| Course | MKT 462 Digital Marketing and Advertising |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Budget reallocation memo |
| Length | About 800 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Marketing |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MKT 462 Topic 7
Memorandum
To: Vice President of Marketing
From: Director of Growth
Date: [Date]
Re: Reallocating the quarterly digital budget based on incrementality tests
The Proposal and the Recommendation
Our analyst has proposed moving 150,000 dollars a quarter from paid social into branded search and coupon affiliates, the channels our last-click report ranks highest. This memo recommends the opposite direction. Our own tests show that paid social causes far more sales than last-click credits it with, and that branded search, retargeting and coupon affiliates cause far fewer. The recommendation moves 135,000 dollars a quarter within an unchanged 600,000-dollar budget. All figures are illustrative.
What the Tests Found
Three tests over the past year measured what each channel adds, rather than what it is present for.
Paid social: a geographic test paused paid social in matched regions for six weeks. Sales in those regions fell by enough to put paid social's incremental return at about 1.90 dollars per dollar spent, well below the 4.10 dollars its platform reports, but still profitable at our margins. Gordon et al. (2019) found in large Facebook experiments that observational measures often misstate ad effects, and our test is consistent with that.
Branded search: pausing brand-keyword ads in two regions recovered about 85 percent of the bookings through free listings, so only about 15 percent of the bookings branded search reports were caused by the ads. Its reported return of about 9 dollars per dollar falls to an incremental return of about 1.35. Blake et al. (2015) found the same pattern at far larger scale at eBay.
Retargeting: a holdout that withheld retargeting ads from a random fifth of site visitors found that it returned about 70 cents per dollar, a loss. Lambrecht and Tucker (2013) found that retargeting is less effective than often assumed, working mainly for shoppers whose preferences are already well defined.
Coupon affiliates were not tested, but their commissions are paid when a shopper with an item already in the cart searches for a code, which suggests most of those sales would have happened anyway.
The Reallocation
Table 1 shows the current quarterly budget and the recommended one.
Table 1
Quarterly Budget, Current and Recommended, Dollars
| Channel | Current | Recommended | Change | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paid social prospecting | 200,000 | 275,000 | plus 75,000 | Incremental return about 1.90 |
| Non-brand search | 100,000 | 160,000 | plus 60,000 | Reaches shoppers not yet searching for us |
| Branded search | 90,000 | 40,000 | minus 50,000 | About 85% of bookings recovered when paused |
| Display retargeting | 80,000 | 40,000 | minus 40,000 | Holdout return about 70 cents per dollar |
| Coupon affiliates | 70,000 | 25,000 | minus 45,000 | Commissions capped; mostly late-cart sales |
| Other display | 60,000 | 60,000 | None | Untested; held steady |
| Total | 600,000 | 600,000 | 135,000 moved |
Why Not Cut Branded Search Entirely
Branded search is cut back, not eliminated. The budget that remains bids only on our brand terms where competitors bid against us, since in those auctions a rival's ad could otherwise sit above our free listing and take shoppers who were looking for us. That is where the ad protects bookings rather than merely witnessing them.
A Caution About the Next Dollar
The 1.90 return for paid social is an average across our current spending. The next dollar will likely return less, because added spending reaches people less likely to buy. Moving 75,000 dollars a quarter into paid social raises its budget by more than a third, so the memo recommends a second geographic test at the new level within two quarters to check that the added spending still pays.
Risks of the Change
Two risks deserve the vice president's attention. First, the tests were run in particular regions and seasons, and their results may not hold everywhere or in the holiday quarter; the follow-up test and the monthly sales review are designed to catch that. Second, the analyst's proposal reflects a real pressure, since the last-click report is what many teams and agencies are paid against. If agency fees or bonuses are tied to last-click results, the change will appear to make those parties perform worse. The memo recommends moving agency reporting to the same total-sales measure before the change takes effect, so no one is penalized for following the evidence.
What the Last-Click Report Will Show
The board should expect the last-click report to look worse after this change. Branded search and coupon affiliates will report fewer sales because they will have less budget to be present at the end of purchases, and paid social will not receive much more last-click credit because it works earlier in the path. Total sales, the measure that matters, should hold or rise. The memo recommends judging the change on total sales in the next two quarters, compared with the same quarters last year and adjusted for market trends, and not on the last-click report.
Request
Approve the reallocation in Table 1 from next quarter and fund a follow-up geographic test of paid social at the new spending level.
References
Blake, T., Nosko, C., & Tadelis, S. (2015). Consumer heterogeneity and paid search effectiveness: A large-scale field experiment. Econometrica, 83(1), 155-174. https://doi.org/10.3982/ECTA12423
Gordon, B. R., Zettelmeyer, F., Bhargava, N., & Chapsky, D. (2019). A comparison of approaches to advertising measurement: Evidence from big field experiments at Facebook. Marketing Science, 38(2), 193-225. https://doi.org/10.1287/mksc.2018.1135
Lambrecht, A., & Tucker, C. (2013). When does retargeting work? Information specificity in online advertising. Journal of Marketing Research, 50(5), 561-576. https://doi.org/10.1509/jmr.11.0503
MKT 462 Topic 7 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 7 brief in MKT-462 asks students to reallocate a digital budget on evidence of cause. Strong memos set the last-click proposal beside what incrementality tests found, channel by channel, with research support. Students should present the reallocation in a table that keeps the total unchanged, explain any channel kept in reduced form and why, caution that marginal returns fall as spending rises, address risks including incentives tied to last-click reporting, and state how the change will be judged on total sales.
