MGT 825 Topic 4 routine decision exposure brief example

Contemporary Business Law Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 825 Topic 4 sample paper is a brief showing that employment exposure at a composite regional bank is created by routine operations decisions long before anyone is dismissed. It forms part of GCU MGT 825, Contemporary Business Law, catalog code MGT-825, which Grand Canyon University offers in its DBA. Three decisions are tested: a bachelor's degree requirement for team leads under Griggs v. Duke Power Co., a move to overnight shifts after a discrimination complaint under Burlington Northern and Santa Fe Railway Co. v. White, and a handbook page promising three warnings, with its disclaimer removed, under Woolley v. Hoffmann-La Roche. The termination objection is answered and three review points follow.

CourseMGT 825 Contemporary Business Law
TopicTopic 4
Paper typeExposure brief
LengthAbout 1,020 words, 4 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 825 Topic 4

1

Exposure Before the Firing: Three Routine Operations Decisions at a Regional Bank Tested Against Griggs, Burlington Northern and Woolley

[Author Name]

College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University

MGT-825: Contemporary Business Law

Topic 4 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the brief's claim, that employment exposure is created long before any dismissal, and names the three cases that test it. The bank and its decisions are an illustrative composite; the cases are real, and the brief is coursework, not legal advice.
2

Exposure Before the Firing: Three Routine Operations Decisions at a Regional Bank Tested Against Griggs, Burlington Northern and Woolley

The Claim and the Audience

This brief is written for the operations leadership of Keel Harbor Bank, a composite regional bank with about 1,400 employees in deposit processing, loan servicing and customer contact centers. Operations leaders approve policies and staffing changes every week, usually without routing them through employment counsel, because the changes look administrative. The brief makes one claim: the employment exposure worth managing is created by routine choices like these, long before anyone is dismissed. Three decisions from the last quarter show how. For each, the brief describes the decision as the manager made it, the case that governs it, the reasoning of that case in a few sentences and the specific exposure it creates for the bank, ending with the question a leader should have asked before approving it.

Decision One: A Degree Requirement for Team Leads

The decision. To raise the quality of supervision, the vice president of operations added a bachelor's degree requirement for promotion to team lead in the processing centers. Most current team leads were promoted from within without degrees, and their performance reviews are generally good.

The governing case. In Griggs v. Duke Power Co., the employer made a high school diploma, plus adequate scores on two general aptitude tests, a condition of transfer into its better-paid departments. The requirements were neutral on their face, but they excluded Black applicants at a much higher rate, and the company had not shown that either requirement measured the ability to do the jobs. The Supreme Court held that Title VII forbids practices that are fair in form but discriminatory in operation, unless the employer shows that the practice is related to job performance (Griggs v. Duke Power Co., 1971).

The exposure. Degree attainment differs across racial and ethnic groups in the bank's labor market, so the requirement may screen out protected groups disproportionately among the internal candidates. If it does, the bank would need evidence that a degree relates to performance as a team lead. The evidence it has points the other way, since the current team leads without degrees perform well. The question to ask before adopting the rule is what evidence connects a degree to this job.

What this page is doingThe Griggs section turns on whether the requirement relates to the job, which is the holding most often misstated.
3

Decision Two: A Shift Reassignment After a Complaint

The decision. A loan servicing specialist reported that a coworker made demeaning remarks about her national origin. The coworker was counseled. Two weeks later her manager moved her from the day shift to the overnight shift, with the same title and pay, citing staffing needs.

The governing case. In Burlington Northern, a forklift operator who complained of sex discrimination was reassigned to track laborer duties within the same job classification and was later suspended without pay, though the pay was restored. The Supreme Court held that Title VII's anti-retaliation provision covers employer actions that would be materially adverse to a reasonable employee, meaning actions that might well discourage a reasonable employee from filing or backing a discrimination charge, and that a reassignment within the same job classification can meet that standard depending on the circumstances (Burlington Northern, 2006).

The exposure. A move to overnight shifts can be a serious burden for an employee with children or a second job, and it followed her complaint closely in time. The fact that title and pay did not change does not make it harmless under this standard. The question to ask is whether the move might dissuade a reasonable employee from reporting, and whether the staffing reason was documented before the complaint.

Decision Three: A Revised Handbook Page

The decision. Human resources revised the employee handbook's discipline page to say that "employees will receive a verbal warning, a written warning and a final warning before termination for performance issues." The handbook's opening disclaimer, which said the handbook was not a contract, was removed in the same revision to make the document friendlier.

The governing case. In Woolley v. Hoffmann-La Roche, Inc., the Supreme Court of New Jersey held that job security and termination provisions in a widely distributed employment manual could be enforced as an implied contract, even for an at-will employee, unless the manual contained a clear and prominent disclaimer that it created no such promise (Woolley v. Hoffmann-La Roche, Inc., 1985). The rule is state law and varies across states, but many courts have followed a similar approach.

The exposure. The revised page uses the word "will" and describes a sequence employees could rely on, and the disclaimer that would have qualified it has been removed. An employee dismissed without the three warnings may argue that the handbook promised them. The question to ask is whether the language makes a promise and whether a clear disclaimer remains.

What this page is doingThe handbook is read for promissory language and for the disclaimer, the two features Woolley makes decisive.
4

The Termination Objection

The obvious objection is that employment claims arise from terminations, not from policies and shift changes, so leaders should focus their caution on dismissals. The objection is partly right: most claims are filed after someone is dismissed. But the evidence that decides those claims is created earlier. A dismissed team-lead candidate's claim will be judged by the evidence behind the degree rule; a retaliation claim will turn on the timing and documentation of the shift move; and a discharge claim will turn on what the handbook promised. By the time of the dismissal, the record has already been written by decisions like these three.

