| Course | MGT 660 Strategic Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Structure and governance fit |
| Length | About 1,010 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 660 Topic 7
Paid on Revenue, Asked for Margin: Testing Ridgeline Supply's Structure, Measures, Incentives and Governance Against Its Chosen Strategy
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MGT-660: Strategic Management
Topic 7 Structure and Governance Fit
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Paid on Revenue, Asked for Margin: Testing Ridgeline Supply's Structure, Measures, Incentives and Governance Against Its Chosen Strategy
The Strategy Everything Must Serve
Ridgeline Supply, a composite regional industrial distributor, has chosen a focused differentiation strategy: certified hose assemblies and documented upkeep programs sold to processing plants near its branches, priced for the difference and not price-matched on commodity items. Chandler (1962) found that firms which changed strategy without changing structure struggled until structure caught up. This analysis tests whether Ridgeline's structure, measurement, incentives and governance serve the chosen strategy, and identifies the largest contradiction among them.
Structure: Who Actually Decides
The reporting chart shows six branch managers reporting to a vice president of sales, and the assembly shop reporting to a vice president of operations as a cost center. The chart does not show where decisions are made. Branch managers set prices on their own accounts and are the ones who invoke the price-match guarantee. The assembly shop's manager cannot add staff without the operations vice president's approval, and the operations budget is set to minimize cost. In practice the chief executive personally approves any discount above 10,000 dollars, so the largest pricing decisions bypass the structure entirely. The arrangement gives the branches authority over the commodity business the strategy deprioritizes and gives the assembly shop, the strategy's core, no authority to grow.
Measurement: What the Organization Counts
The monthly management report shows revenue and gross margin percentage by branch, orders per day and fill rate. It does not show revenue or margin from the target segment, the assembly shop's backlog, the number of plants on documented maintenance programs or the share of certified assemblies delivered on time. An organization manages what it counts, and Ridgeline counts the activities of a general distributor. Kaplan and Norton (1996) argued that measures should be chosen to translate a strategy into the specific results that show whether it is working, which would put segment margin, certified volume and program renewals at the top of the report.
Incentives: What People Are Paid For
Incentives are where most contradictions live, because people follow what they are paid on. Salespeople earn a commission of 3 percent of gross revenue, so a 40,000 dollar catalog order matched to a national's price pays more than a 15,000 dollar certified assembly order at a 38 percent margin. Branch managers' bonuses depend on revenue growth in their branch. The assembly shop manager's bonus depends on keeping cost per assembly below budget, which penalizes adding the technicians the strategy requires. Kerr (1975) warned that organizations often pay for one result while asking for a different one; Ridgeline rewards volume while hoping for margin in a segment.
Table 1
Fit Between Ridgeline's Organization and Its Strategy
| Element | Current arrangement | What the strategy needs | Fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Structure | Branches price; assembly shop a cost center | Authority and budget for the assembly shop | Poor |
| Measurement | Branch revenue, margin percent, orders | Segment margin, certified volume, program renewals | Poor |
| Sales incentives | 3 percent of gross revenue | Pay weighted to margin and certified work | Contradicts |
| Shop manager incentive | Cost per assembly | Capacity and on-time certified delivery | Contradicts |
| Governance | Annual strategy review | Quarterly segment review; CEO pay tied to it | Weak |
Governance: Holding the Strategy in Place
Ridgeline's board has five members, three from the founding family and two independent directors, and reviews strategy once a year. The chief executive plans to retire within three years. A strategy that depends on the current chief executive's attention will not survive the change unless the board holds it in place. The board should adopt the strategy statement formally, review segment results each quarter, tie the chief executive's bonus to segment margin and certified volume and make commitment to the focused strategy an explicit criterion in selecting the successor.
The Largest Contradiction
Of all the misalignments, the sales commission plan is the largest, because it acts every day on the people who decide which business Ridgeline wins. As long as salespeople are paid more for a price-matched catalog order than for a certified assembly, the commodity business will keep growing at the expense of the strategy. Changing structure or measurement without changing commissions would leave the most powerful signal pointing the wrong way.
Recommendations
The analysis recommends four changes, in order. First, replace the revenue commission with one based on gross margin dollars, with a 50 percent higher rate on certified assemblies and maintenance programs. Second, make the assembly shop a profit center with authority to hire against backlog, its manager paid on certified volume delivered on time. Third, replace the monthly report's lead measures with segment margin, certified volume, shop backlog and program renewals, keeping branch revenue as a secondary line. Fourth, have the board adopt the strategy formally and review it quarterly, with the chief executive's pay tied to the segment results.
What the Changes Will Cost
The changes have costs that should be stated before they are made. Moving commissions from revenue to margin will lower the pay of some long-serving salespeople whose accounts are mostly catalog business; two or three may leave, taking some volume with them. A transition year in which salespeople earn the higher of the old and new plans would cost an estimated 180,000 dollars and soften the change. Making the shop a profit center may produce friction with operations over shared equipment and space, which the chief executive will need to settle early. And the board's quarterly review will take time from directors who have been used to an annual discussion. These costs are smaller than the cost of a strategy that the organization's own systems keep working against.
