MGT 805 Topic 6 strategy-structure lag analysis example

Designing Organizational Structures Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 805 Topic 6 sample paper measures how long a composite agricultural equipment manufacturer's structure has lagged behind its subscription strategy for precision guidance. It was completed for GCU MGT 805, Designing Organizational Structures, catalog code MGT-805, one of the organization theory courses in the university's DBA. Board minutes date the strategy four years back, and no structural change since has altered who sells, renews or releases software. Equipment representatives sell subscriptions, the parts function sends renewals and engineering holds features for model years. Renewals fell from 82 to 71 percent while reports showed growth. Chandler, Hannan and Freeman, and Amburgey and Dacin frame the lag and its cost.

CourseMGT 805 Designing Organizational Structures
TopicTopic 6
Paper typeStrategy-structure analysis
LengthAbout 1,100 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 805 Topic 6

1

Four Years and No Following: Measuring the Lag Between a Subscription Strategy and an Equipment-Era Structure at an Agricultural Manufacturer

[Author Name]

College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University

MGT-805: Designing Organizational Structures

Topic 6 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the interval and the finding that the structure has not moved. Coldwater Implement Company and all figures are an illustrative composite; the sources are real.
2

Four Years and No Following: Measuring the Lag Between a Subscription Strategy and an Equipment-Era Structure at an Agricultural Manufacturer

Dating the Two Events

Chandler's proposition that structure follows strategy is usually quoted as a rule. It is more useful as a question about time: after a strategy changes, how long does the structure take to follow, and what does the interval cost? This paper measures that interval at Coldwater Implement Company, a composite farm machinery company with three product lines.

The strategy can be dated precisely. Board minutes from four years ago record the decision to grow precision guidance as a subscription business, selling annual software licenses for automated steering, mapping and field data rather than relying on one-time sales of receivers. The minutes set a target that subscriptions would provide a third of guidance revenue within five years. The structural changes since then can be dated from organization announcements. There have been two: a subscription pricing analyst was hired in the finance function, and the guidance help desk was given a separate phone number. Neither changed who sells, who renews or who decides when software ships. For practical purposes the structure has not followed at all.

What this page is doingBoth events are dated from records, so the lag is measured as an interval rather than asserted as a metaphor.
3

Three Arrangements Built for Equipment

Three arrangements show the mismatch. First, subscriptions are sold by the equipment sales force, whose territory managers are measured and paid on units shipped. A subscription sold with a receiver adds little to their commission, and a renewal adds nothing.

Second, renewals sit with the aftermarket parts function, which inherited them because it already sent invoices to farmers for replacement parts. Parts is measured on fill rate and margin. It sends renewal invoices on schedule but has no one whose job is to find out why a farmer did not renew.

Third, software updates follow engineering's model-year calendar, under which new features are released once a year with the new equipment models. Subscription customers pay every year and expect improvements through the year, while the calendar holds finished features until the next model launch.

Each arrangement can be linked to the renewal decline through evidence the firm already holds. A sample of 120 farmers who did not renew last year was contacted by the guidance help desk. The most common reasons given were that nobody had explained the newer features, that a promised mapping improvement had not arrived and that the renewal invoice came from an unfamiliar department with no contact name. These correspond closely to the three arrangements: a sales force with no reason to explain subscriptions, a release calendar that held back the mapping feature and a parts function that treats renewal as billing.

What this page is doingThe paper limits itself to three mismatches that carry the result rather than listing every misalignment it can find.
4

A Decline the Reports Call Success

Over the last two years the renewal rate has fallen from 82 to 71 percent. With about 26,000 active subscriptions at an average of 1,200 dollars a year, each point of renewal is worth roughly 312,000 dollars of annual revenue, so the decline represents about 3.4 million dollars a year. Over the same period receiver hardware sales grew 9 percent. The firm's monthly reports are built around units shipped and parts margins, so they show the guidance business growing throughout. The renewal rate appears only in an annual finance schedule. The structure is reporting success while the strategy it was meant to serve is losing ground, which is the main reason the lag has gone unchallenged.

