MKT 345 Topic 3 motive gap analysis example

Buyer and Consumer Behavior Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MKT 345 Topic 3 sample paper sets what composite reusable water bottle buyers say against what their orders imply. It was prepared for GCU MKT 345, Buyer and Consumer Behavior, catalog code MKT-345, a course in the Grand Canyon University BS in Marketing. About 62 percent name cutting plastic waste first, yet the average customer has bought 2.6 bottles. About 45 percent of repeat orders follow a new color release and 31 percent ship to another address. Drawing on Nisbett and Wilson, the paper labels novelty, gift-giving and identity as inferences, each with evidence for and against, and sets Maslow aside.

CourseMKT 345 Buyer and Consumer Behavior
TopicTopic 3
Paper typeMotive gap analysis
LengthAbout 970 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Marketing
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MKT 345 Topic 3

1

Buying Five Bottles to Cut Waste: Setting What Water Bottle Buyers Say Against What Their Orders Imply

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

MKT-345: Buyer and Consumer Behavior

Topic 3 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the gap the analysis studies. The brand, its customers and its figures are a composite; the sources are real.
2

Buying Five Bottles to Cut Waste: Setting What Water Bottle Buyers Say Against What Their Orders Imply

The Puzzle

A composite brand of insulated, reusable water bottles surveyed its customers about why they buy. The most common answer, given first by about 62 percent of 1,200 respondents, was to cut plastic waste. The brand's order records tell a different story. Across about 40,000 customers over three years, the average customer has bought 2.6 bottles, and 38 percent have bought three or more. A buyer reducing waste needs one bottle. This analysis sets what buyers say against what their purchases imply, and treats the gap between the two as the place where motivation can actually be studied. All figures are illustrative.

The Stated Reason, Taken Seriously

The analysis begins by accepting that the stated reason is sincere for many buyers. Concern about plastic waste is widespread, and a reusable bottle is a visible, low-cost way to act on it. White et al. (2019) reviewed research on sustainable consumption and found that people often hold sustainable values that do not translate consistently into behavior, and that social, habitual and identity factors shape what they actually do. The aim here is not to show that buyers are lying about their values, but to find what else their purchases suggest.

What the Orders Show

Three patterns in the order records stand out. First, repeat purchases cluster around the brand's seasonal color releases: about 45 percent of second and later orders arrive within 30 days of a new color launch. Second, about 31 percent of orders are shipped to an address different from the buyer's billing address, which usually indicates a gift. Third, buyers who post photos of their bottles on the brand's social pages buy, on average, about twice as many bottles as those who do not.

Table 1

Stated Reasons and Purchase Patterns, Illustrative

EvidenceFigureSuggested motive
Survey: first reason given62% say cutting plastic wasteEnvironmental value, as stated
Repeat orders within 30 days of a new colorAbout 45%Novelty and variety
Orders shipped to another addressAbout 31%Gift-giving
Bottles bought by buyers who post photosAbout twice the averageSelf-expression and identity

Why Buyers May Not Report the Real Reason

Nisbett and Wilson (1977) reviewed experiments showing that people often cannot accurately report the influences on their own choices. When asked why they did something, they supply reasons that sound plausible, often reasons their culture offers for such choices, rather than reasons drawn from direct insight into their own thinking. A buyer asked why she bought a reusable bottle has a ready, socially approved answer: to cut waste. That answer may be partly true and still leave out the influence of a new color, a friend's bottle or the pleasure of owning something attractive.

Motives the Purchase Pattern Suggests

Each of the following is an inference, not an observation, and each is listed with the evidence that supports it and the evidence that would count against it.

Novelty and variety: repeat orders cluster around new colors. This would be weakened if repeat buyers mainly replaced lost or broken bottles, which the brand could check through its warranty and replacement records.

Gift-giving: nearly a third of orders ship to another address. This would be weakened if those addresses were mostly the buyer's own workplace, which could be checked by comparing shipping and billing names.

Identity and self-expression: Belk (1988) argued that possessions become part of how people define and present themselves. The bottle is carried in public, chosen in a color and often photographed. The higher purchase rate among buyers who post photos fits this motive. It would be weakened if posting buyers simply had larger households.

Environmental value: still present. Many buyers likely hold it sincerely, and a reusable bottle does replace disposable ones for its owner. The analysis keeps it as a real motive, but not the only one.

A Framework Set Aside

Maslow (1943) proposed a hierarchy of needs from physiological needs through safety, belonging and esteem to self-actualization. It is often applied to purchases, and a bottle could be placed at several levels at once: hydration, belonging to an environmentally minded group, esteem from a stylish possession. Because it fits almost any purchase at some level, it does little to distinguish one motive from another in this case, so the analysis sets it aside in favor of evidence from the order records.

How the Survey Could Ask Better

Part of the gap comes from the survey itself. It asked buyers to name their main reason, which invites the most acceptable answer and allows only one. Better questions would ask about the specific purchase rather than the brand in general: whether this bottle replaced another, was added to ones already owned or was bought for someone else, and what made the buyer choose this color. Questions about behavior, such as how many bottles the household now owns and how often each is used, are also less open to socially approved answers than questions about values. Linking each survey response to the respondent's own order history, with permission, would let the brand compare stated and revealed reasons person by person instead of across the whole customer base.

