NRS 415 Topic 2 leadership style analysis example

Nursing Leadership and Interprofessional Collaboration Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This NRS 415 Topic 2 sample paper chooses situational leadership over transformational leadership for a rebuilding night shift on a composite 24-bed medical unit. It belongs to GCU NRS 415, Nursing Leadership and Interprofessional Collaboration, listed as NRS-415, part of Grand Canyon University's RN to BSN. Four approaches are summarized with their weaknesses, from Burns and Bass and Riggio's transformational model to Greenleaf's servant leadership. The team of 14 nurses, 6 with under two years and 5 with more than eight, is described. Three facts decide the match to Hersey and Blanchard's model. Cummings and colleagues' review frames outcomes, and the choice's weakest point, perceived inconsistency, is named.

CourseNRS 415 Nursing Leadership and Interprofessional Collaboration
TopicTopic 2
Paper typeLeadership style selection
LengthAbout 1,030 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramRN to BSN
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for NRS 415 Topic 2

1

Choosing a Leadership Style for a Rebuilding Night Shift: Situational Leadership Over Transformational on a 24-Bed Medical Unit

[Author Name]

College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University

NRS-415: Nursing Leadership and Interprofessional Collaboration

Topic 2 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

July 20, 2026

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the choice and the runner-up it beat, and ties both to one specific team. That signals an argument that runs from the team to the style rather than from an admired theory looking for somewhere to land. The unit and its staff are a composite, which lets the paper describe experience levels and morale precisely without describing real colleagues.
2

Choosing a Leadership Style for a Rebuilding Night Shift: Situational Leadership Over Transformational on a 24-Bed Medical Unit

Four Approaches, With Their Weaknesses

Transformational leadership, as described by Burns (1978) and developed by Bass and Riggio (2006), works through idealized influence, inspiration, intellectual stimulation and individual consideration. A transformational leader raises followers' sense of what their work is for, and the nursing research linking leadership to staff outcomes tends to favor it; a large systematic review found that relational styles, transformational leadership among them, were associated with higher job satisfaction and lower turnover intention (Cummings et al., 2018). Its weakness is dependence on trust that already exists. A leader nobody yet believes cannot inspire anyone, and early attempts can read as speeches.

Transactional leadership exchanges rewards and corrections for performance against clear expectations. It is usually dismissed in nursing papers, which is a mistake. On a floor with clear, repeated tasks, high turnover and new staff, clear expectations and prompt feedback are exactly what many people need, and an approach that makes the rules and consequences visible can reduce confusion quickly. Its weakness is that it motivates compliance rather than commitment and does little for experienced nurses who need autonomy more than supervision.

Servant leadership puts the growth and needs of staff first, on the view that a leader serves by removing obstacles (Greenleaf, 1977). It builds loyalty and suits stable teams, but it can leave a struggling team without enough direction, and it is slow. Situational leadership holds that no single style fits every follower; the leader shifts between telling, selling, participating and delegating according to each person's readiness for a given task (Hersey et al., 2013). Its strength is fit. Its weakness is that it demands constant judgment about each person and can look inconsistent to staff who compare how differently they are being treated.

What this page is doingEach approach is set out with enough detail that its weakness shows, including transactional leadership, which the paper credits instead of dismissing. The sources are primary for each model, and the one empirical claim is supported by a systematic review. Describing weaknesses before choosing is what makes the later choice credible.
3

The Team

The team is the night shift on a composite 24-bed general medical unit. Of its 14 registered nurses, 6 have less than two years of experience, 3 are in their first year, and 5 have more than eight years on the unit. Over the past year the unit relied heavily on travel nurses, who have now left, and the night shift lost two of its most experienced nurses to day positions. The roster is therefore unstable in two directions at once: the novices are still learning the unit, and the veterans are tired of orienting.

