A sixty-day buffer and a second foundry cost about 20,000 a year, and each risk gets an owner and a trigger.

CourseMGT 655 Operations Management
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeSupply chain risk analysis
LengthAbout 990 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 655 Topic 5

1

The Risk Sits Behind the Distributor: Mapping a Prep Table Line's Suppliers to Tier Two, Sizing Each Risk in Days and Dollars, and Pricing the Mitigation

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

MGT-655: Operations Management

Topic 5 Supply Chain Risk Analysis

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states where the hidden concentration was found and how the risks are weighed. The plant and every figure are a composite; the sources are real.
2

The Risk Sits Behind the Distributor: Mapping a Prep Table Line's Suppliers to Tier Two, Sizing Each Risk in Days and Dollars, and Pricing the Mitigation

The Product and Its Critical Components

A composite food-service equipment plant builds about 30 stainless prep tables and sink units a day, each contributing about 700 dollars after materials and direct labor, so a lost production day costs about 21,000 dollars of contribution. Not every component is critical. A part is treated as critical if the line stops without it and it cannot be substituted within a week. Four components meet that test: 304-grade stainless coil, which forms every table; drain assemblies for sink units; heavy-duty casters for mobile tables; and argon shielding gas for welding. Fasteners, labels and packaging are available from many sources and are excluded.

Tier One and Tier Two

At tier one, the plant's direct suppliers look diversified. Stainless coil comes from a regional steel service center, drain assemblies and casters from a national industrial distributor, and argon from a gas supplier with two local depots. The concentration appears one tier further back. The service center buys its 304 coil from two mills, so steel has two sources. But the distributor sources all its commercial drain assemblies from a single foundry, and all its heavy-duty casters from manufacturers in one overseas region. Two different distributor catalog numbers lead to the same foundry. Chopra and Sodhi (2004) note that companies often believe they have multiple sources when their suppliers share a single upstream source, which is exactly the case here.

Risk Categories Present Here

Five categories apply. Supplier failure: the single drain foundry could close, lose capacity or exit the product. Geographic concentration: casters come from one region exposed to the same port, weather and trade policy. Transport: imported casters pass through one West Coast port, where congestion has caused delays. Demand shock: a wave of restaurant openings can raise orders faster than steel allocations. Quality: a bad batch of drain assemblies would halt sink assembly until replaced. Argon supply was assessed and excluded from the high-risk list, since two depots and a delivery agreement make a week-long outage unlikely.

Sizing Each Risk

Each risk is sized by its estimated annual likelihood and its consequence in lost production days, valued at 21,000 dollars a day. The likelihoods are judgments from the plant's own history and the distributor's records, and are stated so they can be challenged. Expected annual loss is likelihood times consequence.

Table 1

Supply Risks Sized in Days and Dollars

RiskAnnual likelihoodDays lost if it occursCost if it occursExpected annual loss
Drain foundry failure15%25525,00078,750
Caster region disruption10%20420,00042,000
Port delay on casters30%6126,00037,800
Steel allocation cut20%8168,00033,600
Bad batch of drains10%10210,00021,000

Mitigation Options and Their Prices

Each mitigation has a cost, and resilience is bought with margin. Kleindorfer and Saad (2005) argue that mitigation should be matched to the size of the risk, not applied uniformly. A sixty-day buffer of drain assemblies would cost about 45,000 dollars of inventory, about 11,000 dollars a year to carry, and would cover most of a foundry disruption while a second source is qualified. Qualifying a second drain foundry directly would cost about 15,000 dollars in testing and approval and raise unit prices by about 3 percent, roughly 9,000 dollars a year, because the plant would split its volume and lose its current discount. Dual sourcing casters from a supplier in another region would add about 4 percent to caster costs, about 18,000 dollars a year. A thirty-day caster buffer, about 7,500 dollars a year to carry, would cover both port delays and a share of a regional disruption. A written allocation agreement with the steel service center, guaranteeing a minimum monthly tonnage in exchange for a twelve-month volume commitment, would cost little but would limit the plant's freedom to shop for spot prices.

Recommendation

The plant should act first on drains, whose expected loss is largest: hold a sixty-day buffer now and qualify a second foundry within a year, a combined cost of about 20,000 dollars a year against an expected loss near 79,000. For casters, a thirty-day buffer addresses port delays cheaply; dual sourcing should follow only if the regional risk rises. The steel allocation agreement should be signed. These measures reduce, but do not remove, the risk: a disruption longer than the buffers, or one affecting both drain foundries, would still stop the line. Sheffi (2005) argues that resilience also depends on how quickly a company detects and responds to disruption, which is why each risk needs an owner and a trigger.

Owners and Triggers

The purchasing manager owns the drain and caster risks, with a trigger to draw down buffers and expedite alternatives when the distributor reports a lead time beyond four weeks. The operations manager owns the steel risk, triggered by any allocation notice from the service center. The quality manager owns the drain quality risk, triggered by any incoming inspection failure.

