| Course | MGT 820 Using Business Analytics for Competitive Advantage |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Data asset analysis |
| Length | About 1,080 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 820 Topic 2
A Decade of Baskets Under Test: Whether a Regional Grocer's Loyalty Data Would Still Differ From a Rival's After a Determined Attempt to Close the Gap
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
MGT-820: Using Business Analytics for Competitive Advantage
Topic 2 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
A Decade of Baskets Under Test: Whether a Regional Grocer's Loyalty Data Would Still Differ From a Rival's After a Determined Attempt to Close the Gap
The Strategic Question
Hartwell Markets, a composite regional grocer with 64 stores in two states, describes its loyalty-card data as its most valuable asset. A national chain has announced plans to open 20 stores in Hartwell's region over three years. The strategic question is not whether Hartwell's data is large or useful, but whether it would still differ meaningfully from the rival's after a determined, well-funded attempt to close the gap. This paper treats the data as a strategist treats a plant or a patent: as an asset whose value depends on what it would cost someone else to obtain. The test uses the resource-based conditions of value, rarity, imitability and substitutability (Barney, 1991), with particular attention to imitability.
The Asset and What a Rival Can Buy
Table 1
Hartwell's Data Beside What a Rival Can Purchase, Illustrative
| Feature | Hartwell loyalty records | Rival's purchasable data |
|---|---|---|
| Households covered in region | About 1.1 million | A panel sample of a few thousand |
| Detail | Every basket, item and promotion | Scanned purchases from panelists |
| History in region | Ten years | Panel history, but no own-store history |
| Link to own promotions | Direct | None until rival stores open |
Hartwell's records cover about 1.1 million households over ten years, at the level of individual baskets: every item, its price, the promotion applied and the store and time of purchase, tied to a household identifier. The rival will not start with nothing. It can buy syndicated panel data covering the same region, drawn from a sample of consumer households who scan their purchases, and it has its own national loyalty program with years of data from other regions.
The gap between the two is therefore narrower than Hartwell's executives assume, and it should be stated precisely. The rival can learn regional category trends, price sensitivity by broad segment and national patterns that transfer. What it cannot buy is the purchase history of particular households in Hartwell's trade areas, at full basket detail, across a decade of Hartwell's own promotions.
Barrier One: Accumulation
Dierickx and Cool (1989) argued that strategic assets are stocks built through flows over time, and that some stocks resist rapid imitation because of time compression diseconomies: doubling the investment rate does not halve the time needed to build the stock. A decade of household purchase histories fits that description. The rival can open stores and enroll customers quickly, but it cannot compress ten years of observed behavior into three. Each household's history grows one shopping trip at a time.
The barrier is real but bounded. Much of the value of old history decays, since households move, children leave and preferences shift. A rival with three years of its own data in the region may capture much of what matters for current decisions. This barrier is best described as holding for roughly three to four years after the rival's stores open.
Barrier Two: Exclusivity
The data arises because customers enroll with Hartwell and present their cards. No vendor sells these identifiers, and Hartwell's privacy terms forbid sharing them with other retailers. A partner such as a consumer goods manufacturer receives aggregated results, not household records. The exclusivity is tied to the relationship itself.
This barrier is the strongest of the three. It does not depend on volume or history but on the fact that the data is a by-product of a customer relationship that only Hartwell has. It erodes only as customers shift their spending to the rival, at which point the rival begins to generate its own exclusive records for the same households.
Barrier Three: The Feedback Loop
A loop is often claimed for loyalty data: promotions generate responses, responses sharpen targeting, and better targeting produces more responses. Claimed loops should be checked. Hartwell's records show that redemption of personalized offers rose from 4.1 percent to 6.3 percent over three years, but the improvement came almost entirely in the first year, after the firm switched from mass mailers to item-level offers, and has been flat since. The loop worked once, as a change of method, and has not compounded. This barrier is therefore weak, and a rival adopting item-level offers would capture most of the same gain.
The Diminishing Returns Objection
The most likely objection to any argument about data scale is that more data soon stops improving predictions. There is evidence for it. In a study of retail demand forecasting, Bajari et al. (2019) found that forecast accuracy improved as the length of a product's sales history grew, with diminishing returns, while adding more products to the data did little. For stable, national categories such as cereal or detergent, Hartwell's history probably adds little beyond what a rival's national data and panel purchases provide. The objection is granted there.
It stops applying in local and fast-changing assortment decisions: which regional produce to carry in which store, how a neighborhood's shopping changes when a plant closes, which households respond to which local promotion. These decisions depend on the specific households in Hartwell's trade areas, which national data cannot represent, and here the household history retains value.
Where the Advantage Rests
Of the three barriers, the advantage rests on exclusivity. Accumulation provides a lead of a few years, and the feedback loop has already been exhausted. Exclusivity holds as long as Hartwell's customers keep shopping with Hartwell, and it applies most to local assortment and promotion decisions. The event that would erode it is a large shift of household spending to the rival, which would hand the rival its own exclusive records for those households. Hartwell's data strategy is therefore inseparable from its customer retention strategy: the asset lasts only as long as the relationship that produces it, and the first two years after the rival's stores open will determine how much of the asset survives.
Three practical implications follow. First, Hartwell should direct its analytics spending toward the local decisions where its data still differs, store-level assortment and neighborhood promotions, rather than national category forecasting, where the rival's data is as good. Second, it should identify the households most likely to be drawn to the new stores, those living closest to the announced sites, and use their own histories to design offers that keep them. Third, it should stop describing the data as an asset in itself in investor and board materials, since doing so encourages spending on storage and technique while the real source of value, the shopping relationship, receives less attention than it needs.