Inside the MKT 462 Topic 7 example
The finished memo opens with the analyst's proposal, to shift $150,000 a quarter from paid social into branded search and coupon affiliates, and sets beside it what the brand's tests found, every figure labeled illustrative. A geo test put paid social's incremental return near $1.90 per dollar, well below the $4.10 its platform reports but still profitable. Pausing branded search in two regions recovered about 85 percent of bookings through free listings. A retargeting holdout returned about 70 cents per dollar. The memo then moves $135,000 within an unchanged $600,000 budget: branded search is cut back to the terms rivals bid on, retargeting is halved and coupon-site commissions are capped, while paid social prospecting and non-brand search gain. A caution notes that the next dollar in social will likely return less than the average one did.
Reading the MKT 462 Topic 7 rubric
Faculty reward a memo that follows evidence of cause. An Excellent memo shows paid social at about 1.90 incremental against 4.10 reported, citing Gordon and colleagues. Credit goes to brand search losing about 85 percent of bookings to free listings, with Blake, Nosko and Tadelis, and to Lambrecht and Tucker on retargeting. The rubric values a table moving 135,000 dollars within 600,000. Strong memos keep brand bids where rivals compete and warn that the next social dollar returns less. Top marks go to moving agency reporting to total sales.
MKT 462 Topic 7 help: mistakes that cost marks
Reallocating on last-click numbers is the defining mistake here, and papers that make it lose heavily, because the channels credited last are often the ones intercepting buyers who had already decided. Treating a tested average return as the return on the next dollar is subtler and nearly as common, since social may pay back less as spending rises. Drafts often cut a channel outright on one weak result, when a smaller move paired with a further test would be defensible. Many memos change the total budget as well as the mix, which blurs whether the recommendation is about allocation at all. Leaving out the reported figures makes the argument look one-sided, because a reader wants to see what the dashboard claimed. Without a standing holdout, next quarter's decision falls back on the same reports this memo set aside.
Get an MKT-462 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the MKT-462 Topic 7 instructions and the rubric provided in your classroom, with the budget, channel results or case your section supplied. We write a custom example to those criteria, with reported and tested returns compared, spend moved within a fixed total, diminishing returns addressed and a standing holdout kept, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More MKT 462 papers and BS in Marketing samples
- MKT 462 Topic 1: Tracking Coverage Audit
- MKT 462 Topic 2: Cross-device Path Analysis
- MKT 462 Topic 3: Attribution Model Comparison
- MKT 462 Topic 4: Channel Economics Comparison
- MKT 462 Topic 5: Incrementality Dq Post
- MKT 462 Topic 6: Geo Lift Test Design
- MKT 462 Topic 8: Digital Measurement Plan
- MKT 315 Topic 7: Distribution and Promotion Alignment
- MKT 445 Topic 7: Executive Research Report
- MKT 345 Topic 7: Situational Influence Case Study
- MKT 443 Topic 7: Post-launch Usage Review
MKT 462 Topic 7 questions, answered
Why not move budget to the channels with the most last-click conversions?
Because those channels tend to appear at the moment of purchase, after something else created the interest. Branded search, coupon sites and retargeting all reach people close to buying, and last-click reporting rewards that position. Moving money toward them and away from channels that introduce the brand can look efficient for a quarter or two while the number of new people entering the path quietly shrinks.
What are diminishing returns in ad spending?
The tendency for each additional dollar in a channel to produce less than the one before, as the most responsive audiences are reached first and later spending reaches people less likely to act. A test measures the average return at the spending level tested. The example assumes the next dollar in paid social will return less than that average and keeps the increase within a range the test can reasonably support.
What is a standing holdout?
A small group of people or regions deliberately kept from seeing a channel's advertising on an ongoing basis, so its incremental effect can be measured continuously rather than once. It costs some sales, since the held-out group receives no ads, and it replaces periodic arguments about attribution with a running comparison. The example sets aside a small share of each major channel's audience for that purpose.
Where can I find a free MKT 462 Topic 7 sample paper?
The reallocation memo is shown here complete: the proposal and recommendation, what the tests found, the reallocation table, why branded search is kept in part, the next-dollar caution, risks, what the last-click report will show and the request. Bring your test results and we will draft a free memo.
Why keep some branded search in MKT 462 Topic 7?
In auctions where competitors bid on the brand's name, a rival's ad can appear above the brand's free listing and draw away shoppers who were looking for it. Ads in those auctions protect bookings rather than merely witnessing them.