Keeping the Map Current

A supply map is accurate only on the day it is drawn. Distributors change their sources without telling customers, and the drain foundry concentration was found only because the purchasing manager asked the distributor directly. The plant should ask each critical supplier, once a year, to confirm its own sources for the parts it supplies, and should repeat the tier-two mapping whenever a supplier changes a catalog number or a lead time moves sharply.

Conclusion

Mapped only at tier one, the prep table line looked well supplied. At tier two, all drain assemblies trace to one foundry and all casters to one region. Sized in days and dollars, the drain risk carries the largest expected loss, about 79,000 dollars a year, and a buffer plus a second foundry address it for about a quarter of that. Mitigation reduces the risk without removing it, and each risk now has an owner and a trigger.

References

Chopra, S., & Sodhi, M. S. (2004). Managing risk to avoid supply-chain breakdown. MIT Sloan Management Review, 46(1), 53-61.

Kleindorfer, P. R., & Saad, G. H. (2005). Managing disruption risks in supply chains. Production and Operations Management, 14(1), 53-68. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1937-5956.2005.tb00009.x

Sheffi, Y. (2005). The resilient enterprise: Overcoming vulnerability for competitive advantage. MIT Press.

MGT 655 Topic 5 instructions, in plain terms

The Topic 5 assignment in MGT-655 asks MBA students to analyze supply chain risk. Strong analyses identify the genuinely critical components, map tier one suppliers and trace tier two for those components, and name the risk categories actually present. Students should size each risk by likelihood and consequence in days and money, price the mitigation options, recommend measures matched to the size of each risk and assign an owner and trigger to each. Likelihoods should be stated as judgments with their basis, so others can challenge them. The paper should also say what each measure cannot protect against. Mitigation should be priced in annual terms so it can be compared directly with expected loss.

How this MGT 655 Topic 5 example is built

The finished example looks past the suppliers the firm has contracts with. Tier one is mapped and then tier two, because two apparently independent suppliers frequently buy the same component from the same source, and that hidden concentration is where the real exposure sits. Each risk is sized by likelihood and by consequence rather than being listed, and the consequence is expressed in days of disruption and lost contribution rather than as severity. Sourcing decisions are then weighed as trades: single sourcing buys price and cooperation, dual sourcing buys resilience and costs margin. The example commits to a position and states what it is paying for it. Every exposure in the analysis carries a number rather than an adjective.

Reading the MGT 655 Topic 5 rubric

Faculty reward hidden concentration found and risks sized in money. An Excellent paper traces two distributor catalog numbers to one foundry, citing Chopra and Sodhi. Credit goes to a table of five risks with likelihood, days lost and expected annual loss. The rubric values priced mitigation, buffers, a second foundry and an allocation agreement, with Kleindorfer and Saad on matching mitigation to risk. Strong papers say what mitigation cannot remove. Top marks go to owners and triggers, following Sheffi on detection and response. Credit also goes to excluding a component from the high-risk list with a stated reason, as with argon here. Faculty also value a reminder that a supply map must be refreshed, since distributors change sources without notice.

MGT 655 Topic 5 help: mistakes that cost marks

Mapping only tier one is the omission this topic is written to catch, since the concentration behind most disruptions sits with suppliers' suppliers. Risks given severity labels instead of days and dollars cannot be weighed against what mitigation costs. Papers lose marks for recommending dual sourcing without pricing it, since splitting volume costs margin and discounts. Treating a supply chain as safe after mitigation overstates what any measure achieves, and registers with no owner or trigger are documents rather than plans. Strong papers state each mitigation's annual cost beside the expected loss it addresses.

Get an MGT-655 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-655 Topic 5 instructions and the rubric posted in your classroom, with the product and supply chain your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with tier two traced for critical components, consequences sized in days and money, mitigation costed and residual exposure stated, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More MGT 655 papers and MBA samples

MGT 655 Topic 5 questions, answered

Why map beyond my direct suppliers?

Because your direct suppliers may share theirs. Two vendors you deliberately chose for redundancy can both depend on a single component maker, one factory or one region, in which case you have paid for dual sourcing and hold single source risk. That hidden concentration causes a large share of real disruptions and it is invisible from tier one alone.

How do I size a supply risk?

In two dimensions and in units you can weigh. Likelihood can be qualitative where no data exists, but consequence should be quantified as days of disruption multiplied by the contribution lost per day, plus any expediting or penalty cost. That converts a risk register into something you can compare against the price of a second supplier, which is the decision the analysis exists to inform.

Is single sourcing always a mistake?

No, and treating it as one misses a real trade. Concentrating volume with one supplier buys better pricing, closer cooperation, joint development and priority when capacity is tight. It costs resilience. The right answer depends on how critical the component is and how quickly an alternative could be qualified, which is why the paper should decide rather than recite a preference.

Where can I find a free MGT 655 Topic 5 sample paper?

The supply chain risk analysis is shown here complete: critical components, tier one and tier two, risk categories, sizing each risk, mitigation and its price, the recommendation, owners and triggers, keeping the map current and the conclusion. Name your product's critical parts and a risk analysis follows free.

Why did tier two matter in MGT 655 Topic 5?

The distributor looked like one of several sources, but every drain assembly it sells comes from a single foundry. That concentration only appears when suppliers' own sources are traced.