| Course | MGT 820 Using Business Analytics for Competitive Advantage |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Investment memo |
| Length | About 890 words, 3 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 820 Topic 7
Memorandum
To: Chief Financial Officer, Ridgepoint Equipment Rentals
From: Director of Fleet Strategy
Date: [Date]
Re: Business case for predictive maintenance on the heavy fleet
The Decision and Today's Rule
You asked for a business case for the proposed predictive maintenance program. This memo builds it on one decision rather than on the insight the program would produce: when to overhaul or retire each machine in the heavy fleet. Today that decision follows a fixed rule. Excavators, wheel loaders and large telehandlers are scheduled for a major overhaul at 6,000 engine hours and considered for retirement at 10,000 hours or eight years, whichever comes first. About 600 overhaul-or-retire decisions are made each year across the 2,400 heavy machines. The rule is simple and auditable, but it treats a machine that has worked gently on paved sites the same as one that has run hard in quarries.
What the Program Would Change
The program would collect engine, hydraulic and vibration readings from the telematics units already fitted to the fleet and score each machine's condition against its age and hours. The scores would reach the maintenance planners in their monthly scheduling meeting, before machines are booked for the shop, so the output arrives in time to alter the decision. Planners would keep the right to decide, but a machine whose score diverged sharply from its age profile would have to be reviewed rather than scheduled by the rule. Provost and Fawcett (2013) stress that data science creates value only when it is framed around a specific business decision and its outcomes, and this design follows that principle: the program's only deliverable is a changed schedule.
Value of Changed Decisions
Table 1
Value of Changed Overhaul-or-Retire Decisions, Illustrative Assumptions
| Assumption | Figure | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Decisions per year | 600 | Current overhaul and retirement volume |
| Share changed by condition scores | 15 percent, about 90 decisions | Machines whose readings diverge from age profile in the pilot |
| Average value per changed decision | $12,000 | Deferred overhauls on healthy machines and earlier action on failing ones |
| Annual value at full use | About $1.08 million | 90 decisions at $12,000 |
The value comes from changing the timing of decisions for machines whose condition differs from their age profile. All figures in this section are illustrative assumptions, not company data.
Costs Over Three Years
Costs include a one-time implementation of about $250,000 for integrating telematics feeds and building the scoring model, and running costs of about $540,000 a year: software licenses of $180,000, two data engineers at about $300,000 and roughly $60,000 of planners' time spent reviewing flagged machines. Assuming half the value in the first year while planners learn to use the scores, the three-year totals are about $2.70 million of value against $1.87 million of cost. Discounted at our 10 percent hurdle rate, the net present value is about $0.62 million, which is positive but sensitive to the share of decisions changed (Brealey et al., 2020). If only 10 percent of decisions change rather than 15, the net present value falls close to zero.
Risks to the Figures
Three risks could reduce the value. The first is that planners ignore the scores and keep scheduling by the hours rule, which would leave the program running and the decisions unchanged; the review requirement for flagged machines is meant to prevent that, and the follow-up measure below will show whether it does. The second is data quality. About 8 percent of the older machines have telematics units that report intermittently, and those machines would have to stay on the existing rule. The third is that deferring overhauls on healthy machines could raise breakdown rates on rental jobs if the model is wrong, which would cost far more than the overhaul saved. The pilot should therefore track breakdowns on deferred machines from the first month, and any rise should halt deferrals until the model is reviewed.
Return Is Not Advantage
A positive return is a reason to invest. It is not a competitive advantage, and the memo keeps the two questions apart. The telematics units, the sensor data and the modeling methods are available to every major rental company; two national competitors already advertise condition-based maintenance. A resource that rivals can buy cannot sustain an advantage (Barney, 1991). The program should be approved, if at all, because it lowers fleet costs, not because it will set the firm apart. The only way it might contribute to an advantage is through the planners' accumulated judgment about when to trust the scores, and that is too uncertain to count.
Platform Value
The analytics team argues that a condition-scoring capability will find other uses later, such as pricing rentals by machine condition or predicting resale values. That may be true. The memo notes it and excludes it from the figures, because unnamed future uses could be claimed for any proposal and would justify any investment. If those uses materialize, each should be proposed with its own decision and its own case.
Recommendation and Follow-Up
I recommend approving the program for the excavator and wheel loader fleets first, which account for about 60 percent of heavy fleet decisions, with expansion conditional on results. After twelve months, the decision record should show how many scheduled overhauls were deferred or brought forward because of condition scores, what happened to those machines afterward and what the changes saved. If fewer than 10 percent of decisions changed, the program should be reconsidered before expansion.
References
Barney, J. (1991). Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. Journal of Management, 17(1), 99-120. https://doi.org/10.1177/014920639101700108
Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
Provost, F., & Fawcett, T. (2013). Data science for business: What you need to know about data mining and data-analytic thinking. O'Reilly Media.
