| Course | MGT 825 Contemporary Business Law |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Doctoral liability paper |
| Length | About 1,050 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 825 Topic 3
What the Work Predictably Brings: Enterprise Risk as the Manager's Measure of Liability for Employee Conduct, From Ira S. Bushey and Sons to Faragher and Ellerth
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
MGT-825: Contemporary Business Law
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
What the Work Predictably Brings: Enterprise Risk as the Manager's Measure of Liability for Employee Conduct, From Ira S. Bushey and Sons to Faragher and Ellerth
Two Readings of Scope of Employment
An employer is generally liable for harm its employees cause when they act within the scope of their jobs. Managers usually read that phrase as a question about authorization: what was the employee told to do? On that reading, an employer is safe when it forbids misconduct and the employee does it anyway. This paper argues for a second reading, which better describes both the case law and the exposure a manager should plan for. Scope of employment is better understood as a question about characteristic risk: what harms does this work predictably bring with it? Employers routinely answer for conduct they forbade, because the conduct belonged to the risks their activity created.
Ira S. Bushey and Sons v. United States
A Coast Guard seaman returning drunk to his ship, which was in a private drydock for repairs, turned wheels on the drydock wall that controlled its flooding valves. The drydock flooded, the ship slid off its blocks and both the ship and the drydock were damaged. The drydock owner sued the United States. The seaman was obviously not doing anything the Coast Guard had authorized, and his motive could not be explained as serving his employer. The Second Circuit, in an opinion by Judge Friendly, nonetheless held the government liable. The court reasoned that the seaman's conduct was not so unforeseeable as to make it unfair to charge the government with responsibility: sailors returning to ships after shore leave, sometimes drunk, were a characteristic risk of operating a fleet, and the harm arose from the seaman's access to the drydock that his work gave him (Ira S. Bushey & Sons, Inc. v. United States, 1968).
The case matters beyond admiralty because of its reasoning, not its facts. Liability followed the risks the enterprise characteristically creates, which an employer is better placed than a stranger to anticipate, insure against and reduce.
Faragher and Ellerth: Supervisors and Reasonable Prevention
In two decisions issued on the same day in 1998, the Supreme Court addressed when an employer answers for sexual harassment by a supervisor. In Faragher, lifeguard supervisors had harassed a lifeguard over several years, and the city had a harassment policy it had never distributed to the beach staff. In Ellerth, a mid-level manager had made threats tied to an employee's job, though he never carried them out. The Court held that an employer is vicariously liable for a hostile environment created by a supervisor with authority over the employee, because the supervisor's authority makes the harassment possible. Where no tangible employment action has occurred, the employer may defend itself by proving two things: that it took reasonable care both to stop harassment before it happened and to deal with it quickly once reported, and that the harassed worker passed up, unreasonably, the reporting routes the employer had set up. Where the harassment culminates in a tangible employment action, such as firing, demotion or an undesirable reassignment, the defense is not available (Burlington Industries, Inc. v. Ellerth, 1998; Faragher v. City of Boca Raton, 1998).
These decisions apply the enterprise risk idea to the authority an employer gives its supervisors. The employer answers because it created the authority, and it can reduce its exposure only through prevention and correction it can prove, not through a policy that sits in a drawer.
Application: A Home-Services Company
Hearthline Home Services, a composite company with about 900 technicians, repairs heating, plumbing and electrical systems in customers' homes. Technicians work alone, are dispatched by an app under pressure to complete five or six visits a day, and enter homes where the customer is often alone. Field supervisors set schedules, approve overtime and assign routes.
Read through the authorization lens, Hearthline's exposure seems limited: it prohibits theft, harassment of customers and unsafe driving, and a technician who commits any of them acts outside his instructions. Read through the characteristic-risk lens, the picture changes. Working alone in private homes predictably creates opportunities for theft and for misconduct toward customers. Dispatch pressure predictably produces speeding between jobs and shortcuts in work on gas lines. And supervisors who control schedules and routes hold exactly the authority that Faragher and Ellerth treat as making supervisor harassment the employer's responsibility, especially since a route change can be a tangible employment action. Each of these is a harm the work brings with it, and each is where screening, supervision and complaint systems carry legal consequence.
The Insurer Objection
The strongest objection is that the enterprise risk reading turns employers into insurers of everything their employees do. If an employer answers for whatever its work makes possible, almost any misconduct could be charged to it. The objection is answered by the limits courts actually keep. Liability does not extend to conduct driven by purely personal matters unrelated to the work, such as a technician's dispute with a neighbor in his own time, or to harm far removed from the time and place of the job. And for supervisor harassment without a tangible action, the employer keeps a real defense when it can show reasonable prevention and correction. The enterprise risk reading is not unlimited liability; it is liability for risks the employer is best placed to manage, with defenses that reward managing them.
Three Practices the Argument Implies
If managers measure exposure by characteristic risk, three practices follow for Hearthline. First, screening and supervision should be designed around the harms the work creates: background checks for in-home roles, customer verification of visits and a system for customers to report concerns about a technician. Second, dispatch targets should be set with the risks of pressure in mind, so that the company is not creating the speeding and shortcuts it forbids. Third, the harassment policy must be distributed, trained and used, with a complaint route that bypasses the employee's own supervisor and a record of prompt investigation, because only prevention and correction the company can prove will support the Faragher and Ellerth defense. Route changes after an employee complains should be reviewed before they take effect.
Nothing here assesses a real claim; the argument is offered as doctoral coursework only.
