| Course | NSG 320 Adult Health Nursing I |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Early deterioration case study |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BSN |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for NSG 320 Topic 4
Early Deterioration Against a Chronic Baseline: A Case Study of a 72-Year-Old Woman With COPD Whose Normal Is Not Normal
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
NSG-320: Adult Health Nursing I
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
September 28, 2026
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Early Deterioration Against a Chronic Baseline: A Case Study of a 72-Year-Old Woman With COPD Whose Normal Is Not Normal
The Baseline, Recorded in Full
Mrs. P. S., 72, a composite patient whose lung disease was graded severe at her last pulmonary visit, was admitted two days ago with an exacerbation and is improving on bronchodilators, a corticosteroid and an antibiotic. Her baseline on the morning of day 3, recorded at 0800 by the day nurse: barrel-shaped chest; pursed-lip breathing when she walks; diminished breath sounds in all fields with scattered expiratory wheezes; respiratory rate 22; oxygen saturation 90 percent on 2 liters by nasal cannula, within the ordered target of 88 to 92 percent; heart rate 94; blood pressure 132/76; temperature 98.8 F; alert, oriented and chatty, working on a crossword puzzle; walks to the bathroom with a walker, stopping once to rest. Her daughter says this is close to how she is at home. Current guidance sets a lower saturation target for patients like her, who are at risk of retaining carbon dioxide when given high concentrations of oxygen (O'Driscoll et al., 2017).
The Changes Across the Shift
At 1400, the nurse finds her in bed rather than the chair. Respiratory rate 26; saturation 89 percent on 2 liters; heart rate 104; she is using her neck muscles to breathe. She says she is "just tired." At 1600: respiratory rate 28; saturation 91 percent after her daughter turned the oxygen up to 4 liters because "she looked like she needed it"; heart rate 110; she has stopped doing the crossword and answers questions slowly; she says she has a headache. At 1700 she is drowsy, falls asleep mid-sentence, and her hands have a coarse flapping tremor when she holds them out.
Each value on its own might be dismissed. A respiratory rate in the high 20s and a saturation near 90 percent are not unusual for her. But compared with her own baseline, every direction is wrong: her rate and heart rate are rising, her work of breathing has increased, and, most importantly, her mental status has shifted from chatty and alert to slow, then drowsy. In a patient whose oxygen saturation looks acceptable, a change in how she thinks is the finding that matters most, because it can signal rising carbon dioxide before any number on the monitor does.
What the Changes Mean
The picture suggests hypercapnic respiratory failure developing on top of her exacerbation. As she tires, her breathing becomes shallower and less effective at removing carbon dioxide. The increase in oxygen to 4 liters, though well meant, may have made things worse: in some patients with chronic lung disease, higher oxygen concentrations worsen carbon dioxide retention through changes in ventilation-perfusion matching and the loss of the hypoxic drive's contribution to breathing. Rising carbon dioxide causes headache, drowsiness, confusion and a flapping tremor called asterixis, all of which she now shows. Her saturation of 91 percent on 4 liters therefore reassures no one; it tells the nurse only that her oxygen is adequate, not that she is breathing well enough to clear carbon dioxide (Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease [GOLD], 2024).
The Nurse's Response
At 1700 the nurse returns the oxygen to 2 liters, keeping saturation in the 88 to 92 percent target, and explains to the daughter why more oxygen is not better for her mother. She sits Mrs. S. upright, stays with her, and calls the rapid response team using SBAR, emphasizing the change from baseline: "She was alert and doing a crossword this morning; now she's drowsy with a tremor and a headache, her respiratory rate went from 22 to 28, and her family increased her oxygen to 4 liters at 1600." She anticipates an arterial blood gas, which is drawn at 1710 and shows pH 7.28, PaCO2 68 mm Hg and PaO2 64 mm Hg, confirming acute on chronic hypercapnic respiratory failure. The team starts noninvasive positive pressure ventilation and transfers her to the step-down unit.
What Could Have Prevented the Drift
Looking back, two moments offered a chance to act earlier. At 1400, the combination of being back in bed, a respiratory rate four breaths higher than baseline, neck muscle use and a heart rate over 100 was already a meaningful change, even though each value alone was within what might be expected for her. A reassessment at 1500 rather than 1600, and a call to the provider to report the trend, might have led to a blood gas two hours sooner. At 1600, the family's change in oxygen flow was a second opportunity: an oxygen order with a target saturation range, clearly posted at the bedside with a short explanation, might have prevented it, and the nurse now includes that explanation in the admission teaching for every patient with chronic lung disease and their visitors. Neither lapse reflects carelessness; both reflect how easily a slow change in a chronically ill patient can look like more of the same. The lesson the nurse takes forward is to record the baseline in specific terms and to treat any trend away from it, not only an abnormal number, as a reason to reassess sooner.
What Made Early Recognition Possible
Three things made the difference. First, the 0800 baseline was specific: not "alert," but "chatty, doing a crossword," which made the later change unmistakable. Second, the nurse judged each set of values against where this patient started, not against textbook limits. Third, she treated a change in behavior, being in bed instead of the chair and stopping the crossword, as clinical data. Early warning scores help by combining vital signs into a single number, and a score calculated at 1400 would have risen, but for patients whose baseline values are abnormal, scores can underestimate or overestimate risk, which is why the nurse's comparison with this patient's own normal remains essential (Hinkle et al., 2022). Deterioration in chronic illness is rarely a single dramatic number; it is usually a drift that only a clear baseline can reveal.