Chandler's Lag as the Normal Case

Chandler (1962) traced how DuPont, General Motors, Standard Oil and Sears adopted the multidivisional form. In each case the firm's growth strategy, whether diversification into new products or expansion into new regions, created administrative problems the old centralized structure could not handle. The new structure came only after a period of strain, and often after performance fell enough to force senior managers to act. DuPont's diversification after the First World War, for example, produced losses in new product lines before the company reorganized into product divisions.

Read this way, Chandler makes Coldwater's lag look normal rather than unusual. Firms commonly carry an old structure into a new strategy until the costs become undeniable. That does not make the lag harmless. It suggests that Coldwater is at the stage Chandler's firms passed through, where the costs are accumulating but have not yet reached the reports senior managers read.

Inertia Split Into Two Shares

Hannan and Freeman (1984) argue that structural inertia is not simply resistance to change. Organizations are selected for reliability and accountability, the ability to produce consistent results and to explain them, and those qualities depend on stable routines. Some inertia is therefore the price of being dependable. Applied to Coldwater, the argument splits the lag into two shares.

One share is defensible. Dealers buy all three product lines through one sales force, and farmers expect one contact for equipment and service. Moving guidance sales to a separate team would risk confusing dealers who carry grain and irrigation equipment as well. Keeping a single dealer relationship is a reliability the firm should protect while it changes other things. The other share protects nothing the strategy needs. Leaving renewals with the parts function preserves an invoicing routine, not a relationship, and holding software to the model-year calendar preserves a manufacturing rhythm that subscription customers do not value. That share is the cost of the lag.

What this page is doingThe paper separates inertia that buys reliability from inertia that protects outdated routines, the distinction a doctoral reader expects.
5

The Reverse Argument

Causation may also run the other way. Amburgey and Dacin (1994), studying a large sample of firms over several decades, found that strategy influenced structure more strongly than the reverse, but that structure also influenced later strategy. At Coldwater the existing structure plausibly shaped how ambitious the subscription strategy became. Because subscriptions were sold by equipment representatives and renewed through parts, they came to be seen inside the firm as an accessory to hardware. The board's target, a third of guidance revenue, may itself reflect that framing. The paper concedes this in part: the lag has not only delayed the strategy but limited it.

The Cost of One More Year

If the renewal rate continues to fall at the rate of the last two years, about 5.5 points a year, another year of lag would cost about 1.7 million dollars in additional annual revenue, on top of the 3.4 million already lost. Those figures assume the subscriber base stays constant; if new sales slow as well, the cost is higher. Chandler's firms reorganized when losses forced them to. Coldwater has the advantage of being able to measure the cost before its main reports show it, and the case for moving renewals, subscription selling and software release timing under one owner should be judged against that figure.

References

Amburgey, T. L., & Dacin, T. (1994). As the left foot follows the right? The dynamics of strategic and structural change. Academy of Management Journal, 37(6), 1427-1452. https://doi.org/10.5465/256794

Chandler, A. D., Jr. (1962). Strategy and structure: Chapters in the history of the industrial enterprise. MIT Press.

Hannan, M. T., & Freeman, J. (1984). Structural inertia and organizational change. American Sociological Review, 49(2), 149-164. https://doi.org/10.2307/2095567

MGT 805 Topic 6 instructions, in plain terms

MGT-805 uses Topic 6 to test the proposition that structure follows strategy. The brief asks doctoral learners to examine a real or composite organization whose strategy has changed and to assess how far, and how fast, its structure has followed. A paper meets the prompt when it dates both events from records, identifies the specific arrangements that still serve the old strategy and shows the consequence in measured performance. Learners should read Chandler accurately as a historical account, distinguish defensible inertia from inertia that protects outdated routines, and consider the reverse argument that structure shapes strategy. The analysis should end by estimating what continued lag would cost the organization.

