| Course | NSG 436 Leadership, Ethics, and Policy in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Resource allocation ethics analysis |
| Length | About 1,140 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BSN |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for NSG 436 Topic 3
Two Patients, One Attendant, Eleven Hours: An Ethical Analysis of Allocating Continuous Observation on a Night Shift
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
NSG-436: Leadership, Ethics, and Policy in Health Care
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
May 17, 2027
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Two Patients, One Attendant, Eleven Hours: An Ethical Analysis of Allocating Continuous Observation on a Night Shift
The Case
At 2000 on a composite medical-surgical floor, the charge nurse had two patients who met the unit's policy criteria for continuous one-to-one observation, and one patient care attendant available until 0700. The staffing office had no one else.
Mrs. E. H., 82, was admitted two days earlier with pneumonia and had developed hyperactive delirium. She had a central venous catheter in her right internal jugular vein for antibiotics and vasopressor support, now weaned. She had pulled at the line twice since 1800, loosening the dressing once. Her daughter had gone home to sleep after staying the previous night.
Mr. G. O., 67, was on day 1 after a total hip replacement. He had mild postoperative confusion, especially at night, and had tried to climb out of bed three times since dinner, once getting his operated leg over the rail. He was on anticoagulation, and a fall could dislocate his new hip or cause a bleed. His wife was at home without a car.
The unit policy defines continuous observation as indicated for a patient who is at imminent risk of serious self-harm, including removal of a life-sustaining device or a fall likely to cause serious injury, when less restrictive measures have not succeeded. Both patients met it.
The Decision
The question is: which patient receives the attendant for the night? There are two answers. The attendant could sit with Mrs. H., or with Mr. O. Splitting the attendant between two rooms at opposite ends of the hallway is not continuous observation and would provide neither patient what the policy requires. A third answer, finding another attendant, does not exist tonight.
The Four Principles, Applied to Both
Autonomy. Neither patient can make an informed choice about observation tonight; both are confused. For Mrs. H., autonomy is best respected by honoring what her daughter says she would want, which is to be treated but not tied down. For Mr. O., who is confused only at night and was clear this afternoon, autonomy points to what he said then: he wanted to walk again soon and was afraid of falling. Both patients' prior wishes favor protection without restraint, and autonomy does not distinguish between them (Beauchamp & Childress, 2019).
Beneficence. The attendant benefits whoever receives it by preventing a harmful event. For Mrs. H., the attendant can also reorient her, which is part of treating delirium, not just preventing harm; nonpharmacological measures such as reorientation, a calm presence and a regular routine are the core of delirium management (Inouye et al., 2014). For Mr. O., the attendant prevents a fall but does less for his underlying confusion.
Nonmaleficence. This is where the principles conflict most. The harm to Mrs. H. if she removes her central line is bleeding, air embolism and loss of access, possibly fatal within minutes. The harm to Mr. O. if he falls is hip dislocation, fracture or intracranial bleeding on anticoagulation, serious but usually not immediately fatal. The likelihood of each also matters: Mrs. H. has pulled at the line twice in two hours, and Mr. O. has tried to get up three times in two hours. Both are likely to try again.
Justice. Justice asks that similar cases be treated alike and that scarce resources be allocated by relevant criteria, not by who is closest or who complained. Both patients qualify by the same criteria. Justice therefore requires the decision to be made by the difference in risk, and whichever patient does not receive the attendant must receive the best available alternative.
Alternatives on the Table
Video monitoring. The unit has two remote video monitors with a technician who watches up to eight patients and speaks through the camera. Video monitoring can redirect a patient trying to get out of bed, because a voice can tell him to wait, and a nurse can reach the room within a minute. It is much less effective for a patient pulling at a line, because the harm can happen in seconds.
Bed alarm. A bed alarm sounds when a patient's weight shifts off the bed. Mr. O. already has one. It alerts staff after he has started to get up, not before, and it does nothing for a line.
A family member. Mrs. H.'s daughter could return, but she stayed awake the previous night. Mr. O.'s wife cannot come without a car.
Restraint. Physical restraint is held in reserve by both principle and policy. It increases agitation and the risk of injury in delirium, and it does not reliably prevent falls (Oliver et al., 2010). It is permitted only when less restrictive measures have failed, with an order and frequent monitoring, and it would be a last resort for either patient.
Position and Its Cost
My position is that the attendant should go to Mrs. H., because the harm she faces from removing a central line is faster and more likely to be fatal, because no alternative can stop it in time, and because the attendant can also treat her delirium, while Mr. O.'s risk can be partly covered by video monitoring and a bed alarm. Mr. O. would be placed on video monitoring, moved to the room nearest the nurses' station, checked every 30 minutes by his nurse with a scheduled toileting plan, and given his pain medicine on time, since unmet pain and a full bladder are common reasons for trying to get up.
The cost is real. Mr. O. is still at risk of falling overnight. Video monitoring can tell him to wait, but if he does not listen, it cannot stop him. A fall on anticoagulation after hip surgery could be serious, and if it happened, the decision would have contributed to it. I accept that cost, and I would document the decision and the reasons so that it could be reviewed.
What would change my position: if Mrs. H.'s line were removed or no longer needed, if her daughter could come back, or if Mr. O. became more agitated and video monitoring failed to redirect him, the attendant would move, or the charge nurse would call the nursing supervisor to escalate for additional staff.