References
Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease. (2024). Global strategy for the diagnosis, management, and prevention of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: 2024 report. https://goldcopd.org/
Hinkle, J. L., Cheever, K. H., & Overbaugh, K. J. (2022). Brunner & Suddarth's textbook of medical-surgical nursing (15th ed.). Wolters Kluwer.
O'Driscoll, B. R., Howard, L. S., Earis, J., & Mak, V. (2017). BTS guideline for oxygen use in adults in healthcare and emergency settings. Thorax, 72(Suppl. 1), ii1-ii90. https://doi.org/10.1136/thoraxjnl-2016-209729
The NSG-320 Topic 4 assignment instructions
Topic 4 in NSG-320 asks students to analyze a case of patient deterioration. Strong case studies record the baseline in specific terms, since a patient with a chronic condition has a normal that is not normal, then describe changes across the shift with times and values. Students should explain what the changes mean physiologically, describe the nurse's response, including the reasoning behind oxygen targets and escalation, and identify moments when earlier action was possible. The case should state what made early recognition possible, often a specific baseline, and use a structured report format such as SBAR where the section expects one. Treatment should be discussed only as far as nursing actions require.
Inside the NSG 320 Topic 4 example
Comparison drives the finished case study, since a patient with chronic lung disease never looks textbook normal. The baseline comes first and is recorded in full: a barrel chest, pursed-lip breathing, diminished breath sounds, oxygen saturation within the lower target range the order specifies, and the patient's usual ability to speak in complete sentences. Changes over the shift are then set against that baseline one at a time: a respiratory rate creeping upward, accessory muscles working at rest, sputum turning darker, phrases shortening, and new drowsiness that could reflect rising carbon dioxide. Each change is explained through the pathophysiology of trapped air and impaired gas exchange. The nursing section covers the positioning and breathing techniques used, the findings reported and to whom, and why supplemental oxygen stays inside the ordered range.
Reading the NSG 320 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty reward deterioration measured against a specific baseline. An Excellent case records Mrs. S. at 0800 as chatty and doing a crossword, then back in bed at 1400 with a respiratory rate of 26. Credit goes to explaining developing hypercapnic failure as fatigue makes breathing shallow, after GOLD. The rubric values returning oxygen to 2 liters to keep saturation at 88 to 92 percent, citing O'Driscoll and colleagues, and explaining why to the daughter. Strong cases name two earlier chances to act. Top marks go to crediting the specific baseline.
NSG 320 Topic 4 help before you submit
Deterioration case studies lose most often by comparing the patient with textbook normal values instead of with the patient's own baseline. A saturation that would alarm anyone else may be this patient's usual, while a respiratory rate rising slowly across the shift is the change that matters, and papers that miss that distinction misread the whole case. Treating drowsiness as tiredness is the classic content error on this topic. Writers who note each change but never say which one alone would justify a report have recorded without judging. Oxygen described as the answer to every low reading costs safety credit in chronic lung disease. Reports lacking structure, or lacking a clear request, lose points on communication. The strongest case studies name the first departure from baseline and defend it as the moment to act.
Get an NSG-320 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the NSG-320 Topic 4 instructions and rubric from your classroom, plus the respiratory case your prompt uses. We write a custom example to those criteria, comparing a composite patient against their own baseline and ending in a structured report, and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free. It is coursework, not clinical guidance.
More NSG 320 papers and BSN samples
- NSG 320 Topic 1: Pathophysiology to Assessment Paper
- NSG 320 Topic 2: Fluid Electrolyte Case Analysis
- NSG 320 Topic 3: Heart Failure Priorities Paper
- NSG 320 Topic 5: Priority Finding DQ
- NSG 320 Topic 6: Perioperative Care Plan
- NSG 320 Topic 7: Multiple Problem Care Plan
- NSG 320 Topic 8: Two Patient Prioritization Paper
- NSG 322 Topic 4: Mood and Anxiety Care Plan
- NSG 318 Topic 4: Adverse Effect Analysis
- NSG 430 Topic 4: Organ Failure Systems Paper
- NSG 310 Topic 4: Code of Ethics Application
NSG 320 Topic 4 questions, answered
Why does the baseline matter so much?
Because a patient with chronic lung disease often has findings that would be abnormal in anyone else. Judging change against textbook values produces false alarms and, worse, misses slow decline that stays inside a range. The course expects the nurse to know this patient's usual breathing, speech and saturation, and to recognize movement away from them. The example records that baseline before describing anything that changes.
How much should the case study say about treatment?
Only what the nurse does within the orders and within scope: positioning, breathing techniques, keeping oxygen inside the prescribed range and reporting. Managing respiratory failure belongs to the acute and complex course that follows NSG-320. Where your prompt asks about medications or escalation, follow it, but keep NSG-320 answers anchored in recognition and communication rather than in decisions that belong to the provider.
Is SBAR required for the report?
Many GCU nursing sections expect it or a similar structure, since it organizes a report around what the listener needs to decide. Check your rubric. Whatever format is used, the report should state the change, the relevant history, the nurse's reading of what the change means and a clear request, and the request is the part students most often omit.
Where can I find a free NSG 320 Topic 4 sample paper?
The deterioration case for NSG 320 Topic 4 covers the baseline recorded in full, the changes across the shift, what the changes mean, the nurse's response, what could have prevented the drift and what made early recognition possible. Your own NSG 320 Topic 4 prompt gets a free paper.
Why does the baseline matter so much in NSG 320 Topic 4?
Because a patient with COPD may live with low saturation and fast breathing. Only a specific baseline shows when those numbers have changed.