| Course | MKT 838 Complexity of Marketing |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Product seeding memo |
| Length | About 800 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MKT 838 Topic 4
Memorandum
To: Chief Executive and Marketing Lead
From: Head of Growth
Date: [Date]
Re: The agency's forecast for the 400-creator seeding launch
The Plan and the Forecast
We plan to mail free fermentation kits to 400 creators with large followings the week before launch. The agency forecasts the resulting sales by adding up the creators' audiences, about 90 million followers in total, multiplying by the share it expects to see a post, then by click and purchase rates from past campaigns, to reach about 15,000 kits sold in the first two months. This memo argues that the forecast treats seeding as a push into a still market, when the effect depends on how audiences, competitors and future buyers respond to the push itself. All figures are illustrative.
Audiences Overlap and Saturate
The forecast counts each creator's audience separately, but many followers of fermentation and home cooking creators follow several of them. If 400 creators post about the same kit in the same week, a large share of the 90 million followers are the same people seeing several posts. The second and third posts add less than the first, and the forecast's linear sum overstates reach. In our own data from a smaller seeding last year, about 40 percent of the people who clicked a creator link had already seen another creator's post about the product.
Influence Depends on the Network, Not Only the Seeds
The forecast assumes that large creators drive sales in proportion to their audiences. Research is mixed on how much seeding well-connected people matters. Watts and Dodds (2007) used network models to show that large cascades of adoption usually depend more on a critical mass of easily influenced people than on a few highly influential individuals. Hinz et al. (2011) compared seeding strategies in field settings and found that seeding well-connected people did outperform random seeding. Both lines of work agree that outcomes depend on how the message spreads beyond the seeds, which the agency's arithmetic leaves out.
Competitors and Future Buyers Respond
Two responses the forecast ignores could change the outcome. Competitors will see a wave of creator posts about home fermentation and may respond within weeks with their own discounts or seeding, which would split attention in the category. Future buyers may respond to the volume of posts too: a sudden flood of similar sponsored content can make audiences more skeptical, and some may wait for discounts they expect to follow. Lucas (1976) argued that forecasts built on past relationships fail when a policy change alters how people behave, because the relationships themselves shift. The agency's click and purchase rates come from smaller campaigns in quieter markets; a 400-creator wave is a different intervention, and the rates may not hold.
Table 1
Where the Agency's Forecast Treats the Market as Still
| Forecast assumption | Why it may fail | Direction of error |
|---|---|---|
| Audiences add up | Followers overlap; repeat views add little | Overstates reach |
| Sales scale with audience size | Spread depends on the wider network | Uncertain; often overstates |
| Past click and purchase rates hold | A large wave changes skepticism and competitor behavior | Likely overstates |
| No competitor response | Rivals may discount or seed within weeks | Overstates |
What the Forecast Gets Right
The agency's forecast is not careless. Its click and purchase rates come from real campaigns, its audience figures are accurate, and its arithmetic is transparent, which makes it easy to examine. Seeding creators is a reasonable strategy for a product people need to see in use, and a fermentation kit is such a product. The objection is only to treating the total as a forecast rather than a ceiling.
How We Will Measure the First Wave
Each creator in the first wave will receive a unique link and discount code, so purchases can be traced to the creator who prompted them. We will also track total sales by day, including purchases without a code, since many buyers will see a post and search for the kit directly. Comparing sales in regions where first-wave creators' audiences are concentrated with regions where they are not gives a rough check on the total effect. Two weeks of these measures will give us response rates for this product, this season and this category's level of saturation, which no past campaign can supply.
Recommendation
We recommend seeding in two waves rather than one. Send kits to about 150 creators chosen for audiences that overlap little, measure clicks, purchases and overlap for two weeks, and then decide whether and where to send the remaining kits. Half of the second wave should go to smaller creators with highly engaged audiences, testing whether depth outperforms reach. This approach costs little more, reduces the risk of a saturated, skeptical audience and gives us our own response rates for this product in this market rather than borrowed ones. We should treat 15,000 kits as an upper bound, not a plan.
References
Hinz, O., Skiera, B., Barrot, C., & Becker, J. U. (2011). Seeding strategies for viral marketing: An empirical comparison. Journal of Marketing, 75(6), 55-71. https://doi.org/10.1509/jm.10.0088
Lucas, R. E. (1976). Econometric policy evaluation: A critique. Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy, 1, 19-46. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0167-2231(76)80003-6
Watts, D. J., & Dodds, P. S. (2007). Influentials, networks, and public opinion formation. Journal of Consumer Research, 34(4), 441-458. https://doi.org/10.1086/518527
The MKT-838 Topic 4 assignment instructions
In Topic 4, MKT-838 asks doctoral students to evaluate a marketing forecast that ignores how a market responds. Strong memos set out the forecast's arithmetic fairly, identify each assumption that treats the market as static, and support each objection with evidence or theory on networks, seeding and changing behavior. Students should credit what the forecast does well, recommend a design that learns from the market's response, and describe how results will be measured. Measurement of the first wave, through unique links and regional comparison, should be described.