References
Bajari, P., Chernozhukov, V., Hortaçsu, A., & Suzuki, J. (2019). The impact of big data on firm performance: An empirical investigation. AEA Papers and Proceedings, 109, 33-37. https://doi.org/10.1257/pandp.20191000
Barney, J. (1991). Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. Journal of Management, 17(1), 99-120. https://doi.org/10.1177/014920639101700108
Dierickx, I., & Cool, K. (1989). Asset stock accumulation and sustainability of competitive advantage. Management Science, 35(12), 1504-1511. https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.35.12.1504
The MGT-820 Topic 2 assignment instructions
The Topic 2 assignment in MGT-820 asks doctoral learners to analyze data as a strategic resource. The prompt moves past claims that a dataset is large and proprietary and asks what a competitor would actually need to do to match it. The prompt is met by describing the asset precisely, comparing it with what rivals can purchase, and testing each barrier to imitation separately with evidence from the case. Learners should apply Dierickx and Cool's work on asset stocks, check any claimed feedback loop against the record, and address the objection that additional data soon stops improving predictions. The analysis should end by naming the single barrier the advantage depends on and the event that would remove it.
How this MGT 820 Topic 2 example is built
The finished analysis treats the grocer's data the way a strategist treats a plant or a patent, as an asset whose value depends on what it would cost someone else to get. It begins by describing what the records contain, a decade of basket-level purchases tied to household identifiers, and what a national rival can already buy, syndicated panel data covering the same region at a coarser grain. Three barriers are then tested one by one. Accumulation is analyzed through Dierickx and Cool's point that asset stocks built over time resist rushed replication. Exclusivity is traced to the loyalty relationship itself, which no vendor sells. The feedback barrier is checked for whether promotions actually generate data that sharpens later promotions. A separate section weighs the argument that data shows diminishing returns.
MGT 820 Topic 2 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty marking the analysis reward barriers tested separately, each with evidence and a duration. An Excellent paper sets the firm's data beside what a rival can buy, so the gap is measured rather than assumed. Credit goes to applying Dierickx and Cool's time compression argument to the household histories and to bounding it. The rubric values checking the feedback loop against redemption records, here finding it flat after the first year. Strong papers grant the diminishing-returns objection where the evidence supports it and show where it stops applying, in local assortment decisions. Top marks go to conclusions that name one barrier, exclusivity, and tie its survival to customer retention.
MGT 820 Topic 2 help before you submit
Faculty tend to deduct first where exclusivity is assumed from size. A dataset described as large, proprietary and therefore an advantage has skipped the analysis, since a competitor may reach a comparable picture through purchased data or a loyalty program of its own. Treating all three barriers as present at once, without evidence for each, overstates the case in a way graders at this level spot quickly. Papers that never state how long a barrier would hold present a head start as a moat. The diminishing-returns argument is often missing entirely, and it is the objection most likely to be raised against any claim about data scale. Marks also slip when the conclusion rests on every barrier equally, rather than naming the one the advantage actually depends on and the change that would remove it.
Get an MGT-820 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-820 Topic 2 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and any case company your section named. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the data asset set against what a rival could buy, each barrier tested and the diminishing-returns objection handled, back in 24 to 48 hours. Your first one is free.
More MGT 820 papers and DBA samples
- MGT 820 Topic 1: Analytics Advantage Thesis
- MGT 820 Topic 3: Analytics Decision Rights Map
- MGT 820 Topic 4: Analytics Routines Assessment
- MGT 820 Topic 5: Rival Imitation Timeline
- MGT 820 Topic 6: Reporting Gain Dq Response
- MGT 820 Topic 7: Decision Anchored Business Case
- MGT 820 Topic 8: Advantage Durability Assessment
- MGT 825 Topic 2: Preliminary Agreement Analysis
- MGT 805 Topic 2: Grouping Basis Comparison
- MGT 830 Topic 2: Causal Loop Analysis
- DBA 965 Topic 2: Findings Chapter Presentation
MGT 820 Topic 2 questions, answered
Is a large dataset automatically a strategic asset?
No. Size says little about whether a rival could reach a similar picture. The analysis asks what a competitor would have to do to close the gap: buy syndicated data, launch its own loyalty program, or wait out the years the grocer has already spent collecting. If a purchase closes most of that distance, the records are useful operating data but a weak basis for strategy, however large the file.
Who were Dierickx and Cool, and why cite them here?
Ingemar Dierickx and Karel Cool argued that strategic assets are stocks accumulated through flows over time, and that some stocks cannot be built faster simply by spending more, a problem they called time compression diseconomies. That argument fits accumulated customer data closely. The example cites them for that central point only, not for anything about analytics specifically, which their work predates.
Does more data always mean a better model?
No. In many prediction problems accuracy improves quickly with early data and then flattens, so a rival with less data may perform nearly as well. That is the strongest objection to data-scale advantages, and the example grants it for stable categories. Where behavior is local and changing, fresh data keeps adding value, and that is where the grocer's position is argued to hold.
Where can I find a free MGT 820 Topic 2 sample paper?
The grocer data analysis is shown in full: the strategic question, the asset beside purchasable data, the three barriers, the diminishing-returns objection and where the advantage rests. Tell us what records your case firm holds, and a free inimitability analysis can be written around them.
Which barrier carries the advantage in MGT 820 Topic 2?
Exclusivity. The records exist only because customers enroll with the grocer, and no vendor sells them. Accumulation gives a lead of a few years, and the promotion feedback loop stopped improving after its first year.