Criteria for the Next Night
This decision should not rest on one tired charge nurse at 2000. The floor could agree on allocation criteria in advance: first, the speed and severity of the harm if the event occurs; second, whether an alternative can prevent it in time; third, whether the attendant also provides treatment. Patients not receiving an attendant would get a defined bundle, video monitoring, a room near the station and scheduled checks. The criteria would be approved by the unit's leadership and ethics resource, so that the next charge nurse facing this choice applies a rule the unit has already agreed on.
References
Beauchamp, T. L., & Childress, J. F. (2019). Principles of biomedical ethics (8th ed.). Oxford University Press.
Inouye, S. K., Westendorp, R. G. J., & Saczynski, J. S. (2014). Delirium in elderly people. The Lancet, 383(9920), 911-922. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(13)60688-1
Oliver, D., Healey, F., & Haines, T. P. (2010). Preventing falls and fall-related injuries in hospitals. Clinics in Geriatric Medicine, 26(4), 645-692. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cger.2010.06.005
The NSG-436 Topic 3 assignment instructions
Topic 3 in NSG-436 takes up ethics in leadership decisions. Strong papers state the case and the decision precisely, then test each option against a named framework, the four principles for instance, for every person affected rather than to the situation in general. Students should consider alternatives that might avoid the choice, take a position with its cost stated plainly and propose how the decision could be made more fairly in future, for example with agreed criteria. The case does not need to come from placement, and disagreeing with a decision that was made is acceptable when the reasoning is shown.
Inside the NSG 436 Topic 3 example
The case is set out first, in enough detail that the difficulty is real. One patient, an older adult with delirium, has twice pulled at a central line; the other, recovering from surgery, has tried to climb out of bed three times since dinner. Both qualify for continuous observation under the unit's policy, and only one attendant is available until morning. The paper then works through autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence and justice, each applied to both patients rather than defined in the abstract, and it names the alternatives already on the table, video monitoring, a bed alarm, a family member staying, and restraint, which principle and policy both hold in reserve. It reaches a position, states what that position costs the patient who did not get the attendant, and says what would change it.
Reading the NSG 436 Topic 3 rubric
Faculty reward principles applied to both patients and a position with its cost. An Excellent paper applies Beauchamp and Childress's autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence and justice to Mrs. H. and Mr. O. Credit goes to weighing video monitoring and other alternatives, with Oliver and colleagues on fall prevention and Inouye and colleagues on delirium. The rubric values giving the attendant to Mrs. H. because pulling a central line is faster and more likely fatal. Strong papers state what Mr. O. risks. Top marks go to allocation criteria agreed in advance.
Common NSG 436 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them
An easy case is the quickest way to a low score. Choosing a dilemma where one answer is plainly right, or where policy already decides it, leaves the framework nothing to do. Principles defined in a paragraph each and never applied to the patients cost the application line, which usually carries the most weight. Stopping after the analysis is the next loss: all four principles applied, then no choice made, which leaves out the decision faculty were waiting to see defended. A position that admits no downside reads as unexamined, because the patient without the attendant is still at risk overnight. Papers also slip by relocating the problem to staffing shortages in general, which is true and beside the point, since the charge nurse still had to choose that night with the staff available.
Get an NSG-436 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the NSG-436 Topic 3 instructions and your classroom rubric, with the case your section supplied or a de-identified decision you want analyzed. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the principles applied to every party, the alternatives weighed and a position taken with its cost stated, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More NSG 436 papers and BSN samples
- NSG 436 Topic 1: Leadership Before Licensure Paper
- NSG 436 Topic 2: Observed Leadership Analysis
- NSG 436 Topic 4: Speaking-up Case Analysis
- NSG 436 Topic 5: Silence Barriers Dq Post
- NSG 436 Topic 6: Policy Pathway Analysis
- NSG 436 Topic 7: Written Committee Testimony
- NSG 436 Topic 8: First-year Leadership Plan
- NSG 440 Topic 3: Determinant Pathway Analysis
- NSG 434 Topic 3: Stage-matched Communication Paper
- NSG 444 Topic 3: Delegation Follow-through Analysis
- NSG 432 Topic 3: Labor Stage Nursing Paper
NSG 436 Topic 3 questions, answered
Which ethical framework does NSG-436 usually expect?
Many sections use principlism, the four principles associated with Beauchamp and Childress, alongside the ANA Code of Ethics for Nurses, and some also ask for a Christian worldview perspective. Use whatever your rubric names. Whichever framework it is, apply it to each person affected by the decision rather than defining its terms and moving on to the conclusion.
Does the case have to be one I saw on placement?
Not always. Some sections supply a scenario, and others let you build a composite from situations you observed. Either works if the decision has a genuine cost whichever way it goes. Keep every patient and colleague unidentifiable, and avoid cases where policy already settles the answer, since those leave the principles with nothing to weigh.
Is it acceptable to disagree with the decision that was made?
Yes, provided the disagreement is argued rather than asserted. Reconstruct the charge nurse's reasoning at its strongest, show which principle it weighted most, and then explain why you would weight them differently. Disagreeing with a colleague's call in hindsight is easy; showing that you understand why a reasonable nurse made it is what earns the analysis marks.
Where can I find a free NSG 436 Topic 3 sample paper?
The ethics analysis for NSG 436 Topic 3 covers the case, the decision, the four principles applied to both, alternatives on the table, position and cost and criteria for the next night. Post your NSG 436 Topic 3 prompt and get a free paper.
Can I disagree with the decision that was made in NSG 436 Topic 3?
Yes, if the reasoning is shown. Faculty grade how the principles and alternatives are weighed, not whether the paper agrees with the charge nurse.