MKT 660 Topic 1 standardization position paper example

International Marketing Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MKT 660 Topic 1 sample paper argues that a composite Ohio cordless tool maker selling in five countries should decide standardization element by element rather than adopt one global program. It was written for GCU MKT 660, International Marketing, catalog code MKT-660, in the Grand Canyon University MS in Marketing. Levitt's case for global markets is set against Douglas and Wind's reply and later evidence. The battery platform and brand stay identical, chargers, plugs and labels change by law, and pricing sits within bands, with trade promotion and assortment adapted. A governance split assigns each decision. The paper ends with who decides each element.

CourseMKT 660 International Marketing
TopicTopic 1
Paper typeStandardization position paper
LengthAbout 1,000 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMS in Marketing
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MKT 660 Topic 1

1

Neither One Program Nor Five: A Position Paper That Decides Standardization Element by Element for a Cordless Tool Maker

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

MKT-660: International Marketing

Topic 1 Position Paper

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the paper's position and its unit of decision. The toolmaker and every figure are a composite; the sources are real.
2

Neither One Program Nor Five: A Position Paper That Decides Standardization Element by Element for a Cordless Tool Maker

The Position

A composite Ohio maker of cordless power tools sells in five countries: the United States, Canada, Mexico, the United Kingdom and Australia. Its new chief marketing officer wants one global marketing program by next year. This paper takes a side at the outset: neither one global program nor five local ones, but a verdict reached separately for each element of the marketing mix. The standardization debate has stayed open for decades largely because it is argued about whole programs, when the useful answer changes from one element to the next. All figures are illustrative.

The Case for Standardization

Levitt (1983) made the strongest case for standardization. He argued that technology was drawing consumer preferences together around the world, so that firms selling standardized products at low prices, made possible by global scale, would beat firms that adapted to every local difference. On his view, many apparent national differences were habits that would give way to better value.

The Reply

Douglas and Wind (1987) replied that Levitt's assumptions held only in some product categories and some markets. They pointed out that consumer preferences often remain different, that economies of scale in production are less decisive than he claimed, and that standardization carries real costs when it ignores local conditions. Later research found that the answer depends on the element and the market: Szymanski et al. (1993) studied firms across Western markets and found that standardizing some strategic elements was often feasible where markets were similar, while other elements needed adaptation.

Applying Both to the Toolmaker

The two arguments look less opposed once they are applied element by element. Table 1 gives the verdict for each.

Table 1

Standardization Verdict by Element

ElementVerdictReason
Battery platform and tool designStandardizeContractors buy into one battery that fits every tool; cross-border buyers compare kits
Brand mark and core positioningStandardizeContractors working in several countries recognize one brand
Chargers and plugsAdapt, requiredDifferent plug types and voltages in the UK and Australia
Labels and instructionsAdapt, requiredBilingual English and French in Canada; Spanish and national standards in Mexico
PricingCoordinate within bandsCross-border comparison by contractors near borders; local costs and duties differ
Trade promotionAdaptRetail structures and promotional calendars differ
Retail assortmentAdaptRetailers stock different kit sizes and tool mixes

Where Standardization Wins

The battery platform and brand mark stay identical in all five countries. A cordless tool buyer is really buying into a battery system: once a contractor owns several batteries, every new tool that fits them is cheaper to adopt, and switching brands means replacing the batteries too. Contractors who work on both sides of the Canadian border compare kits and expect the same batteries to fit. Levitt's argument is strongest here: the same product meets the same need, and one platform gives the scale that keeps tool prices competitive.

Where Law Decides

Chargers, plugs and labels must differ, and no strategic argument changes that. Britain and Australia use different plug types and higher voltages than North America, Canada requires product information in both English and French, and Mexico has its own labeling and safety standards. These adaptations are not choices; they are the cost of entering the market, and the paper prices them as fixed.

Where the Answer Sits in Between

Pricing, trade promotion and retail assortment are where the choice is real. Pricing is coordinated within bands rather than set identically: duties, distribution costs and exchange rates differ, but a contractor near the border who sees a kit priced 30 percent lower across it will buy there. Trade promotion and assortment are adapted, because a promotion that works with a large home improvement chain in the United States may not suit a British trade counter or an Australian hardware cooperative. For each, the paper weighs the cost of adapting against the local gain: a separate trade promotion program for Australia costs an estimated 180,000 dollars a year, against an expected sales gain several times larger in a market where trade counters sell most tools to professionals.

Governing the Split

A split of this kind needs clear decision rights, or every element drifts toward whichever side has the louder advocate. The paper proposes that headquarters owns the battery platform, product design, brand identity and the price bands, and that no country may change them without a case reviewed centrally. Country managers own trade promotion, retail assortment and local media within the brand guidelines, and report results quarterly against shared measures. Legal adaptations are owned jointly by product engineering and each country's compliance lead. Writing these rights down at the start prevents the common outcome in which a global program is announced and then quietly localized in every market.

The Risks of Drawing the Line Wrong

Each side of the line carries a risk. Standardizing too much would leave the toolmaker with trade promotions that do not fit British trade counters and kits that Australian hardware cooperatives do not stock, losing sales that adaptation would have won. Adapting too much would fragment the battery platform or the brand, and a contractor who finds that batteries bought in Toronto do not fit tools bought in Buffalo would have a reason to switch brands entirely. The paper's verdicts place the line where the cost of each mistake is lowest.