The work allows moderate discretion. Much of a night shift is routine, medication passes, reassessments and admissions, but deteriorating patients and difficult conversations with families require independent judgment at hours when no manager is present. Morale is low but not hostile. In a recent unit survey, night staff said they felt unsupported and that expectations changed depending on which charge nurse was working. A new night supervisor, the person this analysis is written for, starts next month and has no history with the team.

What this page is doingThe team is described before any choice is made: experience in numbers, roster stability, how much discretion the work allows, and morale in the staff's own words. These facts do the arguing in the next section. A match cannot be judged against a team nobody described, and this is the section most papers skip or compress into a sentence.
4

The Match, Argued From the Team

Three facts decide the choice. The team contains people at very different levels of readiness, from first-year nurses who need direction on unit routines to veterans who need room to use their judgment. The supervisor is new and has no trust to draw on yet. And the staff's main complaint is inconsistency, expectations that change with the charge nurse. Situational leadership fits these facts better than any alternative. It lets the supervisor give a first-year nurse clear, specific direction on how to handle an admission at 0300, while delegating the same task entirely to a nurse with ten years on the unit and involving the middle group in deciding how to handle it.

Transformational leadership is the runner-up, and rejecting it is about this team rather than about the theory. Its effects depend on followers identifying with the leader, which takes months of reliable behavior to build, and a new supervisor who opens with vision statements to a tired, understaffed shift risks being heard as another person who does not understand the work. The first thing this team needs is not inspiration but consistency, and consistency comes from matching direction to each person's readiness in a way the staff can see and predict. Transformational behaviors, particularly individual consideration, can grow once that foundation exists, and they will likely become more important in the second year.

The situational approach also absorbs the useful parts of the transactional style. For the newest nurses, clear expectations with prompt feedback are what the telling and selling styles look like in practice. What the supervisor must avoid is applying that style to the veterans, whose remaining commitment depends on being trusted. In practice that means the veterans are consulted on how the new routines should work and are asked to precept only when they agree to it, rather than being assigned orientees by default.

What this page is doingThe reasoning runs from the three facts about the team to the style, not the other way around. The runner-up is named and rejected for reasons specific to this team, a new leader without trust and a staff asking for consistency, while the paper keeps transformational leadership available for later. The highlighted sentence is the argument in one line.
5

Where the Choice Will Be Weakest

The situational approach has a real risk on this unit. Staff already complain that expectations vary, and a supervisor who treats nurses differently according to readiness could be seen as playing favorites. The approach will be weakest in exactly the moments that test fairness, such as when a first-year nurse is checked on three times in a night and a veteran is not checked on at all, or when a veteran is given the easier assignment because she can be trusted with less support. The supervisor can reduce this risk by being open about the method, explaining to the whole team that direction will change as each person grows and that the aim is for everyone to reach the point where they need little of it.

The approach also handles emergencies badly. In a code or a rapid deterioration there is no time to judge readiness; someone must direct, and the telling style must be used with everyone, including the veterans. The supervisor should say this in advance so that directive behavior during a crisis is not read as a loss of trust. Finally, situational leadership asks a great deal of one person's judgment. If the supervisor misreads a nurse's readiness, the result is either micromanagement or abandonment, and on a night shift with no manager present, the second is the more dangerous error.

References

Bass, B. M., & Riggio, R. E. (2006). Transformational leadership (2nd ed.). Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Burns, J. M. (1978). Leadership. Harper & Row.

Cummings, G. G., Tate, K., Lee, S., Wong, C. A., Paananen, T., Micaroni, S. P. M., & Chatterjee, G. E. (2018). Leadership styles and outcome patterns for the nursing workforce and work environment: A systematic review. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 85, 19-60. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2018.04.016

Greenleaf, R. K. (1977). Servant leadership: A journey into the nature of legitimate power and greatness. Paulist Press.

Hersey, P., Blanchard, K. H., & Johnson, D. E. (2013). Management of organizational behavior: Leading human resources (10th ed.). Pearson.