References
Burlington Industries, Inc. v. Ellerth, 524 U.S. 742 (1998).
Faragher v. City of Boca Raton, 524 U.S. 775 (1998).
Ira S. Bushey & Sons, Inc. v. United States, 398 F.2d 167 (2d Cir. 1968).
The MGT-825 Topic 3 assignment instructions
Topic 3 in MGT-825 turns to agency and employer liability for employee conduct. The brief asks doctoral learners how scope of employment should be understood and what that means for managers. A paper meets the prompt when it compares the authorization reading with the characteristic-risk reading, supports its choice with the cases assigned, and applies the argument to a realistic organization. Learners should use Bushey for its reasoning, explain the Faragher and Ellerth framework including the affirmative defense and its limit where a tangible employment action occurs, and answer the objection that the approach makes employers insurers of everything. The paper should end with practical implications and note that it is academic analysis, not guidance on any claim.
How the MGT-825 Topic 3 example is put together
The finished paper holds a single argument across two lines of cases. The first is Ira S. Bushey and Sons v. United States, where the government answered for a drunken sailor who flooded a drydock on his way back to his ship; the court rested liability on the risks characteristic of the enterprise rather than on any service the sailor was performing. The second pairs Faragher v. City of Boca Raton with Burlington Industries v. Ellerth, in which the Supreme Court made employers answer for supervisors' harassment while allowing a defense built on reasonable prevention and correction. A composite home-services company, whose technicians work alone in customers' homes, shows how a manager would apply the argument. The strongest objection, that the approach turns employers into insurers of all conduct, is answered with the limits courts actually keep.
Where the marks sit in the MGT 825 Topic 3 rubric
Graders reward a single argument carried through two lines of cases. An Excellent paper explains why employers answer for conduct they forbade, using Judge Friendly's reasoning in Bushey about risks characteristic of the enterprise. Credit goes to stating the Faragher and Ellerth rules accurately, including that the defense is unavailable after a tangible employment action such as a firing or an undesirable reassignment. The rubric values an application that names the harms a specific business model creates, here technicians alone in homes under dispatch pressure. Strong papers answer the insurer objection with the exclusions courts keep. Top marks go to practices tied to each risk, including review of route changes after complaints.
Common MGT 825 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Submissions that treat scope of employment as a question of what the manager authorized tend to lose credit from the first page. Employers routinely answer for conduct they forbade, and a paper that misses this has not engaged the cases assigned. Citing Bushey for its facts alone, as a curiosity about a flooded drydock, wastes the reasoning that makes it useful to a manager. The harassment framework is often compressed until the affirmative defense disappears, or described as available when a supervisor has fired or demoted the employee, where it is not. Leaving the insurer objection out makes the position look stronger than it is. Credit also goes missing when the application stays abstract and never says which practices in the composite company the argument would change.
Get an MGT-825 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-825 Topic 3 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and any case list or scenario your section named. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the enterprise risk position argued through landmark cases, the harassment framework stated accurately and the insurer objection answered, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More MGT 825 papers and DBA samples
- MGT 825 Topic 1: Exposure Triage Paper
- MGT 825 Topic 2: Preliminary Agreement Analysis
- MGT 825 Topic 4: Routine Decision Exposure Brief
- MGT 825 Topic 5: Counsel Threshold Dq Post
- MGT 825 Topic 6: Compliance Oversight Paper
- MGT 825 Topic 7: Product Decision Exposure Review
- MGT 825 Topic 8: Disclosure Policy Position Paper
- MGT 830 Topic 3: Backfire Case Critique
- MGT 820 Topic 3: Analytics Decision Rights Map
- MKT 830 Topic 3: Managerial Turn Critique
- MGT 805 Topic 3: Coordination Cost Quantification
MGT 825 Topic 3 questions, answered
What did Ira S. Bushey and Sons v. United States decide?
The Second Circuit held the United States liable when a Coast Guard seaman, returning drunk to his ship in a private drydock, turned wheels controlling the drydock's valves and flooded it. Judge Friendly reasoned that the conduct was a risk characteristic of the enterprise, since crews returning from shore leave predictably behave this way, even though it served no purpose of the employer.
When can an employer avoid liability for a supervisor's harassment?
Under Faragher and Ellerth, where no tangible employment action such as firing or demotion occurred, an employer may defend by showing it exercised reasonable care to prevent and promptly correct harassment and that the employee unreasonably failed to use the procedures offered. Where a tangible action occurred, that defense is not available. The example states the framework for coursework purposes; real claims turn on facts and jurisdiction.
Does this mean an organization is liable for everything employees do?
No, and the paper spends a section on why. Courts still exclude conduct arising from purely personal matters unrelated to the work, and many intentional acts fall outside scope in most jurisdictions. The argument is narrower: liability tracks the risks the work characteristically creates. The practical consequence is that screening, supervision and complaint procedures are where a manager's choices shape the organization's exposure.
Where can I find a free MGT 825 Topic 3 sample paper?
The enterprise risk paper is on this page in full: the two readings, Bushey, Faragher and Ellerth, the home-services application, the insurer objection and three practices. Describe the organization your paper considers and a free argument can be developed for it.
Why was the government liable in Bushey, MGT 825 Topic 3?
The court reasoned that sailors returning to ships after shore leave, sometimes drunk, were a characteristic risk of running a fleet, and the seaman's access to the drydock came from his work, so the harm was fairly charged to the enterprise.