MGT 825 Topic 7 product decision exposure review example

Contemporary Business Law Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 825 Topic 7 sample paper is a memo reviewing the liability a composite power-tool maker would carry by switching to a cheaper battery supplier and cutting qualification testing from sixteen weeks to six. It sits in GCU MGT 825, Contemporary Business Law, catalog code MGT-825, late in this Grand Canyon University DBA course. The switch saves about 2.5 million dollars a year. Greenman v. Yuba Power Products makes the maker strictly liable for defects, United States v. Carroll Towing frames the shortened testing as a precaution declined, and Grimshaw v. Ford Motor Co. warns about deferring safety for cost. The memo answers the silence objection and approves the switch on four conditions.

CourseMGT 825 Contemporary Business Law
TopicTopic 7
Paper typeExposure review memo
LengthAbout 890 words, 3 pages
FormatMemo with APA 7 references
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 825 Topic 7

1

Memorandum

To: Operations Committee, Northgate Power Tools

From: Office of the Chief Operating Officer

Date: [Date]

Re: Liability review of the proposed battery pack supplier switch

 

The Proposal

Procurement proposes switching the 18-volt battery pack in our cordless drill and saw line to a new supplier. The new pack costs 4.10 dollars less per unit, which at 600,000 units a year saves about 2.5 million dollars annually. The supplier has not made packs for us before. To meet the spring launch date, the proposal shortens battery qualification testing from our standard sixteen weeks to six, dropping the extended thermal cycling and drop-and-abuse tests. This memo reviews the liability the switch would carry and recommends approval only on conditions. All figures are illustrative.

What this page is doingThe memo sets out the proposal as received and flags the shortened testing, where the exposure concentrates.
2

Strict Liability for Defects

The first exposure follows any defect, however careful we are. In Greenman v. Yuba Power Products, a man was injured when a piece of wood flew out of a combination power tool his wife had bought him. The Supreme Court of California held that a manufacturer is strictly liable in tort when an article it places on the market, knowing that it will be used without inspection for defects, proves to have a defect that causes injury to a person (Greenman v. Yuba Power Products, Inc., 1963). The injured user did not need to prove that the manufacturer was careless. Most states now follow some form of this rule.

For this decision, Greenman means that careful supplier selection would not defeat a claim if a pack overheats or vents. If a battery pack is defective and injures a user, we answer for it as the manufacturer of the tool, and we generally cannot disclaim that liability to injured consumers through warranty language. The savings must therefore be weighed against a liability that does not depend on fault.

The Precaution Question

The second question is whether shortening the testing is a reasonable precaution to decline. In United States v. Carroll Towing Co., Judge Learned Hand framed the duty of care as a comparison: a party is negligent if the burden of an adequate precaution is less than the probability of the harm multiplied by the gravity of the injury that results (United States v. Carroll Towing Co., 1947). Courts do not apply this as a formula, but it is a useful way to reason about whether a precaution was worth taking.

Applied here, the burden of the full sixteen-week qualification is about 380,000 dollars in testing and a ten-week delay to the launch. The harm it guards against is a thermal failure of a lithium-ion pack, which is uncommon but can cause fires and serious burns, and which could require a recall of every unit sold. The tests being dropped are the ones designed to find exactly that failure. A small probability multiplied by a very large harm can easily exceed 380,000 dollars and ten weeks. Shortening the testing would be a precaution declined to save time, and it would be hard to defend if a failure occurred.

What this page is doingThe Carroll Towing reasoning frames the shortened testing as a precaution declined, which is how a court would view it.
3

Punitive Exposure

The third exposure is the most serious. In Grimshaw v. Ford Motor Co., a California appellate court upheld punitive damages against Ford after a rear-end collision caused the fuel tank of a Ford Pinto to rupture and catch fire, killing the driver and severely burning a teenage passenger. The court found evidence that Ford's management knew from crash tests that the fuel tank design was vulnerable and decided to defer corrective measures that would have cost little per car, in order to save costs, which supported a finding of conscious disregard of public safety (Grimshaw v. Ford Motor Co., 1981). This memo keeps to what the court found rather than to popular retellings of the case.

The pattern to avoid is a documented decision to accept a known safety risk to save money. Approving the switch with shortened testing, after this committee has been told what the dropped tests are for, would come close to that pattern.

Supplier Contract and Insurance

The supplier agreement should require the new supplier to indemnify us for losses from defects in its packs, to carry product liability insurance naming us as an additional insured and to cooperate in any recall. Our own product liability insurer should confirm that coverage applies to tools using packs from the new supplier, since some policies require notice of material changes in components.

The Silence Objection

Some executives argue that safety trade-offs should not be written down at all, because written analysis can become evidence. The objection confuses two kinds of record. A record showing that we weighed a precaution and took it, or declined it for sound reasons, supports our position. A record showing that we knew of a hazard and deferred a fix to save money is what made Grimshaw so damaging. The answer is to make good decisions and record them honestly, not to avoid recording them.