What This Means for the Chief Marketing Officer

The chief marketing officer can have a global program, but it should be global where it creates value and local where markets differ. The battery platform, brand and positioning become the global core, governed centrally. Legal adaptations are handled as compliance. Pricing operates within agreed bands, and trade promotion and assortment are set by country teams within a shared brand framework. This answers the question at the level where it can actually be decided. It also gives the chief marketing officer a version of the global program that can be launched next year, which an all-or-nothing debate would not.

References

Douglas, S. P., & Wind, Y. (1987). The myth of globalization. Columbia Journal of World Business, 22(4), 19-29.

Levitt, T. (1983). The globalization of markets. Harvard Business Review, 61(3), 92-102.

Szymanski, D. M., Bharadwaj, S. G., & Varadarajan, P. R. (1993). Standardization versus adaptation of international marketing strategy: An empirical investigation. Journal of Marketing, 57(4), 1-17. https://doi.org/10.1177/002224299305700401

The MKT-660 Topic 1 assignment instructions

Topic 1 in MKT-660 asks students to take a position on standardizing or adapting international marketing. Strong papers state a position at once, present the case for standardization and the main reply at full strength, and apply both to a specific company. Students should reach a verdict for each element of the marketing mix with reasons, separate legal requirements from strategic choices, weigh costs against local gains where the choice is real, propose who decides each element and explain the risks of drawing the line in the wrong place.

Inside the MKT 660 Topic 1 example

The finished paper takes a side in its opening paragraph: neither one global program nor five local ones, but a verdict reached separately for each element of the mix. Levitt's case for global standardization is stated at full strength, including his claim that technology was drawing consumer preferences together, and Douglas and Wind's reply, that his assumptions hold only in some categories, is set against it. Both are then applied to the composite toolmaker. The battery platform and brand mark stay identical, because contractors who work on both sides of the Canadian border compare kits, and a battery that fits every tool is what they buy. Chargers, plugs and labels must differ by law. Trade promotion, pricing and retail assortment sit in between, argued on cost against local effect, with each figure labeled illustrative.

Reading the MKT 660 Topic 1 rubric

Faculty reward a position argued at the level of each mix element. An Excellent paper presents Levitt's globalization thesis and Douglas and Wind's reply fairly, with Szymanski and colleagues on similar markets. Credit goes to a table standardizing the battery platform and brand, adapting chargers and labels by law, and banding prices. The rubric values pricing an Australian trade program against its expected gain. Strong papers assign decision rights between headquarters and country teams. Top marks go to naming the risks of standardizing or adapting too much.

MKT 660 Topic 1 help: mistakes that cost marks

Most of the credit lost goes to a verdict for standardization or adaptation adopted as policy, which settles in one sentence what the course spends eight topics deciding. Close behind is a literature review that summarizes Levitt and his critics without applying either to a firm, so the theory never touches a price or a label. Drafts often place regulated elements in the judgment column, as though a company could choose whether to print French on packaging sold in Quebec. Some papers argue from culture alone and ignore that the toolmaker's buyers are contractors, whose needs vary less across borders than those of retail shoppers. An unsupported claim that standardization raises profit, where reviews of the evidence report mixed results, weakens a graduate argument. Leaving the fragmentation objection unanswered lets a reader dismiss the element-by-element method as indecision.

Get an MKT-660 Topic 1 example written to your instructions

Send the MKT-660 Topic 1 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the company or industry your section assigned. We write a custom example to them, with a position stated first, the standardization literature applied to one firm and every element of the mix sorted with its reason, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MKT 660 papers and MS in Marketing samples

MKT 660 Topic 1 questions, answered

What did Levitt actually argue about global markets?

Levitt held that modern communication and transport were pulling consumer wants toward convergence, and that companies selling standardized products at low prices would beat those tailoring everything to local taste. It was a deliberately strong claim. Douglas and Wind replied that it rests on assumptions, such as buyers everywhere trading features for price, which hold only in some categories. The example treats both as arguments to test on specific elements, not as rival policies.

What counts as an element of the marketing mix here?

Anything the company can decide separately for a market: the product specification, the brand name and mark, packaging and labels, the price and its discount structure, advertising copy and media, sales promotion, and the retail or distributor channel. Breaking the program into these pieces is what allows some to stay identical while others change. The example lists fourteen such elements for the toolmaker and gives each one verdict.

Is standardization always cheaper?

It usually lowers production, creative and coordination costs, which is why it attracts executives. It can also cost sales where a standardized element suits no market well, and some savings disappear when regulation forces changes anyway. The example sets the savings from keeping an element identical against the local sales it might lose, one element at a time, and labels every figure as illustrative rather than presenting it as data.

Where can I find a free MKT 660 Topic 1 sample paper?

The position paper is shown here complete: the position, the case for standardization, the reply, the element table, where standardization wins, where law decides, where the answer sits in between, governance, risks and what it means for the chief marketing officer. Describe your company and we will write a free paper.

Why keep the battery platform identical in MKT 660 Topic 1?

Contractors buy into a battery system and compare kits across the Canadian border. One battery that fits every tool in every country is what they value, and it gives the scale that keeps prices competitive.