| Course | MGT 655 Operations Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Lean process improvement |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 655 Topic 8
Eighty-Five Hours From Signed Quote to First Cut, 2.3 of Them Adding Value: Observing and Improving a Custom Order Release Process
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MGT-655: Operations Management
Topic 8 Lean Process Improvement
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Eighty-Five Hours From Signed Quote to First Cut, 2.3 of Them Adding Value: Observing and Improving a Custom Order Release Process
The Process and How It Was Observed
A composite food-service equipment plant takes about four working days, on average, from a customer's signed quote for a custom prep table to the first cut on the laser. Customers notice, because the plant quotes three weeks from order to shipment and the release process consumes a fifth of it. The process studied begins when a signed quote reaches the order desk and ends when the laser cutter's operator receives a released job. The writer followed ten consecutive custom orders through it over two weeks, recording the time each spent in each step and in each wait, and asked the people doing the work what each step was for.
The Walk, Step by Step
Each order passed through five steps, and each step was preceded by a wait. On average an order waited 18 hours in the order desk's inbox before 0.4 hours of order entry. It waited 30 hours for an engineer to check the drawing, which took 1.5 hours. It waited 20 hours for nesting, the arrangement of parts on steel sheets and the programming of the laser, which took 0.8 hours. It waited 6 hours for a materials check, 0.3 hours, and 8 hours before release to the floor, 0.1 hours. Elapsed time averaged about 85 hours, including evenings, since work in the queues waits overnight.
Table 1
Average Elapsed Time for Ten Custom Orders
| Step | Wait before step, hours | Work time, hours | Classification of work |
|---|---|---|---|
| Order entry | 18 | 0.4 | Necessary, not value adding |
| Drawing check | 30 | 1.5 | Value adding |
| Nesting and laser programming | 20 | 0.8 | Value adding |
| Materials check | 6 | 0.3 | Necessary, not value adding |
| Release to floor | 8 | 0.1 | Necessary, not value adding |
| Total | 82 | 3.1 | |
Three Categories, Not Two
Each portion of time is classified from the customer's point of view: would the customer pay for it if they could see it? The drawing check, which confirms the table fits the customer's kitchen, and the nesting and programming, which turn the design into cutting instructions, add value: 2.3 hours. Order entry, the materials check and the release are not things the customer would pay for, but the plant cannot simply eliminate them; an order must be in the system and steel must be available. They are necessary but not value adding, 0.8 hours, and the aim is to make them faster, not to remove them (Womack & Jones, 1996). Everything else, the 82 hours of waiting, is waste. Only about 2.7 percent of the elapsed time adds value.
Waste by Type
Ohno (1988) classified waste into types, and four appear in this process, each with observed instances. Waiting is by far the largest: 82 hours per order, mostly because each step works in a daily batch, collecting orders and processing them once a day. Defects appear as rework: three of the ten drawings were returned to sales for missing dimensions, adding an average of about 12 hours each, or about 3.6 hours per order across all ten. Overprocessing appears as double entry: order entry retypes information already in the signed quote, and the materials check re-enters the steel requirements that nesting has already calculated. Transportation of information appears as handoffs between four people in three offices, each of which starts a new wait.
Improvements Sized by the Time They Recover
Improvements are targeted at the largest categories and sized by the time each would recover. Moving from once-daily to twice-daily processing at the order desk, drawing check and nesting would cut average waiting by about half at those three steps, recovering about 34 hours. A dimension checklist completed by sales at the time of quoting would prevent most drawing returns, recovering most of the 3.6 hours of rework per order. Having the quote system create the order record automatically would remove retyping and about 0.3 hours of work. Letting the nesting software check steel availability directly would eliminate the separate materials step and its 6-hour wait. Together these would bring average elapsed time from about 85 hours to roughly 45, about two working days, with the work content almost unchanged. Rother and Shook (1999) recommend drawing a future-state map of exactly this kind before changing anything, so that the target is agreed in advance.
Limits of the Observation
Ten orders over two weeks is a small sample, and the two weeks observed were of average volume. In the spring rush, when orders roughly double, queues at the drawing check grow longer and the share of waiting would likely be larger still. The observation also covered only custom orders; catalog orders skip the drawing check and move faster. The improvement estimates are approximate for that reason, and the thirty-day re-observation should include at least a few orders from a busy week to test them.
Making the Improvement Hold
Improvements of this kind commonly hold for a few weeks and then decay as people return to old habits. Sustainment needs four things. An owner: the operations manager is responsible for the release process as a whole, not each office for its own step. A measure: hours from signed quote to first cut, tracked for every order and reviewed weekly. A visual signal: a board at the order desk showing each open order and how long it has waited, so a stalled order is visible to everyone. And a schedule of checks: the writer will repeat the ten-order observation at thirty, sixty and ninety days and report the results, so that decay is detected before it becomes the new normal.
Conclusion
Of about 85 hours from signed quote to first cut, 2.3 add value, 0.8 are necessary but not value adding and the rest is waste, mostly waiting created by daily batches. Twice-daily processing, a quoting checklist, automatic order creation and an integrated materials check could cut the elapsed time roughly in half, and an owner, a measure, a visual board and scheduled re-observation are what will make the change last.