Recommendation

Approve the switch on four conditions: full sixteen-week qualification testing, with the launch moved if necessary; a supplier indemnity and insurance clause as described; written confirmation of coverage from our insurer; and a named owner in quality engineering for field-failure reports, with authority to stop shipments if a pattern appears. On these conditions, the savings of about 2.5 million dollars a year justify the change. Prepared as a class exercise, the memo offers no opinion on any real product.

References

Greenman v. Yuba Power Products, Inc., 59 Cal. 2d 57, 377 P.2d 897 (1963).

Grimshaw v. Ford Motor Co., 119 Cal. App. 3d 757, 174 Cal. Rptr. 348 (1981).

United States v. Carroll Towing Co., 159 F.2d 169 (2d Cir. 1947).

MGT 825 Topic 7 instructions, in plain terms

Topic 7 in MGT-825 asks doctoral learners to review a pending business decision for the legal exposure it carries. A memo meets the brief when it describes the proposal as decision makers received it, identifies each kind of exposure and the case that governs it, and ends with a recommendation the committee can act on. Learners should explain strict product liability under Greenman, use the Carroll Towing reasoning as a way of weighing precautions rather than a mechanical formula, and describe Grimshaw from the court's findings rather than popular retellings. The memo should cover supplier contracts and insurance, answer the argument that safety trade-offs should stay unwritten and set conditions for approval, noting that it is coursework.

Inside the MGT 825 Topic 7 example

The finished review reads as a memo to a composite tool maker's operations committee, which must approve or reject a cheaper battery pack from a new supplier. Its first page states the exposure that would follow any defect: under Greenman v. Yuba Power Products, a manufacturer that places a defective product on the market is strictly liable for resulting injury, whatever care it took, so the savings must be weighed against a liability that generally cannot be disclaimed to injured consumers. The precaution question is framed with the reasoning of United States v. Carroll Towing Co., which compares the burden of a precaution with the probability and size of the harm. Grimshaw v. Ford Motor Co. supplies the warning about punitive damages where management knowingly defers a safety fix for cost. The review recommends approval on stated conditions.

Where the marks sit in the MGT 825 Topic 7 rubric

An Excellent review earns its marks by weighing exposure against the decision instead of answering yes or no. The rubric rewards papers that explain why careful supplier selection would not defeat a defect claim under Greenman, and that apply the Carroll Towing comparison to the specific tests being dropped. Credit goes to describing Grimshaw from what the court found about management knowingly deferring a safety fix. Faculty look for supplier indemnity and insurance treated as part of the analysis. Strong memos answer the silence objection by distinguishing an honest record of weighing precautions from documenting a deferred fix. Top marks go to approval conditions with a named owner for field failures.

MGT 825 Topic 7 help: mistakes that cost marks

The review falls short most often when it answers yes or no without conditions. A committee cannot act on a paper that approves the switch because it saves money, or rejects it because batteries can fail, since neither weighs the exposure against the decision. Strict liability is regularly confused with negligence, so papers argue that careful supplier selection would defeat a defect claim, which Greenman rejects. Carroll Towing is sometimes presented as a rule courts apply mechanically rather than as a way of reasoning about precaution. Grimshaw is frequently cited with figures and documents drawn from popular retellings rather than from the opinion, so the example keeps to what the court found. Papers that leave the silence objection unaddressed miss the argument a cautious executive would make first.

Get an MGT-825 Topic 7 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-825 Topic 7 instructions and the rubric posted in your classroom, with the business decision or case your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the decision tested for liability, precaution weighed, punitive exposure described accurately and conditions for approval stated, delivered in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MGT 825 papers and DBA samples

MGT 825 Topic 7 questions, answered

What is strict product liability?

Liability for injury caused by a defective product without proof that the manufacturer was negligent. Greenman v. Yuba Power Products, decided by the California Supreme Court, is the landmark statement of the rule, and most states now apply some form of it, though the tests for design defects vary. The example uses it to show why careful supplier choice lowers the exposure without removing it.

What does the Carroll Towing reasoning add to a business decision?

Judge Learned Hand framed negligence as a comparison: a party falls short when the burden of a precaution is less than the probability of harm multiplied by its severity. Courts do not apply it as an arithmetic rule, but it gives a manager a disciplined way to ask whether a skipped precaution was reasonable. The example applies it to shortened battery testing.

Should safety trade-offs be kept out of writing?

The example argues not. A company with no record of considering a hazard looks careless, and evidence that management knew of a hazard and deferred a fix to save money is what supported punitive damages in Grimshaw. The difference lies in what the analysis concludes and whether the company acts on it. This is coursework; document practices in a real company belong with its counsel.

Where can I find a free MGT 825 Topic 7 sample paper?

The battery supplier review memo is printed here in full, covering the proposal, strict liability, the precaution question, punitive exposure, the supplier contract, the silence objection and the four conditions. Send the decision your case describes and a free review memo can be drafted.

What conditions does the MGT 825 Topic 7 memo set?

Full sixteen-week qualification testing even if launch moves, a supplier indemnity and insurance clause, written confirmation of coverage from the company's insurer, and a named quality engineer with authority to stop shipments.