Conclusion
Ridgeline's structure gives authority to the business it is de-emphasizing, its measures count the activities of a general distributor, its incentives pay for volume and its governance reviews strategy once a year ahead of a leadership change. The commission plan is the largest contradiction. Aligning pay, authority, measures and board oversight with the focused strategy is what would make the strategy operate rather than remain a statement. The complete plan that follows carries these four changes into its implementation section.
References
Chandler, A. D., Jr. (1962). Strategy and structure: Chapters in the history of the industrial enterprise. MIT Press.
Kaplan, R. S., & Norton, D. P. (1996). The balanced scorecard: Translating strategy into action. Harvard Business School Press.
Kerr, S. (1975). On the folly of rewarding A, while hoping for B. Academy of Management Journal, 18(4), 769-783. https://doi.org/10.2307/255378
Reading the GCU MGT 660 Topic 7 instructions
In Topic 7, MGT-660 asks MBA students to test whether an organization's design fits its strategy. Strong analyses restate the chosen strategy, examine structure by naming who actually decides what, assess what the organization measures and reports, and address incentives, where most contradictions live because people follow what they are paid on. Students should cover how governance holds the strategy in place across leadership changes, identify the single largest contradiction and recommend changes with their costs. The reporting chart should not be taken as the structure, since decision rights often sit elsewhere and the informal arrangement is what people follow.
How the MGT-660 Topic 7 example is put together
The finished example treats structure as an instrument. The strategy chosen earlier is restated, and each structural element is then examined for whether it supports or undermines it: a differentiation strategy administered through a structure that rewards unit cost reduction will produce cost reduction, because that is what people are measured on. Reporting lines, decision rights and measurement are all addressed, with incentives treated as the most powerful and most frequently contradictory element. Governance appears as the mechanism that holds executives to the strategy across time. The example names one specific contradiction in the firm's current arrangement and states what changing it would cost. Each element is judged against the strategy rather than described on its own.
Reading the MGT 660 Topic 7 rubric
Faculty reward fit tested element by element. An Excellent paper distinguishes the reporting chart from where pricing and hiring decisions actually sit, following Chandler on strategy and structure. Credit goes to measures chosen to translate the strategy, as Kaplan and Norton propose. The rubric values incentives shown contradicting the strategy, with Kerr on rewarding one behavior while hoping for another, and a table rating each element's fit. Strong papers address governance before a leadership change. Top marks go to naming the commission plan as the largest contradiction and costing the fix. Faculty also value recommendations ordered by how much each would change behavior, with the transition costs stated before the changes are made.
MGT 660 Topic 7 help before you submit
Describing a structure without connecting it to the strategy is the failure this topic addresses, since the whole question is fit and a description of an organization chart answers nothing. A second weakness is ignoring incentives, which are the most powerful element and the one most likely to contradict a stated strategy. Papers lose marks for treating the reporting chart as the structure, when decision rights frequently sit elsewhere and the informal arrangement is what people actually follow. Governance omitted leaves out how a strategy survives a change of leadership. Recommending structural change with no cost and no resistance identified reads as a diagram rather than as a proposal. Recommendations that require a culture change with no mechanism attached are aspirations.
Get an MGT-660 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-660 Topic 7 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the firm and the strategy chosen in your earlier assignments. We write a custom example to those criteria, with structure, measurement, incentives and governance each tested for fit and the largest contradiction named and costed, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More MGT 660 papers and MBA samples
- MGT 660 Topic 1: Strategy Definition Analysis
- MGT 660 Topic 2: Weighted External Analysis
- MGT 660 Topic 3: Internal Capability Analysis
- MGT 660 Topic 4: Business Level Positioning
- MGT 660 Topic 5: Corporate Scope Analysis
- MGT 660 Topic 6: MGT-660 Topic 6: Sample Paper, in Real Form
- MGT 660 Topic 8: Complete Strategic Plan
- MGT 655 Topic 7: Schedule Slack Analysis
- MGT 641 Topic 7: Agile Adoption Behavior Audit
- MGT 640 Topic 7: Benefits Realization Review
- ACC 502 Topic 7: Cash Flow Statement Build
MGT 660 Topic 7 questions, answered
Why do incentives override strategy?
Because people respond to what is measured and rewarded rather than to what is announced. A firm pursuing differentiation while paying its managers on unit cost will get cost reduction, and the managers will be behaving rationally. Any strategy implementation that leaves the incentive system untouched is relying on people to act against their own interests, which is not a plan.
Is the organization chart the structure?
Only partly. The chart shows reporting lines; the structure that matters is where decisions actually get made, which budget approvals require whose signature, and which conversations happen before anything is formally proposed. Firms with identical charts can operate completely differently. Locating the real decision rights is more work and considerably more informative.
What does governance contribute here?
Continuity. Executives change and a strategy chosen by one leadership team can be quietly abandoned by the next without any decision being announced. Board oversight, stated measures reported over time and a documented rationale are what hold a strategy in place across those transitions. It is the element student papers omit most often and the one that determines whether the strategy survives.
Where can I find a free MGT 660 Topic 7 sample paper?
The fit analysis is printed here in full: the strategy, structure, measurement, incentives, governance, the largest contradiction, recommendations, costs and the conclusion. Describe your firm's structure and pay plans and a fit analysis follows at no cost.
Why is the commission plan the largest contradiction in MGT 660 Topic 7?
It acts daily on the people choosing which business to win. Paid on revenue, salespeople earn more from a matched catalog order than a certified assembly.