Three Review Points

Leaders could adopt three review points. Any new qualification for a job should be supported by evidence that it relates to performance in that job, and its effect on internal candidates should be checked before adoption. Any change to the schedule, duties or location of an employee who has complained within the past six months should be reviewed by human resources before it takes effect, with the business reason documented. And any revision to the handbook should be checked for language that promises procedures, with the disclaimer kept clear and prominent. As a coursework brief, it reviews no actual employer's practices and stands in for no attorney's review.

References

Burlington Northern & Santa Fe Railway Co. v. White, 548 U.S. 53 (2006).

Griggs v. Duke Power Co., 401 U.S. 424 (1971).

Woolley v. Hoffmann-La Roche, Inc., 99 N.J. 284, 491 A.2d 1257 (1985).

MGT 825 Topic 4 instructions, in plain terms

In Topic 4, MGT-825 asks doctoral learners to connect employment law to everyday management decisions. The brief places the source of exposure in policies and staffing choices rather than in terminations. A paper meets it when it takes concrete decisions, identifies the case that governs each, explains that case's reasoning briefly and states the specific exposure for the organization. Learners should state Griggs as a job-relatedness rule, apply the Burlington Northern standard to an action that left title and pay unchanged, and read handbook language for a promise and a disclaimer. The paper should answer the objection that claims arise from terminations and close with review points leaders could adopt, noting that it is coursework rather than counsel.

How the MGT-825 Topic 4 example is put together

The finished brief is written for a composite regional bank's operations leadership and makes one claim: the employment exposure worth managing is created by routine choices long before anyone is dismissed. Three decisions carry it. A new bachelor's degree requirement for team leads is tested under Griggs v. Duke Power Co., where the Supreme Court held that a neutral requirement with a disparate effect must be shown to relate to the job. Moving an employee from day processing to overnight shifts after she reported a coworker's remarks is tested under Burlington Northern and Santa Fe Railway Co. v. White, which asks whether an action might dissuade a reasonable worker from complaining. A handbook page promising progressive discipline is read against Woolley v. Hoffmann-La Roche. The objection that terminations are where claims arise is answered at the end.

MGT 825 Topic 4 rubric: what Excellent looks like

An Excellent brief earns its marks by keeping attention on decisions made before any firing. The rubric rewards one section per decision, each naming the governing case, its reasoning and the exposure it creates. Credit goes to stating Griggs correctly, that a neutral requirement with a disparate effect must relate to the job, and to recognizing that a reassignment with no pay cut can still be retaliation under Burlington Northern. Faculty look for the Woolley analysis to ask both whether the handbook promises a procedure and whether a disclaimer remains. Strong briefs concede that claims follow dismissals and show that the evidence is made earlier. Top marks go to specific review points instead of general advice.

MGT 825 Topic 4 help before you submit

Briefs on this topic most often go wrong by waiting for the firing. A paper that analyzes a termination at length and treats the earlier decisions as background has reversed the topic's emphasis. Griggs is regularly misstated as prohibiting any requirement with an uneven effect, when the decision turns on whether the requirement relates to the job. The Burlington Northern standard is frequently confused with the stricter test for discrimination claims, so a reassignment with no pay cut is wrongly dismissed as harmless. Handbook analysis loses credit when the disclaimer question is never asked. Recommendations that tell managers to consult human resources in general terms leave out the specific review point each decision needed, which is what the rubric in many sections rewards.

Get an MGT-825 Topic 4 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-825 Topic 4 instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with the scenario or decisions your section described. We write a custom example to those criteria, with each routine decision tested against the governing case, the reasoning applied rather than recited and the termination objection answered, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MGT 825 papers and DBA samples

MGT 825 Topic 4 questions, answered

What did Griggs v. Duke Power Co. hold?

The Supreme Court held that Title VII reaches practices that are neutral on their face but operate to exclude protected groups, unless the employer shows the practice is related to the job and consistent with business necessity. Duke Power's diploma and testing requirements failed that test. Congress later codified the disparate impact framework. For a manager, the lesson is that a reasonable-sounding qualification can still carry exposure.

Can a transfer with no pay cut be retaliation?

It can. In Burlington Northern and Santa Fe Railway Co. v. White, the Supreme Court held that retaliation covers actions that might well dissuade a reasonable worker from making or supporting a discrimination charge, and a reassignment to dirtier, harder duties within the same job category qualified. Whether a given shift change meets that standard depends on context, and the example treats it as a question for analysis.

Can a handbook create a contract?

In many states it can. In Woolley v. Hoffmann-La Roche, the New Jersey Supreme Court held that termination provisions in an employment manual could be enforceable absent a clear and prominent disclaimer. States differ on the rule and on what disclaimer suffices. The example reads a composite handbook page against that holding, as coursework rather than as advice on any real policy.

Where can I find a free MGT 825 Topic 4 sample paper?

The bank exposure brief is printed here in full: the claim, the degree requirement, the shift reassignment, the handbook page, the termination objection and three review points. Tell us which decisions your case describes and a free brief can be prepared for them.

Why is the shift move risky in MGT 825 Topic 4?

It followed a discrimination complaint by two weeks, and a move to overnight shifts might dissuade a reasonable worker from reporting. Under Burlington Northern, unchanged title and pay do not make such a reassignment harmless.