How this MKT 838 Topic 4 example is built
The finished memo is addressed to the vice president approving the gifting budget. Its frame is the Bass model, which divides adoption into an external push, what Bass called the coefficient of innovation, and an internal pull from earlier adopters, the coefficient of imitation, both acting on a fixed pool of buyers. Seeding raises the early push, and an illustrative curve shows much of the launch-quarter gain as adopters arriving sooner, not adopters added, a lift the agency's forecast would credit in full. Two responses alter the effect. Audiences may discount gifted posts once disclosure labels mark them as sponsored, weakening the imitation they were meant to start. Watts and Dodds's simulations, which found large cascades driven by many easily influenced people more than by a few influentials, support moving budget toward kits early buyers pass on.
Reading the MKT 838 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty reward a memo that shows the market responding to the push. An Excellent memo explains overlapping audiences with evidence from an earlier seeding. Credit goes to Watts and Dodds on easily influenced majorities and Hinz and colleagues on seeding hubs. The rubric values the Lucas critique applied to borrowed click and purchase rates and a table of assumptions with their likely error. Strong memos credit the forecast's transparency. Top marks go to two waves, unique links and regional comparisons. Memos that reject the forecast without offering a better design lose credit.
MKT 838 Topic 4 help before you submit
A memo that forecasts the seeding effect from the launch quarter alone overstates it, because the Bass frame shows early gains that are partly borrowed from later ones. Close to that error sits the plan judged by creator reach, a count of impressions that says nothing about whether imitation followed. A common draft describes the Bass model accurately and then forgets that its pool of eventual buyers is fixed, the very assumption that makes pulled-forward adoption visible. Watts and Dodds do not show that influencers never matter; their simulations found influentials playing a smaller role than marketers assumed, a narrower claim. Competitor response is often left out, although seeding is easy to copy and a rival's matching offer changes what the push can do. Recommendations that reject seeding entirely discard the one lever that reliably moves timing.
Get an MKT-838 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the MKT-838 Topic 4 instructions and the rubric listed in your classroom, with the launch, campaign or scenario your section described. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the intervention framed in a diffusion model, pulled-forward adoption separated from added demand, market responses traced and a longer judging horizon set, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More MKT 838 papers and DBA samples
- MKT 838 Topic 1: Near-decomposability Essay
- MKT 838 Topic 2: Hit Attribution Post-mortem
- MKT 838 Topic 3: Peer Effects Literature Review
- MKT 838 Topic 5: Contribution Claim Dq Post
- MKT 838 Topic 6: Emergent Brand Meaning Case Study
- MKT 838 Topic 7: Agent-based Model Critique
- MKT 838 Topic 8: Interaction-aware Budget Recommendation
- MKT 834 Topic 4: Disconfirming Result Brief
- MKT 832 Topic 4: Personalization Narrowing Appraisal
- MKT 830 Topic 4: Relationship Paradigm Appraisal
MKT 838 Topic 4 questions, answered
What is the Bass diffusion model?
A model of new product adoption developed by Frank Bass. It treats the chance that someone adopts at a given moment as the sum of an external influence, often associated with advertising, and an internal influence that grows with the number of people who have already adopted, usually read as word of mouth. Both act on a fixed market potential. In the example, it separates added adopters from earlier ones.
What does pulling adoption forward mean?
Bringing forward purchases that would have happened later anyway. In a diffusion model with a fixed pool of eventual buyers, a push early in the launch makes the curve rise sooner, and the gap between seeded and unseeded curves then narrows as later buyers run out. A campaign judged in its first quarter gets credit for all of the early gap. The example judges the program at twelve months to avoid that.
Should brands stop seeding influencers?
The example does not argue that. Creators can supply early visibility cheaply, and in the Bass frame early adopters matter because they start imitation. The argument concerns balance and horizon: what the push is credited with, how the market's responses weaken it, and whether some budget does more when kits pass between ordinary buyers. Watts and Dodds's simulations suggest the second route deserves more weight than influencer plans usually give it.
Where can I find a free MKT 838 Topic 4 sample paper?
The seeding memo is printed here in full: the plan and forecast, overlapping audiences, network spread, responses from competitors and buyers, what the forecast gets right, measurement and the recommendation. Share your launch plan and we will write a free memo.
Why seed in two waves in MKT 838 Topic 4?
A first wave of about 150 creators with little audience overlap gives response rates for this product and season, so the second wave can be placed where it adds most instead of saturating the same viewers.