How this MGT 805 Topic 6 example is built

The finished analysis dates the strategy from the board minutes that adopted it and then asks which parts of the structure changed afterward. Almost none did. Subscriptions are sold by an equipment sales force measured on units shipped, renewals sit with the aftermarket parts function, and software updates follow engineering's model-year calendar. Over the last two years the renewal rate has fallen from 82 to 71 percent, figures composite, while receiver hardware sales grew, a pattern the current measures report as success. Chandler's account of DuPont and General Motors, where the multidivisional form arrived only after diversification overloaded a centralized structure, frames the lag as normal. Hannan and Freeman's argument about structural inertia explains part of it as the price of reliability. Its conclusion: the reliable portion is small, and the renewal decline is the cost of the rest.

Reading the MGT 805 Topic 6 rubric

The rubric rewards an analysis that treats lag as a measured interval. An Excellent paper dates the strategy and every structural change from documents, then limits itself to the few mismatches that carry the performance result. Credit goes to showing the consequence in figures and explaining why the organization's own reports missed it. Faculty look for Chandler used for what his cases showed, delay followed by reorganization under pressure, not as a rule that every firm needs divisions. Strong papers use Hannan and Freeman to separate inertia that protects reliability from inertia that protects old routines. The highest band concedes part of the reverse causation argument and prices another year of lag.

Common MGT 805 Topic 6 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Lag analyses fall short when they quote structure follows strategy as a rule and never date either event, leaving the lag a metaphor rather than an interval. Papers that list every misalignment they can find dilute the three that carry the renewal decline. Chandler traced how particular strategies of growth produced particular administrative problems, so reading him as prescribing the divisional form for every firm misstates a source the course leans on heavily. Treating all inertia as resistance to change ignores Hannan and Freeman's point that reliability has value, and a doctoral reader expects that distinction to be drawn. Missing the reporting problem, measures that count receivers while renewals fall, overlooks why the lag has gone unchallenged. The reverse argument about structure shaping strategy is the objection most often absent, and without it causation runs only one way.

Get an MGT-805 Topic 6 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-805 Topic 6 instructions, the rubric from your classroom and the organization, strategy or case the assignment describes. We write a custom example to those criteria, with both events dated, mismatches located, the lag's cost measured, inertia divided into defensible and costly shares and the reverse argument answered, returned in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MGT 805 papers and DBA samples

MGT 805 Topic 6 questions, answered

What did Chandler mean by structure follows strategy?

Alfred Chandler studied large American firms, including DuPont and General Motors, and found that strategies of growth and diversification created administrative problems their centralized functional structures could not handle. The multidivisional form emerged in response, typically after a delay and often after performance suffered. His conclusion was that a new strategy calls for a new structure, and that firms tend to adopt one only once the old structure visibly fails.

What is structural inertia?

Michael Hannan and John Freeman argued that organizations are favored when they perform reliably and can account for their actions, qualities that depend on stable, reproducible structures. The same stability makes structural change slow and risky, so inertia is partly a product of selection rather than simple resistance. The example uses that argument to decide which part of a lag protects something valuable.

Can structure shape strategy instead?

Many scholars argue it can, since existing units, measures and reporting lines influence which options managers notice, how proposals are framed and which strategies seem feasible. The example concedes that the manufacturer's functional structure made subscriptions look like a hardware accessory. It still treats the renewal decline as a structural cost, because the strategy was adopted clearly and the structure never moved to serve it.

Where can I find a free MGT 805 Topic 6 sample paper?

The complete strategy-structure lag analysis is here: the dated events, the three equipment-era arrangements, the renewal decline, Chandler's cases, the inertia split, the reverse argument and the cost of one more year. Give us your organization's strategy history and a free analysis can be drafted.

What does the lag cost in MGT 805 Topic 6?

Each renewal point is worth about 312,000 dollars a year, so the fall from 82 to 71 percent represents about 3.4 million dollars annually. Another year at the same trend would add about 1.7 million.