MKT 830 Topic 1 founding object essay example

The History and Philosophy of Marketing Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MKT 830 Topic 1 sample paper argues that early American marketing scholarship took the distribution system and its cost to the public, not the firm, as its founding object. It was written for GCU MKT 830, The History and Philosophy of Marketing, catalog code MKT-830, which doctoral students take in Grand Canyon University's DBA. The commodity, institutional and functional approaches are read as three ways of dividing one flow of goods. Copeland's classification of goods and Shaw's analysis of middlemen serve as primary evidence, and the objection that Shaw wrote for manufacturers is met directly. The essay closes by arguing that the later turn to the firm should be read as a choice, not a discovery.

CourseMKT 830 The History and Philosophy of Marketing
TopicTopic 1
Paper typeFounding object essay
LengthAbout 990 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MKT 830 Topic 1

1

The Founding Object Was the Distribution System: An Essay on What Early Marketing Scholarship Believed It Was Studying

[Author Name]

College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University

MKT-830: The History and Philosophy of Marketing

Topic 1 Essay

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the essay's thesis. The argument draws on primary and historical sources that are real and cited.
2

The Founding Object Was the Distribution System: An Essay on What Early Marketing Scholarship Believed It Was Studying

Thesis

When marketing became a university subject in the United States in the first decades of the twentieth century, its founding object was the distribution system and its cost to the public, not the individual firm. Early scholars asked why goods cost so much more in the city than on the farm, why so many middlemen stood between producer and consumer, and whether their charges were justified. The chain of middlemen, rather than any single seller, was the unit of analysis. This essay defends that claim from the field's early approaches and primary texts and then meets the strongest objection to it: that some of the earliest and most influential writing was addressed to manufacturers, not to the public.

The Intellectual Setting

Marketing grew out of economics, and in particular out of the German historical school's interest in how economic institutions actually worked, which several early American marketing scholars encountered through teachers trained in Germany. Jones and Monieson (1990) traced this lineage and showed that early marketing thought at universities such as Wisconsin was concerned with the efficiency and fairness of distribution, a public question as much as a business one. Agricultural marketing was a central concern: farmers received a small share of what consumers paid for their produce, and the gap demanded explanation. Bartels (1988) documented how the first courses and texts took shape around problems of distribution rather than around the decisions of individual firms.

Three Ways of Cutting One Object

The field's three early approaches can be read as three ways of dividing the same object, the flow of goods from producer to consumer.

The commodity approach studied the distribution of particular goods, such as grain, cotton or fruit, following each from farm or factory to final buyer and asking what each step added. The institutional approach studied the organizations that handled goods along the way, wholesalers, jobbers, brokers and retailers, and asked what each did and what it cost. The functional approach studied the functions performed along the chain, such as assembling, storing, financing, risk bearing and selling, and asked whether each was necessary and who could perform it most efficiently.

Each approach takes a different slice, but all three slice the same thing. None takes the individual firm's decisions as its starting point. The firm appears, but as one participant in a system whose overall performance is the question.

Primary Evidence

The classification of convenience, shopping and specialty goods (Copeland, 1923) is often remembered today as a tool for brand managers. Read in its original context, it is an argument about distribution: the classification sorts goods by how consumers buy them in order to explain which channels and how many outlets each kind of good requires. Convenience goods need wide distribution through many retailers; specialty goods can be sold through few. The unit is the channel appropriate to a class of goods.

Shaw (1912) analyzed the functions of middlemen and the problems of market distribution in a long article in an economics journal. Shaw asked how goods reach consumers, what the middleman contributes and how distribution costs might be reduced. The analysis is organized around the movement of goods and the activities that movement requires, which is the functional view in an early and influential form.

The Strongest Objection

The objection deserves to be stated at full strength. Shaw was not a public economist but a businessman and publisher, and the article was written in part for manufacturers. The article was concerned with how a manufacturer might reach consumers more effectively, including by bypassing middlemen, and it discussed demand creation, which sounds like the modern firm-centered field. If one of the founding texts was addressed to manufacturers, the claim that the founding object was the system rather than the firm seems weakened.

Answering the Objection

The answer lies in how Shaw framed the manufacturer's problem. Shaw treated it as a problem of moving goods through a system of distribution: which functions the manufacturer could take over from middlemen, how much it would save, and how the price consumers paid would change. Even the discussion of demand creation is set within an analysis of how goods flow and who performs each function. The manufacturer is a participant deciding how to position itself in a flow, not a decision maker choosing among controllable variables in an environment of uncontrollable ones, which is how later managerial texts would frame the firm. Shaw's firm-level problem was still a system-level problem seen from one point in the system. The objection shows that the early field had an audience among businesses; it does not show that its object was the firm.

Why the Distinction Matters

Recognizing the founding object matters for how the field's later history is read. If marketing began as the study of the distribution system and its social cost, then the later turn to managerial decision making was not the field finding its true subject but changing it. Questions the founders treated as central, such as whether the costs of distribution were justified and who bore them, moved to the margins. The essay does not argue that the change was wrong. It argues that it was a change, and that the field's origins offer a standard against which later definitions can be measured.