References
Ohno, T. (1988). Toyota production system: Beyond large-scale production. Productivity Press.
Rother, M., & Shook, J. (1999). Learning to see: Value stream mapping to add value and eliminate muda. Lean Enterprise Institute.
Womack, J. P., & Jones, D. T. (1996). Lean thinking: Banish waste and create wealth in your corporation. Simon & Schuster.
What the MGT 655 Topic 8 instructions ask for
Topic 8 of MGT-655 asks MBA students to improve a process using lean principles. Strong papers choose one process the writer can observe, state how it was observed and walk it step by step, classifying time as value adding, necessary but not value adding, or waste. Students should compute the value-adding share, categorize waste by type with observed instances, size each improvement by the time it recovers and plan how the improvement will be sustained. Value should be defined from the customer's point of view, not the firm's. Each improvement should be sized in the time it recovers so improvements can be ranked.
How the MGT-655 Topic 8 example is put together
The finished example is built from watching. The process is followed end to end and the time is split into work that changes the product, work that does not but is currently necessary, and pure waste, which is the distinction that makes the analysis useful. The proportion of elapsed time spent actually adding value is computed and is usually startlingly small, which is the finding that motivates everything after it. Waste is categorized concretely, naming the waiting, the transport, the rework and the overproduction with observed durations attached. Improvements are then sized by the time each would recover, and the example is honest that some waste is currently necessary and cannot simply be removed.
Where the marks sit in the MGT 655 Topic 8 rubric
Faculty reward waste observed rather than described. An Excellent paper tables five steps with waits and work times for ten orders. Credit goes to a third category for necessary steps, following Womack and Jones, and waste typed by Ohno's categories. The rubric values improvements sized in hours, with a future-state target in the manner of Rother and Shook. Strong papers state the limits of a two-week sample. Top marks go to sustainment with an owner, a measure, a board and scheduled re-observation. Credit also goes to explaining why daily batching at each desk creates most of the waiting. Faculty also value a sample that admits its size.
MGT 655 Topic 8 help before you submit
Describing waste categories without observing a process is the failure the drawer line specifically guards against, since the assignment asks for one process the writer can watch. A second weakness is classifying everything as either value adding or waste, which forces necessary activities such as inspection or regulatory recording into a category implying they should be eliminated. Papers lose marks for improvements proposed with no time attached, because a recommendation that cannot be sized cannot be prioritized. Ignoring sustainment repeats the pattern where an improvement holds for three weeks and decays. Value adding defined from the firm's perspective rather than the customer's inverts the definition the method rests on. Observations taken once, on a quiet day, describe a process nobody actually runs.
Get an MGT-655 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-655 Topic 8 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the process you can observe or the one your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with three classification categories, the value adding proportion computed, waste given observed durations and sustainment addressed, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More MGT 655 papers and MBA samples
- MGT 655 Topic 1: Operations Strategy Analysis
- MGT 655 Topic 2: Forecast Error Analysis
- MGT 655 Topic 3: Process and Capacity Analysis
- MGT 655 Topic 4: Control Chart Interpretation
- MGT 655 Topic 5: Supply Chain Risk Analysis
- MGT 655 Topic 6: Inventory Policy Analysis
- MGT 655 Topic 7: Schedule Slack Analysis
- MGT 641 Topic 8: Hybrid Delivery Defense
- MGT 640 Topic 8: Governance Failure Diagnosis
- MGT 605 Topic 8: Personal Leadership Plan
- ACC 502 Topic 8: Ratio and Control Analysis
MGT 655 Topic 8 questions, answered
What counts as value adding?
Something the customer would knowingly pay for, which is a stricter test than it sounds. Transforming the product counts. Moving it, storing it, inspecting it, recording it and correcting it do not, even where they are currently unavoidable. Defining value from the customer's perspective rather than the firm's is what makes the method uncomfortable and useful, since most of what an organization does fails the test.
Why three categories rather than two?
Because some non value adding work cannot currently be removed. Regulatory documentation, safety checks and certain inspections do not add value the customer would pay for and also cannot be deleted this quarter. Putting them in the same bucket as pure waste produces recommendations nobody can implement. The middle category is where you look for reduction rather than elimination.
How do I make an improvement stick?
Change the conditions rather than the instructions. If a step was eliminated because material was moved closer, the improvement holds as long as the material stays there. If it depended on people remembering a new sequence, it will decay once attention moves on. Naming what physically or procedurally holds the change is the difference between an improvement and a temporary result.
Where can I find a free MGT 655 Topic 8 sample paper?
The full lean study appears below: how the process was observed, the walk, three categories, waste by type, sized improvements, limits of the observation, sustainment and the conclusion. Describe a process you can observe and an improvement study follows at no charge.
Why classify some steps as necessary rather than waste in MGT 655 Topic 8?
Order entry and the materials check add nothing a customer would pay for, but orders cannot be cut without them. They should be made faster, not removed.