MGT 820 Topic 7 instructions, in plain terms
Topic 7 in MGT-820 asks doctoral learners to write a business case for an analytics investment that rests on a decision rather than on insight. The brief expects a memo a financial officer could hold the program to. A paper meets it when it names the decision and the current rule, explains how the analysis would reach decision makers in time, and estimates how many decisions would change and what each change is worth, with every assumption labeled. Learners should cover costs over several years, apply discounting, separate a positive return from a competitive advantage, and answer the argument that the capability will find other uses later. The memo should propose the decision record that will show, after a year, whether the change happened.
Inside the MGT 820 Topic 7 example
The finished case reads as an investment memo addressed to a composite chief financial officer. It names the decision first: overhaul-or-retire choices on the heavy fleet, currently made on age and hours alone. It then states what the program would change, the timing of those choices for machines whose sensor readings diverge from their age profile, and estimates in clearly labeled illustrative figures how many decisions a year that affects and what each changed decision is worth. The cost side covers software, data engineering and the maintenance planners' time. A separate section asks whether a positive return would also be an advantage, and answers that it would not, since rivals can buy the same telematics. The platform-value objection, that the capability will find uses nobody can yet name, is answered in its own section.
Where the marks sit in the MGT 820 Topic 7 rubric
An Excellent memo earns its marks by anchoring every figure on one decision. The rubric rewards papers that state today's rule, show the analysis arriving before machines are scheduled, and value changed decisions with labeled assumptions instead of company data the case never supplied. Credit goes to a three-year cost view with discounting and a sensitivity test, here showing net present value near zero if only 10 percent of decisions change. Faculty look for the return kept separate from advantage, since rivals can buy the same telematics. Strong memos note platform value and exclude it from the figures. Top marks go to a follow-up measure drawn from the decision record.
Common MGT 820 Topic 7 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Investment cases in this topic lose the most credit when the decision never appears. A justification built on better insight into fleet health, or on the firm becoming data-driven, describes capability acquired and gives the financial officer nothing to hold the program against later. Figures presented as fact when the case supplied none are marked as errors, so illustrative assumptions need labels. Some papers show a strong return and then call it an advantage, which merges two questions the course keeps separate. Platform value is a frequent crutch, counted into the return as though unnamed future uses had a price. Papers also forfeit ground when no follow-up measure is proposed, since a decision-based case should say which decision record would show whether the change occurred.
Get an MGT-820 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-820 Topic 7 instructions, the rubric your classroom posts and the proposal or company your section described. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the investment resting on named decisions, illustrative figures labeled, return kept apart from advantage and the platform-value objection answered, in 24 to 48 hours. Your first one is free.
More MGT 820 papers and DBA samples
- MGT 820 Topic 1: Analytics Advantage Thesis
- MGT 820 Topic 2: Data Asset Inimitability Analysis
- MGT 820 Topic 3: Analytics Decision Rights Map
- MGT 820 Topic 4: Analytics Routines Assessment
- MGT 820 Topic 5: Rival Imitation Timeline
- MGT 820 Topic 6: Reporting Gain Dq Response
- MGT 820 Topic 8: Advantage Durability Assessment
- MGT 825 Topic 7: Product Decision Exposure Review
- MGT 805 Topic 7: Divisional Redesign Proposal
- MGT 830 Topic 7: Reversible Reorganization Proposal
- DBA 965 Topic 7: Chapter Reconciliation Audit
MGT 820 Topic 7 questions, answered
Why justify analytics by a decision rather than by insight?
Because insight has no price and no test. A decision that changes, overhauling a machine earlier or retiring it later, can be counted, valued and checked afterward against what actually happened. Analytics functions justified by insight tend to grow without anyone being able to say what moved. Anchoring the case to decisions gives the approver a standard to hold the program to.
What is value of information, and does the paper need the formula?
It is the difference between the expected outcome of a decision made with the new information and the same decision made without it. The example uses the idea informally, estimating how many fleet decisions would change and what each change is worth. Some sections expect the formal calculation from decision analysis; check your rubric, and label every probability and payoff as an assumption where the case supplies none.
Can an investment pay off without being a competitive advantage?
Easily. A program that cuts maintenance cost may return its outlay well within its life and still give no edge, because rivals can buy the same sensors and software and earn a similar return. The example recommends the investment on its return while stating that the strategic claim does not follow. Keeping those conclusions separate is one of the things graders check.
Where can I find a free MGT 820 Topic 7 sample paper?
The predictive maintenance memo is on this page from start to finish: the decision, the program, the value table, three-year costs, risks, return versus advantage, platform value and the follow-up. Describe the investment in your case and a free decision-based memo can be prepared.
Is the program an advantage in MGT 820 Topic 7?
No. The memo finds a positive return, about 0.62 million dollars in net present value, but rivals can buy the same telematics and models, so it recommends approval for lower fleet costs, not for differentiation.