What the Gap Means for the Brand

The gap suggests the brand serves at least two kinds of buyer: those who want one durable bottle to cut waste and those who enjoy collecting, giving and displaying bottles. Marketing that speaks only of waste reduction addresses the first group and may make the second group's behavior look inconsistent with the brand's own message. The brand should test, rather than assume, which motive drives which purchases, for example by asking buyers at checkout whether an order is a replacement, an addition or a gift. It should also consider whether encouraging many purchases fits its environmental claim, a question its most committed buyers may raise.

References

Belk, R. W. (1988). Possessions and the extended self. Journal of Consumer Research, 15(2), 139-168. https://doi.org/10.1086/209154

Maslow, A. H. (1943). A theory of human motivation. Psychological Review, 50(4), 370-396. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0054346

Nisbett, R. E., & Wilson, T. D. (1977). Telling more than we can know: Verbal reports on mental processes. Psychological Review, 84(3), 231-259. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.84.3.231

White, K., Habib, R., & Hardisty, D. J. (2019). How to SHIFT consumer behaviors to be more sustainable: A literature review and guiding framework. Journal of Marketing, 83(3), 22-49. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022242919825649

The MKT-345 Topic 3 assignment instructions

Topic 3 of MKT-345 asks students to analyze consumer motivation. Strong analyses take buyers' stated reasons seriously and then test them against what purchases show, explaining with research why people may not report the real influences on their choices. Students should label every inferred motive as an inference, give the evidence that supports it and the evidence that would count against it, judge whether broad motivation frameworks help in the case, suggest better ways to ask about motives, and explain what the gap means for the brand's marketing.

How the MKT-345 Topic 3 example is put together

The finished analysis treats the stated reason with respect and then tests it. Survey answers put waste reduction first, and the example accepts that many buyers hold that value sincerely. The order records tell a fuller story: repeat purchases cluster around new color releases, and bottles are frequently bought as gifts. A buyer reducing waste needs one bottle; a buyer expressing identity, marking membership in a group or enjoying novelty may want five. The example draws on the well-known finding by Nisbett and Wilson that people often cannot report the real influences on their choices and supply plausible reasons instead. Maslow's hierarchy is mentioned and set aside as too coarse for the case. Every motive the purchase pattern suggests is labeled as an inference, with the evidence that supports it and the evidence that would count against it.

MKT 345 Topic 3 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward an analysis that keeps inference and observation apart. An Excellent paper accepts the waste-reduction motive as sincere and then tests it against 2.6 bottles per customer. Credit goes to a table pairing each order pattern with the motive it suggests. The rubric values Nisbett and Wilson on unreliable self-reports and Belk on possessions and identity. Strong papers state what evidence would weaken each inferred motive and set Maslow aside with a reason. Top marks go to better survey questions and implications for the brand's message.

MKT 345 Topic 3 help: mistakes that cost marks

Taking the stated reason as the whole explanation is where marks drain first, since the course's central point here is that people give accounts of their choices rather than records of them. The opposite overcorrection also costs credit: treating buyers as hypocrites whose stated values are false, when the evidence supports several motives operating together. Papers that infer a motive and present it as fact have replaced one unverified claim with another. Maslow's hierarchy applied mechanically, a water bottle placed on a tier, adds little analysis and is widely criticized as a predictive tool. Order data described without being compared to the stated reasons leaves the gap undemonstrated. A conclusion that tells the brand to abandon its sustainability message ignores that the stated value may still be what brings a first-time buyer in.

Get an MKT-345 Topic 3 example written to your instructions

Send the MKT-345 Topic 3 instructions and the rubric attached in your classroom, with the product, brand or data your section provides. We write a custom example to them, with stated reasons reported fairly, purchase patterns laid out, the gap between them shown and every inferred motive labeled with its evidence, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MKT 345 papers and BS in Marketing samples

MKT 345 Topic 3 questions, answered

Why are stated reasons unreliable?

People usually explain a choice once it is made, assembling an account from what sounds reasonable. Nisbett and Wilson's well-known work found people confidently naming influences that had played no part in their decisions. The survey answers therefore tell the brand how its buyers see themselves, which matters, and the example treats that as a separate question from what drove each order.

Is Maslow's hierarchy useful here?

As vocabulary more than as a tool. The hierarchy offers a familiar way to name needs such as belonging and esteem, and those names help describe what a purchase pattern suggests. As a predictive model it has been widely criticized, and placing a product on a single tier oversimplifies purchases that serve several needs at once, as the water bottles clearly do.

How is an inferred motive kept honest?

By labeling it as an inference and showing its basis. The example writes, for instance, that buying new colors each season suggests novelty or self-expression, then names what would weaken that reading, such as the new bottles going mainly to family members. A motive presented with its evidence and its counter-evidence can be judged; one asserted as fact cannot.

Where can I find a free MKT 345 Topic 3 sample paper?

Every section of the motive gap analysis is shown below: the puzzle, the stated reason, what the orders show, why buyers may not report the real reason, inferred motives, a framework set aside, better survey questions and what the gap means. Send your case's data and we will work through it free.

What do the orders suggest in MKT 345 Topic 3?

Novelty, since repeat orders cluster around new colors; gift-giving, since nearly a third ship to another address; and identity, since buyers who post photos buy about twice as many. Each is labeled an inference.