The NRS-415 Topic 2 assignment instructions

Topic 2 in NRS-415 asks students to select a leadership style for a specific situation and justify the choice. Strong papers describe several approaches fairly, including their weaknesses, then describe the team in concrete terms, such as experience levels and recent turnover, and argue the match from those facts. Students should avoid treating any style as the right answer in general and should say where the chosen style will be weakest on this unit and how that risk will be managed. A self-assessment may be required in some sections, and evidence on leadership styles and nursing outcomes should support the argument. A short description of the team's experience mix, with numbers, is the evidence the choice rests on, so faculty expect it before the argument.

Inside the NRS 415 Topic 2 example

The finished example describes each approach in enough detail that its weaknesses show. Transformational leadership appears with its dependence on a leader people already trust; transactional appears without the sneer, credited for what it does well on a busy floor with clear tasks and turnover. Servant and situational approaches are given the same treatment. The team then arrives, described concretely: how experienced the staff are, how stable the roster is, how much discretion the work allows, and what morale is like after whatever has recently happened. The match follows from those facts, and the example says which approach it is rejecting and why that rejection is about this team rather than about the theory. A closing passage admits where the chosen approach will be weakest.

NRS 415 Topic 2 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward a style matched to a described team. An Excellent paper summarizes transformational, situational, servant and transactional approaches with their weaknesses, citing Burns, Bass and Riggio and Greenleaf. Credit goes to describing 14 night nurses by experience, including 3 in their first year. The rubric values arguing for Hersey and Blanchard's situational model from three facts about readiness. Strong papers use Cummings and colleagues on leadership styles and outcomes. Top marks go to naming the risk that varied treatment looks like favoritism, with a response.

Common NRS 415 Topic 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them

The give-away here is a paper that admires transformational leadership for three pages and never mentions a team. Faculty are marking the fit, so an approach chosen without a described setting cannot score well however accurate the description is. A second loss is the caricature of transactional leadership as mere reward and punishment, which misreads the theory and forfeits the comparison. Papers lose marks for choosing every approach at once, claiming a flexible blend, since that is a way of not deciding. Uncited definitions cost marks too, because these terms belong to specific authors. Strong versions say where the chosen approach will fail this particular team, which most papers carefully avoid.

Get an NRS-415 Topic 2 example written to your instructions

Send the NRS-415 Topic 2 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with anything you can tell us about the team you are writing about. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the approaches cited to their authors, the setting described in detail and the match argued from the team outward, in 24 to 48 hours. First one free.

More NRS 415 papers and RN to BSN samples

NRS 415 Topic 2 questions, answered

Which leadership style is the right answer?

There is no style faculty are waiting for, and papers that guess transformational because it sounds best often score less than papers that argue for something plainer. What is being marked is the fit between the approach and the team you described. A well defended case for transactional leadership on a high turnover floor will outscore an unsupported case for anything.

Can I say my style is a mix of several?

Only if you say what the mix is and when each part applies, which is really situational leadership under another name. A claim to blend everything reads as avoidance, because it commits to nothing that could be wrong. If you genuinely shift approach with the task and the person, name the trigger that makes you switch and the paper becomes an argument again.

Do I need a leadership self assessment for this?

Several sections assign one, and where yours does, the results belong in the paper as evidence rather than as a decoration. Report what the instrument said, then say whether you recognize yourself in it, since the interesting paragraph is usually the disagreement. Where no instrument is assigned, a described pattern from your own practice does the same work.

Where can I find a free NRS 415 Topic 2 sample paper?

The style paper for NRS 415 Topic 2 covers four approaches with their weaknesses, the team, the match argued from the team and where the choice will be weakest. Share your NRS 415 Topic 2 prompt for a free paper.

Can I say my style is a mix in NRS 415 Topic 2?

Only if you say what each part does and when. The paper picks situational leadership because the team spans first-year nurses and veterans, and it explains how direction varies by readiness.