Conclusion

Early American marketing scholarship took as its object the system that carries goods from producers to consumers and the cost of that system to the public. Its three classic approaches divided that object by commodity, institution and function. Copeland's classification and Shaw's functional analysis, the field's best-known early texts, both treat the channel and the flow as the unit. Even where early writers addressed manufacturers, they framed the manufacturer's problem as a position within that flow. The firm became the field's object later, and that later shift should be read as a choice.

References

Bartels, R. (1988). The history of marketing thought (3rd ed.). Publishing Horizons.

Copeland, M. T. (1923). Relation of consumers' buying habits to marketing methods. Harvard Business Review, 1(3), 282-289.

Jones, D. G. B., & Monieson, D. D. (1990). Early development of the philosophy of marketing thought. Journal of Marketing, 54(1), 102-113. https://doi.org/10.1177/002224299005400107

Shaw, A. W. (1912). Some problems in market distribution. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 26(4), 703-765. https://doi.org/10.2307/1883802

The MKT-830 Topic 1 assignment instructions

Topic 1 in MKT-830 asks doctoral students to explain what early marketing scholarship took as its object of study. Strong essays state a thesis rather than a timeline, place the field's origins in its intellectual setting, read the early approaches against that thesis and use primary texts as evidence. Students should state the strongest objection to their thesis at full strength, answer it from the texts themselves, and explain why the founding object matters for reading the field's later history. The essay should end by showing how its reading changes the way later definitions of the field are judged.

How the MKT-830 Topic 1 example is put together

Its thesis comes in the finished essay's opening paragraph, and every later page defends it. Early American marketing scholarship, it argues, grew out of economics and asked, among other things, why goods cost so much more in the city than on the farm, which made the chain of middlemen, not the individual seller, its unit of analysis. The commodity, institutional and functional approaches are read as three ways of cutting that one object: by the goods moving through it, by the institutions handling them, and by the functions performed along the way. Copeland's classification of convenience, shopping and specialty goods and Shaw's analysis of middlemen's functions serve as primary evidence. The essay then takes the objection seriously, since Shaw wrote as a businessman for manufacturers, and argues that even his firm-level problem was framed as a flow of goods.

MKT 830 Topic 1 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward an essay that defends a thesis from primary sources. An Excellent essay places the founding object in the distribution system, drawing on Jones and Monieson and on Bartels. Credit goes to reading the commodity, institutional and functional approaches as three cuts of one flow. The rubric values Copeland's goods classification read as a channel argument and Shaw's middleman functions as primary evidence. Strong essays state the objection that Shaw wrote for manufacturers at full strength. Top marks go to answering it by showing his firm problem was framed as a flow.

Common MKT 830 Topic 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them

At this level the heaviest deduction goes to the essay that recounts who wrote what and when, since a chronology of the founding decades can be accurate throughout and still say nothing about the object the founders believed they had. Treating the early schools as a list, commodity then institutional then functional, misses the question of whether they shared an object. Many drafts read the founding period through the managerial vocabulary that came later, describing early scholars as studying customers or the marketing mix. The objection from Shaw's manufacturer-facing writing is often left out, which makes the thesis look stronger than it is. Secondary histories are sometimes cited as settled fact, when their periodizations are themselves positions. Doctoral readers also mark down invented dates or quotations, which careful essays avoid by citing the work and describing its argument.

Get an MKT-830 Topic 1 example written to your instructions

Send the MKT-830 Topic 1 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with any readings your section assigned. We write a custom example to those instructions, with a thesis about the founding object stated first, the early schools read as evidence, the strongest objection answered and every source cited for what it argues, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MKT 830 papers and DBA samples

MKT 830 Topic 1 questions, answered

What were the early schools of marketing thought?

Histories usually identify three founding approaches: the commodity school, which studied how particular goods moved to market; the institutional school, which studied the wholesalers, retailers and agents who moved them; and the functional school, which studied the tasks performed along the way, such as buying, storing, financing and selling. Later classifications, including the one by Sheth, Gardner and Garrett, extended the list to many more schools.

Why does a doctoral course care about the founding decades?

Because the questions a field starts with shape what it later treats as normal. A discipline founded on the cost of distribution to the public carries different obligations from one founded on the firm's need to sell, and knowing which came first lets a scholar see what the later redefinitions kept and what they dropped. The example uses the founding period as the baseline for every later topic.

Can secondary histories be cited instead of the original texts?

They can, provided the essay is clear about which it is doing. Bartels and Wilkie and Moore are valuable guides, but a claim about what an early scholar argued is stronger when the original article is read and cited. The example cites originals where they are available and marks each place where it relies on a secondary account instead.

Where can I find a free MKT 830 Topic 1 sample paper?

The essay is shown here complete: thesis, intellectual setting, three ways of cutting one object, primary evidence, the strongest objection, the answer, why the distinction matters and the conclusion. Bring your doctoral prompt and we will draft a free essay to it.

How does the essay answer the Shaw objection in MKT 830 Topic 1?

Shaw wrote partly for manufacturers, but he framed their problem as choosing which distribution functions to take over within a flow of goods, so even his firm-level question was a system-level one.